Little White Lies Ch. 11

Tying the top back on as the hostess brought in the next group, Jessie saw a good-looking guy with a close-cropped haircut. It looked like he worked out regularly too, as he had a really nice-looking body, his muscles defined, but not ridiculous. With him were a group of guys that seemed to be taking the well-defined guy out for a dinner.

The group was highly enamored with her boobs, though, as was to be expected, and after taking several pictures with them, she spent more time than she probably should have to let them ogle her a bit. Eventually 8:00 rolled around and she made sure that Cadence was good with her leaving. After a quick conversation and a friendly hug, she gave her trainer a hug and went to clock out.

"Hey," a voice behind her called. She spun, seeing the good-looking guy that she'd waited on.

"Hi!" she said happily.

"I uh... just wanted to see if I could get your number?" he asked. "You're incredible and I just got back into town, so I was hoping I could find someone to hang out with."

She smiled sweetly. "That's so sweet," she said, immediately feeling bad that she was going to have to shoot him down. "You're really cute and I'd normally love to, but I have a boyfriend."

"Ah... I see," the well-built guy said with a laugh. "I mean... of course you do. You're gorgeous. Why would you not?"

Jessie smiled. "You can always come visit me here and ogle my goodies while I'm working."

"True," he said. "Alright, I'll quit houndin' you. You have a good night."

"You too, and I'll see you next time you come in!" she said sweetly, turning and heading for the manager's office to check her schedule.

***

Twenty minutes later, she pulled into her parents' drive and parked. Inside, she found them out on the patio, relaxing and drinking with her brother, Jake, and Kayleigh, his fiancée.

"There she is!" her dad called out. "Holy cow! Look at that outfit, wouldya!"

Jessie rolled her eyes and let herself be pulled down into his lap.

"Be good," she heard her mother admonish. "Jessie, you better watch his hands. He's been drinking."

"He's already groped Kayleigh three times already," Jake informed her with a wide smile.

"Aww hell, I was just havin' fun is all," her dad protested.

"I wasn't complaining," Kayleigh said, winking at Jessie.

Jessie joined in on the conversation for a few minutes and relaxed with her family. Her dad took great delight in pointing out the tattoo on her left breast, laughing and carrying on as if it were the funniest thing he'd seen.

"That's really good work," Kayleigh said, leaning a little closer to inspect it.

"It certainly makes a statement," Jake said, sounding a like he was a little disappointed in her.

She scowled over at her brother, but then heard her mom chime in.

"Jessie is perfectly capable of handling herself," her mother said, coming quickly to her defense. "If that's the form her sexuality takes, then I'm happy for her. You should be too."

Jack smirked and raised his hands defensively. "I'm just messin' with her guys," he protested. "It's nice."

Jessie told them the story of where she got it and even went into detail about how they offered to pierce her nipples, as well as how the piercer told her about piercing the head of someone's dick before. Both her dad and brother winced painfully when she detailed that part, though the girls found it humorous.

After a few more minutes of visiting, she kissed her dad on the cheek and hopped up off his lap, then excused herself to go and take a much-needed shower. After a quick wash and rinse, she hopped out and wrapped a towel around her after cleaning up the mess she'd left. She was about to head to her old bedroom and slip in bed for some sleep when she saw Kayleigh sitting on the bed in the room next to her old bedroom.

"Hey," her future sister-in-law said. "How's the boyfriend?"

"He's good," Jessie said as she stepped in and laid down on the bed. "He's studying this week for a big test, plus work is hell for him lately."

"Ugh... that sucks," Kayleigh said.

She'd been idly playing with her phone but tossed it to the bed when Jessie laid down, reaching out for to come to her. Happily laying in her lap, Jessie sighed in contentment as Kayleigh stroked her hair and the two talked about the upcoming wedding plans.

After a while, she was ready to fall asleep from Kayleigh's soft scalp scritches. Her brother coming noisily into the room made her grumble and sit up. She glowered at him before she tucked the towel back into her cleavage. Hopping onto the bed, he smiled happily at the two and looked at them pointedly for a moment.

"Y'all gettin' friendly?" he asked.

Jessie looked at Kayleigh and rolled her eyes. "Is he still pestering you about watching you with another woman?"

Kayleigh giggled and nodded, her phone back in her hands as Jessie looked back at her brother and gave him a disappointed stare.

