The Blowjob Contest

Story Info
Old college athletes can't resist some friendly competition.
8.9k words
4.42
35.7k
40
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

"I think this is the turn off here," Jordan told me from the passenger seat. I steered the car off the winding back road and on to an even more windy driveway.

My fiancé, Jordan, and I were joining two of my old college roommates and their significant others on a long weekend, lakeside getaway. We were all about a year out of undergrad and our lives had taken us in different directions, so we thought it would be nice to get together over the summer. When one of my old roommates, Megan had been offered use of a family friend's empty lake house, well we couldn't pass it up.

I followed the drive up to the house and parked next to the other two cars. It looked like Megan and her fiancé Logan, as well as Melanie and her husband Payton had already arrived. I parked the car and Jordan and I grinned at each other looking at the house.

It was a beautiful two story built into the side of a hill. The bottom floor had big double doors on the side that opened to a path that led down to the beautiful blue lake. There was a fire pit with chairs clustered around it on the path and cute little dock on the end, leading out into the water.

To the left of us in the driveway was a set of stairs built into the hill, leading to the front entrance of the house. We grabbed our bags from the car and hadn't even made it halfway up the stairs before Melanie came bursting out of the house to say hello.

"ITS SO GOOD TO SEE YOU CASEY!!!!" She shouted as she gripped me in a bear hug.

"Let me go you goober," I fought out through crushed lungs and laughter. She let go, still beaming and turned her attention to Jordan.

"How are you big guy?" she asked giving him a playful punch to the arm.

"Not even here 5 minutes and already with the fat jokes huh?" Jordan shot back, mock pouting.

Jordan was definitely overweight, but it wasn't entirely his fault. He had been a soccer player at the same school I went to, but in the last year of his career had torn his ACL. During surgery prep for that, doctors had discovered some irregularities in his heartbeat and he later underwent heart surgery to fix a heart valve. Understandably his exercise regimen had been significantly impacted and he had gained quite a bit of weight.

"Oh stop. It just means there is more of you to hug." Melanie laughed and grabbed him in a hug. Jordan and Melanie were longtime friends. She was actually the one who introduced us. They never missed an opportunity to tease each other.

"OW!!" Melanie shouted laughingly and punched Jordan again, he had pulled on her blonde ponytail as they were hugging.

I laughed as Jordan winked at me and we picked up our bags and continued up the house. Jordan may be overweight, but his personality was why I loved him. He loved to laugh, and make me laugh most importantly. He was so gentle and kind. I truly loved him and was so happy to be with him forever, whatever his physical shortcomings were.

As we approached, the other 3 occupants ducked their heads out. First, I saw Payton. He was a little over 6 foot and really skinny, he had a sort of wiry muscle look to him. I think that was more because he just had no body fat than because he was strong. He was a cop back home and managed to keep himself thin between the job and a lot of running.

Melanie ran up to give him a hug. Payton was a quiet, serious guy, quite different from Melanie who was always loud and joking. He loved my friend and was a good man, which was good enough for me.

Pushing past Melanie and Payton came Logan and Megan Both had huge grins on their face and I set my bags down for the imminent hug with Megan. She enveloped me, although not quite as aggressively as Melanie had.

"What's up girl!? It's been forever!!" she said when she pulled back. She was in graduate school like me, but I was in Indiana and she in Phoenix. We hadn't seen each other in person for a while.

"Way too long!" I agreed with her. I went to pick up my bag, but Logan had already grabbed it.

"Don't worry, I got these" he said with a smile as he picked up Jordan's bag too. He'd set it down to hug Megan.

"First Melanie calls me fat and now you think I'm an invalid!" Jordan playfully shot at Logan as he walked up the hill. Logan just laughed and continued carrying the bags.

Logan was about the same height as Payton, both a few inches taller than Jordan. He filled out his clothes much more, you could tell it was all muscle. I'd seen pictures of him on Megan's Insta with his shirt off and I would be lying if I wasn't excited to see in person this weekend.

Jordan followed Logan in the house with Payton not far behind while us girls hung back outside.

"What should we do!?" Melanie asked. She was a mile a minute and always wanted to be moving.

"She's been going nuts sitting and waiting for you guys to get here," Megan laughingly told me while Melanie mockingly made a face at her.

