My Petite Fiancée Surprises Me Pt. 07.5

I realize Heather wanted me to do this for her sister, but I'm such an old-fashioned guy I couldn't help but feeling a little awkward doing this. I would have felt shy doing this alone with Tammi but I knew I had to be blushing with her sister, my girlfriend, watching me lick her baby sister's pussy. The truth is though, I felt good knowing she was beginning to relax as I've suffered blue balls way too often to ever wish that on my worst enemy and I want Tammi to be happy.

Eventually Tammi's legs lowered, and she released her grip on my head with her hands and thighs. Heather rubbed my back, kissed the back of my head, and said, "You are such a good boy! That was a great start!" She paused and once Tammi's breathing returned to normal she said, "Do you think you have another orgasm in you or are you fully relaxed?"

Tammi eyes buldged, "I've never cum twice in a row, I don't know if I can."

Heather said, "There's only one way to find out!" My beautiful girlfriend said to me, "Honey, can you move over here for a moment? Tammi, please roll over and get on all fours for him!"

I couldn't believe I was to be subjected to more embarrassment. I just felt a little more exposed with my face at the same height as Tammi's perfect little butt. Heather was right and after all, Tammi didn't complain at all when I had my cock in her mouth. Or maybe she did complain but I couldn't understand what she was saying with her mouth full. Either way I more than owed her a good massage to let her know how much I appreciated what she does for me.

I got ready to shove my tongue into Tammi's pussy from behind when Heather pulled me back and said, "No, you silly goose! You need to finger her to another orgasm, it's how the spas do it." She could see I was hesitant and then whispered to me and said, "Honey, you just had your tongue in my sister's pussy, would it be so bad to slip a couple of fingers into her pussy."

She was right of course. I never know what's considered acceptable behavior. I just didn't want Tammi to ever think I was taking advantage of her or being too forward. Jeez, Tammi had a tight pussy, even with just two fingers she felt tight. I was now working my fingers in and out of her tight, young pussy as she moaned up a storm. She didn't seem to be offended.

I'm glad her sister looks out for her; I'd hate to think of an innocent young thing, like Tammi getting used by some pervert. I rubbed Tammi's back as I fingered her slippery, wet, little pussy. Her smooth little pussy is truly perfect, I never get tired of looking at it.

Heather put a mirror in front of Tammi so I could see her beautiful face. It made it much easier for me to know when I was doing it right. I liked looking into her face as her mouth hung wide open. She tilted her eyes up at me to maintain eye contact in the mirror. She was moaning so hard I couldn't help but get harder myself.

Heather said, "You know what, if we really want her to relax, we need to get her hormones excited. Hold on..." Heather scooped up some of my cum and rubbed it on the entrance to Tammi's pussy. My girlfriend motioned for me to push it into her sister. I inserted my fingers without really thinking it through because I trust Heather. Heather said, "Sis, he's putting his semen into your pussy, can you feel it?"

Tammi said, "OH yes, it's so much better with his cum inside me." Heather must have thought if a little cum helps, more cum would be better so she just kept scooping it off me and feeding it into her sisters little pussy. "Please just a little bit more!" Tammi begged.

Unfortunately, we had run out of my spent cum so Heather knew just want to do. "The problem is her vagina needs the natural feeling of a penis. Just put your great big cock at the entrance of her pussy and rub your semen around on her lips. That should stimulate her properly."

I felt this might be a bad idea, but I had rubbed my cock on her pussy plenty of times when she was kind enough to give me a really nice haircut. This time my cock had a lot more cum on it but since I already pushed it inside of her it wasn't really any worse.

I never enjoyed going to the barber because I feel awkward being so close to strangers, but I really started to look forward to my next trim Tammi would give me. Even though we were both naked when she somehow made me feel like the rest of the world didn't exist so I didn't feel that awkward. I admit her sexy soft body rubbing all over mine as she sat in my lap was very enjoyable.

I got up on my knees behind Tammi and rubbed the head of my cock at the entrance of her pussy. She's such a sweet innocent girl; she just saw this as a massage, so I kept reminding myself that is what this was. Tammi was moaning up a storm. My cock was absurdly hard from all the rubbing and moaning. I hope Heather didn't notice; she might get the wrong impression.

