All Comments on 'Ex Gratis'

by Soppho

Sort by:
  • 4 Comments
buttersbuttersabout 13 years ago
i like this...

its layout breaks and slows the read, making me take my time over each image. also, your sound-work feels more solidly connected so, whilst i am made to take my time reading, the sound also carries me on to the next phrasing.

i do have small reservations towards its end, though:

To die still and not later

Searching without answer

Ethereal perfume

Refuge and beginning

In the vertical howling

Response to my wondering

it feels a more natural end to the piece with 'to die, still' but i get that you want to include the searching thing. i would suggest that you could end this with 'to die, still, in the vertical howling' and scrap the rest as unnecessary, making an ending with punch: your 'in the vertical howling' is very very strong!

buttersbuttersabout 13 years ago
one other thing...

i'm not sure this benefits from the capital letters starting each line; your word-placing and line-breaks define those starter words well enough imo. :) you don't need a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

WilliamButlerYeatsWilliamButlerYeatsabout 13 years ago
lines should be elongated

I'm a fan of short lines as long as it doesn't sound choppy. This poem would benefit from the ten plus syllabic line. 'earthly paradise' is a little dated, but it's a good poem nonetheless.

twelveoonetwelveooneabout 13 years ago
Aye

Billy B. three comments all on the same person, that raises an eye. "Saline sheets" is nice. The rest of it looks pretty much stock, some overreaching "Ethereal perfume". In the greater context of things this is a killer line

"Response to my wondering"

I gave you a 5, don't take it too serious.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous