Ch. 03 Ellie Meets Peter's Girlfriend

Story Info
Ellie's relationship with Peter expands to sexy girlfriend.
4.6k words
4.54
8.3k
19

Part 3 of the 6 part series

Updated 02/27/2024
Created 12/30/2023
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

I probably should have been more optimistic about my trip to see Peter. As it was, I was feeling very bitter sweet.

Sweet, because I was going to see my big brother, who also happened to be my lover. We'd become intimate after I seduced him to take my virginity last summer. We'd both been away at college now for months - me at UCLA and Peter at Florida State University. I missed him terribly. We'd always been close as siblings go, but since we'd experienced a new level of intimacy, I ached for him even more.

The trip was a little bitter, because I was going meet Peter's girlfriend Laura. Yes, there was now another woman in his life. I was bummed.

As our summer had drawn to a close, Peter and I had discussed this very topic. We both knew college brought opportunities for new relationships. Peter had had girlfriends before and I didn't want to hold him back. Even though I was pretty jealous, I loved my brother too much to want to have him exclusively. But that didn't stop me from feeling the loss.

What I faced now was the distinct possibility that I'd never make love to my brother again. That made be very sad.

The primary reason I was going to Florida State was for a tennis match. I was on a full-ride tennis scholarship to UCLA and on the traveling team, even though I was just a freshman. Peter is eighteen months older than me but already a junior at FSU. We'd agreed to meet at a restaurant after my matches were done on Friday.

Did I mention that I'm really good at tennis? It matters, because, in one of my matches, I beat last year's national collegiate women's tennis champion in straight sets. That just doesn't happen, especially for a freshman. It caused a big stir in the women's college tennis world. After the match, I was surrounded by reporters who were focusing on me as the "next big thing" in women's tennis.

We'd been scheduled to return to Los Angeles on Saturday. But when Sports Illustrated called and said they wanted to do a feature on me that next Monday, my head coach and I stayed on for the weekend.

It was late October, and the days were getting shorter. Fortunately the weather was still great in Tallahassee - with temperatures in the 80's. When I finally broke free from the scouts and reporters at the tennis center, I hurried to my hotel.

There, I changed into power blue leggings. I took a moment to admire myself in the hotel room mirror. The leggings were the kind that are so tight through your crotch that they nicely outlined my butt cheeks and pulled so tight in front that they showed off my pubic mound and outlined my pussy lips in a coffee bean-like shape. I finished off the outfit with a fairly tight-fitting crop top that pulled against my pert tits.

At 5'5", I'm much shorter than Peter's 6'1". I remember when we were younger, he would innocently kiss the top of my head of dark brown hair. It made me laugh to think of the other places he'd kissed me since we became intimate.

You might be asking why I was dressed like that? Well, while I was going to accept Peter's girlfriend, for sure, I also wanted Peter to know what he was missing, and perhaps show off my body a bit.

The restaurant was busy, but Peter had reserved a quiet booth surrounded by tall panels on three sides. When I approached the table, Peter and Laura were already seated. There was my Peter, as handsome and sexy as ever, a huge smile on his face.

Sitting across from him was Laura, the new girl. Pictures Peter had shared did not prepare me for seeing her in person. I knew she was good looking, but now, in the flesh, she was just magnificent. As she scooted to the edge of the bench seat I noticed long blonde hair, halfway down her back and tied in a single French braid. Her face was silky smooth, blue eyes that sparkled and fair eyebrows - hinting at a light blonde bush.

What stunned me most in those seconds were her breasts: two perfect and perfectly large globes. She was wearing a white knit top that was so tight, it outlined every curve of her boobs. She must have been wearing a non-padded bra because I could clearly see her nipples pushing straight out and even glimpsed the bumps on her large areola also outlined through the top.

As she began to stand I noticed her flat stomach, narrow waist, and long legs. As she spread her legs apart just a bit to get out of the booth, I could see she wore a very short skirt and underneath: not knit shorts but a pair of lacy pink panties covering her pussy.

I did not expect myself to be ogling over Peter's girlfriend. I was embarrassed, but when I looked up, I noticed Laura was smiling, her eyes just lifting from my crotch, across my chest and into my eyes. Was she checking me out?

All this happened in, like, two seconds as Laura got off the bench to greet me. "Ellie! It is so great to meet you," she said, reaching out for a hug. "Peter's told me so much about you!" she whispered in my ear as she wrapped her arms around me.