"Sorry, I'm so excited! And these guys took forever!" she gestured to me.

"I'm sorry, how long did you guys have to wait?" I asked, feeling a little guilty.

"Like 20 whole minutes!!!" Melanie teased back and we burst out laughing at her impatience.

"Come on, I want to get in the water before it's too dark!" she led the way inside.

We entered in the house and there was a large open area with couches and chairs in a semicircle around a fireplace and TV. To the right of that was the kitchen area, it was open too, much like the living room. The only thing separating it was an island counter in the middle with some stools around it.

To the left it looked like a hallway with bedrooms, my suspicions were confirmed when I saw Logan and Jordan emerge, presumably after setting the bags in the room. I smiled as I saw Jordan making Logan laugh, probably talking nonsense.

I looked right again and saw Payton coming up from a stairway, probably to the bottom floor of the house. He was holding a cooler and began putting some beers in it and the other boys walked over to help.

"Let's go get changed while 'the men' get the beer," Megan joked and led the way to the rooms.

Megan pointed me to my room and she and Melanie ducked into theirs to grab bags before joining me. The bedroom wasn't big, the bed took up most of the space. However, a little bathroom was connected to it which was nice.

The real selling point though was the large windows on the lakeside wall. If there had been any other homes around, I would've worried about privacy, but considering we were surrounded by trees and water, it made for an impressive view.

Melanie and Megan came in and we started to get ready to go down to the water. We had been roommates as well as teammates on the soccer team together in college so we had no qualms about changing in front of each other.

Melanie especially wasn't shy, it always made us laugh how outgoing she was and it was an interesting opposition to her husband. Payton was pretty quiet and serious and seemed very private. They probably made a good match, because they needed each other to pull them away from the extremes a little bit!

Megan and I hadn't even found our swimsuits, before Melanie was completely naked.

"Have your boobs gotten bigger!?" Megan exclaimed at Melanie. Both Megan and I were somewhat flat chested compared to Melanie. She had always had big boobs and wasn't scared to flaunt them, whether that meant wearing a low-cut shirt or just no shirt at all!

"A little bit, yeah!" Melanie laughed back while holding her breasts up with her hands and looking down at them. Her breasts were easily the biggest out of the three of us and were well more than a handful for just about any man.

"The rich just get richer," I teased her.

"Jealous much," she stuck her tongue out and shook her chest a little making us all giggle.

"No, cause we know you need them to make up for that flat ass!" Megan teased Melanie and smacked her butt playfully for good measure.

"Hey now that's not fair!" Melanie mockingly pouted.

"Nuh uh," I teased back. "You don't get to lord those over us and then play victim."

Melanie rolled her eyes playfully and pretended to be mad, but we could see the smile on her face. Melanie didn't truly have a flat ass. Just compared to prodigious backsides of both Megan and I.

Megan and I were both fairly short, I was 5'3" and she was 5'2". Melanie was a bit taller than us at about 5'6". Both Melanie and I have blonde hair with fair skin. We were often mistaken for sisters. Megan has dark brunette hair and darker, more olive skin tone, accentuated by all the Phoenix sun she had been exposed to.

Apart from the skin and hair color though my body was much more similar to Megan's. We both have thick lower halves and strong legs to go with large, curvy butts. Probably from our years of soccer and love for weight training. A hobby we had picked up to improve our soccer game and now continued to stay healthy.

Both Megan and I have very toned core muscles. Hers slightly more defined than mine, but you could see the outline of our abs, again hours of playing and being in the gym. Melanie was a little thicker than us, but she was still fairly skinny, you just couldn't see definition in her core.

Megan and I were smaller chested, and we both joked with Melanie that we couldn't have big boobs like hers or else we'd have everything and it wouldn't be fair. Melanie would always retort back that one day she'd get into lifting like us and it would be over for you "big booty bitches" as she liked to call us.

We got dressed in our bikinis, joking and laughing, enjoying our easy camaraderie. We all had scandalous coverage, taking advantage of our mid 20s bodies and lack of unfamiliar eyes this weekend.

Melanie wore a plum one-piece that was cut low, low, low. Her nipples were practically visible and her boobs were busting out. It offered close to full coverage in the back, but nobody was going to be looking back there with all she was showing in the front.

