Birthday Pool Party Ch. 41

I know I should stop this kiss, it isn't right. Yet, when Stacey's tongue probes at my lips, I find my mouth opening, allowing her entry. Our tongues dance as we clutch at each other, her breasts squishing against my chest while we both sway softly. That's when I hear a throat clearing behind us.

Our arms fly away from each other as Stacey and I break our kiss and each take several steps back. Facing the other two women in the apartment, I see that Lexi has her arms crossed and a small frown on her face. April looks unsure of how to handle this. We're all silent for at least twenty seconds.

"I, um, we were just..." Stacey eventually mumbles pathetically.

"Stacey was really emotional." I speak up. "I was comforting her."

"With your tongue down her throat?" April wonders with a raised eyebrow.

"Sorry." Stacey squeaks.

"Yeah, sorry Lexi." I say to my girlfriend.

"Should I be worried?" Lexi asks plainly.

"No!" Stacey and I shout at the same time.

"It's okay." Lexi says after a few seconds, finally breaking into a smirk. "I did let you kiss before, and this is a really emotional time for Stacey. Still, fair is fair."

Lexi then shocks all of us by turning and grabbing April by the back of the head. My girlfriend then pulls the stunned nerd forward and plants a big kiss on her. April lets out a surprised squeak before accepting the situation and pressing herself against Lexi so the two short girls can make out.

As Stacey and I watch, April places a hand on Lexi's chest and starts caressing my girlfriend's breast from outside her shirt. Lexi and April moan heavily as their tongues wrestle and they clench at each other. A minute later, they break apart, both red in the face.

"Well that was fun." Lexi comments as she walks over to me and stands on her toes to peck my lips.

"Um, yeah!" April agrees in her cute voice.

"So, what now?" Stacey asks.

"Oh!" April exclaims before holding out the overnight bag on her shoulder. "I packed some clothes for tomorrow, our toothbrushes and birth control pills. I figured we could just put on shoes and get in the car with Lexi and Steven."

"We're gonna go out like this?" Stacey frowns.

"Sure, why not?" April shrugs. "We're wearing robes, we're covered. And we're just going to the car."

"Okay, let's go!" Lexi chirps.

April and Stacey step into shoes before grabbing their phones and purses. I set the door so that it looks like it's firmly shut. That, combined with the crime scene tape should ensure no one tries to get in. Then the four of us head out to my car. The three girls get in my car while I place the overnight bag in the trunk. Then we're off. I call Sarah to let her know that Stacey and April are with me.

"Yeah, Sarah, everything went fine. I owe you one." I say.

"I'm sure I can think of a way for you to repay me, hero." Sarah purrs.

Glancing sideways, I see Lexi smirk in the front seat. Then I look in the rear view mirror and notice Stacey and April giggling in the back seat. Sarah doesn't realize she's on the car speakerphone. My fault for not telling her, I suppose.

"We thank you, too, Sarah!" April can't help but be a little bratty, despite her actual gratitude.

"You're on the car speaker, Sarah." I tell her way too late.

"Oh, um... I'll talk to you later, Steven." Sarah embarrassingly ends the conversation.

I hear a noise, and soon realize that April is leaning forward in her seat. The petite blonde runs her thin fingers along the side of my neck, finding a ticklish spot. I struggle to keep my eyes on the road as I shudder from the tickle and eroticism.

"Yeah, hero..." April breathes into my ear, "we owe you one."

The adorable nerd then breaks into hysterical giggles as the nerves of the night overwhelm her. The giggles turn into full laughter, and soon April is sitting back in her seat with her hand over her mouth. The laughter becomes sobbing tears as I watch in the rear view mirror. April buries her face into Stacey's shoulder. Adrenaline really is a weird thing.

"Breathe." Stacey urges, holding her girlfriend close. "We're okay. We're okay."

"I was so scared!" April wails. "What if he hurt you, Stacey?"

"He didn't hurt either of us." Stacey coos, trying to comfort April. "We're both okay. We're both safe."

"Do either of you need anything?" I ask, trying to take their mind off their fears as I turn my full attention back to the road. "I can stop somewhere if you're hungry."

"I'm okay, how about you, April?" Stacey wonders softly.

"I'm not hungry." April mumbles.

"You're both staying with us tonight." Lexi adds. "We won't let anyone hurt you."

Stacey spends the rest of the ride soothing April. By the time I park the car at the mansion, April is mostly calm. The four of us make our way through the house until we reach the hallway with the bedrooms. Lexi knocks on Kayla's door, then Hazel's. Kayla and Hazel both come out of Kayla's bedroom, this time wearing robes.

