Turning Contest: A Friend of Amy's

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

"Most," Veronica agreed, thinking of the plethora of girls and women she'd seduced in this room.

Amy joked with foreshadowing words, "My makeover yesterday was life-changing."

"Really?" Brenda asked, not seeing any difference in Amy today other than perhaps the nylons... and the invitation to go out today.

"Yes," Amy said, not sure what more to say without giving away what likely lay ahead for her friend.

Veronica added, "Attraction in a woman is defined by many things: looks, brains and personality are all important, but fashion is the fourth aspect... put them all together and voila! you have the perfect woman."

Brenda joked, "Well I'm considered pretty brainy, so I got one out of four."

Veronica heard the insecurity spilling out of the cute girl and walked over to her, took her hands in hers and said, "Sweetheart, you are a beautiful young woman, and I'm not just talking about skin deep."

Brenda laughed softly, "No, I've looked in mirrors, and I'm not."

Amy added, feeling sorry for her somewhat friend, "Brenda, you are very beautiful."

Brenda could feel a warmth growing inside her at the complementary compliments arriving from two sources.

Veronica continued, "True beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and that begins with believing in yourself. In other words, if you behold yourself as beautiful then others will too."

"Why do you wear a garter belt and stockings beneath your clothes?" Amy asked, trying to help move the seduction along, while also helping with the unhidden point of this conversation.

"Are you wearing them now?" Veronica asked, as she raised Brenda's dress to reveal that indeed she was. "Well, you are a bit of an enigma, aren't you?"

"Usually just in my own mind," Brenda chuckled awkwardly, surprised to have her dress lifted up by a relative stranger, "although Amy called me one just before we came in."

"See? Corroboration! But in your mind is where it needs to start," Veronica nodded, as she dropped the dress back down. "The rest is about living it."

"Flaunt what you got," Amy added.

"Exactly," Veronica agreed, as she walked over to a rack of elegant clothing.

Amy went over to Brenda and said, "I wasn't just saying that, Brenda. I do think you're very pretty, and kind of sexy."

"Only kind of?" Brenda asked, now feeling flattered enough to fish for more. "You either think I'm sexy or you don't."

"Okay," Amy laughed, "You are sexy, especially when I discovered you dress a little kinky beneath your unflattering clothes."

"Are they actually unflattering?" Brenda asked, thinking they were just old school.

"They don't let anyone see the shape of your body," Amy explained. As she cupped her own breasts she added, "this push-up bra enhances my tits, which is why I wear it."

"I often don't even wear a bra," Brenda shrugged.

"So bohemian of you," Amy joked.

"It's my style," Brenda replied.

"Are you wearing one now?" Amy asked.

"Yes," Brenda nodded.

"Take off your dress," Amy ordered.

"W-w-what? W-w-why?" Brenda stammered, even though these were words she had fantasized hearing from Amy more than once.

"So you can try this on," Veronica answered, returning with a classic red dress.

"Oh my," Brenda said, gazing at the dress. It was gorgeous!

"You'll look amazing in it," Amy promised, as she moved her hands to Brenda's dress and began lifting it off over the stunned girl. Oh my god! Nobody's ever seen me in this sexy stuff before, not even my mom. And she's the one who gives it to me!

Veronica experienced her next surprise when she saw the sexy lingerie underneath this girl's clothing. It wasn't something she'd ever seen on a teen she was seducing. Lace bra and garter-belt and a thong! She was indeed a little minx behind her deceptive exterior... something she'd seen in many women, but never to this extent in a teen. "Wow sweetheart, you really are a complex number!"

Amy too was surprised by what she was seeing. This nerdish girl had been hiding an amazing body... and lingerie that was way sexier than anything she'd ever worn. She said as much, "Wow, your body is even hotter than mine."

"You're hilarious," Brenda deflected as she was being stared at by a pretty stranger and a hot cheerleader.

"I'm dead serious," Amy said, staring avidly at her nerdish friend.... who was suddenly not so nerdy after all.

"I'm not falling into the trap of comparing you two," Veronica said, impressed by the tight body of the nerd, "but you definitely have an amazingly ripe body. Besides, Amy already knows how beautiful I think she is."

"Thank you," the flattered Brenda responded.

"Yes, thank you," echoed Amy.

"And this lingerie is hot," Veronica added, as she moved around to check out her prey from behind.

"My mom owns a lingerie store and..." Brenda was explaining just as the older woman gasped.

"Oh my," Veronica gasped, as she saw the butt end of a butt plug barely held in place by the tiny thong.