"Oh, y'all know I'm just kiddin' around," he said, moving to push Jessie back down on her stomach. "I'll rub your back to apologize."

"Ooo yes!" Jessie said happily as his hands moved to her shoulders and started to rub, eliciting a groan of contentment from her.

Briefly letting her scoot completely back on the bed, Jessie felt him slide back over to crouch over her butt, his hands starting to knead into the flesh of her shoulders just above the towel.

"So, what's new with Dexy the Sexy?" he asked.

"Not much," she said with a snicker. "We're still wonderful and he's still incredible."

She grunted in approval as Jake ground his fingertips into her. He seemed to keep wanting to move further south but the towel was obviously getting in the way.

"Here," she said, twisting to the side and pulling the end from between her boobs. He shifted around and pulled the towel free, then continued as he had before.

"So... has he gotten used to the idea of you and Jake?" Kayleigh asked.

Jessie nodded but didn't turn her head to face her. "I think so. He hasn't really brought it up since the last time we talked. We've been focusing on other things in our relationship to be honest."

"Yeah?" Kayleigh asked. "Like what?"

Jake moved down to her lower back, and she felt a familiar presence in her butt crack as he scooted lower down her body.

"Well, I know I told you guys that he and I had started having sex. I also let my roommate Donna in on the fun, as well as a few other girls."

"Yeah, you mentioned that before," Kayleigh said.

"Well, he's always felt bad that he gets to play so much when he's not okay with other guys fucking me. I mean, he's the least jealous guy I've ever been with, and he feels so bad about it, you know?"

"Yeah, I get it," Kayleigh replied. Jessie felt her sister-in-law's presence close to her again, gently lifting her head and putting it in her lap so she could start stroking her scalp again.

"So y'all are working through that?" Jake asked, working down to her thighs.

"Mmm, yeah," she said, her brother's massage making her feel wonderful. "But we've had some real breakthroughs recently. John, Donna's boyfriend, has always been really sweet and nice to me. He also happens to have a relatively small cock, and he's got a thing for women humiliating him. So... he's kind of the perfect candidate for a guy to test his limits with his girlfriend, if you follow."

"I think so," Kayleigh said. "You and John and Dex had a threesome?"

"Foursome," Jessie corrected. "Donna was there too. So, he got to have Donna, who's so incredible and sexy, and at the same time he got to see John to have fun with me while he was there watching. It was perfect. After the four of us split up, John and I went to have fun in his room while Dex and Donna stayed in mine."

"So, your boyfriend got to watch you have sex with a non-threatening guy and get a little action himself?" her brother asked.

"Exactly," she confirmed.

"What was the conversation like the next day?" Kayleigh asked. "Like... was it strained or was everyone cool about everything?"

"Dex had to leave before John and I woke up," she replied. "But I spoke to him later that day. He was super pleased with how everything turned out and I'm sure we'll be doing it again sometime. He even told me that he'd come to a decision about something and that he wanted me to agree to it."

"Oh?" Kayleigh said.

Jessie nodded. "He wants to make sure that we're both happy and fulfilled, but he knows that I'm happiest when I'm able to make other people around me happy. So, he told me that he wants me to start being my normal, flirty self again around people. I even made sure to clarify who he was talking about. He said that I had a good sense of judgement about folks and that the people I'd been with before had obviously passed my standards, so they generally got a free pass to play with."

"That's really awesome, Jess," Kayleigh said. "Do you think that's a good plan for you guys?"

Jessie nodded. "I really do. I mean, he made me promise to save my pussy just for him," she stopped mid-sentence to turn and look up at Kayleigh, "and girl... let me just say that hearing him tell me that I wasn't allowed to give it to anyone else was such a turn on. Wow."

Kayleigh giggled, then wriggled Jessie back into her lap as Jake continued his massage, moving down to her feet. Jessie felt Kayleigh's subtle nudge to turn over and happily did so. Her brother lifted the foot he'd been working on before once again and let his eyes drift over her nude form.

"What the..." he said, looking down between her legs.

"Oh," she said, giggling and covering her mouth. "I forgot about that one."

Watching as both Kayleigh and her brother looked at the "cumslut" tattoo on her crotch, Jessie spread her legs a bit and let them see a little closer.

"That's you for sure," Jake said, laughing.

"That's so raunchy," Kayleigh said, sliding back into place again.

