Tom & Sue & John & Debbie Ch. 14

"Jimmy went to work on finding a suitable guest for our threesome and last Thursday, he told me, 'he'd found a couple guys that might just be the ticket for our threesome.'

"Jimmy set it up for us to go out with a couple of his wrestling teammates and their dates last Saturday night. According to Jimmy, his teammates' dates were a 'shoo-in,' so I'd get a glimpse of what each of them had to offer, and in turn, they'd get more than an eyeful while Jimmy and me got it on—perhaps spurring their interest in becoming a guest in our devil's threesome—that is, if we chose to invite one of them."

Cathy laughed, "Shit, after prom night I certainly wasn't bashful about making love with Jimmy in front of other couples, so it didn't matter to me if we had an audience or not!

"After dinner, a movie and dancing at the 'Shoe we all drove out to the lake. The guys parked next to each other on this little bluff overlooking the lake.

"The full moon was shining bright, like the sun without a cloud in the sky. The stars were bright and twinkling, you know star light, star bright, twinkle, twinkle little star... But, for some reason, no one seemed interested in stargazing this first September Saturday night!

"The guys got the blankets out of the trunks and laid them on the ground side by side. Everyone started making out like crazy. We were getting really worked up, and that familiar musky smell of three horny pussies was so thick in the air, you could cut it with a knife!

"We were all butt naked lying next to each on this grassy knoll, getting ready to fuck when I got more than just a peek at Jimmy's two teammates' cocks fully erect and ready for action! I thought to myself, 'Gee, either one of these guys would fit the bill very nicely as our guest in the devil's threesome. Both were about the size of Tom and John, and that is exactly what I was hoping for—a bigger cock than Jimmy's, but not something soo soo big that it would split me in half!!' Of course, Jimmy would have the last say..."

Angie interrupted Cathy, "So, Cathy tell me who were they? How big were their 'fuck muscles?' Since there were two guys who did y'all pick?"

Cathy laughed at Angie, "Okay, its Ryder and Andy. Y'all met'em last night at the 'Shoe."

Angie commented, "I don't know what those studs have hanging between their legs, but both of those guys are damn good looking, that's for sure—like a couple Hollywood movie stars!

"I'm beginning to figure out why those two studs didn't push the issue last night at the Horseshoe with Misti and Beverly. It seems both of those studs already had their sights set on someone way better than the two virgin soccer players who were dreaming about Tom and Misti's brother, Bobby. And, one of those studs was going to get a 'once in a lifetime opportunity' for his 'fuck muscle' to go where no other cock at ever been—right Cathy?"

Cathy smiled at Angie while she continued, "Jimmy was standing up, butt naked, getting his condom out of his billfold, when he noticed me glancing toward his teammates. Both were standing up butt naked, opening their condom packets.

"Jimmy winked and smiled down at me, dropping to his knees, moving slightly to the side so I could get a better view of what our 'potential guests' had to offer while he opened the condom packet and rolled the ultra-thin Trojan on his cock.

"I glanced first in Andy's direction while he was rolling the condom on his hard cock. Andy's cock looked to be longer than Tom's, give or take a bit—maybe just a tad shorter than John's. Andy's bulging manhood appeared to be not quite as thick as either John or Tom. I'd guess Andy to be right around six inches in the girth—give or take, but still an inch or so bigger than Jimmy!

"Andy's cock was topped off similar to John's with a pale, bluish, perhaps even a light purplish colored thick mushroom-shaped head flaring at the rim—definitely bigger around than his shaft! It looked as if his cock was not quite two inches wide with protruding veins from the base to just below the rim. His pubes were this sexy golden color and his balls looked to be much bigger than Jimmy's while they were hanging low in his nut sack.

"I was just a bit too far away from Andy to get a more detailed look at his cock before he rolled the condom in place and rammed his cock into his Zeta date's pussy, causing her to let out a whimper and groan, 'OH... OH... UH HUH... OHHH.' The way the Zeta moaned I thought perhaps I'd misjudged the size of Andy's cock!

"Ryder, on the other hand, was just a few feet away and I got a very good look at his cock. Ryder's cock looked to be definitely longer than John's and just as thick. Ryder's cock was almost identical to Tom's except much longer—perhaps an inch or maybe a tad more.

"Ryder's cock was topped with a near perfect sexy pink colored thick helmet shaped head and a pronounced 'V' shape underneath. His cock flared nicely at the rim, but not quite as flaring as Andy's or John's. The veins in his shaft were definitely not as protruding as Andy's veins, but his shaft was wider, looking to be two full inches. His pubes were this really sexy strawberry blonde, a light red color with balls looking to be the size of John's as they dangled low and free in his scrotum.

