Too Good To Be True Ch. 10

Chapter 10

School dragged on. Courtney and I were both excited to expand the harem. The excitement was only increased by the mystery of who Sarah had picked to be the next one brought into the fold.

Suki found us in a break between classes and asked how much we knew about what was happening tonight. Turns out Sarah hadn't told Suki any more than she had told us. Suki was excited, but even better.

"It's amazing, normally, I'd have to sneak away and... um.... take care of myself. But with you, and what we've done... I'm okay, and I can wait to do it... properly." She proudly explained.

Courtney and I gave her high fives. "I'm glad we're helping you out." Courtney smiled, "That's why we're doing this."

"Life changing, let me tell you." Suki said, "I had to pretend that the squad's taunts got to me, but like even all their sex talk... Did you know some of those girls have been sleeping around for three years at this point and have only orgasmed half a dozen times? Tom gave me more orgasms than that in a weekend!"

"We found a good guy. We're lucky to have him." Courtney glowed, leaning on my arm.

After classes, Courtney and I went home. Sarah had said we'd get together around 5, which gave Courtney and me time to study and do some grading. We also had time to swap out the sheets, so whoever hopefully joined the harem could have fresh sheets.

About ten minutes early Suki showed up. She'd brought a few outfits and a dozen pairs of underwear. "The outfits are easier to rewear. If I get too turned on, or get cum on my panties... they need thoroughly cleaned."

Courtney helped her put her things in our shared closet temporarily, until the furnishings arrived for the second room.

Sarah arrived shortly after we finished. She looked businesslike, in her blouse and skirt. She smiled and greeted me with a kiss, her breath catching. She shook her head, "Today isn't for me. I'm fine."

She straightened and assembled us all in the living room, "We're going to have to be delicate tonight." Sarah cautioned. "Unless I tell you to, please refrain from speaking. It should make this go smoother."

My stomach knotted, but I had to trust in my girls.

Shortly later, there was a knock on the door and Courtney opened the door, welcoming in Brittany. The dark brown beauty had her black hair done smooth and over her shoulder. She was wearing a red spaghetti strap blouse that emphasized her C-cup breasts and her matching skirt was short enough to show off her shapely legs and curvy ass. Her makeup obviously had some serious effort in it and she looked amazing.

She hugged Sarah and Suki, and Sarah invited her to sit.

"So, when is everyone else joining us?" Brittany asked Sarah, it seemed we all knew who set this up.

"You can relax Brittany, everyone's here." Sarah told her.

Brittany looked at her confused. Then she looked at Suki, then Courtney, and finally me.

Suddenly Brittany exploded, "YOU MOTHERFUCKERS! I TRUSTED YOU!" Brittany bolted to her feet, "HOW COULD YOU TREAT ME LIKE THIS!? I'M NO CHEAP WHORE YOU CAN SELL OUT LIKE THIS!"

Sarah silenced us with a hand and looked at her friend, and when she stopped to catch her breath, Sarah interjected, "Do you want to keep jumping to wild conclusions or do you want to hear what this is actually about?"

"Oh, you think I'm so desperate I'd buy your man-whore?! Is that what this is about?" Bethany demanded, less sure of herself, but still angry.

Sarah raised an eyebrow at her friend, "Do you want to keep jumping to wild conclusions, or would you like to hear what this is actually about?"

Brittany huffed. The obvious concern on my face, as well as that on Suki's face and Courtney's was apparently sincere enough to buy us at least enough time for Sarah to explain.

Brittany sat down, her arms crossed and her anger still evident.

"You ready? Because believe it or not, we are here to help you. Now if you want to take some time to cool off, we can do this another night. Would you like that?" Sarah continued.

"Depending on what your 'explanation' is, there may not be another time. I thought you guys were my friends." Brittany snapped.

"We are, and if we take some deep breaths together, we can move forward and I believe you'll see that we are here to help you. Have we ever betrayed your trust before?" Sarah pressed.

"No..." Brittany muttered.

"Now, you think we are doing what you told me that your friends in high school did, correct?" Sarah continued.

"Well, it sure as fuck looks like it!" Brittany snapped.

"How did I react when you told me about it?" Sarah moved forward.

Courtney, Suki, and I were obviously concerned for her, and Brittany could see it. Suki was almost crying.

