Is it a Trick or a Treat?

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

Terrance turned to look at Faith who was still laying on the bed, her knees hiked up, her skirt still around her waist, one hand softly toying with her pussy whilst her other teased one of her hard nipples, her wetness glistening in the dim light of the room, biting her lip looking back at them both with a look that was both innocent and sexual in equal amounts and once again made Terrance's cock twitch between Tori's fingers.

Stopping her stroking, much to the dismay of Terrance, Tori whispered to him "Why don't we put this nice hard cock of yours to some use Terrance, do you wanna fuck Faith?"

Looking from Tori to Faith and back again, Terrance was past wondering when this prank was going to stop as he spat out as quickly as his tongue could work, "Abso-damn-lutely I do!"

Releasing her grip on his cock, Tori smiled at him, still making Terrance uneasy with the look in her eyes, "Go get her Terrance."

Quickly moving up the bed, Terrance smiled as Faith bit her bottom lip once more opening her arms up for him, as he quickly crawled over her, his cock teasing over her dripping wet pussy as Faith pulled him to her and kissed him passionately.

Their tongues toying with each others, Terrance felt Faiths hand reach down between them, wrapping gently around his cock and positioning him at her dripping wet pussy, her legs then taking over as she wrapped them tightly around his waist and with one squeeze pulled his hard cock deep into her pussy, both of them groaning out in pleasure as she did.

Terrance slowly started to get into a rhythm as they both continued to kiss, his hands roamed over her body, toying with Faith's breasts, teasing her nipples, as his cock slid slowly in and out of her wet pussy, every thrust feeling so good.

Suddenly, he felt Tori's hands stroking up his back, leaning over him, her breasts pressing against him through her dress as she nipped at his earlobe whispering to him, "How does she feel? Do you like your treat so far?"

Breaking the kiss with Faith for a moment to respond as he continued his gentle but deep thrusts into Faith's pussy, Terrance moaned back to Tori, "Best Halloween ever!"

He couldn't see but Tori had that wicked grin on her face again as she continued to lean over him, whispering to him once more, "Lucky you, you get the treat and the trick tonight, that OK with you?"

Tori knew the answer she was going to hear, Terrance was too far gone to stop her now as he nodded his head and moaned out to her "Anything you want." Looking down at Faith under him as she wrapped her arms tighter around his neck pulling him into a deep kiss, their bodies so tightly entwined as his cock continued to slide deeply in and out of her perfect pussy.

Feeling Tori moving away from him Terrance continued to kiss Faith, thrusting in and out, pulling all the way back before sliding deep into her once more as he felt Faith's legs loosen dropping back to the bed and her arms around his neck slowly sliding down his back and gripping his ass tight pulling him deeper into her causing Faith to grimace and moan out "Ohhhhh yes Terry, it's so deep, feels so good!"

Looking into Faith's eyes she looked back at Terrance before leaning into him and whispering into his ear, "Just relax Terry, you're going to love it, I can tell."

Confused Terrance looked down at her, his thrusting slowing for a moment as he considered what she had just said and was about to ask her what she meant when he heard Tori behind them both asking, "You ready for your trick then Terrance?"

Looking back whilst staying in position, Terrance's mouth dropped open as his eyes travelled down Tori who knelt on the bed behind them completely naked now, that wicked grin of her more evident that ever, her breasts easily double D's looking stunning, before travelling lower as he saw she was wearing a strap-on.

Opening his mouth to object, he was pulled back to face Faith one hand on his cheek as she softly kissed him to stop his words, "Relax Terry," kissing him passionately one more, her other hand pulling on his ass again urging him to start sliding his cock in and out of her again.

Terrance softly kissed Faith back, the feel of her pussy so good, his heart racing as he felt Tori's hand on his ass too, holding the opposite cheek to Faith, feeling her lean over him her bare breasts now pressing against his back as she whispered in his ear, "I could tell by how much you enjoyed my finger that you'd enjoy this Terrance, so just relax." Tori's other hand holding the strap-on and carefully positioning it at Terrance's tight hole as she felt him tensing up beneath her.