"Anyway," Jessie continued, "I think it will be great for us. I mean... he was right. I am at my happiest when people are using me for their own desires. My own roommates treat me like their little sex toy, free to use all the time."

"They do?" Jake asked, resuming his foot rub after ogling Jessie's lower tattoo.

"Mmmhmm," she confirmed as Kayleigh's hands moved across her neck and down to her chest, the fingertips lightly dancing circles around her nipples.

"What... like... they just walk up and start fucking you?" he asked.

"Well, kinda. It's usually just enough to turn me on and I'm pretty much yours. Come on... you two know that much about me."

"That's true," Kayleigh said, leaning down to draw one of Jessie's nipples into her mouth and gently suckle.

"John likes to shower with me and can get pretty friendly, but Donna is more of... 'Get over here and do me.' I just have to make sure that they know that their options to use me are limited now." She was enjoying the feeling of Kayleigh's warm, persuasive tongue on her nipple, smiling as she switched over to the other one.

Kayleigh and Jessie had done this a few times before, but they'd never really gone any farther than some light breast play. She idly wondered if Kayleigh would want to go further now that she knew that Jessie had been with other women.

"So, what kinds of stuff have your roommates done?" her brother asked.

Jessie giggled. "Well, Monday night, I let John have anal sex with me while we were alone in his room. Like I said, he's got a small sized cock and the time just felt right."

"Ouch," Kayleigh said. "No thank you."

Jessie laughed at the comment but gave a shrug. "I really liked it. Maybe you should try it with someone that's not as big as my brother?"

"He's not that big," Kayleigh joked dismissively, drawing a protest from Jake.

She was running her hands along Jessie's body, the combined actions of her brother's vigorous foot rub and Kayleigh's forceful pressure drawing Jessie up the other girl's body until she was lying in a half sitting position.

Reaching forward more, Jessie watched as Kayleigh's fingers slid lower, teasing her by inches. She felt warmth on one of her toes and saw her brother sucking on one of them, though he was still rubbing her foot with both hands.

"So, you liked being with another woman?" Kayleigh asked, pulling Jessie's face up for a brief but passionate kiss.

"Very much," she said quietly, Kayleigh's fingers dancing lower and lower then back up again. She felt her sister-in-law's fingertip push through her pubic hair for a moment, then retreat again.

"But I like it more when Donna just makes me do things to her, or just does things to me," she said quietly.

Seeing the arousal in her sister-in-law's face, Jessie wasn't surprised when she felt Kayleigh slide her fingers down Jessie's body again before plunging one of them into her pussy.

"Nngh," Jessie whimpered.

"Is this breaking the rules?" Kayleigh asked suddenly.

"Mmm?" Jessie inquired, feeling her brother sucking on more of her toes. "Oh... I don't know," she said honestly.

Kayleigh frowned. "We better play it safe," she suggested. Jessie giggled but nodded, intercepting Kayleigh's finger and sucking it into her mouth.

"Maybe we take care of Jake?" Kayleigh suggested.

Playfully feigning having to think about it, Jessie looked down at her brother as he frowned unconvincingly.

"Aww... he looks so pathetic like that," Kayleigh pointed out.

"Well... he loves watching us suck his cock, doesn't he?" Jessie pointed out.

Kayleigh giggled. "Almost as much as he wants to see me and you going down on each other. Should we?"

Jessie smiled, nodding almost immediately as her brother cheered and started to undress, causing the two women to laugh at the sight.

Very quickly, he was naked and sitting in the spot that Jessie and Kaylie had just been. Jessie stood and left the room for just a second to grab her phone, but quickly returned to see that Kayleigh had disrobed and was already sucking off Jake.

"Here," she said, unlocking it for him before passing it over. "Take pictures of Kayleigh and I for Dex."

He raised an eyebrow but didn't question it.

Leaning down, Jessie slid next to Kayleigh as she worked her mouth around the head of his cock. Wasting no time, Jessie leaned her head to the side and suckled on the shaft while Kayleigh sucked on the crown. Her brother's hands moved around and cradled both of their heads, urging them to shift a bit and eventually forcing the head of his cock into Jessie's mouth.

"Nnngh... fuck... that's so fucking naughty," Kayleigh gushed. "I don't think I'll ever not be turned on by seeing her doing that to you, baby."

Jake smiled widely, pulling her up to kiss her, then repeated the move with Jessie as he pushed Kayleigh's head back down into his lap.

"Don't forget the pictures," she snapped, scowling at him.

