Little Sister's Big Butt Ch. 04

For long intense moments, the siblings remained immersed in their tender make out session, letting their loving bond dispel the emotional tension and momentary unpleasantness they had just gone through. By the time their affectionate lip lock broke, only the most minimal residual shades of Tyler's bad thoughts still lingered, but he expunged them all in the form of a question that he now simply had to ask.

"Why, Mimi? Tell me: why did you want to try this so bad?" Tyler asked, holding his purring little sister in his arms and meeting her beautiful green eyes as she gently rocked into his embrace, rubbing her puffy nipples against his chiseled pecs and letting his fat shaft nestle between the soft, nectar-damp outer folds of her labia. "I really don't get it, Mimi. This whole double anal thing... It just seems..."

"Stupid? Ridiculous? Crazy and unnecessary and borderline psycho? Yeah, I know..." Michelle cut in, making a comical self-deprecating face as she nodded and sighed, letting her brother know that she had learned her lesson and that she was glad he had called the whole thing to a stop when he had.

"Well, I was just gonna say 'silly'," Tyler grinned with a dismissive shrug of his broad shoulders, "but sure, all that stuff you said seems about right too!"

The siblings laughed at that, snuggling closer and thus making Tyler's horsecock press harder against Michelle's juicy labia and engorged clit. Gently pressing her groin against Tyler's stiff meaty rod to stimulate her pussy, Michelle resumed speaking, trying to make sense of her recent obsession both to herself and to her brother.

"I know it makes no sense, Ty. I guess I knew it even before we tried. But I still had to try, you know... After seeing Gabby do it, I guess I just felt like I had to be on her level. I mean, it was so hot and we were so horny about it, and the thought that Gabby could do it and I couldn't... I thought, like... I wanted to be special, Ty. For you," Michelle finally blurted out, ending her rant with a disarming half-smile and half-pout. "I wanted you to know that I could do double anal too, just in case. Like, only hypothetically..." Michelle rambled on, tripping over her own tangled thoughts, until she finally exhaled and declared: "I don't know, Ty. I felt insecure, for some reason. And jealous. I guess I felt bad because I wasn't the biggest buttslut around anymore, kinda."

At that, Tyler smiled and scoffed at the same time as he hugged Michelle's curvy little frame and enjoyed the sound of her happy humming moans while she rested her head in the hollow of her shoulder and hugged him back. All the while, his huge dick and her slick virgin pussy remained as cozily smushed together as the rest of their snuggled bodies, making their breathing quicken and their arousal grow. Tucking a long lock of hair behind her ear and nuzzling her cheek to fill his nostrils with her unique signature scent, Tyler spoke with his usual calm, smiling as he did his best to dispel Michelle's unfounded self-doubts.

"Mimi, you're awesome in every way. You have nothing to be insecure about. Nothing. Especially when it comes to butt stuff," Tyler said, meaning every word. "You're my one and only anal goddess, Mimi. You know it's true."

As he spoke, he let his hands slide down along the smooth skin of Michelle's back until his palms were possessively cupping the big protruding globes of her bubble-butt. Squeezing and kneading and caressing her fabulously plump asscheeks, Tyler looked his beloved little sis right in her bright green eyes and planted a deep kiss on her gorgeous lips, trying to convey his undivided affection for her. Judging by her equally loving smooches, Tyler sensed that Michelle had gotten the message loud and clear and reciprocated in kind.

By the time they broke their soulkiss, Michelle's breathing had gotten way more labored and her soft little moans had grown much louder, the grinding undulations through which she was rubbing her clit and labia against Tyler's veiny shaft all the while getting more urgent by the second. Loving how her big tits felt against his chest, how fully her jiggly asscheeks filled his palms and how lewdly satisfying it was to feel her juicy labia lather his rock-hard horsecock in her nectar, Tyler smiled with deep satisfaction as he savored the intoxicating mix of sensations brought on by having his sister's voluptuous little body snuggled against his, especially now that she was clearly working herself up to climax.

Still, as glad as he was that the whole double anal debacle was concluded, Tyler couldn't help but make one last thing clear. Chuckling and grinning even though he was dead serious about what he meant to say, Tyler planted one more smooch on Michelle's lips before he stated: "And for the record: I would never want to feel another dude's dick inside your ass while I'm in there anyways! Like, seriously, fuck double anal! This ass is mine, Mimi," Tyler stated in no uncertain terms, sinking his fingers into the bouncy plumpness of his sister's booty. "I don't want to share your ass with anyone. And I sure as hell don't want to share you."