Feeling Faith and Tori's hands working together spreading his ass, Terrance's eyes opening wider as he felt Tori applying more pressure and the head of the toy push into his tight ass but his initial fear falling away as a moan escaped his lips, a moan of pleasure.

Eyes locking with Faith, she smiled at him as she leant up kissing him again, her tongue wrestling with his as slowly the trio started to get into a rhythm. Tori thrust gently back and forth easing the strap-on deeper into Terrance, which forced him deeper into Faith, all three filling the room with moans of pleasure.

Leaning over him once again, Tori started to force the strap-on deeper and faster now as Terrance's ass became more accustomed to the toy, whispering to him, "How does that feel Terrance?"

Groaning out from the pleasure of Faith's tight pussy and Tori using her ass harder and faster Terrance moaned out, "It feels so good." Feeling his balls tightening as the pleasure was driving him closer to climax

Smiling at Faith, as Tori leant over Terrance as they conquered another guy and whispered to him, "Such a good boy Terrance, you'll make a great pet," and pushed her hips further forward pressing the strap-on deeper into his ass, knowing he was getting close.

Terrance almost cum right then, hearing Tori call him a good boy once more but was determined to enjoy this for as long as he could. He looked back into Faith's eyes as she moaned with him, she could feel that he was getting close to and whispered to him, "Cum for me Terry, fill my pussy with that sweet juice."

Feeling Faith's pussy clamping down hard on his cock and Tori sliding in and out of his tight ass Terrance closed his eyes knowing that his resistance was futile, as he allowed his body to relax and groaned out as his tight balls finally got their way, sending his load quickly up his shaft, jerking forward deep into Faith cumming so hard, feeling Tori moving forward with him and holding the strap-on deep in his ass.

The room was filled with moans and groans once more as the sweaty trio were held so close together, Terrance bucking between to gorgeous double as he cum so hard and so much deep inside Faith, feeling their bodies pressed together in a tangled mess the whole situation so hot.

Faith smiled as she kissed him hungrily between Terrance's gasps for breathe her hand stroking his cheek, whilst Tori kissed his back softly, whispering to him "Seems like your trick was a treat to Terrance."

Still gasping for breath, Terrance moaned softly as he felt Tori slowly sliding back off of him and sliding the strap-on out of his ass. Kissing Faith under him gently, savouring the kiss, Terrance slowly moved back, lifting to his knees his cock sliding out of her incredible pussy as he looked from one to the other still admiring their stunning bodies in their naked glory.

Once again it was Tori who broke the silence, "Did you enjoy our little game of trick or treat then Terrance? Do you like my pet Faith?"

Terrance still gasping for breath for the first time seemed to relax as he smiled nodding, the fact he had just taken a strap-on up his ass not seeming important right now in his post orgasmic bliss but a confused look falling over his face as he looked from Tori to Faith and back again.

Recognising the look of confusion Tori grinned knowing what he was thinking as she reached over and stroked Faith's cheek, "Faith here, is my pet, she does as I tell her, when I tell her, isn't that right pet?"

Without hesitation, looking up at Tori, Faith nodded enthusiastically, "Yes Miss, that's right," Leaning in to Tori's stroking hand.

Kneeling on the bed still gasping for breath, Terrance watched on, looking up at Tori as she spoke, "Would you like to be my pet Terrance?"

A little surprised by the question, Terrance froze looking at Tori, his cheeks blushing, as she crawled over the bed to him, her hand stroking his cheek now as she looked into his eyes, "Would you like that? Would you like to be there for my pleasure whenever I wanted it, more moments like tonight?"

Cheeks still blushing a deep crimson, Terrance knelt there still froze but his cock gave away his true feelings as it twitched at the words of Tori, that familiar wicked grin on Tori's face as she looked at him awaiting an answer.

Unable to deny the truth Terrance gave in to his desire, still looking into Tori's eyes, and slowly nodded. With that Tori reached up her hand around his head pulling him to her and arched her back, pushing her ample breasts out and pulling him down to them, pressing the flesh into his mouth, Tori's gentle moans filling the room as she felt Terrance's lips latch on to her hard nipple.