Brittany allowed her anger to dissipate somewhat. "You were outraged. You said if you ever hear of something like that again, you'd string them up by their thumbs and beat them."

Sarah nodded, "So, which is more likely, are we trying to pimp you out, or is something else is going on?"

"Okay," Brittany conceded, "If you guys aren't trying to pimp me out, and you aren't pimping Tom out, what the fuck is going on, and why am I here?"

Sarah smiled, "Alright, now that you're ready to listen. Suki, dear, how are you feeling?"

Suki frowned, "Well, I'm worried for Brittany."

Sarah laughed, "Other than that?"

Suki smiled, "Other than that? I'm fine."

Sarah pressed her, "Now, Suki, how many times have you masterbated since the party on Friday ended?"

Bettany rolled her eyes.

Suki sat up proudly, "I haven't masterbated once."

Brittany's eyes narrowed, "Bullshit. You have to rub one out at least four times a day."

"What do you think could have helped Suki no longer need that kind of stimulation?" Sarah asked.

"I'm not letting you hypnotize me, we've been over that." Brittany stated, but she was clearly losing control of the situation. "Wait, Suki, did you find a man?"

Sarah smiled, "Suki has indeed found a man. And so long as she agrees to not do anything sexual with someone other than her man, he has agreed to meet all her needs. And he has committed to her as well."

Brittany looked at Sarah suspiciously, "Congratulations to her, but that doesn't affect me, now does it?"

"Now, since Suki is devoted to him, and he is devoted to her, that is a committed relationship. Suki is not a whore, and her man is not a 'man-whore' as you so eloquently put it. Correct?" Sarah pressed.

"Sounds like it, but again, how does this affect me?" Brittany was definitely calling down, but her suspicions were still there.

"Now, in a committed relationship the people in the relationship can set their own rules for that relationship, and so long as they abide by those rules, and they are being faithful to one another, correct?" Sarah continued.

I could see what Sarah was doing. Obviously, Bettany had some history, and Sarah had to work through that history to get Brittany to accept what we were trying to do here.

"Within reason, yes." Bettany conceded.

"So if Suki and her man agreed that they were going to do a threesome, would that be cheating?" Sarah asked.

"No, if Suki and her mysterious man agreed to having a threesome with another girl, it wouldn't be cheating." Brittany accepted. "Suki knows about it, is a part of it, and has consented."

Sarah was pleased and continued. "Now what if this became a regular thing? Just so long as none of the partners had sex with anyone outside the threesome. Would it be cheating?"

"No, it wouldn't. Same reasons." Brittany was confused now.

"Would they be whores?" Sarah inquired.

"I guess not. I mean, they aren't just sleeping around, and no one's paying for sex or being pimped out..."

"Now what if Suki said that her man could have sex with their threesome partner without her if she wasn't available. Would that be cheating?" Sarah pressed.

"I... I guess not. I mean, Suki knows about it... at least in this circumstance... I mean, where is this going?" Brittany was struggling.

"Now what if everyone agreed to add another girl to the group, so now there are three girls and one guy? They have all committed to only have sex within the group, and no one is taking advantage of anyone. They aren't pimping anyone out. No one is paying for sex. Would they be whores?" Sarah suggested.

"No, I guess. It's no different from the threesome, though I suppose if they have rules and have committed like that... Holy Fuck!!!" Brittany gasped, her eyes widening.

She looked at the three girls and me. "You're all fucking him!?"

"Yes. We have agreed that we will allow each other to have sex with Tom. Tom is only permitted to have sex with people we have all agreed to join the group. We have all proved we are disease free, and have committed to only have sex with Tom, and if we do anything sexual with anyone but Tom, or the other girls in the group, we leave the group. This includes prior activity, so only virgins are being considered. We have found no reason to make exceptions." Sarah explained.

Brittany was looking from me to the girls and back to me.

"How long has this been a thing....?" She struggled to ask.

"Suki was the first one Courtney and Tom invited to join in. They invited her right after the party. You see, they aren't doing this because of any sexual predation. They are doing this because Courtney cares about all of us, and doesn't want any of us suffering like Suki was. She had to masterbate four times a day, for the love of god! Now she is sexually satisfied, and can turn to Tom whenever she has sexual needs." Sarah informed Brittany.