"Aw, Ty!" Michelle cooed, positively beaming and gladly overwhelmed by the comforting, fuzzy sense of warmth spreading from the very core of her being in response to her brother's passionate words. Far from feeling objectified, Michelle loved the idea of being desired and cherished and lusted after with the kind of devotion and exclusivity that Tyler expressed in all his actions and was now declaring out loud.

Still, her voice was trembling not just with emotion but also with the tell-tale tension that precedes an orgasm. Rocking urgently and pressing her dripping pussy all over her brother's huge schlong, thus rubbing her clit ever more desperately against his throbbing, monumental slab of dickmeat, Michelle was practically whimpering as she shivered in pre-orgasmic delight, which made her soft moaning words even more significant to Tyler as she rested her forehead against his and spoke.

"I... Uhhh! I feel the same, Ty. It was just something I wanted to try. But it's not like I want another guy in my ass, no. No, ooohhh... No, never! I want to be yours, Ty... Uuhh! Only... Yours!"

Aware of how close to cumming she was, knowing her as well as he did both as a caring big brother and as a devotedly passionate lover, Tyler decided to make that impromptu pussy-rubbing climax as intense as possible for Michelle. Quickly moving one hand off of her plump buttcheeks to let it travel deep into her luscious ass-cleavage, Tyler slipped first one then a second digit into his sister's welcoming, perfectly lubed bootyhole with the skilled ease he had developed by repeatedly paying homage to her epic bubble-butt with his mouth, his fingers and his cock. Needless to say, the effects of that unexpected anal stimulation were instantaneous and very much appreciated.

"Uuh! Oohh Ty, yeeeess! Ooowwhh fuck yeahhh!" Michelle squealed the moment she felt her brother's talented digits slide inside her twitching little anus and start to saw in and out of her slick, sensitive bootyhole.

Amplified by Tyler's ass-pumping fingers, Michelle's clit-focused pleasure boiled over in a matter of seconds, causing her orgasm to explode with a sizzling intensity that left her deliciously breathless after the mellow, teasingly slow build-up she had endured up to that moment by grinding her labia and clit along his thick shaft. Mewling out in ecstasy, her O-shaped mouth brushing against Tyler's grinning lips, Michelle bucked against her brother's fat schlong one final time before freezing in a spasm of sensuous ecstasy, her curvy little frame snuggled cozily in his powerful arms, her engorged clit and gushing slit smushed firmly against his monstercock as her puckered little sphincter pulsated and squeezed with orgasmic joy around his fully buried fingers.

Thrilled by the sight and sound and feel of his sister cumming while he held her in his arms with one hand kneading her plump booty while the fingers of the other were embedded knuckle-deep into her asshole, Tyler was particularly happy to register how much girlcum was overflowing her delicious slit to bathe her labia and therefore his achingly stiff pole. All the while, as the lower part of his veiny truncheon stayed nestled between the dripping outer folds of Michelle's pussy, his bloated glans kept poking against her soft tummy, painting her flawless skin with a glinting trail of runny precum that testified to Tyler's own scorching arousal.

As soon as the sweet haze of her climax abated, Michelle let out a satisfied sigh that morphed into a giggle as she reached a dainty hand between their snuggled bodies and wrapped her fingers around the upper half of Tyler's boner, immediately starting to stroke away. Tyler's grunt of delight was drowned out halfway out of his mouth by Michelle's loving kiss, and in a heartbeat the siblings were making out again, even more passionately than before. As Michelle resumed grinding her clit against the lower portion of his huge schlong while lovingly caressing its upper part, Tyler picked up his ass-prodding manipulations on her snug forbidden hole, causing their kisses to be interspersed with frequent and ever louder smooch-muffled moans.

Happy to keep kissing his amazing little sis and masturbate her tight butthole indefinitely, even more glad to let her jack him off to completion in her soft dick-tugging hand, Tyler suddenly let out a disappointed growl when he felt Michelle pull back. Beside causing her gorgeous lips to be unglued from his smooching mouth, that unexpected move also meant that Michelle's juicy shaft-massaging labia were no longer smushed against his dong. The fact that she was still skillfully tugging away on his erection and stroking his big precum-leaking tip only partially mitigated Tyler's disappointment, but his attempt to voice a complaint died in his throat as soon as he realized that Michelle was not just jacking him off now, but aiming his meaty pole at the soft, nectar-slick entrance of her pristine pussy.