Eyes up on Tori, Terrance sucked hungrily on her hard nipple, looking to his side as Faith knelt up alongside him and started to suck on Tori's other breasts. Tori reached up stroking her hands over their heads as they both sucked hungrily on her ample flesh.

Gently Faith's hand reach down between them, wrapping her fingers around Terrance's cock, gently jerking it, feeling it already growing again as they both continued to worship Tori's breasts, licking and sucking at her tit flesh, Tori's moans filling the room.

Suddenly the mood changed once more as Tori's gentle stroking hand gripped Terrance's hair tighter pulling his gaze up at her, "You best get that dick hard again, I want fucking, do you understand Terrance!"

The look in her eye almost crazed, Terrance dare not refuse what she wanted, gulping and just nodding grateful for Faith's more vigorous jerking but also hardening further by the way Tori had spoken to him.

Pulled off of Tori's breast, Terrance was forced down onto his back looking up at the two stunning women as Tori straddled him not saying anything just taking his hard again cock and positioning it at her pussy and slowly easing herself down onto it. Her body arched closing her eyes and moaning softly as she slid herself deep down onto Terrance's cock.

Grinding on his cock, moaning softly, Tori leant forward her hands resting on his chest as she worked his cock, pleasing herself looking up at him, "Your dick feels so good Terrance, do you like me fucking you?" The double meaning not lost on either of them.

The feeling of her pussy grinding so deep so tight on his cock felt so good as he looked up at Tori, her breasts in all their glory before him, her wicked glint in her gorgeous eyes as he nodded to her, "Yes, I do!"

Still riding nice and slow but nice and deep her nails digging into his chest as she does, Tori grinning wickedly once more at his response, "You know for every treat, you have to have a trick though don't you Terrance?"

Heart racing nervous about what Tori had in mind for him after last time but her pussy felt so good and he was desperate for her not to stop he just gave in to his instinct nodding to her as she looked up at her, "Anything."

As the words escaped his lips, he looked up as Faith crawled up the bed once more as she had done earlier, lifting one leg and moving herself slowly into position straddling his face. The reality dawning on Terrance as to what the trick was as he looked up at the mess that was Faith's pussy, his own load buried so deep in there only a few minutes ago.

Instinctively closing his mouth as Faith slowly lowered herself down on to his face he felt Tori lift herself up and slam herself down onto his cock harder their bodies slapping loudly together, feeling so good Terrance couldn't help himself as he opened his mouth to moan and felt the salty juices leaking from Faith's pussy pressed to his mouth.

All the while Tori continued to lift herself up, almost sliding off his cock and slamming herself down knowing how good it feels for Terrance and knowing he won't be able to keep his mouth closed, moaning to him, "Make us both cum pet, show us what a good slut you can be for your new owner."

Each hard bounce on his cock causing Terrance to moan just as Tori knew it would, feeling Faith starting to grind down on his mouth, her juices covering his face, his nose rubbing over her clit, his moans vibrating through Faith's body.

Terrance's initial feelings of not wanting to taste Faith's pussy drifting away as the desire to please Tori and make both of them cum started to take over, slowly snaking his tongue out as he felt Faith grinding her dripping wet pussy on his face focussing on her clit, whilst thrusting his hips up to allow his cock to slam as deep as possible into Tori's pussy.

The room was filled with their ladies moans as they both used Terrance, Faith grinding her hips faster over his tongue, whilst groping her own breasts, Tori bouncing up and down harder her bare breasts bouncing up and down with each thrust.

Faith reached down stroking her hands through Terrance's hair before gripping it tight her hips bucking, rubbing her clit over Terrance's snaked out tongue, knowing exactly how she likes it, working herself closer and closer.

Her body stiffening suddenly once more unable to deny herself Faith's moans filled the room once more as her orgasm crashed over her, bucking wildly, quivering atop of his mouth, her juices covering his face even more a wet mixture of her own juice and Terrance's cum.

Terrance just moaned into her pussy feeling her pussy gushing over his face and Tori bouncing harder and harder, feeling her pussy tightening on his cock too he kept thrusting up in time with her bounces as best as he could without seeing her but feeling so close to pleasing them both as instructed.