"Both Ryder and Andy's cock were much longer, thicker and wider than Jimmy's cock with heads superior to Jimmy's spear-shaped head which was just a bit thinner than his shaft.

"Angie has been commenting John's cock was 7-1/2 inches with like a 6-1/4 inch girth or so—well, if that's the case, I would have guessed Ryder's to be somewhere around 8 inches in length, give or take a bit with a girth equal to John and Tom—something over six inches.

"Anyway, Ryder noticed me glancing, well... I was actually gawking, marveling at the size of his cock while he was rolling his condom on. He gave me a quick cheeky wink and a smile before he rammed his cock its full length into his Theta date's pussy causing her to cry out in a bit of pain, 'OW! OH FUCK!'

"Once Ryder sunk his cock into his Theta date's pussy, I looked Jimmy in the eye and whispered, 'I'm done looking Hon, go ahead and fuck me now.'

"Jimmy quickly buried his six-ish inch cock its full length inside my pussy with one thrust to the hilt. His five-ish inch girth stretching my pussy walls, his spear shaped head sliding across my G-spot, his pubic bone rubbing against my clit with each slow deep stroke—his cock was caressing my pussy's G-spot building up to that magical moment.

"Everyone was fucking like crazy. Moaning and groaning, Ryder with his Theta, Andy with his Zeta and of course, me and Jimmy.

"We were the last to finish so we had ourselves quite the audience! I was twisting and squirming, clawing Jimmy's back with my nails, my legs were wrapped tightly around his waist, my heels dug into his ass, my ankles were locked, giving me more leverage to meet each of Jimmy's thrusts with an upward one of my own, impaling myself on his dick, wanting to get him even deeper inside me when I cried out, 'Don't stop Hon, I'm about to cum... faster... faster... OH YESSS...'

"We were in sync and really getting it on! Jimmy was giving me everything he had, thrusting faster and faster until that magical moment when I moaned, 'OH GOD... I'M CUMMING... I'M CUMMING!' My pussy clamped down on Jimmy's cock like a set of 'gator jaws' and I really let loose with some uncontrollable noisy sex as the orgasm was rippling throughout my body.

"Jimmy was grunting louder and louder, he was breathing short gasping pants, his cock was throbbing, pulsating, and he was moaning, 'UHHH... SQUEEZE ME TIGHTER HON, OH FUCK... YES... DON'T STOP... UHHH!'

"My pussy kept clamping down on Jimmy's cock—tightening, releasing, and tightening again while Jimmy thrust his cock in, out and in again. His cock got even harder, jerking and twitching, his thrusting sped up, his balls were tight in his sack when he let out one last cry, 'SQUEEZE ME TIGHTER HON... OH YESS... I'M GONNA SHOOT... SQUEEZE ME... I'M ABOUT TO CUM... I'M GONNA... OHH... AH...,' shooting forth his semen into the confines of the Trojan ultra-thin.

"Jimmy pumped his cock, spurting several times before eventually just oozing and dribbling until his balls went dry.

"Jimmy and I finally finished and after a brief recovery period we began to get dressed.

"I noticed Ryder eyeing me over when I stood up just a few feet away in my birthday suit. My boobs were relaxed and before I pulled my T-shirt over my braless 36C's, I smiled a sexy smile while shakin' my boobs in his direction. Ryder returned my sexy smile with one of his own.

"I knew I had Ryder's full attention, so I made sure he got more than a glimpse of my shaved pussy. I reached down slowly, very slowly, wiggling like a snake, rolling my hips in his direction as I pulled my panties up over my thighs and up to my waist.

"I pulled my shorts up, gave him a quick wink, a flirty smile, turning my back to him, wiggling my ass in his direction one last time.

"For some reason, I felt a physical attraction already existing between Ryder and me, and while looking back over my shoulder, I gave him another wink as Jimmy and I got into his Chevy.

"Once inside the Chevy, Jimmy asked me, 'Hon, what do you think about Ryder or Andy for the threesome?'

"I smiled a 'satisfied smile', 'HON, EITHER ONE WILL WORK OUT JUST FINE!'

"Jimmy grinned, 'I kind of thought you'd like'em! They're roommates and were high school teammates at North Central—both were State Champions. Ryder won the 160-pound weight class and Andy the 152-pound class. Coach wants Ryder to wrestle 165 and Andy 155 this season.

"I noticed them the first day of practice in the shower stalls. After practice I started chatting quite a bit with them in the dorm, dining hall, before and after practice—you know, checking them out and getting to know them. Let me see what I can hook up with them. You have a preference?'

"I grinned, 'I guess it'd be Ryder, but Hon, you pick, it doesn't really matter to me.'