"Are you okay?!" Kayla squeals as she rushes to hug Stacey.

"I'm okay." Stacey mumbles, hugging my daughter back.

Hugs are exchanged as Stacey and April repeat their story for Kayla and Hazel. Eventually, we realize just how late it is. April, Stacey, and I are definitely skipping work tomorrow, and Lexi says she isn't going to school. Hazel and Kayla are still planning on going in, so I kiss them before they disappear into their bedrooms.

"You two can use the room beside Hazel's." I say to Stacey and April as I head toward the bedroom.

"I don't want to be away from you." Stacey whispers, tears forming in her eyes.

"It's okay, I'll be with you." April says, taking Stacey's hand. "Lexi and Steven need to go to bed. They've done enough for us."

"Wait." Lexi says before letting out a sigh. I can see compassion in her eyes as she looks at Stacey.

"Everything okay, Lexi?" I ask with a frown.

"Yes." the redhead nods. "Stacey and April have been through a lot tonight. We're here for them."

"Of course we are..." I reply, not sure where my girlfriend is going with this.

"If I had been through that, if Kayla had been through that, neither of us would be able to sleep without you being right there. Remember what happened after the kidnapping? Anyway, we have the giant bed." Lexi smirks. "There's room for all four of us."

"Lexi, are you sure?" April asks slowly.

"I am." my girlfriend nods.

"Thank you." Stacey whispers. "Thank you so much."

"Works out for me, I get to sleep with two hot babes!" Lexi winks as she walks by us and slips into the master bedroom.

With bemused expressions, April, Stacey, and I follow Lexi into the bedroom. We kick off our shoes and socks, then I set the overnight bag down on the vanity before Stacey starts going through it. Lexi is plugging her phone in so it can charge, and April is looking around the large bedroom with interest.

"April, you didn't pack any pajamas." Stacey says while searching through the overnight bag.

"Why would we need pajamas?" April wonders as she confidently drops her robe, revealing her tight body, including her cute, little boobs.

"April!" Stacey hisses, standing over the overnight bag while holding a toothbrush in one hand and a pill container in the other.

"I completely agree!" Lexi announces, whipping off her shirt and tossing it in the hamper.

"I bet you're loving this." Stacey crosses her arms beneath her breasts as she looks at me and rolls her eyes.

"No complaints." I shrug, trying to pretend like I'm not interested. I'm actually watching April out of the corner of my eye. She has a hot, little body, and I'm getting hard just thinking about what I want to do to her. April looks especially cute in her light green panties.

"We can all tell you're checking out April." Lexi giggles, dropping her pants so that she's clad in only her underwear. They're cute; the white pair with pink and red hearts that she wears sometimes.

"I have no idea what you're talking about." I reply, feigning innocence.

"Feel free to look!" April grins, striking a sexy pose, with her arms above her head. "Sadly for you, all of this is for Stacey!"

"Thanks." Stacey smirks, still standing in her robe. "I'm going to go brush my teeth."

"Bathroom is in the back." I inform her, pointing toward the master bathroom.

"Don't change the subject!" Lexi insists, hands on her hips. "Steven, lose the clothes."

"And Stacey, tits out!" April adds, nodding firmly.

Stacey and I look at each other, both of us smiling as we realize how alike our partners are. Both so fiery and energetic, and of course, both perpetually horny. I'm glad that the four of us are starting to become friends. I hope that, in time, all the negativity and awkwardness will completely disappear.

My blonde assistant's eyes start to sparkle as she unties her robe and shrugs out of it, exposing her tight body. I swallow weakly as I admire Stacey's flawless frame. Flat stomach, large breasts, shapely legs, and she's only covered by a pair of red panties.

"Yup, he's hard." Lexi confirms. "Nice job, ladies!"

"I can't help it." I acknowledge with a helpless expression. "All three of you are fucking gorgeous."

"Thanks, sexy man!" April replies, walking up to me and standing on her toes to kiss my cheek. "Now, Stacey and I are going to the bathroom to brush our teeth. You'd better be down to your undies by the time we get back!"

With that, April walks over to Stacey and grabs her own toothbrush before looping her arm through my assistant's. Both girls give me mischievous grins before turning around and heading for the bathroom. The two sexy blondes disappear, leaving me alone with the sexy redhead.

"You sure you're okay with all this?" I ask my girlfriend as I pull off my shirt.

"Why wouldn't I be?" Lexi frowns. "You see titties all the time. And not just in person; I know the Sluts are always sending you random nudes."

"You know what I mean." I respond while taking off my pants. "We'll all be in bed together, practically naked."