I returned the hug and felt her breasts pressing against mine.

She then held me at arms length. "I've kind of been obsessed with you since Peter told me how good of a tennis player you are. And today? Shit, Ellie - you're a star!"

"It was just one match," I said, trying to keep my perspective and not let one victory go to my head.

"Oh, it was more than that!" Peter said, stepping over to get his hug.

Laura let me go and I felt the strong arms of my brother and lover surround me. I missed him so acutely that it hurt.

"Hey sis," he said quietly. "I've missed you!"

"Me too," I replied. "Very much!"

We exchanged a knowing look for a brief second.

"Come and sit," Peter said as he sat back down on the bench and Laura scooted in beside him.

I took a seat facing them with Peter closest to me. We ordered something to drink. Once the server left, Peter put his right hand on Laura's bare thigh. Oh, how I wished that hand was on me! He reached over with his left hand and gave my hand a squeeze. Maybe this was hard for him too?

"So tell me," Laura said. "What did it feel like, beating a national champ?"

"I mean, it felt great, of course," I answered. "Maybe she was having an off day. Not sure. She is very good and would probably beat me if we played again tomorrow."

"Everybody's talking about it," Peter said. "I couldn't be prouder of you - my little sister!"

I was starting to blush. Fortunately, I was saved from further embarrassment by the server, who came by to deliver our drinks.

"Tell me about you two," I said, once the server left. "How'd you meet and all that?"

I actually already knew this from conversations with Peter, but I wanted to hear it from Laura.

Laura looked at Peter and said, "we're in a poly sci class together. That's my major. Anyway, we did a project together and had to spend time outside of class." She reached up and stroked Peter's cheek with the fingers of her right hand. "Let's just say we hit it off big time!"

"We've gotten very close pretty quickly," Peter said, returning Laura's gaze and kissing her gently on the lips.

The couple turned and faced me again, smiling with a 'we've fucked each other a lot' kind of smile. Oddly, I wasn't disgusted or even disappointed. In fact, it kind of turned me on to thing about Peter sticking his cock into Laura's pussy. I nearly had to shake my head to break out of this impromptu fantasy. I was supposed to be feeling sad and jealous, not aroused!

"Peter is such a great lover," Laura said, staring straight at me. "So gentle and yet so hard where it counts."

Now this was unexpected. Boy, was she forward.

She continued, "but you already know that, right?"

Shit! What was happening here!

"Wait, what?" I said, dumbfounded.

I looked at Peter who shrugged his shoulders slightly.

"I guess I sort of spilled the beans about us a little," he said, sheepishly.

"What the fuck, Peter?" I said.

I immediately expected judgment from Laura. Maybe she was even angry that Peter would have an incestuous relationship with his younger sister. But when I looked back at Laura she just lifted the corners of her mouth in a very naughty smile, her head tilted down just a bit and one of her eyebrows raised ever so slightly.

"It's okay, Ellie," Laura said finally. "I know you and Peter are lovers too."

My eyes widened in surprise and shock.

Laura continued, "at first, I must admit, it felt a little strange. But the more he talked about you and your relationship, the more intrigued I got."

"Seriously?" I said.

"Oh yeah," she said, looking at Peter and placing her left hand on his right thigh. "Once he showed me your picture, I knew why he was attracted to you, even though you're related."

She laughed gently and looked back at me, "I know this is going to sound weird, but one time when we were fucking, and Peter was driving his cock deep into my pussy, I started fantasizing that I was you fucking my brother."

"Shit!" I said, very surprised. I looked around briefly to see if anyone could hear but our booth was in the back and very private.

"You don't mind if I'm totally honest, do you?" Laura asked.

I looked back at her, slowly coming to grips with the turn the conversation had taken. "Of course I don't mind, um, I just never thought someone would fantasize about me," I said, with my own version of a naughty smile.

"When I said I was obsessed with you, it wasn't just about tennis," Laura said with a frank look on her face. "I started asking questions about where you've made love, what positions you've tried, how easy it is to bring you to an orgasm. That sort of thing."

My eyebrows rose in response and my pussy started itching. I was getting turned on by my brother's girlfriend!

"And why did you want to know all that?" I asked.

Laura looked over at Peter, who smiled and nodded.

Looking back at me, she said, "I know this is hard for you, knowing your brother is fucking another woman. But I don't want to be just the other woman. I'm really hoping we can join together in loving this exceptional man and his wonderful body."

