Her Sister's Husband

Story Info
Sisters who share everything.
10.1k words
4.39
44.5k
84
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

At birth she had been named Gennifer but had always gone by 'Jenny'. In high school Jenny had always been a popular enough girl. She'd dated a bit but nothing serious ever came about from those dalliances. Academically speaking she was mediocre and she wasn't really interested in going to college. After twelve years of compulsory education she'd had enough of school and instead opted for a nice enough job at a coffee place in Bozeman.

Her parents were fine with this choice. They weren't really the academic types themselves and hadn't complained when Jenny's older sister Leslie took a pass on the college and career path. To some degree they were relieved because paying for college wasn't really one of their goals in life.

When Leslie took a job at a local lumber mill it wasn't long before the divorced owner of the place asked her out on a date. Her long brown hair, comfortable demeanor, and her pleasant appearance captivated him. Despite the fifteen year age difference between them Leslie didn't hesitate when he took her to a fancy place one night and proposed.

The thirty-three year old Zack was successful in business but not so much in his first marriage which ended with a difficult divorce. His ex-wife had left him the six bedroom house and she moved away to Florida to escape the snow. He was a big man who had the look of someone who worked hard and who never needed to work out. He held his own in a business suit and he also wore his Carhartt's as if he were born in them.

Their wedding was modest as weddings went in rural Montana. Leslie wore the requisite white dress and deservedly so. There were friends, family, neighbors, and business associates in attendance and it was truly a lovely event.

It was later that night when Leslie discovered the full spectrum of Zack's ardor and passions. Although Leslie had talked about holding off on children for a while she discovered that Zack had no such plans. She had been caught up in the passion of her first sexual experience when Zack took her virginity and soon enough she accepted her first load of baby batter.

Their honeymoon was spent in a friend's place on the lake at Coeur D'Alene. It was a blur of romance and bare, unprotected sex and Leslie wasn't terribly surprised when soon enough she discovered she was pregnant. Zack was overjoyed at the news and that pleased his new bride.

The baby boy was born right as Jenny graduated from high school. Not having anything else to do she stayed with Zack and Leslie for a few weeks to help with the new baby and the big house. In that time she spent more than a little time sneaking glances at her sister's husband and admiring his rugged good looks.

In due time she went home and embarked on her new career in the coffee business.

When Jenny's nineteenth birthday came along Leslie couldn't attend the family dinner because the second pregnancy wasn't as easy as the first. Even though she was only in her first trimester Leslie was nauseous all the time and it was hard to function.

In one of those quirks of the universe a candle from Jenny's birthday cake hadn't quite been extinguished when it had been tossed into the kitchen garbage can. Hours later the diligent family dog woke everyone up and they escaped from the house and huddled together to watch their family home brightly burn in the night.

Jenny and Leslie's parents decided that the fire was their reason to retire and after the insurance issues were settled the two of them decamped for the warmer climate of Florida.

That left Jenny in need of a place to call home and of course her sister Leslie came to the rescue. Well, actually Leslie was laid up with complications from the pregnancy so it was Zack who helped Jenny get settled in at the house.

It was understood that Jenny would satisfy her rental obligations by handling her sister's duties about the house. Jenny had no problem with this and after quitting the coffee gig she did a fine full time job of juggling child care, laundry, shopping, and caring for pregnant Leslie.

Zack got used to seeing Jenny working around the house and taking care of her sister and the baby. As a particularly hot summer started in Jenny found herself going about her duties in a halter top and shorts. Zack couldn't help but stare at her long legs and trim body. Jenny would catch him staring at her and she misread it as Zack's disapproval of her efforts.

Jenny spoke to Leslie and Leslie just dismissed Jenny's concerns thinking it was work pressure and worries about the pregnancy that were bothering Zack.

Eventually Leslie took notice of Zack's attentions towards her younger sister and decided to confront him about it one evening.

"So you're checking out my sister quite a bit lately. What's that about?"

Zack shrugged. "She's cute, what can I say? You girls are something special and I don't mind looking at you."

Leslie's face scrunched up. "And nothing more? You're not going to fuck her?"

"Leslie!" complained Zack, "You're the only woman for me, baby! Can't blame a guy for looking at a pretty girl can you?"

"But it's crossed your mind, right?"