"I know." Lexi lets out a breath as she walks up to me, seeming incredibly vulnerable as she looks up into my eyes. "I trust you, Steven. I have to trust you."

"But, we don't have to do this." I explain, wrapping my arms around Lexi and pulling her close. "We can still tell the girls they need to sleep somewhere else. They'd understand."

"No, it's okay." Lexi replies, letting out a breath. "Like I said, I trust you."

"Trying to convince me or you of that?" I wonder with a raised eyebrow.

"Maybe both?" Lexi suggests with a wince. "I just don't ever want to lose you."

"You won't, Lexi. I promise." I whisper.

Lexi leans up, her small breasts squishing against my bare chest as her eyes close. Keeping my arms around my girlfriend, I lower my head and press my lips against hers. We are making out within seconds, Lexi is moaning into my mouth as her fingers clutch the back of my head. At the same time, I slide my hand into the back of Lexi's underwear so I can squeeze her tight ass.

"Starting the party without us, I see." April's cute voice calls out.

"What party?" I scoff, looking over Lexi's head so I can see Stacey and April. "You and Stacey are off limits."

"So, you're planning on having sex right in front of us?" Stacey inquires as she and April hold hands and watch us.

"I probably do owe it to Steven." Lexi replies, looking over her shoulder at the blondes. "I had to give him blue balls when Stacey called."

"You guys were fucking when Stacey called for help?" April asks as Stacey winces, looking guilty.

"Yeah, I was riding him." Lexi shrugs.

"Shit. Sorry." Stacey mumbles, looking mortified.

"Hey, no need to apologize." I quickly say, pulling my hand out of Lexi's panties. "Your safety is more important than Lexi and I getting off."

"Well..." Lexi begins with an evil grin.

"Lexi." I state firmly.

"It's fine." the redhead sighs theatrically. "I suppose."

"I'm really sorry." Stacey says, looking like she's about to cry.

"Lexi was just kidding around, Love." April insists, leaning over to kiss Stacey's cheek. "Everything's fine."

"April's right." I add. "Lexi's just a brat. Why don't we get in bed and relax? We're all safe here."

"I didn't mean anything by it." Lexi speaks up quickly when she realizes her mistake. "I'm sorry, Stacey. Let's lay down."

We stare at each other awkwardly for several seconds before Stacey and April hesitantly approach their side of the bed. Lexi and I walk up to the other, then more awkward staring ensues. The fact that we're all practically naked does not help the situation. I keep finding my eyes drawn to tight curves and hard nipples.

"This is ridiculous." Lexi rolls her eyes as she swats me on the butt. "It's your bed, get in!"

"He's your boss." April adds, copying Lexi by giving Stacey a smack on her pantie-clad ass. "You first!"

Stacey and I look at each other with nervous smiles. I manage to kill a few seconds by reaching down and pulling back the comforter. When I look up, my eyes lock on to Stacey's large breasts. When I finally glance up to her face, she's smirking. This serves to relieve some of the tension, and all four of us laugh softly.

I climb up on the bed, and Stacey follows, allowing my eyes to once more gravitate to the two swaying orbs of perfection hanging from my assistant's chest. She and I lay down side-by-side in the middle of the bed as Lexi and April join us, Lexi next to me and April beside Stacey. Finally, April takes off her glasses, Lexi switches off the lamp on our bedside table, and I pull the covers over the four of us.

We lay in the massive bed, trying to fall asleep. I am on my back, not wanting to turn away from either Lexi or Stacey. Lexi wastes no time snuggling up against my side. Stacey is on her back as well, clearly torn between clinging to me and comforting April. After a short time, my assistant's hand finds mine under the blanket, our fingers lacing. I squeeze Stacey's hand, trying to convey my support and love.

Suddenly, the bed shifts, causing me to frown and open my eyes. On Stacey's far side, April roughly flips from her back to her front. I close my eyes again. A couple minutes later, the bed again shifts as April tries laying on one side, and then the other.

"This fucking sucks!" April announces in a huff, breaking the silence and the awkwardness of four people trying to share a sleeping space together for the first time.

"I think the bed feels nice." Stacey loudly whispers to April. My blonde assistant squeezes my hand tightly.

"The bed is fine." April sighs, finally sitting up. "It's just that, after everything that happened. The terror. The excitement..."

"You're horny." Lexi suddenly grunts, completing the short girl's thought.

"I'm so fucking horny I can't sleep!" April yells out in a combination of a groan and a growl. "Every part of me is vibrating. Fuck it, I've got a date with a shower head."