"Jimmy said, 'Okay Hon, but what if I can't pick between them? Both are super great guys with great looks. Both are built like freaking Greek Gods, smart, athletic, and as you've noticed are very well hung when it comes to their manhood.

"'Hon, last but not least, one important characteristic I wanted to make sure our guest would possess was a high degree of class—you know, an individual who is poised, graceful, mature, excellent self- control, not obnoxious, disrespectful or offensive but rather inoffensive.

"'Hon, I can assure you, both Ryder and Andy handle themselves with a lot of class, and either would fit the bill for the type of guy I'd want to pick for you in our devil's threesome. So, if I can't choose, you'll have to choose unless you'd be okay with both Ryder and Andy in a foursome instead of a threesome—Hon, you'll have to make that choice.

"'The only other alternative would be if neither of us can make a choice between Ryder and Andy and you didn't want to do three guys, well, I could just be a bystander making sure the M-F-M goes according to our boundaries.'

"I just smiled at Jimmy, 'No way Hon! I want you to be a player too! After all, you're the guy I'm going to marry! I wouldn't want to have an M-F-M without you! Let's just make a choice between Ryder and Andy, even if we have to flip a coin. I gave Jimmy a nice long sexy juicy French kiss before we drove away."

Angie giggled, "Shit girl, sounds like those studs are hung pretty dang good! I mean to be equal to or a tad bigger than John's big cock... Well, that's definitely a piece of swinging meat! I know for a fact, John was a solid 7-1/2, and Tom-boy was every bit a good seven, maybe even a tad more at times with the same girth and width as John.

I was pissed at Angie once again for again bringing up Tom and glared an 'evil eye' in her direction with my Italian eyes!

Angie knew she'd pissed me off again, but didn't let it bother her while she continued, "Cathy, you're really serious about going all out and doing the M-F-M threesome, aren't you? So who did y'all choose? Or, are you going to do all three guys in an M-M-M-F? Which is it going to be?"

Cathy chuckled, "I guess it was Monday after wrestling practice when Jimmy finally dropped some hints to both Ryder and Andy that we were interested in doing a devil's threesome—inviting one of them to join us as our guest.

"Jimmy called me later that night and told me when he asked, 'Would either of you guys care to join Cathy and me as the guest in a devil's threesome?'

"Jimmy couldn't keep from laughing when he said, 'Both Ryder and Andy went ape-shit, like a couple kids at Christmas time—especially Ryder when they answered at the same time, 'OH FUCK YES! SHIT JIMBO, ARE YOU SERIOUS? OR ARE YOU JUST FUCKING WITH US?'

"Jimmy was still laughing, 'Hon, I was grinning ear to ear when I told them, 'No kidding guys, it's the real deal—Cat wants to do a devil's threesome, so we're looking for a classy sort of guy to be our guest and both of you guys 'hit the bull's eye!'

"Jimmy told both of them, 'I'll have to pick one of you guys for the threesome, it'll come down Homecoming night, Cat's nineteenth birthday, and after it's over and done, what happens in the motel... stays there.'

"Jimmy said, 'Ryder immediately replied, 'No problem Jimbo, Cathy is a foxy classy chick, one to be pampered and pleasured not be treated like a slut. I'll damn sure play by your rules and she'll be treated like a Princess!

"'Jimbo, if you pick me, I'll make sure all of Cathy's wishes for doing an M-F-M all come true. I'll be her sex slave and beckon to her every command! Shit, I can't fucking believe this—a chance to fuck a hottie like Cathy in a devil's threesome—unbelievable!!'

"'Andy chimed in, 'I agree with everything Ryder has said. Trust me, we'll both treat her like the goddess she is and it'd be a blessing from up above if you pick me to be the guest!'

"Jimmy said, 'Hon, both of these guys think you hung the moon and it makes me feel really good deep inside that classy guys like Ryder and Andy think so much of my special girl. It'll be a hard choice, but I'll have to pick either Ryder or Andy Wednesday after practice.'

"We hung up with our traditional, 'I love you!'

"After Jimmy told me what Ryder and Andy had said about me I was so excited—I had that sudden 'swoosh' feeling in my stomach, you know kind of like when you are driving down a road and unexpectedly hit that deep dip!

"I was so turned on by the prospects of Ryder or Andy being our guest in the devil's M-F-M, I thought I was going to orgasm right then and there!

"Ryder would be the perfect guest. He looks like a Hollywood movie star—strong, lean muscular built, six-pack abs with muscles of steel rippling throughout his 5'10", 165-pound athletic frame. Flaming red hair, just a speck of sexy looking freckles under those very sexy hazel eyes, not to mention those strawberry blonde pubes. Big masculine looking balls and equipped with the biggest cock I'd ever seen! Ryder was most definitely someone I wanted to fuck and I was already physically attracted to him!