Zack was savvy enough to stop and think about what was being said. "Is this some sort of trap where no matter what I say I'll get in trouble?"

Leslie shook her head. "No, I guess I'm not going to blame you for looking when we haven't been able to do much lately with me sick all the time." She said this while caressing her baby-filled belly.

They changed the subject after that and talked about other things. What was ironic was that Zack had not consciously thought about Jenny in an improper way and now it seemed to be stuck in his head. It was also stuck in his head that his wife seemed to be encouraging him to pursue Jenny.

For her part Leslie found herself smiling later that night as she saw Zack eyeballing Jenny's legs again. Neither of them were aware that Leslie was harboring a bit of a kinky desire to see her husband and her sister together. Leslie felt guilty for having such a kink but at the same time the idea of her husband boinking the chaste and proper Jenny gave her chills. On balance she knew there was something a bit wrong about her kink but she embraced it anyway.

Over the years Leslie had harbored a love/hate relationship with her proper little sister. This grew when people had treated Leslie like a trophy wife for marrying the older and successful Zack. Those same people would gush and go on about Jenny's virtues and how she was 'one of those girls who will always do the right thing'. Leslie loved her sister but she also wanted to see her brought down a bit.

Thus Leslie started doing whatever she could to push things along between Zack and Jenny.

Her first effort was to get out of bed one day and keep company with Jenny while Jenny did the laundry. When Jenny put a load of her own things in the washing machine the sly Leslie reached over and switched the cold water to hot. The result was Jenny's clothes were now a tad smaller than before. This made Jenny's modest tits stand out more than before.

The next time it was putting too much bleach in with Jenny's panties. Jenny always used a touch of bleach with her panties to help keep down any bacteria but after Leslie got done with them they were always kind of itchy because they'd never been rinsed enough.

Then there were the sexually charged conversations she started having with Jenny. At first Jenny was shocked that her sister would talk about such things but then she did so in a mature way and it wasn't long before Jenny opened up about her own desires. Leslie enjoyed having gotten Jenny to discuss the notions of sex and Zack at the same time.

Leslie did some other clever things but the one that worked the best was the one she hadn't planned at all. One night she was getting into bed and she vomited all over the place! With the summer heat the smell of puke permeated the bedroom.

Jenny helped to clean it up and she made the bed afresh for Leslie while Leslie cleaned up. For his part Zack decided it was time to sleep in the living room. A little pissed off at the situation he got himself four fingers of whisky and drank it down.

It was well past midnight when Jenny decided to go to bed and having a raging headache she went to Leslie's medicine cabinet and found a brand name bottle of pain reliever. Blue pills. She took three of them and went to her bedroom.

With the hot night and the air conditioning on the fritz Jenny was uncomfortable to say the least. Add to that her itchy panties and she was fit to be tied! Getting up she closed her bedroom door, hesitated for a moment, slipped off her panties, and then lay down on her bed. Sleep hit her like a pickup truck.

Zack was restless on the couch. It had been months since the last time he'd been with his wife and as usual he was trying to sleep with a hard on. He thought about going to the bathroom to relieve himself in the sink but then his mind drifted to Jenny. He thought about her long legs. Her pleasing smile. Her perky little tits. The tight belly. Her delicate hands.

Rising to his feet he silently crept to Jenny's room and was surprised to find the door closed. He thought for a moment about a plausible reason for opening the door and decided he'd ask Jenny something about the baby. He opened the door and quietly said something that really didn't matter. In the dark he could see her sleeping on her side.

The three blue pills Jenny had taken about forty minutes prior were pain relievers but they were also the 'PM' kind which came with a sleep aid. The directions said to take one and she'd taken three.

Which meant she didn't feel Zack's fingers when he'd first ventured to touch her bare foot to see if she was awake.

Zack noted Jenny's lack of response to his touch. He thought about it for a moment and then ran his hand up her ankle to the hem of her sleep shirt. He ventured a bit more hoping to feel her cotton panties and then he realized she wasn't wearing panties at all!

He pulled back his hand and listened to Jenny snoozing. He could tell she was in a deep sleep. Pondering the situation before him he considered what to do next. He ended up telling himself that he just wanted to explore Jenny's body a little bit and then head back to his couch. His hand slowly drifted to her thigh and then slid up to her bare ass. The sleep shirt rose as he did this.