She reached across the table with her right hand to grasp mine. "Bottom line, Ellie, we want to make love with you!"

A threesome with another woman. This was a first for me, especially when that woman was my brother's girlfriend.

"What do you say, Ellie?" Peter said.

I looked at Peter, then at Laura. I couldn't help but notice that her tits were really pushing out of her top, making nice little mounds sticking straight out. She was getting aroused as well.

"You like my tits, Ellie?" Laura said, following my gaze.

"They look delicious, and so big," I said, letting my arousal take away the shock of what was being proposed.

"Oooh, that's what I wanted to hear," Laura said, squirming slightly. "I couldn't help but notice how tight your leggings are. It makes me want to explore between your ass cheeks and lick up and down your slit."

As Laura and I looked at each other, I licked my lips sensuously.

"I could get into that," I said, smiling.

"Fuck, guys," Peter said. "I'm super glad with where this is going. Maybe it's time we head back to my place to continue the conversation and a lot more?"

We all scooted out of the booth. Peter took my hand and kissed it. Laura put her arm around my waist and gave my butt cheek a little squeeze as we headed for the exit.

Laura and Peter rode in the front of Peter's car and I took the back seat behind Peter. I touched his shoulder gently and he reached up and gave my hand a squeeze. He was still my Peter, but now I was going to share him with another. I was getting royally turned on!

When we got to Peter's apartment, we sat on the couch with me in between Peter and Laura. I turned my head to Peter who kissed me. I opened my mouth and our tongues met for the first time in months. We broke off the kiss as Laura gently turned my head towards her.

"I've been so looking forward to this," Laura said, moving in and placing her lips on mine.

I felt a new feeling of arousal course through me as she pushed her tongue into my mouth. I explored her tongue and mouth and she explored mine. I felt Peter's tongue on my neck and in my ear.

"My cock is so hungry for you," he said, nibbling on my earlobe.

As I continued to make out with Laura, I felt Peter's hand on my left breast, kneading and cupping it through my bra. A moment later Laura was stroking my right nipple, making it stand up and harden. I found myself lifting my chest in response, a fresh sense of arousal flowing between my legs.

"Fuck, you guys!" I said, breaking off the kiss with Laura. "You're really turning me on! I'm getting so wet."

"Right now I need better access to those great tits!" Laura said.

I lifted my arms and the two pulled my top off, throwing it on the ground. Laura leaned over and put her mouth on my nipple, making my bra wet with her tongue.

"Mmmm," I said. "That feels great!"

I reached back and undid my bra, letting it slide off my shoulders.

"Fuck!" Laura said. "You weren't kidding, Peter. Such great tits!"

"They're not as big as yours," I said, admiring Laura's big globes.

"I can't wait for you to taste them!" Laura said.

I reached over and gently stroked her hardened nipples. She shivered in response.

Laura leaned over and took my entire areola into her mouth. She started licking and sucking it. Peter did the same with my other breast and I was overwhelmed with wonderful feelings. I looked down at the two of them suckling my nipples and noticed a big wet spot on my crotch. I was already soaking through my thong and leggings.

Laura left my breast and lifted up her face to kiss and tongue me. She took my nipple between her fingers and twisted it, lifting it slightly. I shuddered at the feelings that shot through me.

As I made out with Laura again, Peter reached down and began to caress my pussy lips through the stretchy fabric of my leggings. My hips rose up to meet his fingers. I placed my hands on the waist band and lifted my butt off the couch, sliding the leggings down to my knees. Peter and Laura pushed them the rest of the way off of my legs and onto the floor.

This gave Peter better access to my pussy - only my thong separated me from his fingers as he rubbed up and down my slit.

"Peter," I said, breaking off from Laura. "I've missed your cock so much." I moved my hand and started rubbing Peter's hardening dick. "I wasn't sure I was going to ever get to experience it again!"

"Mmmm," Peter said, closing his eyes. "I wouldn't let that happen!"

"I want to suck your dick!" I said, undoing Peter's belt and snaps and zipper.

Peter responded by lifting up and letting me pull them off, exposing that gorgeous dick. I began stroking his member with both hands, squeezing and moving up and down his shaft. I kissed the top of his dick and began licking it.

"Oh shit!" Laura said. "I'm watching a sister give her brother a blow job!"

As I put Peter's dick into my mouth and began sucking it, I noticed Laura reach down and begin to rub her pussy.