Megan wore a jade two piece. It was a moderate thong cut in the back and her lack of tan lines on her ass indicated it probably wasn't the first time she'd worn it. It was a string tie and looked really good paired with her tanned skin.

I had brought a simple navy two piece. The top was rather conservative, almost a sports bra cut, with a fun lace design below the neck. My bottom was far from conservative though. It was a high waisted thong cut and showed even more ass than Megan's. I was a little self-conscious when Jordan had convinced me to buy it, but I wasn't as nervous breaking it out among friends.

We grabbed our towels and exited the room to walk down to the lake. Peeking out the doors we saw the guys had gone down without us and were juggling a soccer ball around between them. Jordan had been the only soccer player so I figured it was his idea.

Their jokes and laughter got louder as we got closer and it made me smile to see how easy they all got along with each other. Both, Logan and Jordan were jokesters and were always laughing and never taking things too seriously, it was hard not to smile with them and even Payton's serious demeanor would diminish around them.

Payton and Jordan had their backs to us and Logan was facing us as we got closer. All 3 had their shirts off enjoying the sunshine and beautiful weather. Payton and Jordan were pale from the midwestern spring, but Logan was tan. Even more so than Megan. He cut an impressive figure as his muscles would flex and move under his tan skin as he would lunge and move to the ball.

All 3 had brown hair. Logan's was a lighter shade, probably a little bleached from all his time in the sun. His face was covered in a flattering length of stubble and his green eyes popped in his tan face.

Payton wore a beard. It was a lighter brown than his hair and eyes with flecks of red in it. It helped round out his otherwise very skinny, angular face.

Jordan had a jolly, round face with blue eyes. He didn't have any facial hair, but could grow a good beard when he chose to.

Payton was the least naturally athletic and was somewhat herky jerky in his movements. That wasn't entirely fair to him because it was in comparison to Logan and Jordan.

Logan was the most athletic and even though he wasn't particularly skilled at soccer he moved with smooth, easy grace.

Jordan was the best at soccer of the 3, his years of playing hadn't left him yet. It always made me a little sad thinking he'd had to sit out his last season due to injury.

My eyes were trained on them and then on Logan's toned abs, muscular chest and arms as we got closer. I looked up and realized he had caught me staring and I blushed as he winked at me.

"The ladies have arrived and oh my do they look lovely!" he intoned as we approached, saving me some embarrassment by looking away from me.

Melanie, never shy to lead the way, danced and twirled as we got close and went up to give Payton a kiss on the cheek. Megan took off down the dock to jump into the water and Logan sprinted after her, almost catching her as they both laughingly crashed into the water. I sauntered up to Jordan to give him a kiss.

"Enjoying the weather baby?" I asked him.

"More now that you're out here in that!" he stepped back from me to look me up and down.

"Oh please, you're ridiculous," I teased, but loving his attention and reaction.

"I wish you'd have told me we were wearing the hot swimsuits and I'd have broken my thong speedo out!" I laughed knowing that there was a distinct possibility he wasn't kidding and had actually bought one without telling me.

"Thank goodness you didn't. No one would want to see that!" Melanie teased from the side having heard our interaction.

"Payton, tell her to cool it over there!" Jordan retorted with a grin.

"She says what she wants." Payton laughed back.

"Damn straight," Melanie said with self-approval written all over her face.

"She's just all covered up and jealous of the tan I would be getting if I'd known!" Jordan joked back over to them referencing Melanie's one-piece suit.

"Who says I'm gonna stay covered up!?" Melanie stuck her tongue out at him and she pulled her suit apart to flash her huge boobs at us before turning to run into the water.

We looked over at Payton who shrugged at us and walked down after her. I laughed at Jordan who was grumbling under his breath.

"Well what am I supposed to say to that?" He joked rolling his eyes.

Laughing, I kissed his cheek and grabbed his hand to pull him to join everyone else in the water.

We hung out in the water splashing around for a while until the sun started to go down and the bugs started to come out. We toweled off and trudged back up to the house joking with each other and enjoying the company.

Once inside Megan got to work prepping some ready to bake pizzas, she had picked up on the way here. Melanie grabbed her bag from my room and took it back to hers, I grabbed Megan's bag to take back into her room so when she was ready, she could change.