"Or..." Lexi trails off, pushing on my chest to half sit up and look over at the girls as April moves to get out of bed. "We could all play a game to break the tension and settle us down."

"What kind of game?" I ask suspiciously, knowing how crazy my girlfriend can be.

"A sexy game!" Lexi chirps as she turns on the bedside light, revealing April sitting at the edge of the bed and looking over her shoulder at us with a frown.

"I'm not sure Stacey would be-" April begins.

"That is the best kind of game!" Stacey exclaims, cutting April off.

"Are you sure?" I ask my assistant.

"Yeah, we don't have to." April says. "I can make myself cum in the bathroom, then we can all sleep."

"Am I sure if I wanna play a sexy game with my hot girlfriend, a sexy guy, and his gorgeous girlfriend?" Stacey asks rhetorically. "Yes, I'm sure."

"Great!" Lexi grins. "Now, for the rules!"

"Remember, nothing too crazy." I remind the fiery redhead.

"Hey! I'm the one with jealousy issues, remember?" Lexi points out before waving her hand dismissively. "It's fine now, I trust all of you."

"Thank you." Stacey whispers, tears in her eyes.

"So, tell us about the game!" April grins, pulling her legs back up onto the bed.

Instead of responding, Lexi chooses to climb across the bed. Getting off the bed and walking around it is probably the smarter choice, but no, my girlfriend just crawls over me, her knee digging into my stomach and making me wince. Stacey grunts out when Lexi places her hand on the blonde's stomach so she can get over us, landing in front of April. Finally, Lexi sits cross-legged while facing April. In response, April gets into position in front of the pillow, legs crossed as she watches the redhead, who is a couple feet away.

"Are you gonna tell us the rules, or would you rather knee me in the stomach again?" I ask, giving her a fake look of annoyance.

"Just be glad it wasn't your balls." Lexi rolls her eyes.

"C'mon, tell us!" Stacey urges as she sits up.

"Okay, okay!" Lexi giggles. "This may push some boundaries. Maybe even mine. I don't know yet. That's why the first rule is that, anyone who wants to stop, just say so and everything ends. Anyone."

"That's a good rule." I reply, nodding in approval as I sit up.

"Second, the game is called Mirrors. I'm gonna sit across from April, and Steven will sit across from Stacey." Lexi explains as she points to the spot on the bed where she wants me to sit. "Whatever I do to April, Steven is going to do to Stacey. And whatever April does to me, Stacey is going to do to Steven."

"Oh! This sounds fun!" April exclaims in her cute voice as she claps her hands. Then she freezes and glances over at Stacey nervously. "Um, as long as you're okay with me playing with Lexi?"

"I am." Stacey nods. "Well, I'm okay with it if I can play with Steven!"

"That's fine with me." April says, letting out a breath. "I trust you."

"Yeah, yeah. Mushy later. Orgasms now." Lexi grins.

"What about Nicole?" I ask.

"Inviting another lady to the party, great!" April laughs.

"No, no, I mean, I don't want to cheat on her or anything." I explain.

"You're not, she already gave you permission." Lexi reasons. "She's asleep now, we'll tell her the details tomorrow."

"Okay." I state with a nod.

Moving down the bed, I take my place across from Stacey, sitting cross-legged while wearing only my boxer briefs. My assistant looks incredibly sexy in her red panties. Sitting on Stacey's right is April, wearing just a pair of light green underwear. The little nerd's pink nipples are hard, and I can tell how horny she is. Finally, to my left, is Lexi. The sexy nymphomaniac's auburn hair is framing her face as she smiles at April, my girlfriend's only clothing is a pair of white panties with pink and red hearts.

"Who's first?" Stacey asks hesitantly, her hand brushing back her long blonde hair as her baby blues look at me with a mixture of nerves and desire.

"Lexi." I insist firmly. "It's her game."

"Mm, don't mind if I do!" Lexi husks, giving April a sultry look.

The two blondes and I watch Lexi, all three of us wondering what the freckled redhead will do first. My anticipation turns to shock as I see the fire dim in Lexi's eyes, her lustful gaze faltering and her predatory body language giving way to fidgeting. I glance toward April and see my confusion mirrored on the petite blonde's face. She doesn't know what's wrong, but I can see the problem. The fiery, confident girl is actually afraid. Lexi is in her head too much and doesn't want to look like a kid in front of the two older women.

Lexi's uncertainty is allowing the three of us to see her soft side. The aura of the strong seductress is breaking, leaving behind the insecure girl that Lexi usually only shows me. I only stay quiet because I know that Lexi will not want to be embarrassed in front of the blondes. It's too late for that, this is going on for too long. I have to speak up.