by Mainefiddleheads
Deep. The story left me confused, of course! Into the comments! One stood out above the others at the end. Michelle swapped her boots for some of her sister's fancy-shmancy heels, putting them last in Michelle's possession. IF her words were true! The author cunningly mentions a "pair of yellow heels" found where Marin was in the same town where Michelle was visiting. Ergo, Michelle was with Marin out of town it seems, and somehow left her heels behind. Bad girl! It slides by the reader, but not we presume by an ace detective. "How long"? "About six months." (if I remembered the quote right.) Both sisters were seeing Marin.
So many complaints about needing a better ending, or leaving the
question of which or both sisters, or why or what does the MC do.
A good short story ( and this is a good one ) quite often leaves a
lot of unanswered questions. That’s their charm. Your imagination
Is challenged and you get to play with various conclusions. Fun !
Nicely done, shr
Pretty clear that both sisters did thr cheating with the loser Steinman. Monique went first and dragged Michelle into it. Poor unresolved ending.
Fun to see lyrics of the 'Dead in a story. Tone of the detective--brusque and terse--seemed right on. I was surprised at the end--thought his wife was the adulterer. Nice job.
Thanks I enjoyed this. Yeah sure. Blaha blah blah.
But I couldn't do it any better.
So if Michelle and Monique always do everything together or the same. This apparently was Monique's 3rd affair and has been going on with Steinman for 6 months
... So, what affairs has Michelle had?
Well Michelle made it crystal clear that whatever her sister did she followed suit, so when is the divorce?
Could the photo of the tattoo be a reverse image? This one always leaves questions.
Half finishing a story just isn't a good look. Who really gives a fk about how and why she got caught, that's just setting the scene. The only thing we the reader are really interested in is in how she explains it and the consequences.
Not sure that I could have a relationship with someone so lacking that they'd have an American beauty tattoo on their arse. I guess it's one step better than an ace of spades, but not by much.
The consequence of the final conversation is that no one could have a real relationship with the MC'd wife because the other twin will always fk it up with her degenerate behaviour.
JEEZ!! Just another of this authors half finished stories that started out quite good and then died…. A disappointing hour spent and wasted!!!
IF YOU CANNOT FINISH THE DAMN STORY DON’T POST IT!!!
The ending was much too confusing. Was the woman in the security tapes the MC's wife Michelle or was it her twin Monique? I reread the ending four times and I still can't tell. Excellent story line but absolutely terrible, awful ending.
An excellent story; vivid description as seems to be your standard. A bit too twisty for me with the shoe swap, tattoos and the monkey see/monkey do sisters, I had to summon Chopinesque’s comment and be spoon-fed clarification. You did provide some insight into the question of why the detective’s wife strayed. You’re just a little too tricky for me Mr. fiddlehead.