Heather said, "Tammi, you need to simulate sex if you want this to work, you better bounce a little and thrust back." My cock was already at the entrance to her pussy when she backed up. The angelic little thing had no way of knowing my cock wouldn't give. She accidentally impaled herself on the head of my cock. She was so sweet she didn't say anything. She just groaned loudly as I pulled out.

"Please, Baby, put it back in. I need you to put it inside me! I'm so close!"

Heather whispered in my ear, "that's it Honey, put your cock into my sister's pussy." I put the tip of my cock back into her little sister. Heather was massaging my balls and rubbing my shaft. Tammi was moaning loudly as I accidentally slipped another inch inside of her when Heather said, "Good boy! Is this how you pictured it, my little sister begging you to put your cock inside of her?" I didn't think I could cum at all but I could tell my cock was spitting out a small load in my girlfriend's little sister's pussy.

Tammi starting yelling, "OH God, I'm cumming, oh God, I'm cumming again!" Heather continued to massage my balls. I didn't dare pull out was I was still cumming and that would be embarrassing to explain. I hoped Heather didn't notice my cock surging as she squeezed it from the base towards the tip.

Tammi finally lay down when my cock slipped out. I collapsed sweaty next to her. Tammi kissed my cheek and then my lips and said, "Thank you so much. You have no idea how much I needed this." What the hell is wrong with me -- even when she thanks me it makes me blush -- just like when her sister does. Tammi rested her head on my shoulder and ran her hands over my chest until she slowly fell asleep. She had one leg resting over my leg and I could feel my cum dripping out of her pussy. She looked like a little angel as she slept.

Heather turned my face towards hers as she kissed me all over my face. "You are the best boyfriend a girl could ever want. Look at how relaxed my sister is, I think she's asleep! Thanks for putting her needs first. I know how shy that must have made you feel." She gave me a very hard kiss on the cheek and made a kissing sound. Hopefully next time you won't feel so shy. Next time? I wonder how often Tammi needed stress relief.

I started to drift off lying between Heather and Tammi. Heather was playing with my cock and whispering in my ear. "Just imagine how good it will feel for both of you when you finally thoroughly fuck her little pussy!" I can't believe she said, that. I would have thought by now she'd figured out how determined I was not to cheat on her. I have no idea why she would think she could ever convince me to have sex with another woman. I would have argued with her, but I think my second cumming had drained the life from me.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

About 45 minutes later, I felt Tammi start to stir. Heather was now asleep -- my girlfriend looked like a beautiful romance period painting of a goddess or a nymph. She was stunning when I first saw her but when you love someone, they become even more attractive. It's hard not to just stare at her beauty. I put a sheet and light blanket over her. She smiled in her as she made that 'I'm comfy' face she makes when she's half asleep. I know it isn't much, but I really like when I get to take care of her.

Tammi took me by the hand and led me to the bathroom. She closed the blinds and lit a few candles. I guess she was in spa mode and wasn't ready to return to the real world. She turned on the shower and let the water warm up before leading me in to clean up.

Tammi slowly rubbed her body wash over every inch of my body. Her soft hands and the intimacy made me feel warm as she kept looking into my eyes and smiling. I returned the favor and gently rubbed her soft skin from head to toe. We hadn't said a word to each other since we got into the bathroom, but it just felt nice to have the companionship.

Tammi pointed to the shampoo and indicated for me to sit down in the tub. She poured a little shampoo onto my head and proceeded to massage my scalp. I think she knows how much I enjoy it as she'll take five minutes to give me a shampoo even though she cuts my hair very short. I think it is because I have a hard time not grinning like a fool when she runs her fingers through my hair.

She then sat down in front of me with conditioner in her hand. I reached for the bottle, but she gave me a gentle swat on the wrist. She then took my hands and wrapped my arms around her body like when we sit on the couch. She then nodded her head like she had set things right.

I pulled her close so she could lean against me. She reached back and put her right hand up against my cheek as she tilted her head to kiss my cheek letting me know I was doing the right thing. I'm terrible at understanding personal space -- my first instinct is to give people plenty of space since I'm so shy. I appreciate it when someone just lets me know what normal behavior in interpersonal relationships is. My girlfriend's sister understands my awkwardness and helps me through these situations.