The door was cracked slightly and I didn't think anything of opening it and pushing in. Standing across from me, going through his bag completely naked was Logan.

"OH SHIT! I'm sorry!" I managed before closing the door and backing out. I had gotten a full view of his body though and wow! He's a jaw dropper. I'd seen his chest, arms and stomach in all their glory down at the water, but what was between his legs was easily most impressive.

Megan had alluded to the fact that Logan had a big cock, but I'd never given it a ton of thought before now. It was probably longer than Jordan's soft and way thicker, it looked like he had a cucumber just dangling between his legs. I'd seen my fair share of cocks before and this was easily the most impressive one I'd ever laid eyes on.

I realized I hadn't moved when the door opened and Logan's smiling face peeked out.

"You good Case?" he asked, not a hint of embarrassment in his voice.

I looked down, noticing he was thankfully fully clothed. "Yeah....I'm sorry I was just bringing Megan's bag over," I gulped, my face hot from blushing.

"Thanks. Hey no reason to be weird, I was just changing." He took the bag and set it on the bed before turning back around. "We good?" he asked with a smile?

"Yeah...I'm sorry..." I mumbled, "I feel awkward now." I half laughed.

"Don't, I'm not embarrassed, so you shouldn't be," he winked at me and walked towards the kitchen.

I turned back towards my room, "Easy for you to say," I said to myself. Jordan had already started the shower in our room so I decided to hop in with him.

I stripped down and joined him. He smiled when he realized I was under the water with him. He wrapped me up from behind and started kissing my neck.

"Hey there cutiepie," he whispered in a mock seductive voice. "Wanna get frisky?" he licked my ear jokingly causing me to giggle. I turned so we were facing each other now.

I kissed him and reached down to stroke his cock with my right hand. He was hard in no time and I looked down, I couldn't help but mentally compare him to what I had just seen.

I had been with a couple guys before Jordan and I knew he was on the smaller side. He knew it too, but handled it well. He was excellent with his tongue and managed to not let his ego be attached to his cock, something a lot of guys, big or small, are unable to do.

"How about later?" I whispered into his ear, not wanting to kill the mood, but needing to get Logan's hanging monster out of my head before doing anything with Jordan.

"Fine," he mockingly rolled his eyes, but smiled to let me know it was okay. "But only if you put something sexy on for me later," he winked at me.

"I can do that," I winked back at him, feeling a bit of a tingle develop between my legs.

We finished showering and started getting dressed. I made sure to wait until he left so I could pick something to surprise him with later. I chose a black lace g string that I had brought, knowing how much he loved those. I had brought the matching bra and put that on. Covering it with a plain t shirt and a pair of pj shorts.

The shorts were pretty tight on my ass, and with the right angle you could see the lower part of my cheeks. I knew it would be the perfect thing to tease him with for the evening.

I went out and hung out amongst my friends. We talked and laughed and ate pizza. Then we all migrated to the couches and hung out playing cards against humanity and just generally enjoying the company.

Before long we were all yawning and Payton made the first move for bed. As he was getting up Logan and Jordan started to clean up our trash and put it away.

Taking advantage of it just being the 3 of us Melanie looked at Megan and I. She mimed giving a blowjob before saying, "Duty calls". We laughed as she got up and followed Payton to bed.

"You go get Logan, Jordan and I can finish this," I told Megan.

"You don't have to tell me twice," she said with a suggestive smirk. She walked over and jumped on Logan's back. Her shirt pulled up and her shorts adjusted and I saw she had a little thong on underneath as well. Looks like she had the same plan as me.

"Goodnight guys," Logan said laughing as he carried Megan on his back to bed. She wiggled her eyebrows at me as they passed and I couldn't help but laugh.

I got up to help Jordan in the kitchen with the trash and noticed his eyes following Megan's ass down the hall.

"Hey now, it's not polite to stare," I mocked him and gave him a little punch on the arm. I liked to think I wasn't the jealous type, and I'd catch him looking from time to time at other girls, but I knew he'd never do more than just sneak a peek.

"Uh huh, I could've told you the same thing down at the water," he mocked.

"What are you talking about?" I teased back.