Brenda's eyes went big at the realization that she'd just been caught with a plug in her ass... she'd totally forgotten she was wearing it, since she'd become so accustomed to wearing it whenever she was out, at school and even in church.

"Oh my what?" Amy wanted to know, as she hurried around and also spotted the surprise.

"Enigma is definitely the word for you," Amy said, as she moved back around Brenda.

She remained speechless as Amy suddenly stepped close and kissed her.

Veronica smiled, as her newest pet was already well on her way to becoming a great asset. Since she was still standing behind Brenda, she took hold of the teen's bra and unclasped it.

Brenda was stunned, as an intriguing situation suddenly exploded into an amazing one! From out of the blue Amy, her dream girl, was kissing her; but even more overwhelming was to feel her bra being unclasped by a relative stranger. This was really happening... this must be the prelude to something sexual... just like in the movies! She hesitated only briefly before returning the kiss... her first real kiss with anyone ever. It was tender and sweet... even as her entire body melted at the touch of both seductresses.

Veronica whispered, choosing to use a sweet seduction which was rare for her, she tended more towards aggression, but sensing this young girl was more than ripe for the picking, "You're so beautiful, Brenda."

Brenda was glowing with the compliments and melting under the touches as she felt the older woman's hands go to her ass. This time they were anything but innocent as they squeezed, probed and caressed her, and she loved it.

Veronica asked, "Have you ever been with a girl?"

Amy broke the kiss and Brenda admitted as she stared into Amy's eyes, "No, never."

"But you want to be, don't you, my pet?" Veronica whispered, as she gently pushed the toy deeper into the teen's ass to establish the hierarchy in a subtle, soft way.

"God yes," Brenda moaned, still not breaking eye contact with Amy, as she noticed the term 'pet', a term she'd encountered online that turned her on.

Amy asked, confident she knew the answer, "Have you ever fantasized about me?"

"Only like every day," Brenda answered, completely captivated by what was happening and deciding to just let it all out. This was no practical joke, this was her dreams being fulfilled.

"What do you fantasize?" Amy asked.

"I'm a little embarrassed to say," Brenda admitted, suddenly not so sure she did want to let it all out.

"There's no reason to be embarrassed, my pet," Veronica crooned, as she pulled the thong down the teen's legs. "There's no shame in fantasy."

Brenda summoned her resolve and blurted it right out: "You being my sex slave!" as she raised each foot to allow the older woman to finish removing her thong, but meanwhile totally astounding both Amy and Veronica! They both had, not surprisingly, assumed it would be the other way around.

"Really?" Amy asked.

"And all my bullies, too," Brenda added, feeling a rush of power at the stunned look on Amy's face, "I even bought a strap-on for the hopeful day."

"Well, you can fuck me anytime you want," Amy offered sincerely, before explaining (unnecessarily) to Veronica, "I like someone who knows what she wants."

Months of reading and watching porn, not to mention writing some herself, took over, and Brenda ordered, "Knees."

Amy felt a gush of wetness in her cunt at receiving such an order from the normally meek nerd. She obeyed, "Yes, Brenda."

"It's Mistress Brenda," Brenda corrected, briefly forgetting there was another person here until she felt the plug in her ass being plucked out.

"Yes, Mistress Brenda," Amy corrected herself, in awe of this suddenly strong-willed woman. She was also dying to taste her pussy. Would it taste different than Veronica's had yesterday?

Veronica had watched this taming in awe, watching a Mistress in the making, as she strolled over to the cupboard where she kept her wide range of toys. She removed her skirt and fastened her favourite strap-on in place as she continued to watch the lesbian teen act unfold.

Brenda glanced back and saw the older woman putting on a strap-on, hopefully to fuck her with, as she asked Amy using words she'd only ever read in stories before, "Do you want to eat my cunt, slut?"

Amy was stunned once again at being called a 'slut', this time by a girl she'd never before even heard swear. Who had actually apologized for saying 'darn' once. Yet, it turned her on and she admitted the truth, "Yes, Mistress Brenda, I'm dying to eat your cunt."

"You'll be my little cunt-licking slut whenever I beckon you?" Brenda continued the informal ritual, reveling in this realization of the power she had fantasized about for so long.

"I'm now your cheerleading cunt-munching sex slave twenty-four-seven," Amy answered, the cunt in front of her face so tantalizingly close that she had to have it, and somehow this just felt right. This domination was way more sexually stimulating than any sex she'd ever had with a boy. She knew then and there she was a lesbian. Not curious, not bi, but a complete cunt-craving lesbian.

"Get licking, slut," Brenda snapped, grabbing the back of her dream girl's head and pulling it into her cunt, a rush of adrenaline coursing through her. A rush so much more powerful than she'd ever imagined in any of her fantasies. The reality was she'd never thought this possible, yet now that it was happening she was going to ride the high.

Amy began licking, getting her own adrenaline rush at being used so roughly. She'd had no idea she was a submissive, and yet now after two days of obeying two Dommes, she knew what she was.

Veronica was watching in quiet pride when her phone buzzed.

She glanced at the phone and cursed to herself; Crystal had now gotten her third turn. This was getting ridiculous! How could she be tied for last? She'd expected some competition, but trailing a submissive like Carol was inexcusable; she needed to finish this turn herself, to at least get back into a tie for first.

Score at 1:42 PM on Saturday:

Scorecard:

Carol: 3

Crystal: 3

Jasmine: 3

Portia: 2

Veronica: 2

She walked over to the standing teen getting licked and said, "Want to get ass fucked?"

"Is a cheerleader eating my cunt?" Brenda asked rhetorically.

"Yes, she most certainly is," Veronica laughed as she cupped Brenda's tits. She then said, "Let's get into a more comfortable position."

"Yes, Mistress," Brenda said, wanting to make it clear she was happy to be a switch: both a mistress and a pet.

"Lie down on your back, Amy," Veronica ordered.

"Yes, Mistress," Amy responded, now having not one, but two mistresses and reveling in it.

"Brenda, straddle her face," Veronica ordered.

"A dream come true," Brenda said, having imagined straddling Amy's face every time she tutored her.

"Cum with a U?" Veronica joked, as she watched the nerdish teen straddle the drop-dead gorgeous cheerleader. Almost anyone would have assumed the blonde would be in charge, yet that was the power of sex, normal hierarchies could be completely turned upside down. Today the immutable social strata of high school had been flipped upside down in this very room.

"Definitely with a U," Brenda agreed, as she began rubbing her wet pussy on the cheerleader's face and against her extended eager tongue. She then lifted up a bit and ordered, "Beg for it, you sexy slut."

Amy, having just had Brenda's pussy rubbed all over her face as she tried eagerly to lick it, was desperate to eat that wet cunt, desperate to be used as a submissive slut, so she had no reluctance in begging, "Please use my face for your pleasure, Mistress. Make me your bimbo bitch."

"Good girl," Brenda smiled, as she lowered her cunt back down on her dream girl, just as she felt dominant hands grasping her hips.

"Lean forward, you sexy slut," Veronica ordered, as she positioned her strap-on cock at Brenda's inviting back door.

Brenda obeyed, as she felt Amy eagerly licking her pussy, her orgasm already building, and dying to feel what it was like to be fucked in the ass. It was one thing to have a butt plug in there, but this was a whole new level of involvement, which was enhanced by the tongue busily licking her pussy. She then became the one begging, even as she felt a cock head poking at her asshole, "Please fuck my asshole, Mistress. Fuck your slut good!"

"As you wish," Veronica smiled, as she pushed herself into a four-way tie for first in the competition.

"Ohhhhhhh," Brenda moaned, as a cock filled her ass while her pussy was still being ravished by Amy's eager tongue.

Amy hungrily licked Brenda's tangy twat, loving the submissive act and loving the tantalizing taste.

Veronica began fucking the until-moments-ago anal virgin as Brenda moaned loudly, the pleasure now swarming through her being so much more amazing than her many masturbation nights, "Oh, God!"

"You're such a sexy ass slut," Veronica purred, rubbing the teen's back sensuously and even scratching it a bit as she slowly fucked her.

"So good," Brenda whimpered, her orgasm already about to erupt.

"Come, my ass slut," Veronica ordered, always knowing when a girl was close to coming.

"Oh yes, fuck me Mistress," Brenda moaned, "slam-fuck my asshole."

Veronica began slamming into the teen, knowing that would make the bubble burst and in only a few strokes, Brenda was screaming, perhaps even loud enough to be heard by the customers in the store, "Fuck! Oh fuck! Oh fuck meeeee!"

Amy's face was suddenly getting coated with cunt cum and she eagerly lapped up as much as she could, it being her new favourite adult beverage.

Veronica kept slamming into the teen's tight ass for another minute, until Brenda collapsed forward and the cock slipped out of her ass. Wanting an orgasm herself, she cast aside the harness and said, as she hopped onto a desk, flipping her heels off, "Both of you come and worship my feet."

Brenda weakly climbed off Amy and crawled over to her Mistress; Amy's face was wet with the gleam of cunt cum as she rolled off her back, and also crawled to her Mistress.

Both girls massaged her feet with their hands and tongues for a couple of minutes as Veronica grabbed her phone and typed in an update before ordering, "Slut Brenda, come and taste your first cunt."

"Yes, Mistress," Brenda obeyed happily, having been staring at the inviting cunt constantly while she worshipped the nylon-clad foot. Amy was jealous of Brenda as she continued massaging the foot while watching Brenda position herself between their Mistress's legs.

"Good girl," Veronica moaned, as the teen began licking and she snapped a picture of her newest conquest before she looked at her phone to add her latest conquest to see that... oh no!... Portia had also added a third turn just thirteen minutes ago!

Score at 1:45 PM on Saturday:

Scorecard:

Carol: 3

Crystal: 3

Jasmine: 3

Portia: 3

Veronica: 2

She sighed as she added hers to the scoreboard which was now a frustrating five-way tie for first place.

Score at 1:58 PM on Saturday:

Scorecard:

Carol: 3

Crystal: 3

Jasmine: 3

Portia: 3

Veronica: 3

Oblivious to her Mistress's dilemma, Brenda pondered that she had long fantasized licking a pussy, and now that she was doing it, she knew she was indeed bi and perhaps even a lesbian.

Veronica moaned in pleasure but also sighed in simultaneous frustration as she was now tied for first, but still at the bottom of the list... stupid 'V' first name. She needed to seduce another conquest to take the lead if someone else didn't beat her to it, but first she needed an orgasm. She grabbed the back of the rookie licker's head and guided it deeper into her box.

Ten minutes later Veronica had orgasmed, and Brenda was given a red dress. Yes, the gorgeous one.

The final surprise of the turn was what happened as the two teens left: they were holding hands. Something they would do again Monday morning at school, shocking both students and teachers... Amy and Brenda became an adorable egalitarian lesbian couple at school and had a Mistress-pet relationship in the bedroom. And in the locker room, the bathroom and even Mrs. Walker's classroom... with her present, naked and cheering them on, no less!

Veronica smiled at her part in forming what could turn out to be a lifetime relationship... funny how crazy love and lust could be.

She then perused the store, wondering where pet number four might be found.

THE END

Coming next: Turning Contest: A Girl Guide's Sis

12
Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
14 Comments
4chuckssite4chuckssite10 months ago

599. Threesomes are fun and they bring out many possibilities for continuing relationships. Perhaps in Mrs. Walker’s classroom.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 5 years ago
Amy, Amy, Everywhere!

Great work and I keep loving this series! (Can't wait to read today's entry, as that's what led me to know I'd missed this one.)

One minor detail…there are actually TWO girls named Amy in play, and I thought this was going to be about the other one. (Amanda's friend in the Carol-seduces-Tabitha-at-the-beach-changing-room chapter; Amanda had always wanted to suck Amy's tits, she says, but Amy only played lookout.) Clearly, the way to solve this is with some hot Amy-on-Amy action.

Off to the next! (Carol, Tabitha, and Daphne in the movie theater? No, it's a girl scout's sister…which is a pity as that seems to preclude the "underage incest" possibility. Oh, well…I bet it's still hot.)

agamotto1313agamotto1313about 5 years ago
A twist of fate

Have a pre-op mtf who thinks she likes guys only get caught in Veronica's little web.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 5 years ago
Good

You should do a gay version of turning contest

AnonymousAnonymousabout 5 years ago
Meh, spice it up

This was not a bad story, you really don't write bad stories, but you have let it go so long, and many of the turns seem the same, so it has sort of lost its punch. I say raise the stakes. All the moms save one own their daughters and the winner gets them all. I say, in a desperation move to win, one of them turns someone close to one of the others unexpectedly, and it is not seen favorably. Maybe a mother, sister, bff, minister's wife, someone that the other contestant wouldn't like. A heated but brief exchange ends in a double or nothing bet. There are no restrictions on who may be turned, and the winner not only gets the daughters for the weekend, but the other four contestants as well. Perhaps humiliating them by having them serve the daughters. How about it? No turns barred double or nothing.

Show More
Share this Story

Similar Stories

Turning Contest: A Beautiful Blonde Teen seductress MILF molests and takes teen in clothing shop.in Lesbian Sex
Turning Contest: A Girl Guide's Sis 18-year-old selling cookies for her younger sis is seduced.in Lesbian Sex
Straight Bride Seduced Bride is gradually seduced by fiancé's lesbian sister. in Lesbian Sex
MILF TURNS: Daughter's Best Friend Divorced horny MILF explores her lesbian side with teenager.in Lesbian Sex
My Ex-Boyfriend's Hot Mom Coed gets revenge on cheating boyfriend in a surprising way.in Lesbian Sex
More Stories