She lowered her head then, impatiently waiting her turn to suck her brother's cock. Kayleigh let him slide out and Jessie immediately took advantage.

"Okay... both of you side by side and look up at me," Jake said.

They both did as he asked, smiling seductively while he took a few pics. From there he had them sit up on their knees, clutching at each other hungrily, then moved on to a little bit of kissing before Kayleigh got impatient and went back to sucking him off.

Jessie briefly looked at the pictures and handed him back her phone.

"More?" he asked, getting only a nod in response as she went back to doing what she loved.

Taking the crown into her mouth as Kayleigh maneuvered her way to his testicles, Jessie heard the gentle click of her phone every few seconds. After a few minutes of having to alternate with Kayleigh, Jessie had her brother's cock in her mouth when he let them know he was getting close.

"This is your fantasy baby," Kayleigh said. "Where do you want to cum?"

"Jessie's mouth," he grunted, drawing giggles from the two. Whenever she was involved, her brother always chose his sister's mouth.

Hearing his choice, she resumed her frantic stroking and slurping, feeling him thrusting weakly against her lips before the familiar tasting burst of yummy deliciousness filled her mouth.

"Don't swallow yet," he barked out between gasps. Jessie frowned but did as she was told, waiting for him to finish before sitting back up and looking at him expectantly.

"K... kiss Kayleigh but let me get a few pics," he said.

The two women turned and giggled as they got closer. Kayleigh opened her mouth and dipped her tongue into Jessie's mouth, drawing out some of the puddled cum there before their lips locked and they passed the load back and forth, moaning into each other.

Weakly tossing the phone to the bed, he kissed Jessie on the cheek, then his fiancée before collapsing into the sheets.

"I think we broke him," Jessie said, giggling.

"Snuggle time?" Kayleigh suggested.

Jessie nodded happily and slid into bed after darting over to cut off the lights in the room.

***

The next day, Jessie spent part of the day with her family and resisted the urge to bug her boyfriend. She didn't have a shift at work that day, so she didn't have that to distract her. After spending a little bit of time getting her butt plug into place without any assistance, she smiled and playfully took a picture of it as best she could.

She was growing a little worried that she wasn't going to have much in the way of evidence of her being naughty for her and Dex to look at. Sure, she had the pictures of her with her brother and Kayleigh, but that wasn't any big surprise to Dex. He already knew about her and Jake and she didn't think he'd be that impressed with it.

Donna texted that they were definitely going out that evening and said that she had to come along. Happily accepting, she drove over around lunch intending to say hello to Donna's family again. She'd met Daisy and Debbie both before when they'd visited and liked them immensely.

When she got back to the apartment, she saw that John was the only one there, snoozing on the couch. Seeing a bit of a mess in the kitchen, she quietly went in and started cleaning, doing her best to let him keep sleeping. After a few minutes though, he woke up and found her hard at work on loading the dishwasher.

"Hey," she said happily. "They all off somewhere?"

He nodded. "Daisy's checking out the University."

"You didn't wanna go with them?" she teased playfully.

"Heh, nah was thinking about rubbin' one out and zonked out. Donna said we need to be a little more discreet about fuckin' since Daisy's boyfriend is here."

"Oh yeah, she mentioned him before. Is he as bad as Donna says?"

"Sadly yeah, he's kind of a dipshit," John admitted.

Jessie frowned. "Well... I'm sorry you didn't get to fool around like normal. Did you want me to take care of it for you?"

He smiled. "Is that a trick question?"

Happy giggles and enthusiastic clapping followed as she knew he was going to user her again. "My ass and my mouth are your choices from now on, remember? What will it be?" As she spoke, she quickly stripped out of her scant clothing and left it in a pile on the ground.

He chuckled, taking her firmly by the arm and forcing her to the floor. She smirked as he pulled his shorts down, his cock already hardening for her. Looking up at him expectantly, she tilted her head and waited.

"Throwing me to the floor doesn't tell me where you want to deposit the load of cum, it just turns me on. Ass or mouth?"

He pursed his lips in thought, then stepped forward, practically jamming his cock between her lips.

Twenty minutes later, the door to the apartment opened and Jessie saw Donna, her two sisters, and three others come in through the door. John had finished fucking her mouth by then and had treated her to a delicious helping of his spunk. He'd went to clean himself up but was back in the kitchen helping her clean when the others arrived.