"Courtney invited me to join next, knowing I'd figure it out soon enough and she wanted to make sure she wasn't endangering anyone's mental health with this. As you can see by Suki's condition, it has clearly been good for her." Sarah explained.

"Then wanting to avoid bringing friends in based on sexual preference, but based on needs, Courtney and Tom asked me to assess needs and extend invitations." Sarah continued.

"So I'm the needy one?" Brittany snapped.

"No, Suki was the neediest one. As she was already being taken care of, I could consider other aspects as well. You bring unique benefits as far as our friend group goes. You see, as I just passed my certification and am now a licensed therapist, and graduating with a degree in neuroscience and behavior, I can help care for the mental health of the group. But when it comes to our physical health, I'm pretty worthless. You, however, are a Medical Sciences major. Before too long you'll be a doctor. You can help with our physical well being. That's in addition to your needs, which we've discussed and I don't believe you want aired here, but I can if you'd like." Sarah corrected her.

Brittany blinked, twice.

"Really, honey, when you've made soul-bearing confessions to your un-official therapist, who is therefore not bound by client-doctor privilege and professionalism, and she goes out of her way to help you... do you really want to argue with her about it with your mental state?" Sarah chided her.

"So what do we call ourselves? Tom's bitches?" Brittany asked.

It was not lost on me that Brittany had said 'we' and 'ourselves', it seemed Brittany was deciding to join the harem.

"No. That would imply a lot of things that aren't so. We've been saying we're Tom's harem." Sarah laughed.

"Harem girls, huh?" Brittany mused, "I suppose I could do worse. Beats Dean trying to tell me I'm his bitch whether I like it or not..."

"And everything in the harem is voluntary. You never have to do anything with Tom. There are enough of us that his basic sexual needs will be met, happily, by one of us. So you're free to do what you want." Sarah continued.

"That includes stuff with the other girls, that threesome stuff usually involves girl on girl stuff... and I don't know if I'm down for that." Brittany interjected.

Sarah looked to Courtney curiously, Courtney jumped in.

"Of course, that's all voluntary. And honestly, the only girl-on-girl things that have happened this far is a little kissing or licking of boobs while watching Tom make love to each other, and Suki and I have licked Tom's sperm out of the other's vagina. But that was all done with the knowledge we didn't have to do it, we did it because we wanted to. So girl-on-girl action is not forbidden, but not mandated." Courtney finished her explanation.

"And would you let a lesbian into the group?" Brittany pestered.

"We could... but it would be harder to make sure she's following the rules." Sarah admitted, "Women spending time together alone is not nearly as suspect as a woman and a man together. Plus there's the matter of prior activity."

"What do you mean?" Brittany pressed.

"Courtney, dear, would you show Brittany the photos?" Sarah requested.

Courteney pulled out her phone and walked to our potential newest harem member. She showed her first Sarah, then Suki, then herself, legs spread, blood and sperm leaking from their love tunnels.

"Lesbians could do quiet a lot, sexually, and still get a picture like that. There's... less.. that a straight woman can do and still prove herself." Sarah explained.

"You know that non-sexual activity can break a hymen, right?" Brittany explained, "Science tells us that doing any number of physical activities like gymnastics, horseback riding, or even riding a bike could stretch your hymen and make you not bleed during your first sex. I'm shocked Suki did."

"Well, it's been working so far." Sarah shrugged. "And yes, we are aware that it isn't foolproof. All I'd take is deciding to use a dildo to try to meet some sexual needs, but as you saw, this far, it's been a good indicator. And I know from previous discussions that you've checked and yours is intact."

Britney grudgingly conceded the point. "So hard rules, what are they?"

"You must not engage in sexual activity of any kind, except with members of the harem. If you do, you must alert the harem and cease all harem related activities at once. We can still be friends, but you won't be allowed the sexual privileges of a harem member. Alternatively, continued membership is voluntary so if you wish to pursue another man, you can leave the harem at any time by informing the harem members. You also must show that you are free of any sexually transmitted diseases, so as not to spread them to your fellow members. " Sarah began, and Brittany nodded. "All members of the harem must approve of new harem members." Again, Brittany nodded. "While it shouldn't affect our reputations, knowing there was an active harem on campus might draw the ire of disparate groups, from the administration to the men we've scorned, so we do not speak publicly of the harem." Brittany's nods continued. "All harem related activities must be consensual on the parts of all harem members, Tom included. You cannot force Tom to do anything here doesn't want to, and he cannot force you."

