All Comments on 'Lizzie Borden and Hyman Lubinsky'

The one thing missing in this theory is any evidence that a relationship existed between the two supposed murderers prior to the murder trial. It is likely that one could randomly select any resident of the town, and then build an argument for how or why a relationship could have existed between this person and Ms. Borden. Lacking evidence that such a relationship existed, however, would make such an exercise meaningless; as meaningless as the argument in favor of this ice cream peddler.

There are other issues that argue against an accomplice from outside the home. If an outside accomplice existed, why did so much evidence remain inside the home? Furthermore, it is improbable that an outside accomplice would possess a comparable amount of rage; the amount of rage necessary to commit the murders in the manner they were commotted.

While an interesting and well written essay, the logical flaws limit this writing to no more than that.