In a heartbeat, wide-eyed wonder mixed with extreme horniness appeared all over Tyler's face as he locked gazes with Michelle and held his breath in disbelieving anticipation. Judging by the way she was staring back at him, smiling and nodding slowly while biting her lower lip as she shivered excitedly in his arms, he could tell that his sister's goal wasn't to simply let his bloated cockhead get all nice and lathered in her pussy juices so that he could then penetrated her anus.

No. This was it, Tyler knew. They were actually going to do it. Michelle was gifting him her virginity.

That mind-blowing realization and all its equally awesome implication flashed through Tyler's brain in the blink of an eye, yet the silent knowing look that he shared with Michelle was so pregnant with meaning and so deeply emotional that they both felt like they had just shared an entire wordless dialogue about the milestone they were about to set.

The siblings were holding their breath as Michelle's delicate hand guided Tyler's monstercock into position, wedging his broad purple tip into the soft opening of her untouched slit and easing it inside. The tell-tale squeezing spasms that made her little asshole clasp onto his deeply buried digits came at the same moment when Michelle's gently rocked forward once more to press her fabulous tits against his chest and snuggle in his embrace, thus forcing his cockhead and her slit to also move into each other. The sensation of his sister's juice-drenched folds opening up for him and the indescribable thrill of feeling his pulsating glans slide into her virgin pussy to be engulfed within its wet, deliciously snug confines made Tyler grunt with pleasure, almost drowning out Michelle's soft sexy whimper.

Despite the spontaneous suddenness with which she had started it and he had embraced it, the monumental significance of their very first vaginal coupling became undeniably evident as Michelle continued her snuggling motion toward Tyler, pressing her big rack more firmly against his chest and thus leading more of his huge dick to ease its way into her pristine, nectar-soaked slit. Hugging and panting into one another's gaping mouth, the siblings couldn't help but pause right there, with just Tyler's cockhead and an inch of his fat shaft sheathed inside Michelle's snug pussy, at the very threshold of another big first for both of them, one they both knew to be particularly crucial.

"Mimi! Oh my god... Are you sure about this?" Tyler mumbled, trying to remain motionless even as his monstercock throbbed and swelled even bigger and harder with crazy arousal, causing the scant portion of it that was already embedded inside his sister's pussy to feel even more massive to her.

"Oohhh Ty! Yes, I'm sure! Uuhh fuck... You feel so good inside me!" Michelle breathlessly replied as she panted and mewled, overwhelmed by the rush of sensations and emotions caused by having even just little more than the tip of her brother's schlong wedged inside her virgin slit. "I really want this, Ty... I always wanted you to be my first."

"Fuck, Mimi!" Tyler moaned in reply, too blown away to put his whirling thoughts and feelings into better words. Being also too excited to remain still, he couldn't help but pull his curvy little sister closer in his embrace, thus making his thick pole slide another inch inside her untouched vaginal passage. The sharp squeal that Michelle let out instantly made Tyler stop his lust-fueled progress and brought a shadow of concern to his face, but she was quick to reassure him.

"I'm okay, Ty," Michelle smiled softly, "It's just that, uh... I'm not really used to having stuff in that hole! You'll have to go real easy on my pussy, even more than you did when you popped my butt cherry! I never even had a dildo in there, actually... I was super obsessed about stretching my ass for your big cock and I came so much when I fingered my butthole that I didn't even think to prep my pussy too!"

That weird yet fun fact about the somewhat upside-down way in which Michelle viewed her holes and took pleasure from them unavoidably made both her and her brother chuckle, but it also made her imminent vaginal deflowering even more special for them, exactly because her lovely little slit had been left almost untouched up to that point. While their laughter still hung in the air, Michelle looked Tyler straight into his piercing gray eyes and huskily spoke.

"Do it, Ty... Take my virginity and make my pussy yours. Just go slow, okay? But don't stop until you're all the way inside me," she whispered before planting a long kiss on his lips that made Tyler's dick flex with arousal as his brain sizzled with barely contained exhilaration at the thought that he was about to claim his sister's last and most significant cherry, thus making her totally and indisputably his.