Moans continued to fill the air as slowly Faith climbed up off of Terrance allowing him to see Tori bouncing hard up and down on his cock the sight so erotic almost causing him to cum instantly, locking eyes with Tori as she looked down at him, "Don't you dare cum before you please me pet, do you understand?"

Nodding as he continued to look into her eyes, Terrance just watched on in awe as Tori bounced on his cock, completely in control of the situation taking what she wanted. Tori reached down stroking her hands over his chest once more digging her nails into his chest as she started to rock back and forth faster, more eager, Tori's moans becoming more desperate as her orgasm was getting closer and closer.

The sight of her heavy breasts bouncing up and down only making Terrance's balls tighter the need to cum growing looking up at Tori bouncing, her moans filing the air even louder, seeing her grimace, her pussy gripping his cock tighter, Terrance knew she was close.

Suddenly it was Terrance grimacing as Tori dug her nails even harder into his chest as her body stiffened and then she screamed out bucking atop of him her orgasm crashing over her shaking wildly atop of him, Terrance looking on in awe.

Still scared to cum it was taking all of Terrance's willpower to hold back his own orgasm as Tori continued to grind and ride on his cock enjoying her orgasm, watching her grope at her big breasts tugging her own hard nipples, before she opened her eyes and smiled at him, "Mmmmm you are going to make a very nice pet Terrance."

Terrance just smiled gasping for breath as Tori slowly climbed up off his aching hard cock, pulling Faith up with her as they stood at the foot of the bed looking down at him, "You ready to cum pet?"

Nodding as eagerly as he had done all night, Terrance looked up into Tori's eyes, seeing that all to familiar wicked glint in her eyes as she responded, "On your knees," and pointed to the floor in front of them both.

Eyes up on them both as they stood before him, Faith still look so innocent, Tori just looking down at him, "Jerk yourself off on to our feet pet, thats all your deserve for now."

Wrapping his fingers around his cock, it felt so degrading to jerk off in front of them both but Terrance wanted to do it more than anything as he jerked his hard cock, looking up at the two stunning ladies stood over him watching him.

Already so close from Tori bouncing on his cock it didn't take long, Terrance was gasping for breath, his hand a blare as he jerked himself hard as he could and groaned out as his cock spurt out, jet of cum splashing down across Tori's ankle, jerking still as jet after jet sprays out, spraying over Faith and Tori's feet until every last drop was drained.

Tori reached down and stroked her hand through his hair smiling at him "Good boy," before her persona changed again gripping his hair tight, "Normally, I would make you clean that mess up, but I'll let you off tonight, now get yourself dressed and go home, your party is finished, understand?"

Gasping for breath Terrance just nodded as he started to gather his things, it had been by far the best Halloween party he had ever been to and who knows what the future after the party had install for him but one thing he knew was he wouldn't be so reluctant to come to these parties in the future.

Thanks for reading and please don't forget to vote, Happy Halloween.

12
Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
8 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousover 2 years ago

who's mike?

bret1625bret1625over 2 years ago

This is a dream scenario! Very immersive writing too

Dan_EnglandDan_Englandover 2 years agoAuthor

Appreciate the feedback all, sorry to hear about the punctuation and grammar issues. I think the suggestion of an editor is a good one and I'll look into it for next time.

Glad to hear the premise of the story was good for some.

TheRealDealerTheRealDealerover 2 years ago

Great story, but could use some editing.

GschladtGschladtover 2 years ago

Really hot premise and story! Punctuation and syntax, (and some inadvertent pronouns inversions) make it a bit confusing and hard to read sometimes, though. But still, very exciting read.

Show More
Share this Story

Similar Stories

Prom Night Pegging Prom date reveals how naughty she really is...in First Time
Strap-on Secrets Comforting best friend leads to unexpected secrets.in Fetish
Tamed by Meg Megan introduces me to the pleasures of being penetrated.in Anal
Her Presents She had a number of surprises for him.in Fetish
Pegged for Love Straight guy is pegged by the girl of his dreams.in Fetish
More Stories