All Comments on 'All I Want for Christmas'

God I love thus story, had this bear of a man with tears in his eyes. To the author, you made futile mistake, it matters not, jew, gentile, gay, straight, bi, non binary, we all got this 1 thing in us - it's what we like. Yes Orin can not be attracted to guys, because Justin is his goldilocks or ideal man I am head over heels for. It's the reason men have brawls over dating that 1 particularl girl. I am bi, my ideal man has to be feminine in nature. The more girly, the closer. That's my type. Justin was Orin's type period. I am 55 yo, and in my entire life, only 3 guys have come into my life that were my type. All were fembois. Do a better job when you write the next story with that information. Still I loved the story, hope to see next chapter.

Loved it, write more like this

Sweet, I loved it!🥰

Exquisite!

One day I will feel this way 🥰

I loved this beautiful story.

I just discovered and so enjoyed this tender, lovely story. It was well written, obviously with love.

This was the most beautiful story I have ever read. Even 13 years later it still one of the best stories I have read in a long time. I hope you continue writing.

So cute, so sweet, so wonderful! <3

Wow it was the most beautiful story I have ever read I hope u continue writing

I found the story of intense interest and excitement until the condom was reached for.........these true lovers are going to fuck for the first time and unload in each other with a condom ! No way.............made me lose interest fast..........

Gives new meaning to fate being a stone cold bitch. Loved Autumn, though. She's the perfect foil for those callous bitches.

That scene was amazing! You gave us a marathon session in amazing detail.

I see from your profile that you were very ill, and I truly hope that you're well these days.

Best, Lucat.

When I started reading this site I fell in love with this story and 3 years later this is still In my top 5. Your writing pulls the reader in and you feel each drop of emotion.

I've been a reader on literotica for over 10 yrs. I found this story shortly after starting to read here and loved it then. Sadly I forgot the name of the story and who wrote it, but never what it was about. I searched and searched so long and finally found it again and it was just as wonderful as I remembered. So now I've bookmarked it and will continue to come back and read it and the rest of your work. Would soo love to read more about them!!

Give us more of the two here. I was hard the whole time.

I really do love this story. I want another chapter. I am at work and i stop working and everything just to read it. Its so amazing i cant wait to read more about Orin and Justin. I think they are so cute.

I loved it. Perfect mixture between smut and love

Absolutely fabulous!! I'm all for love and romance. Life and discovery. Would love to read more of these two and of course that little blurb at the end about Autumn!! Care to share more?

I just discovered this great story. Would love to read more about this duo.

I wish you'd continue with another short piece, where Justin actually DOES hold Orin down and fuck him hard.... Pretty pleaseeeeeee?!?!

It was really touching. I nearly had wet eyes. Please do write some more!

Just loved this - felt it was so well written and could infact have been written just for me helping to explain my own failings in my own life Has really made me think for I am sure that I am not alone in experiencing events and people that really should have meant so much more but 'society' can often dictate otherwise. Thank you so much for this!

...Conquers all! A wonderful heartwarming story of love and discovery. The realisation that two hearts belong together. Loved the twist at the end re Autumn!

Each read evokes a tear. Then a smile. Everytime. Congrats! Keep writing!

E.R. Saw this ages ago and it took me months to find it again. Also trying to find another one so maybe this is lucky? Great story!!

I read this story months ago, and have been looking for it ever since. This is probably one of the most touching stories I have ever read and I can't thank you enough for being so brilliant as to write it. I mean, crap! Who CAN'T love this story?!

Merry Christmas to you, Sachiaiko! Thank you for sharing such an incredible, heart warming, breath taking love story with us. Wow! It brought shivers and tears and I realized how many walls of pain I as well have up from experiences, it's truly hard not to be cynical. Your story has been so touching and inspirational. I fell in love with the happy couple. Does love like that exist? I want to believe so.

As a man who has always been attracted to women, but who has also been in love with my best male friend for the past 10 years or so, I saw so much of myself in both Orin and Justin. My friend has known of my feelings for at least the past 5 or 6 years and it hasn't affected our friendship, but it hasn't led to anything more either. I guess I just need a little magic working in my favor like it did for Justin. :)

its really romantic i think i have fallen in love with justin

Seriously this story is heart touching . I woke up whole nite to complete this story

this is by far my favorite. i have reread it so many times. just love it. thank you for such a beautiful and HOT story.

It could have only been better if there was a chapter with Orin loosing his anal cherry.

I can't believe how real it seemed .it made mr think I was right there watching (wish I was) lol good job

I couldn't stop reading !!!! My eyes are burning. I was supposed to read one page and ended up reading the whole thing !! Good job !!!

i enjoyed it fully from beginning to end i would like to know autumns part in all this yes i got she is some kind of goddess and her mum is one of the fates why is she fixing lovers if she is not a fate?would like to know more wishing you well love nix

MORE PLEEEEZ MORE

One of the most intense and amazing pieces I've ever read!