After a minute or so, I got off the couch, crouched down and turned around. "I've been lusting after your pussy all night, Laura," I said. "Let me help you by eating you out!"

Laura responded by pulling off her tight top, revealing a lacy, thin bra that she quickly undid. Her two incredible breasts burst forth, nipples erect and pointing straight out, her large dark brown areola begging to be licked.

I moved up between her legs and began sucking and licking her nipples and kneading her breasts.

"Oh fuck!" Laura said, gently moving my hair to the side.

I gently bit one of her nipples and pulled out. Laura gasped in response.

"Oh fuck!" Laura said, holding my head to her chest.

Peter leaned over and began kissing Laura while I used one of my hands to take over rubbing her clit. Laura lifted up and I removed her skirt and pink panties in one move.

I got down on my knees and stared at her beautiful pussy. Her bush was as light as her eyebrows - thin, wispy hairs, nicely trimmed into a triangle pointing to her pussy lips. I could smell her scent. It was sweet and a little salty. I couldn't wait to taste her juices.

Peter and Laura broke off.

"Oh please lick my pussy, Ellie!" Laura said, running her hands through my hair.

I began kissing Laura's inner thighs, licking with my tongue and getting closer to her pussy. I ran my fingers through her delicate bush. Her hips began thrusting forward to meet my mouth.

"Oh yeah, oh fuck!" Laura said, her breathing faster.

Peter continued to fondle her breasts and kiss her neck. Laura began stroking Peter's dick with her left hand.

I flicked my tongue between her pussy lips and felt a gush of juice flow into my mouth. It tasted so good, just like her scent. I used my fingers to separate her lips and began licking up and down her slit.

"Oh shit. Oh shit. Oh shit!" Laura cried out. "You're going to make me cum!"

I knew she was getting close so I moved my tongue up and began gently sucking on her clit, flicking out my tongue across her love button.

"I'm cumming!" she cried as her legs began to shake. She arched her back and held her breath before crying out in pleasure.

"Oh! Oh! Oh! Ahhhhh!"

Laura held my head to her pussy so hard I could barely breathe. I just kept licking her gently until the orgasm subsided. She then pulled me up and kissed me deeply, tonguing my mouth that was full of her own juices.

"Shit, Ellie!" Laura said, still breathless. "You made me cum so hard, and I'm still turned on!"

Peter then came into for a kiss with me, and then with Laura.

"Wow!" Peter said when they'd broken off. "I've never seen you eat another pussy before, Ellie. That was amazing and really made my dick want to explode!"

"Oh don't cum yet, Peter," Laura said. "I want you save that for inside your sister's cunt!"

"I like the sound of that!" I said.

"Let's take this into my bedroom," Peter said, standing - his erection sticking straight out.

"I think you're ready," I said, standing and helping Laura up off the couch. "So nice and hard!"

We stood facing each other for a moment and started a three-way kiss. It was incredible to feel all those tongues and lips melding together. Finally, Peter broke off and pulled us down the hallway and into his room.

Peter got on the bed and laid on his back. Laura and I got up on either side of him and began working on his cock. We licked up and down his shaft with two mouths, tongues, and lips.

"Oh shit that feels good!" Peter moaned.

As Laura and I got to the top of his dick we french-kissed each other around his mushroom-shaped head. I was getting majorly wet and really wanted my brother's dick inside my pussy.

"I want to fuck you now, Peter!" I said.

"I've got to see this!" Laura said. "You're going to make me cum just thinking about you two fucking together!"

"Why don't you fuck me from behind while I eat out Laura's pussy again?" I said.

"Shit yeah!" Peter said, getting up onto his knees and turning.

I also got on my knees and pulled off my thong, turning my ass to Peter's dick. Laura scrambled up to the head of the bed, sat down and opened her legs up to me, her pussy red, swollen, and ready for my tongue and lips.

"Fuck me, brother!" I said, reaching between my legs and pulling Peter's dick to my waiting cunt.

As I felt him push against the opening to my pussy I pushed back on his cock, sending it deep inside me. The feeling of having my brother's dick in me once again was surreal. I'd gone from despairing that I'd never make love to him again, to having a threesome with his girlfriend!

"Fuck me, Peter. Fuck me with your cock!"

Peter began thrusting in and out of my pussy, sending waves of pleasure through me. Laura watched with wide eyes.

"A brother and sister fucking!" she said, starting to rub her clit. "Shit! Fuck! I'm so horny!"

12