I massaged her shoulders just a bit more and I have no idea why but I kissed the back of her shoulders and the top of her shoulders. I kissed my way up her neck and to on her cheeks which got big from her smile.

After a bit, Tammi kissed my cheek again and moved my hand so she could pour some conditioner into it. She leaned forward to get her hair soaked. She leaned back and I proceeded to give her head a massage. She put some more conditioner in my hand, and I made sure to get the ends like she taught me. I really like our time in the shower. Her naked body feels so good against mine. I'm so glad Heather convinced me that my shower time with her sister was perfectly normal.

Tammi tapped my forearm indicating we should stand up. We did a dance so we could both get another rinse under the shower head. She put her arms over my shoulders and pulled me down so she could whisper in my ear. "I need your help cleaning my girlie parts. A girl can get an infection if you leave your cum inside me for too long." I have no idea why but, somehow, I liked the thought my girlfriend's little sister still had some of my cum in her. I think it made me feel accepted as a good friend.

As if reading my mind she said, "don't worry you can put your cum in my pussy any time but we have to clean it out because it might get an infection. If we clean it, you can use it more often." I'm not sure what she meant by that, but I certainly don't want her getting an infection. I guess she expected more massages, so she was going to teach me how to take care of her afterward.

She took my hand and kissed it before rubbing the white bar of soap lightly on my hand. She then rinsed most of it off. She then took my fingers and guided them to her vagina. "Please put a couple of fingers inside me," she whispered into my ear. Her soft lips rubbing against my ear as she spoke.

I started to put my fingers in and out of her pussy as she directed the warm water down there to help with the cleaning effort. Her lips still against my ear, she moaned in appreciation into my ear. She pulled back so her face was directly in front of mine as I continued to clean her girlie parts; her pupils were huge in the dim light. The entire time we just stared into each other's eyes until Tammi pulled me forward to kiss me.

I eased my fingers in and out of her over and over to help replace my cum with water. She's such a sweet girl, it's nice the way she let me know how much she appreciated what I was doing. I always say the wrong thing or feel awkward when I try and show appreciation with a hug or a pat on the shoulder.

Tammi pulled away after groaning in my mouth. "Oh fuck, I'm cumming again!" Oh good, I thought, she's still enjoying her massage. She's such a sweet, young girl, I'd like to relax her silly. Eventually after the relaxation passed, her eyes returned to normal as she looked at me and smiled. She pulled me in and continued to kiss me. I may be out of my comfort zone, but I appreciated how much Tammi communicated her appreciation towards me. I pulled her tight and kissed her back so she would know I appreciated her efforts to communicate with me.

She then got a smirk on her face and started to wash my cock again with the white soap. She looked me in the eye as her hand slipped up and down my painfully hard cock. Tammi has such soulful eyes, it would be easy to get lost in them or her warm, sweet smile. I realized Tammi was just trying to give me an innocent massage, but I was going to cum soon and I think it was sexual to me. I'm not nearly as innocent as Tammi or Heather.

I pulled my cock out of her hands, kissed her forehead, and rinsed myself down before getting out of the tub. Tammi looked disappointed and I didn't want to leave the shower either, but could she look at me the same way if I came all over her? I'm sure Heather let her know I'm a pervert but as long as I can hide it from her, I'm hoping she won't think less of me.

I certainly wouldn't ever want to do anything my girlfriend or I might consider cheating. I know I'm old fashioned, but some people might consider getting a hand job while naked in the shower with your girlfriend's little sister, cheating. I'm lucky Heather lets me know what is acceptable and isn't.

I helped Tammi get nice and dry to show thanks for how she dotes on me. She returned the favor. I'm always amazed at how flexible she is when she bends down to dry my feet without bending her knees. I have to crouch down to get her feet top and bottom.

To stretch out when we go jogging, she can put her palms on the pavement when she bends down to stretch. I can just touch my toes. She makes sure to mock me about that every time -- I kid her and tell her it's because she so short she doesn't have to bend as far. Today she was showing off as she stood directly in front of me while bending over and reaching back to dry my feet!