An amazing love story, a great piece. ;) in love with every characters because you can truly feel them, they have been brought to life. BY you. So tnx for sharing this wonderful piece of work . Keep on writing . =)

I saw this in the recommendation box while reading another story. I was curious as to why it had 72 comments. I wanted to know what all the hype was about. It took me a while to finish the whole thing but I LOVE the way you write. It makes you live with the characters, feel their high and lows. Certain parts where a bit to dragged out but I don't mind it that much cause it give you story a sort of credibility. I would love to see another story about Orin being topped and with more explanation in regards to Autumn. Keep up the good work, definitely one of the best I've read.

I often read romance novels and come on here to get a change. I haven't read many gay romantic stories but this was simply amazing. I really loved it and wonder if perhaps you have ever considered writing. You might have a chance. Really liked this peace thank you for sharing it. =)

I really liked how you described the sex in detail but the part at the end with autumn could have been left out. Overall it was amazing.

another story with an overly fem character (justin), overly emotional, cry-baby__who the author ends up making the dominant, big-dicked man by the end of the story----now i know where the 'fantasy' comes from in your story.

you had justin say that orin humiliated him in the spin the bottle game- but none of the onlookers seemed to care- then justin does humilate himself by being a drama queen and confessing his love and disappointment that his kiss didn't get orin hard___now that is reason to be humiliated and he did it to himself

(button down shirt with long sleeves. It was an unassuming look that showed a bit of flesh around his narrow hips,)

how does a button down shirt show flesh around the hips? button down shirts usually have longer bodies so they stay tucked in- so i don't get how a dress shirt made his flesh show by his hips

a bit too much drama for my tastes and way too much unbelievable situations/dialogs

however i thought it a little long winded....8 paragraphes just to fuck i found myself missing a full page and still able to keep the story...jonathan.....uk

Autumn is awesome. Who'da thought ....

This is one of my favorite stories on the site. Its sooo beautiful and brings tears to my eyes. You are an incredibly talented writer and I would love to read even more. I hope you can write a story for Autumn, she intrigues me (or at least another story with a cameo appearance by her with her matchmaking again). Can't wait to read more of ur stories. Thank you for writing this one!

Fantastic story!

thanks for a wonderful story...:)

Sorry I ment 213 640 1616

I wana get fucked! Call me 212 640 1616

LOVE IT

PLEASE give us more! I want to see his family's reaction, and I ESPECIALLY want to hear about Justin topping Orin. Pretty please?

The story was exceptional. Very good. As a helpless romantic my self I really fell into you story.

I have one favor to ask though...please, please please...learn the difference between the words THEN and THAN. That's the only thing distracting about your writing for me..

A pretty well done, passionate story...with some random occult fanfic-style Mary-Sue bullshit tacked on haphazardly at the end.

Awesome story. I love your writing.

I really appreciated how you did express the motions between the two lovers. It would have been even better to have described how the dinner was going and their families opinions about them being lovers. Keep up the good work

one of the best stories on here! The descriptions of the characters' emotions and just.... everything- WOW!!! <3 <3 <3

The others wanted to cry but I actually did cry. The story was so touchingly real. I to am like Autumn, ever lonely and at the same time just like Justin was, loving someone from afar for so long and terrified of rejection but savoring a friendship at all cost. Still wiping my tears. Thanks

This was a really touching story. You are a very gifted writer. Be proud and keep up your fantastic work.

Everything a Christmas story should be! Thank you!

OMG i was crying by the end of the first page! so moving heartachingly sweet <3 :D

Wonderful. I feel like autumn... hooking people up, but never one to love for me :) que sera sera... what ever will be will be

Glad you are well and working on yourself :)

I think I want to cry. This was the most beautiful story I have ever come to read, and as a writer, I feel so intensely inspired that I really want to cry. This story...Wow...I believe I am speechless now.

Maybe I should say thank you. Thank you so very much for making such a truly fantastic and heart pounding story as this. You've made this young writer and avid reader the most happiest in days.

Thank you, thank you, thank you.

-Taz

This is the best story I have ever read! Not just online stories, novels as well! Seriously astounding. Played with my emotions from start to finish and just couldn't stop reading it 'til the heart-warming finale. Great job!

I LOVED it. you made a manly man with a soft spot for your stories tear up .

I would throughly enjoy a continuation with Autumn. I thought that she would get involved with the boys lives, but as a lover. LOVED the ending. Thanks.

i love this story so much i have it saved and reread it all the time

THIS STORY WAS GREAT KEEP WRITING PLEASE!!

Would that I could be as good as you. This was freaking awesome. From start to finish I loved it and the Autumn character at the end was "fantastic" and a nice touch

I don't like gay stories, movies and anything to do with gay but this story had me from start to end and had me crying along with the characters. It was so sweet and so real. You did good.

SOOO good! I was really hoping you would write a follow-up with Orin being the bottom. You could write a chapter with Justin "preparing" Orin for his massive tool, lol.

