All Comments on 'The City of Charn is Dying, Mike.'

by greenmountaineer

Sort by:
  • 8 Comments
Ashesh9Ashesh9over 10 years ago
A happy family @

Christmas : there are layers within layers of meaning in your poem GM !! 5-ed & Merry Christmas .

AngelineAngelineover 10 years ago
This is just a symphony of a poem

a family sharing a Christmas moment plus the Narnia story plus the irony. You weave them all together into a skillful narrative.

buttersbuttersover 10 years ago
for those of us who grew up with...

...the books, this one's even more a christmas special of a poem. liking the fact digory got a mention, and the links to 'a boy and his horse'. the scene as seen through the N's eyes as he watches the child watching, the adult v child's comprehension of what's happening, and the glib roar of commercialism leaves a bitter note behind the 'delight' of a tale fit for turkish nights.

buttersbuttersover 10 years ago
duh

i meant to type The Horse and His Boy

GuiltyPleasureGuiltyPleasureover 10 years ago
How cleverly....

.....you weave Narnia and its characters into this domestic situation. I am nostalgic for a Christmas I've never known, it's always been about gifts and greed. For we like sheep....ya know. Great poem gm. <3

buttersbuttersover 10 years ago
and in case anyone missed it...

forgot to mention the importance of Charn here. not everyone's read the Narnia books, though they are missing out on a part of childhood - Charn is a dead/dying city because of Jadis' magic - as related in The Magician's Nephew.

HarryHillHarryHillover 10 years ago
wish i had the context

to appreciate this in its entirety

AnonymousAnonymousover 10 years ago
Harry

In case you re-visit, this poem relates to C.S. Lewis's "The Lion, Witch, and the Wardrobe."

For some reason, Lit's acting up on me again and listing me as "anonymous," but this is greenmountineer replying to your comment.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous