ToXXXic

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

"Someone was a little more excited...mmm aroused than they led us to believe, girls," Mandy suggested, building a bridge for the rest of the Toxic trio to walk across and join in on the taunting.

Jacy fired up first, spatting out, "Nice crotch, Rox. Ooh, but it'll look a lot better with a cock that can pummel my fuckin' butthole!"

"You greedy bitch!" Gigi fired up, shoving her teammate. "It's my turn to get bummed!" A small shoving match ensued, but Mandy was quick to shut it down.

"Girls, girls, please! Roxanne's a stallion. She's young and fit, I'm sure she'll have more than enough cock for each of you, regardless of who goes first," Mandy complimented, helping Roxanne step out of her leggings.

"Yeah girls, don't worry! I'll save some energy for you once I'm done pounding your Mistress' fat ass," Roxy assured as Mandy took each side of her thong and slowly pulled down to reveal her dripping wet cunt.

Rolling her eyes, Mandy quipped, "That's cute but my ass, while lovely, isn't exactly on the menu for you tonight. Strictly Gigi and Jacy, but if you'd like to broaden the size of our little menu I'd be happy to add your big, brown, booty into the mix?"

"Uh, no thanks," Roxy confirmed, almost a little humbled by Mandy's ability to put her in her place. She didn't let that sway her confidence for too long though. Roxanne had butterflies in her stomach, even after Mandy refocused on her upper body, quickly doing away with Roxy's top to allow her small, supple breasts a chance to breathe. They weren't quite as impressive as her backside, but Roxanne was still quite fond of them, and she imagined most of her fans would be too.

Nevertheless, Mandy was showing her appreciation, immediately reaching out for a feel but, once again, Roxy shut her down. "Sorry, but I don't think so. How about we just get me a strap-on and we get on our merry way? Does that sound okay?"

Mandy backed away, hands facing out. "Hey, no worries. Like I said, I just want you to be comfortable." Again, Mandy's words sounded very genuine, but Roxanne couldn't help but take them with a grain of salt considering Mandy said them with a large pink member protruding from her crotch. That became much easier though, after what happened next.

Mandy undid the harness from her waist and handed the strap over to Roxanne, the kind words, "It's already broken in," accompanying her gift. Roxy slowly reached out and took the large toy in her hand. She examined it for a moment, unsure of how to properly put it on, or how she would use it once she had. But luckily, Mandy was willing to show her.

"Like this," Mandy said, guiding Roxy's hands and directing her, ultimately helping to speed the process along. In no time at all, Perez was fully strapped and ready to rock. Well, not exactly ready, at least mentally.

Wearing the strap-on, it was an awkward feeling, one that Roxanne expected but was thrown off by nonetheless. Her front end felt heavy, and the coarse leather of the harness had already begun to dig into her tan flesh, something she imagined most tops had to "get used to", but that didn't make it any less uncomfortable to wear. Nevertheless, it was time to begin; now, the only question that remained was where would she begin?

Mandy gestured outward, towards her pair of alluring, poisonous babes, the choices obvious. Narrowing down who Roxy would start with was the trickier decision. You never forget your first time, and even though she didn't care too much about topping, she definitely wanted to give the opportunity a fair chance to swoop her in and make her a fan. Gigi, on paper, was the more obvious selection with her pale, luxurious body, equal parts sex, seduction, and sugar from top to toe.

While Jacy, or nearly anyone in NXT for that matter, could compete with Gigi in those regards, Jacy was a feisty one. Roxy had walked past her many times knee-deep in bliss, her loud mouth almost always shooting off in one way or another which, as you could imagine, probably made for a rather satisfying experience. But on the other-other hand, Gigi had become quite well-known amongst the locker room for her especially kinky and submissive nature.

Truthfully, Roxy would've chosen Mandy given the opportunity, simply for the fact that she'd be the most satisfying fuck out of the three. Obviously gorgeous, a body to die for and maybe the only body in NXT that could compete with Gigi, and of course, the high standing as the reigning alpha. Roxanne may be new to the game, but topping the alpha on your first night had to be some kind of record. That kind of accolade was definitely fitting for someone named "The Prodigy".

Alas, Mandy wasn't on the table and frankly, Roxanne wasn't going to try pushing her luck. At least not yet. Gigi and Jacy were both incredibly hot, and either one would suit more than fine for Roxy's first lesbo lay. But with that said, only one person could fit the billing.

"Gigi," Roxy called out and Gigi immediately perked up.

"Aww c'mon! Her? What the fuck, Rox? I'm waaay better than Gigi," Jacy cursed, that loud mouth that nearly swayed Roxy her way initially in full effect.

"Yeah, sure you are," Gigi remarked sarcastically, pronouncing her large, natural breasts. "I think it's obvious why Roxy picked me. I mean...no offense but, compared to me you just come up a bit...short." Gigi doubled down, turning until her ass faced outwards, directly in Roxanne's field of vision, and then proceeded to give it a nice, loving rub.

"Yeah, so what? You've got huge tits and a massive butt, big deal! I'm the better fuck and everyone knows it," Jacy argued.

"Whatever you say, flatty."

"I'm not flat, you whore! I just don't go out of my way to let my ASS hang out at all times like you!"

Gigi smirked. "That's an awfully funny way to say you're flat, now isn't it?"

Jacy responded with a shove, one that Gigi quickly returned in kind, before Mandy ran over to break them up.

"D-Does this happen a lot?" Roxy asked.

"More than you can imagine..." Mandy confirmed dishearteningly, each hand pushing one of her stablemates away, keeping the two separated but failing to stop them from swiping and clawing at the other. Though, none of the attacks landed.

"Girls, girls, girls! Geez, calm down! You see, this is why you guys couldn't keep the tag straps" Mandy demanded and they both adhered, though Jacy was a bit more hesitant based on how worked up she was. "Look, you'll both get a turn with Roxanne tonight, understand? Gigi goes first, and Jacy, you'll be second. It's only fair, since if Roxy hadn't shown up, it would've been Gigi's turn anyway. Are we clear?"

"But, Mistress Rose, I-" Jacy attempted to argue, but her owner wasn't having any of it.

"I said, are we clear?" Mandy asserted, raising her voice slightly.

With a sigh, Jacy confirmed, "Crystal, Mistress."

"Alrighty then!" Mandy perked back up, returning her attention to Roxanne. "For tonight, my bitches are your bitches. And you've chosen Gigi first so...go ahead, give her an order."

"Okay..." Roxy agreed, transitioning into thinking about where she wanted to take things next. "Gigi, on the bed, now!"

Gigi snickered before agreeing, "Yes, Mistress Prodigy," before skipping over to the bed and crawling into the center, her massive, pale ass cheeks facing out to form the fullest of moons.

"No, not like that!" Roxy barked as she followed behind. "On your back." Gigi raised her brow, confused but ultimately willing. She flipped over, pulled a pillow over to prop her head up and held her legs back.

"On her back, huh?" Mandy asked, sharing a similar confusion to her sub. "That's a little unorthodox."

"Is it a problem?" Roxy asked with a hand on her hip and a knee on the bed.

"No, we just...we usually go doggy, you know? Fuck the bitch like a bitch?" Mandy explained.

Roxanne shook her head. "Well, 'we' ain't me, now is it? I'm the champion and I'm gonna do things the way I want to! Is that okay with you?" Mandy nodded in approval, leading Roxanne to perform a similar gesture to show that they were on the same page. Then, just as Roxy swooped in, ready to claim her prize, Mandy chimed in with some more sage advice.

"Did you want to prep her hole first? I usually start with some rimming just to relax the muscles back there. Makes the early stages much easier for both parties," Mandy explained, immediately eliciting a disgusted response from Roxanne.

"You mean lick here," Roxanne pointed to Gigi's inviting, winking butthole. "That's gross! Not happening!"

"Just advice from a seasoned pro," Mandy chimed back. "Take it, don't take it, it's up to you. Either way, my bitch is well trained. Isn't that right, Gigi?"

Gigi immediately agreed, "Mmm yes, I've taken so much cock up my fat butt, I'll be really loose for you, Rox, I promise!" Roxanne responded in kind by placing a hand around Gigi's throat and gripping tightly, taking a chance on Dolin's history as a kink-spert to silence the bitch before she really got going. Then, with utmost focus, Roxy directed her cock to its target.

Her heart pumped furiously; finally, after over a year of watching everyone else partake in this uniquely sadistic form of sin, Roxanne was about to take the leap herself. No more watching, no more wondering what it must feel like to have complete control over another woman, and no more pretending like it wasn't interesting for the sake of staying focused. Roxanne felt her tip's voyage end, just on the threshold of Gigi's backdoor. With nothing else standing in her way, she closed her eyes and pushed forward.

Gigi gasped underneath Roxanne's grip, struggling to keep hold of her meaty, pale thighs as her entrance was violated. With no experience or anything resembling knowledge of the act, Roxy was winging it and it showed. Her movements were slow, as they should've been, her overall pacing was start-stop instead of powering through like she should've. Gigi was more than equipped to handle a bit of pain, hell it probably would've gotten her off. Luckily, she had just the remedy for Roxy's lack of training, that being her own immense amount of skill as a pro wrestling bottom.

While Roxy may have been taking her time and then some, Gigi's butt was just so loose, so worn out from the last year-plus of taking Mandy's cock several times a day and twice on Sundays. That big, juicy bum of her's was made to be fucked, and Mandy's ensured that so many times that swallowing up Roxy's length was a piece of cake, even if it took a bit longer than it should have.

"Look at that, Rox! Your balls-deep inside of her!" Mandy pointed out as she moved in for a closer. Roxanne was sweating almost as much and as fast as her heart was pumping; the heat was so intense, she could hardly bear it. Still, she kept her grip around Gigi's throat tight, allowing only a miniscule amount of air to escape the fiery-haired firecracker's person.

"F-F...Fu...Fuck...me," Gigi, struggled to squeal out, a soft, desperate plea powered by only the smallest, weakest of breaths. With that cock ruminating inside of bowels, Gigi was so, so ready for a proper pounding, so, so ready to see what if The Prodigy was truly just a nickname for Roxanne inside of the squared-circle and, so too was Mandy.

"Fuck her, Rox!" Mandy purred, running her hand along Roxanne's back lovingly. "Pound that fucking asshole long and deep! Mmmm...yeah, Gigi's a very special bitch, she can take it no matter how hard you go! The rougher you are, the sooner she'll be begging and pleading to cum! So fuck her harder! Deeper!"

Mandy's encouragement was welcomed by all, except by Jacy, who secretly took offense to her Mistress' claim that Gigi was a 'special bitch'. Roxanne didn't respond, at least not verbally. Instead, she got to work doing as exactly as Mandy had advised. Punishing the former Priscilla's pooper.

Again, her lack of experience showed, but that's also why she chose Gigi to be her first. Roxanne knew that whatever she may have been doing wrong would not only be accepted, but welcomed. Gigi had made a name for herself as maybe THE sluttiest bottom in all of NXT, so once Roxanne got going, it mattered little what she did. Nonetheless, the long, measured strokes she began with definitely did the trick.

It wasn't long before Roxanne began to pick up the pace; with each thrust, she could feel that already loose pipe beginning to open up even further. As she began more comfortable inside Gigi's chute and vice versa, Roxy finally released her grip on the pale girl's throat and relocated down, clasping on one of her large, natural breasts and squeezing it as hard as she could.

Gigi let out a small, adorable groan as her breast was fondled, Roxy taking it a step further from time to time and squeezing the tiny pink nipple that accentuated its beauty so well, and even switching over to the other to show some love. All the while, she picked up her pumping pace.

Gradually at first, Mandy's hand was still on her back, acting as a guide to help her keep tempo but, eventually, the pressure disappeared, and The Golden Goddess gave Roxanne free reign to go to town on Gigi's asshole. Given an inch and Perez took a mile, practically powering up to an obscene degree. Before she knew it, Roxanne was delivering a proper butt-busting performance, the first of her young life.

Gigi was completely under her control; all the submissive little whore could do was moan, whimper, and desperately hold her meaty thighs back as Roxanne's tan, sweaty, muscular body crashed down on top of her own pale, curvier frame over and over again. The deeper they both got into their respective zones, the more Roxanne found herself switching between fast and short strokes and longer, more powerful ones, each delivering nothing but pure pleasure to the former NXT Tag Team Champion.

Dolin wore a face of dazed enthusiasm, the pleasure drowning out the world around them. Mandy had forced her to abstain in the event that something like her losing to Roxanne occurred; what better way to lure someone into the hierarchy that Gigi Dolin's fat, un-fucked asshole? It was her first time today, a rare sight for sure as, by this time at night, Gigi had usually taken at least three ass fuckings throughout the day. This one was hitting surprisingly deep thanks to the brief abstinence, and it was welcomed in kind.

It helped that Roxanne wasn't pulling any punches either, fully aware of Gigi's history and penchant for delving deep into the world of kink. Roxanne herself has honestly never been one to take things past an otherwise vanilla avenue. For some reason though, she found herself reveling in Gigi's punishment. Mixing it up, pushing both her own boundaries as well as Gigi's. Slaps to Dolin's pretty face, the sound of which correlated perfectly with that of the pair's meaty thighs slapping together after every thrust.

What really pushed things to the brink, however, was when Roxanne reached out and grabbed a firm handful of those bright orange locks. And Roxanne tugged and tugged roughly, using Gigi's hair as pulley to keep her line of sight focused on the action. No matter the strain it placed on her head or how painful it became, Gigi moaned emphatically and even openly screamed for more at times. Such was the treatment Gigi Dolin came to expect.

"Listen to her, Rox," Mandy suggested, a light whisper sing-songing its way into Roxanne's ear. Mandy's poisonous allure continued, "You're doing so well, a real natural. I'm a little envious."

"E-Envious, huh?" Perez huffed. "Of who? Me? Or this bitch?" In an attempt to sell her statement, Roxanne picked her pace up significantly, really trying her best to look like a stud which, truthfully, was a strange feeling since she couldn't ever remember trying to look strong or powerful in the past.

"Nice try, hun, but alpha babes don't take dicks," Mandy assured before reaching around and cupping Roxanne's small, firm breast in her hand, which acted as a successful distraction to slow down the wrestling and apparently topping prodigy. "But I will, however, clean yours off."

Mandy helped guide Roxy's movements to a standstill. Then, she took the unsheathed base of Perez's pipe and slowly plucked it from Gigi's backdoor, savoring the pungent smell of the juices that coated the shaft. From tip to base, every inch was covered in enticing cream; Mandy just couldn't help herself and gladly took the rod into her mouth.

A soft moan popped its way out of her mouth the second her lips wrapped around it. Ass cream fresh from the source was surprisingly a rarity for Mandy; owning two bitches who both love the taste of each other's asses usually meant them hogging it. That creamy, delicious snack was a nice treat, one that was quickly gobbled up and, once it had been, Mandy attempted to return that cock from where it had come from. But, a disgruntled bystander made her presence felt.

"Hey, what the fuck? I'm ever gonna get a turn or what?" Jacy barked, peeking her head up over the edge of the bed.

"Y-Yeah, you w-will, when mine's done," Gigi teased, her partner growling in response; it's no wonder these two couldn't hold onto the tage belts for very long, they're constantly going at it!

"What's say you, Rox? Fancy a change of scenery?" Mandy asked before dropping a few loads of spit down for good measure, just to ensure that Roxanne's cock would be good and lubed for either hole.

Roxanne contemplated deeply in order to make the right decision. You could argue there really wasn't any way to go wrong here, either girl would've served just fine. Gigi's turn had gone on for a while now, and Jacy was definitely due for an ass fucking. But in turn, Roxy wasn't quite ready to give that ass up.

Having gotten lost in the thrill, she hadn't really stopped to soak in the feeling of officially becoming a top. Her heart started pumping at first, but all other insecurities had been checked at the metaphorical door and, as a result, Roxanne became far more comfortable with each passing second. Gigi still had plenty to give but, with that being said, Jacy was smoking hot as well, and raring to go. Ultimately, the thrill of topping a second woman one out, with a caveat.

"Jacy," Roxanne called out, similarly to how she'd done with Gigi before they began. "On the floor. I wanna take you from behind."

"Atta girl," Mandy complimented lovingly, of course referring to Roxy's desire to fuck Jacy in the proper "bitch position".

Roxanne began to navigate away from the bed but, before she did, she gave Gigi's thighs a few firm but playful slaps as she assured, "I'll be back, don't worry. Keep that hole loose for me."

"Yes, ma'am," Gigi agreed with a smile, and Roxy was on her way.

The Prodigy strutted over to her second target, whom Mandy had already joined, the former being petted by the latter. Roxanne wasted no time lining up her cock with Jacy's hole, not fully recovered from the pummeling it had taken a little while earlier. Just as Roxy was ready to start her second round though, Mandy interrupted again, offering some more "veteran advice."

"Not that she needs it, but now might be a good time to get a feel for rimming a bitch out," Mandy initially suggested, further arguing, "It's a very valuable skill to know, and Jacy works perfectly as a target, since I've already loosened her up earlier."

Roxanne shot her a dirty look. "Again, no thanks. I'm not sticking my tongue there, I'm not putting my fingers there. Basically, if it's not a toy, count me out. Got it?"

"Aw c'mon, Jacy really wants you to, don't you, Jacy?"

Jacy, honestly, was ready to side with Roxy on this one. After sitting idly by, watching as that selfish bitch partner of her's was experiencing the luxury of being the new champ's first fuck, Jacy was pretty set on joining that exclusive club herself. Getting rimmed would just delay that. But, Roxanne wasn't her mistress...Mandy was, and what Mandy wants, Mandy gets, as per usual. So, Jacy went along with it.