I held her hips to keep her and myself steady. She had me lift my feet to dry them even though I think that is what the bathmat is for. I have no doubt if someone walked into the bathroom and saw this situation, they'd completely misread it as something sexual just because we were both naked and I was grabbing on to her hips as she was bending over in front of me.

Truth was it was nothing of the sort- she's so much shorter than me that my balls were touching her tush and my cock was resting on her back. I'd have to bend my knees while she got on her tippy toes before I could drive my cock into her spectacular, tight little pussy. Of course I'd never even think about doing that because the massage was over.

Once we finished drying off, I was keeping her company when she started to run a big yellow comb through her long, wet hair. She looked at me in the mirror and smiled before handing me the comb. I admit my heart was beating hard as I was nervous; I might push too hard on the comb or pull to hard if I hit a tangle.

She let me do this for several minutes making sure I got the technique right. Her long blond hair kept trying to curl as I kept straightening it with the comb. I think she appreciated being the one whose hair was being fussed over for a change. Hopefully we'd go jogging together tomorrow and I'd have a chance to see if I did any better combing her hair after our shower together.

I felt guilty every time my hard cock brushed against her buns, but she just smiled each time it did, letting me know it was OK. Sometimes she'd reach back and just grab on to it like she was playing with a stray puppy.

Tammi kissed me in the hallway and then said thank you in a quiet voice as we paused to look each other in the eyes. She then headed back to her room to finish up. My bonnie Heather was beginning to stir so I lead her by the hand and took her to the bathroom where the candles were still lit.

Heather didn't say a word, she just guided me down, so I was lying face up on the bathmat. I didn't ask questions; I just let her control my position.

Heather looked at me with a grin, I don't think I've ever seen before, as she straddled me and began to kiss me. She reminded me of the face Tammi makes just before she's about pile drive me with a good burn. Heather reached down and grabbed my cock, "he's been such a naughty boy!" I thought about it and couldn't figure out what she was talking about. Oh, no -- hopefully she's not upset about my small discharge while giving her sister a massage.

Heather aimed my cock for her pussy and lowered herself on me. Holy cow she was wet and hot down there. Her eyes had a wildness to them as she looked at me and smiled widely. "I'm going to have to reclaim my Honey since he's been such a bad boy. Can you feel how wet my pussy is?"

I started to respond when she put a finger gently over my lips and said "sshhh -- I'm not talking to you. I'm talking to him." She said as she glanced down to where are bodies met. She eased more of my cock into her tight pussy. She was tight as ever, but she's never been more lubricated in her life. I was making my way into my favorite place in the hole world. She said excitedly, "Oh God, this is so hot! Every time you go someplace you shouldn't, I'm going to have to make sure you know whose boss!"

She turned around with my cock still in her. Her little buns were amazing as she rode me hard. I was so surprised she was up for this since we already fooled around earlier. "That's it, you know where you belong." She spread her legs as wide as she could while riding my cock. I couldn't tell if it was all show, but it was like I wasn't even in the room when she was talking, she seemed to be genuinely trying to talk to my cock.

Heather was now slamming down on top of my cock. "I can't believe you are making me do this after you already had me this morning. Oh God, this is so much hotter than I ever imagined!" I could feel her pussy squirting on my cock. She moaned loudly, "uuaahhhhhn!!!"..."Whose pussy do you love the most?" I was going to say something, but I wasn't sure the question was for me.

"That's right," Heather said. "You love my pussy the best. I'm going to fuck you until you never forget that!" She was slamming up and down and she was gyrating like crazy. "That's it, I'm your little whore and you belong to me!" she said. The naughty language and the wild movements were too much for me to even think about holding out. I shot all the cum I could muster into her pussy.

"That's it," she said. "Fill me with your seed you naughty boy! This is where it belongs. Oh God! I'm cumming again!" We remained in this position for a few minutes as I felt her pussy still clamping and loosening on my cock.

I could finally feel my cock soften a bit. "Oh no," she said, "every last drop is mine!" she said as she squeezed my cock from the base towards the tip in her pussy.

She crawled back to face me and kissed my cheek hard and said, "I'm going to be in a lot of pain today and tomorrow, but it was sooo worth it. My honey is an animal." I was thinking she was such a wild woman I barely moved. I'm stoked she was so happy with my performance.