"Seriously though, if Jimmy chose Andy I wouldn't be all that disappointed! Andy was a 'lady-killer' with his good looks, blonde hair, sexy blue eyes, powerful muscles rippling throughout his rock-hard, 5'11", 155-pound athletic body. Sexy golden pubes, equipped with a set of balls, definitely much bigger than Jimmy's and a cock that was longer than Tom's, just maybe a tad short of rivaling John's massive manhood! Make no mistake about it, Andy was a STUD, one of the sexist guys I could ever hope for to be our threesome guest. I'd fuck Andy PDQ, and never give it a second thought if Jimmy ended up choosing Andy!

"Butterflies were dancing in my stomach all day Wednesday. I was a nervous wreck in class, at practice and then Wednesday night when we were all at the library. I couldn't keep my mind from wandering—who did Jimmy pick for our threesome—was it going to Ryder or Andy? Who would be fulfilling my fantasy, my desire for a strange big cock to fuck me in our M-F-M?

"I guess it was maybe thirty minutes or so after we all got back from the library that Jimmy called me and told me, 'both Ryder and Andy were so ecstatic about the possibilities of being the guest in our threesome that I couldn't choose between them. They both kept driving me up a wall all day wanting to know if I'd made a choice yet—who was going to get to be our guest in the devil's threesome!'

"Jimmy sighed, 'I don't want to hurt anyone's feelings Hon, and since this is for you, I guess it'll be up to you to choose unless you'd want to do the foursome instead of the devil's threesome. That way, I don't have to pick between Ryder and Andy.'

"I thought about it for a second or two... Then I told Jimmy, 'In all fairness, I really can't pick between them either, although I do feel a physical attraction toward Ryder.

"I never thought about doing three guys in an M-M-M-F, but I guess I could. I really only wanted you and one more. So if I did three guys at once, that'd mean I'd be in a 'gang bang' wouldn't it? Hon, I don't think I can handle being thought as 'the girl' that got gang banged by Ryder, Andy, and you!

"Jimmy snapped at me, 'Hell no, and don't you dare think of it that way! Both Ryder and Andy are class acts and they wouldn't dare treat you like a slut in a gang bang! If they try anything outside our boundaries I'll kick their ass!'"

Cathy smiled, "I told Jimmy, 'Go ahead Hon and tell them they are both invited and we'll be doing a foursome for my birthday on Homecoming night!'

"Jimmy called back a few minutes later and told me, 'It's all set up for Homecoming weekend. Ryder and Andy went ballistic, absolutely haywire over both of them being selected to be our guest in the M-M-M-F and are going to pop for the hotel bill, champagne, room service, and anything else we might need for Homecoming weekend! Ryder has already made reservations for Friday and Saturday nights at that ritzy Plaza Hotel, booking the honeymoon suite. Both Ryder and Andy wanted you to be treated like the Queen of England.'

"I asked Jimmy, 'Whose idea was it for the M-M-M-F to be two nights instead of one?'

"Jimmy replied, 'Ryder suggested it, and after giving it some thought, I agreed with him.

"'Friday night we'd have all the Homecoming events, so that would cut into our foursome time, and then on Saturday afternoon it's the Homecoming game. The dance is Saturday night and you'll be getting all dolled up so that would limit our foursome time significantly. I just didn't think there was going to be enough time to do a M-M-M-F the right way if we limited it to Homecoming night—especially since it was going to be a once in a lifetime experience for you.'

"I replied, 'Okay Hon, whatever you think is okay with me.'"

Angie shouted, "OH MY SWEET JESUS! Shit Honey, those studs must really want a piece of your pussy! The Plaza is the most expensive hotel around these parts and they've booked the honeymoon suite for two nights! I've never known anyone who has ever stayed at the Plaza, much less in the honeymoon suite!"

Jamie smiled, "Angie, Kyle and I spent the night at the Plaza celebrating our five-month anniversary, but we only had a deluxe room.

Jamie looked at me, "I do know someone who was supposed to have stayed at the Plaza in the honeymoon suite celebrating their engagement, but she let a one night stand interfere with her better judgment, got hard-headed and called it off—right Sue?"

I just hung my head without saying a word as tears began to well in my eyes.

Nancy responded to Jamie, "Listen y'all, I can understand why Sue didn't accept Tom's proposal and broke up with him, well at least for the time being anyway. I don't know all the 'nitty gritty' yet, but Sue loved Tom with all her heart and then he goes and cheats on her first with Sally and then with Debbie, her BFF, while she is away playing summer league or whatever..."