Courtney concluded with, "That's all for now. We haven't had any problems with it yet. The rules are subject to change if all the harem members agree, so we can change them or add more as needed."

"Makes sense... do changes have to be unanimous or just majority?" Brittany inquired.

"It is regarding everyone's sexual experiences, I think it needs to be unanimous. Can you imagine if you got outvoted and got told you HAD to do something sexually you didn't want to? We can't have any paths that would lead to this becoming some sort of weird sex cult." Courtney stated, and Suki and Sarah nodded. Brittany seemed to like that.

"Um... are there any rules about whether or not people can be in the room when you... make love?" Brittany asked, she was actively not looking at me and blushing furiously.

"That's all up to the one being made love to. Tom seems to be okay either way, right, Tom?" Courtney asked, turning to me for verification.

I nodded, "I mean, I'm making love to all of you. It's nothing you haven't or won't see. And I guess it can help seeing someone else experience something you're curious about to see if you want to try it or not." Then for Brittany's sake, I added, "And, Courtney, you've been there to support Suki and Sarah when they lost their virginities, it seemed to help them push through and enjoy it. I wouldn't want to take that from any of the new girls as they join."

Brittany's blush increased.

"Well, any more questions, Brittany?" Sarah asked.

"Do I have to decide right now?" Brittney asked, but she was squirming in her seat, her legs clamped together and her thighs rubbing. Her hands wringing in her lap. Her blush was still going strong. The discussion was having clear effects on the poor girl and it wasn't hard to see.

"No, you could decide at any point, so long as you still meet the requirements. The invitation is extended, and you may accept whenever you are ready." Sarah informed her, but she was smiling knowingly.

"Can I... Can I talk to Tom... Alone?" Brittany begged. "To help me make the decision?"

"Of course. The rest of us can either wait here and you can go to the bedroom to talk, or we can go to the bedroom and you can talk here. Which would you prefer?" Sarah replied.

"I'll... I'll take him to the bedroom." Brittany decided and she stood up, I stood with her and she took my hand and walked me, slightly hurried, to the bedroom.

Brittany closed the door behind her and leaned against it, her eyes closed. "I can't believe this is happening." She whispered.

"You're telling me." I retorted as I sat on the foot of the bed. "You know you have a choice."

"That's the crazy thing!" She muttered exasperated.

I patted the bed next to me and she came and sat, her dark skin glistening with the sweat of her concentration.

"Okay, here goes. You've seen me naked. I've seen you naked...." She started. "I am not going to pretend I didn't like what I saw. You are fit, but not undernourished, and I am terrified and excited by the size of your package... but what about me? Did... did you like what you saw?" Brittney stammered.

"Oh yes!" I hurried to assure her, "Your breasts are amazing, big enough to grope and play with, and dying to be sucked on. I love the way your waist makes your hips pop. Your fine ass is going to be great to hold while we make love, and your skin contrasts with all your intimate parts... your sexy vagina, your nipples, and your anus and really draw me to them. You are beautiful, and sexy, and I am honored to even be considered as a lover."

Brittany looked up at me, "That's sweet. But every boy has a type, and you have three girls in there saying you are into small boobs and butt. My ass isn't like theirs. They got those tiny asses, and you clearly like that. You still like my fat ass?"

"Brittany, I like 'fit' asses. I also like my girls to be natural. Fake giant asses and tits do nothing for me. Especially not those fake brazilian asses. I want an ass that responds to my hand." I explained, "And frankly, something that is extremely hot for me is the variety of my... err... harem. I mean, as a man, the idea of having multiple women is incredible. Yes, Courtney, Suki and Sarah are similar in many ways but each is unique in their own way, and you are just unique in more visible ways. If you doubt me, the giant erection in my pants will testify on your behalf. You are sexy and I can hardly believe you are considering allowing me to enjoy your sexiness. I promise, you aren't some sort of pity fuck. Don't worry, Suki and Sarah were both worried about that too. But I find each of you sexy and appealing in your own way."

Brittany seemed comforted by that, "Really, the asian cheerleader worried she wasn't fuckable?"

"Oh, she was terrified of it. Apparently her nickname from her fellow cheerleaders is "the two-by-four", because they say she is a flat, skinny board." I informed her.