In her sleep Jenny felt someone caress her body. She dreamed it was Zack and even in her dream she chastised herself for the improper thought.

"Mmmmm Zack...please..." she sleepily uttered aloud.

Zack was taken aback with the girl's mumblings. Was she awake? Was she okay with this? Did she want him?

It took him the veritable eternity of twenty seconds to see if Jenny was okay with his touch. Slipping his hand under her sleep shirt he ventured to feel further up her body eventually stopping at her ribs. He could feel the tender flesh where her tits came together with her ribs. He moved further.

In her dream Jenny felt Zack caress her boob. He was gentle and it felt so good!

"Oh, gahh, yeah..." she mumbled.

He gently tweaked her nipple and saw the welcome response as Jenny pushed her ass back as if to entice him.

That did it for him. He dropped his shorts and pulled off his t-shirt.

Reaching down he pulled Jenny up into a sitting position.

"Wharrrs going on?" she asked, being somewhat awake now.

"I'm taking off your nighty for you." he answered as he pulled the garment up and off of her body.

"Oh, okay." she answered as she lay back naked on the bed.

In Jenny's mind she wasn't sure if she was dreaming or if she was awake but she didn't mind having Zack's attentions either way. She felt him pull her legs apart and then felt him move up between them.

She heard herself moan as Zack's mouth latched onto one of her nipples and suckled. It felt so good!

Zack loved hearing Jenny's approval while he sucked her tit. Moving up her body he kissed her neck and then she moved her hair so he could kiss it some more. His kiss on her neck morphed into a suckle at the same time he let his weight rest on top of her.

Zack had been with three other women in his life and Jenny would be the fourth. He had a little bit of a tradition that each of his conquests would be sporting a very telling hickey when he got done with her. He liked marking them as his. He liked that other people would see it.

Jenny sleepily writhed with pain and arousal as Zack sucked hard and bit on her neck. In her struggles her legs spread further apart and Zack moved himself closer to her treasure.

She felt it. It was poking into her right where she'd long wanted to be poked.

But it was just a dream, right? It couldn't be real. Right?

Now Zack might have been about to fuck his wife's virgin sister but he wasn't entirely an asshole. He stopped and whispered in Jenny's ear.

"Jenny, do you want me to make love to you?"

Jenny hadn't expected the Zack of her dream to ask such a thing. She was confused and teetering on that twilight border between being asleep and being awake. She was also the most sexually aroused she'd ever been in her life. She knew there were reasons why she shouldn't do such a thing but this was just a dream, wasn't it?

"Yes." she finally managed to say.

Zack responded to Jenny with a gentle kiss as his cock started to search for the right angle.

Jenny woke up a bit more as she felt Zack's cock push and prod at her body.

"Is this real?" she wondered to herself. It felt real. It felt good too. She moved her legs up and rested the soles of her feet on the sides of Zack's thighs.

Jenny's new position put her in the perfect position for Zack. Her flower had opened and the moist mouth of her pussy now kissed the swollen head of Zack's cock.

"Ohhhh, fuck!" she exclaimed as years of sexual need and longing was finally answered. Zack's cock slipped into her and then it pulled back leaving her wanting more. And then he drove himself deeper into her.

She'd long expected her first sex to be painful but this felt wonderful! She told herself this must be a dream as the two of them were finally and fully coupled.

"I'm not a virgin anymore" she silently observed to herself.

Zack passionately fucked her. He'd been obsessed with fucking Jenny ever since Leslie made him confront his own feelings. And it had been months since he'd been with Leslie. The combination of desire for Jenny and simple pent-up sexual need (not to mention a liberal dose of whisky!) now had him pounding away.

Jenny felt a sudden anxious sensation as Zack fucked her. It was so much stronger than anything she'd ever done on her own. The orgasm started in her belly and seemed to radiate out from there.

"Oh...oh.....ohhhhhhh" she sighed as her body convulsed with joy! Zack felt her pussy seize his cock and it rippled along its length...milking it and demanding it give up his essence.

Zack couldn't hold back any longer. He plowed deep into Jenny's body and heard her cry out as his cock throbbed and pulsed and danced in her moist embrace.