Great story

I LOVE this story. It is one of my three favorite stories on the entire site. I say 3 not because it is the third, but because I can't choose between them. I read "All I Want for Christmas" every other, to every couple of month especially when I am feeling a little down. Reading to me is my way of escaping. "All I Want for Christmas" is one of my favorite worlds to which I escape. Thanx!

The story was brilliant and I fell in love with the characters. I enjoyed the twist at the end with the women who I can only assume are two of the Norns (based on Orin's Norse heritage that it).

I just have to say that this story got to me. I am a straight woman who doesn't normally read the gay male stories, but this one was reccomended to me by a friend. I will absolutely make certain to read the rest of your stories. Keep up the good work.

I liked the story, and while I have to admit its not my favourite piece of lit i did really enjoy it... i also wanted to say to the commentators who say that the tale (esp justin) is too feminine- that there are many kinds of gay out there. "masculine" is definately not the first word that would be used to describe me, its probably not even in the top ten... but im gay and i do want to read lit that describes fems as more then a one dimensional stereotype- so please dont dis those authors that write such stories just because you dont relate to them...

I Love All Of Your Stories, But I think This One Is By Far In My Top Two.

It's Just Beautiful the Way The Story Is Told.

Everytime I Read It, TI Becomes Even Greater.

I know from the amount of comments this story has gotten there is no need for me to repeat the sentiments that are so clear...but I will anyway. I don't think I've come across a story that has mixed the delicacy of new love with erotic, hot sex with such beautiful results. Your writing is one to be respected. I cannot tell you how many times I have reread this story and how each time I find something new to treasure, there simply is no explanation for your ability to do this.

Liked it much... it had much love as much as sex... thanku

Wonderful story(although it COULD use some spelling corrections).

It brought me to tears!(the good kind, of course)!

as always this story gets to me

I wish that you would continue this story and tell more about these two! I didn't really care for the ending though.

i liked every story i read so far from you.

my only distraction when reading your stories are the writing errors on your part, mostly in confusing "you're" with "your" and vice versa. :/

Honestly, Justin sounds a little bit feminine... But it was pretty cool... I only read the first 2 pages tho...

You must not know the first thing about "masculinity", let alone masculine pride. Just comical. Your piece is strictly effeminate and flowery, particularly in the last section and the attempt to involve Fate in such silliness. But this makes sense. What else could it be?? Keep up the good work.

I absolutely loved the story. I can't wait to read more of your stories.

Very impressive you took the what if question and made it into a beautiful story. Well written and touching with of a touch of mystery at the end. I hope we get to see a part II. Keep up the good work.

I switch between crying ang cumming when ever I read this story. I shiver from excitement, every time I re-read Orin's confessions to Justin in the kitchen. I cum like a fireworks display every time I hear Orin in my head begging Justin not to make him cum from his blowjob. I cry like baby when Orin tells Justin over and over that he loves him. And then I cum again when they do.

This story is damn exausting! Great work!

Wow this story is amazing! I read it over and over and over! So beautiful a love story... just... WOW!!!

I'm out of words...

Loved it. Melancholy and uplifting at the same time. Thank you xxx

I absolutly loved this story. It is probably been one of the best gay stories that i have read. keep on making these brilliant stories.

The way you describe the love in Orin and Justin's hearts is amazing. It was a truely touching story. Keep writing and never doubt yourself. You are amazing! :)

Thank you for such a wonderful and sweet story. I'm interested in what happens to Autumn.

This story warmed my heart like no other possibly could. The discovering of these two beautiful people was so awe inspiring. I had tears of hurt and then love in my eyes. I would really love to see this story in film. It would be a beautiful film to be enjoyed by everyone. Terrific story!!!!!!!!!

I was looking all over this site to find a sweet story like this one. Thanks so much!

I really enjoyed your story and I really want to hear more about the very end of the story. I've taken to calling her the Twister of Fate. Please?

I cried through most of it. It was so beautiful. You could relate to the characters and feel their love. Thank you for such a lovely story. I'm another one of your straight female fans. :o)

I actually read this story after I found it on the favorites list of of one of my favorite authors (WildWildBest) and almost did not read it once I saw that it was a "GayMale" story, however, I was surprised...although I shouldn't have been...great writing transcends sexuality and tells a story all can appreciate.

I have NEVER read anything that erotic before!

un-f***ingbelievable. I am straight hetero, but this story moved me like few stories ever have. This story was so moving that I fell in love with both Justin and Orin. From this story it is obvious that if hetero men want to know what hetero women want, then they need to ask gay men. Why isn't this author writing full time for a living? Did I mention how beautiful this story was?

This was less an erotic story then it was the begginging of a novel. Great character developement, smart internal monolog, all-round great writting. I have to say i'll be looking up your other works (if there are any). Its nice to see that there is legitimate talent on this site and not just "fuck n' cum" style writting. Down side: hard to get off to, except for when the "straight" boy is experimenting. HA! Hot imagery.

P.S. Love the hinting at fantasy, and the name "Orin" also reminds me of some series i've read before...