That thought was so insanely hot, plus Michelle's trust and willingness felt so emotionally rewarding for Tyler, that he was instantly spurred into action. In one fluid motion, he tightened his bear hug around his beloved little sis's voluptuous body and brought her snuggled frame even closer to his chiseled chest, making her moan as his huge dickmeat eased its way even deeper into her soft, nectar-drenched folds. At the same time, even as Michelle threw her arms around his neck and pushed herself forward, making her pillowy boobs bulge out against his pecs, Tyler gently rolled the both of them over so that she was lying on her back and he was draped on top of her in a missionary position, his achingly hard schlong all the while pushing slowly but surely into her juicy slit with their every motion.

"Uuhh fuck! Oowwhh fuck, yesss!" Michelle wailed brokenly as her girlcum-slick walls parted meekly before Tyler's massive pole, engulfing him in their wet velvety snugness as he kept cramming more and more of his girthy shaft inside her pussy.

Even though there was no denying the underlying sense of uncomfortable stretching pressure radiating from her virginally tight hole, the feel of her brother's horsecock penetrating her dripping vaginal tunnel and widening it to the limit was so indescribably amazing that Michelle could already savor the sweet rumbling wavelets of her very first pussy-centric climax swelling up inside her. Indeed, her pleasure in gifting her last and arguably most precious cherry to Tyler was so potent that it didn't just match the discomfort of her deflowering, but it quickly started to prevail. Lewdly eager to transition from enduring her first vaginal coupling to actually enjoying it instead, unwaveringly convinced that her brother's enormous dick would soon make her virgin pussy cum as spectacularly as he always did when plowing her tiny butthole, Michelle didn't hesitate to egg Tyler on.

"Ooohh my god! Uuhhh... Keep going Ty!" she wailed, breathing raggedly as she was hit by a quick yet sharp jolt of pain that she interpreted as her hymen being totally annihilated by Tyler's slit-jamming monstercock. "D-d-don't stop, oowwwhhh... Pleeease, don't stop now! K-k-keep fucking meee!"

As soon as her whimpering yet lust-saturated words left her mouth, Michelle spread her shapely thighs wantonly open and locked her legs around Tyler's midriff, the feel of his veiny hugeness sliding into her vaginal sheath and rubbing along its sensitive, untouched walls already soothing her discomfort with sizzling shocks of pleasure that seemed to wash over her more and more intensely the deeper her brother pushed himself into her tight pussy and the fuller he filled her with his pulsating dickmeat. His hands cupping her big bubble-butt and caressing her round asscheeks felt good too, providing Michelle with an additional layer of delight that helped her stay relaxed as Tyler's huge dong advanced carefully deeper into her slit, her fleeting moments of pain becoming rarer as her pleasure became steadier and stronger.

"Your clit, Mimi... Touch your clit for me..." Tyler muttered between grunts of ecstasy as he willed himself to proceed slowly and resist his barely tameable desire to slam his raging boner balls-deep inside Michelle's delicious pussy and finally feel the nectar-saturated suctioning tightness of her cozy vaginal walls enveloping his whole stiff length from tip to root.

The softness and wetness of his sister's pristine slit were indeed as heady for Tyler as the very fact that he was taking her virginity to begin with, a monumental event that was getting him rabid with arousal. And yet, for the time being at least, all those incredible sensations and the savage need to fuck that they instilled in him were being reined in by even stronger guiding principles: his deep love for Michelle and his ever-present desire to make her feel good. Thanks to his affection for his sister, Tyler did still retain enough lucidity not to get carried away, even though the sheer forbidden hotness of that situation was mercilessly tempting him to throw caution to the wind and ram his dong to the hilt inside Michelle's juicy hole. In light of all that, reminding her to rub her clit and thus make his penetration easier, slicker and faster seemed liked a very wise move to Tyler, for maintaining his slit-stretching plunge nice and slow was one thing, but actually stopping entirely, in case it was needed, might soon become impossible for him if he kept getting hornier and increasingly pussy-addled by the second.

Luckily, his clit-diddling idea worked like a charm. Swept up as she was in a storm of rising pleasure and confusing random jolts of discomfort, lust-drunk and emotionally overwhelmed by the forbidden perfection of having her brother claim her untouched pussy, Michelle barely had the time to feel silly about not having thought about frigging her engorged love button until that moment. In an instant, she acted on Tyler's suggestion by bringing a hand down from the side of his face and stabbing her fingers right at the throbbing, girlcum-drenched clit. Immediately, she started frigging away like crazy, and that made all the difference.