Zack moaned as his balls emptied into Jenny's willing pussy. It felt so damned good to finally have his cock inside her pussy! It felt even better to him that his was her first cock and that his was the first cum to claim her body.

Jenny had cried out when Zack speared her deep. It had been sudden and forceful and despite her bleary eyed, post-orgasmic sleepiness she found herself much more awake and very aware of Zack's cock. She felt it throbbing and pulsing and felt him straining to get himself deeper into her body.

"Is this real?" she said out loud.

Soon enough Zack's cock stopped pulsing cum into her pussy and he rolled himself off of her. The cool night air swept across her hot sweaty body and she felt satisfied and relieved all at the same time. She soon rolled away from Zack and onto her side before the chemically induced deep sleep overcame her again.

For his part Zack was a little amused and also a little slighted that Jenny could have her first fuck and then just roll over and go to sleep. He let his hand feel her bare ass and considered sleeping with her for the night. Realizing that his wife might not be so keen on finding her naked husband and naked sister together in bed he reluctantly got up.

He thoughtfully pulled the bedsheet over Jenny's sleeping form and enjoyed how the sheet accented the curves of her body. Leaning down he kissed her on the lips and then quietly closed the door on his way back to the couch.

It was late Friday morning when Jenny finally rose from her bed. She contemplated her unexpected nakedness and then let it go to the hot night and itchy panties. She went to the bathroom and did her usual morning routine before putting on her usual outfit of a t-shirt and shorts. She noticed she needed to clean up 'Miss Pussy' a bit more than usual. And she noticed a vague soreness in her pussy. Ignoring it all she followed the scent of coffee to the kitchen.

"Good morning, sleepyhead! I was wondering when you'd get up" said Leslie as she handed her sister a cup of coffee.

Jenny shook her head. "Crazy dreams last night. They were so real!" she said as she pulled back her hair.

Leslie saw the hickey just below Jenny's right ear and put it together and smiled.

"Oh, what did you dream about?"

Jenny sipped her coffee. "Um...it was kind of inappropriate really."

Leslie sat down, "Oh, then you must tell me! I'm all ears!"

"You won't be mad at me?"

"I promise." said Leslie as she crossed her heart.

Jenny looked around, "Where's Zack?"

"He left for work hours ago. Why?"

Jenny blushed. "I had a dream that he'd made love to me. He even asked me if it was okay and in the dream I said yes."

Jenny sipped her coffee and continued. "It was so vivid! Like I felt everything but it was supposed to be a dream. I've never had a dream like that before." She looked at Leslie, "I hope you don't mind me being honest about having a dirty dream about Zack. Is that okay?"

Leslie smiled. "I'm okay with it. I appreciate that you're honest with me, too. Now maybe you need to go take a good look at yourself in the mirror."

Jenny looked quizzically at her sister. "What?"

Leslie shooed her. "Go look in the mirror. Go!"

Jenny got up and went to the bathroom off the kitchen to look at herself. It took a moment but then she saw the red purple hickey before she returned to the kitchen.

"What the hell is this?" she asked her sister.

Leslie smiled again. "It's a hickey."

Jenny was clearly confused. "Yeah, but how did I get it?"

Leslie sipped her coffee and swallowed before responding. "I'd say you got it from Zack. He likes to do that the first time he makes love to you."

Jenny's jaw dropped. It had really happened!! Suddenly in her mind she connected all the dots. She had woke up naked after being undressed in what she thought was a dream. She said yes when Zack had asked her if she wanted to make love. She'd loved it when he fucked her. She'd spread her legs for him like a wanton slut. Her pussy had been a mess this morning because Zack's cum had been in there.

A thought occurred to her and she ran upstairs to Leslie's medicine cabinet. Grabbing the bottle she studied it carefully: "Ambusol PM, pain reliever with sleep aid"

""Oh shit." she said to the empty bathroom.

She went downstairs expecting to face the music of her sister and instead was greeted with a topped-off cup of coffee and a smile.

Leslie spoke first. "Looks like that wasn't a dream you had. Care to tell me how you thought that was a dream?"

Jenny explained herself. Leslie nodded in acceptance.

"I'm so sorry!" whispered Jenny.

Leslie shook her head. "Don't be. He needed to get laid and so did you. You were having feelings for him anyway so it's good that it's out in the open and now we can move on."