Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.
You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.
Click here
Yeah. They were right. You really do need to exercise more.
Eventually, the three of you make it back to the apartment building, but the girls decide to go ahead of you, as the stairs are a bigger struggle for you than you thought it would be. Once you make it back to your apartment, you're immediately yanked by Cassie into the common bathroom.
"Stella took the bathroom in your room to shower. So, I thought we could share one here." Cassie tells you with a curious lip bite, only covering herself up with a towel. In all honesty, you can barely move a muscle anymore, so fucking doesn't seem like a possibility right now. But once Cassie's towel comes off, the main muscle in your pants doesn't seem to care.
You try to take off your hoodie but your aching back muscles and shoulders are having trouble raising it over your head, and you release pained grunts as you struggle to take it off. Cassie just laughs and tells you to raise your arms, as she takes the hoodie off for you.
"That was a light full body workout for Stella and I. I didn't think it was this bad." Cassie tells you. "Want me to give you a massage while we share a bath instead?"
You wouldn't say no to that, so you nod to answer that you'd very much enjoy her suggestion. She smiles and takes off your pants and underwear, pulling them down, for you. She's kneeling in front of your semi-erect dick and asks if she should massage that area first.
"Let's save that for the ending" you jokingly say, and she giggles before she stands up to fill the bathtub with water.
You slip out of your shoes and let out an old-man grunt as you sit down on the edge of the bathtub to try and take off your socks. Your pained noises and barely being able to raise your legs enough for your hands to reach your foot is making you incredibly embarrassed, as your new girlfriend just watches your struggle with a fascinated smile.
"You're so hot right now." Cassie tells you. You'd think she's joking, but her tone and her look is actually one of arousal; not one, of embarrassment for you or even cringing at you for being such an old man right now.
She eventually helps you take off your socks, and now you're both fully naked. She tells you to get on the tub and asks you to scoot to the middle once you're inside. She takes the spot behind you and washes your back. She massages your back muscles as well as your shoulders before planting kisses on the spots she massaged. She moans every once in a while as the extended touching is probably giving her pleasure also.
Her massage and kisses are actually starting to make you feel relaxed and not notice the muscle and joint pains that plagued you earlier... probably because all the blood is going to your dick.
As Cassie finishes up her massage and washing your back, shoulders, and arms; she gives you a tight hug from behind, pressing her breasts near the small of your back. She washes your chest area from behind, and slowly goes lower and lower, eventually taking a grip of your erect dick. She gives a satisfied moan as she firmly wraps her hand around your cock.
She continues to plant kisses on the back of your neck as she starts stroking your cock under the water. Each stroke is matched by her breasts sliding on your back. You move your hand back towards her crotch area to start playing with her pussy as well. She adjusts her position to give your fingers better access to her entrance, and you proceed to match her pace in strokes with your fingering. Your arm gets tired quickly though, and she instead just grinds and rides your still fingers under the tub. She plants kisses and gentle bites on the back of your neck as her pace for her handjob increases, which makes you get closer to climax.
Not wanting to swim in your own cum, you tell her you're close and with a pained grunt, stand up on the tub and turn around to face her. She continues where she left off, and even increases the pace of her handjob. She starts using both her hands now, as one hand works the head while the other works the base. You warn her you're getting close and she sticks her tongue out in response.
"Cum for me. I want your cum. I want it all on my tongue." The sudden dirty talk from Cassie is taking you further to the edge as her innocent girl facade is shattered by her begging for your cum. She continues to stroke your dick, and her mouth is so close to it now that you can feel her hot breath hitting the tip.
"Don't hold back Daddy. Cum for me. Cum for me Daddy!" Cassie calling you 'Daddy' takes you over the edge and you spurt your cum all over her tongue, some of it even hitting her face. She swallows it all and sticks her tongue out again to show you all of it went down her throat. She wipes some of the cum away from her cheek and forehead with her hand and laps that up too.
"You really like it when I call you Daddy, huh?"
CHAPTER 39.1
What happens next?
Cassie gives you a shower
"You really like it when I call you Daddy, huh?" Cassie asks you with a happy smile on her face.
"I'd prefer if you start calling me Jay instead of Mr. Craig, to be honest. I'll start to feel old if my girlfriend doesn't even call me by my name." You tell her to dodge the question, not wanting to admit that you might have discovered a 'Daddy' fetish because of her and Tanya calling you something to that effect.
"I will eventually... Jay. I'm just not used to it yet. I'm just so used to calling you Mr. Craig." she admits. You don't push the issue any further as she doesn't seem to have noticed that you dodged her question entirely.
"Get up, it's your turn now" you tell her, licking your lips.
"Wait" Cassie tells you before getting out of the tub and towards the faucet. She's brushing her teeth. She's doing it at an exaggerated level too. She looks towards you as she brushes her tongue with the back of her toothbrush. Meanwhile, you're just standing inside of the tub watching your naked girlfriend as she cleans her mouth.
Once she's done, she goes back to the tub with you and says, "No excuses this time."
"Kiss me." Cassie commands you. You jokingly kiss her on the cheek. "Mr. Craig!" Cassie reacts in annoyance. You kiss her other cheek now.
"Say my name first" you tease her.
"Jay~" she says in an 'annoyed at how horny she is' kind of way.
You finally stop teasing her and cup her cheek with your palm, and caress it with your thumb. You give her the slow passionate kiss she's been yearning for since this morning. You both savor the moment, building up each other's lust for one another as your lips don't break away from each other. She finally releases a moan, and you know it's time to take things up a notch.
Your kiss lingers for a few more seconds, as both of you breathe in, before proceeding to make out furiously. Your hands explore each other's bodies not sure where to touch or what to squeeze as you both lose yourselves in the lust you've built up moments ago. Cassie decides to wrap her leg around yours, and rub her pussy along your wet thigh, while continuing to wrestle your tongue with hers. You both continue like this until Cassie can't hold on any further and has a mini orgasm, her leg wrapping around yours even tighter as she rides the wave of that short climax by rubbing her clit on your thigh even more.
You finally decide that you'll continue what you started earlier and play with her pussy with your fingers. You break away from the kiss and start planting small kisses on her neck and collarbone as you rub her wet pussy with your fingers. The mix of the bathwater and her own juices have made her pussy so slick, rubbing your fingers back and forth on her clit has made your motions much quicker.
Your mouth makes its way downward along her torso, sucking her nipples briefly before planting kisses on her belly, licking the insides of her innie belly button, and stopping just short of above her pubic area where your fingers are inside her pussy now.
You look up to her and her eyes are closed, taking in the feeling of your fingers inside her pussy which are just sucking in your fingers inside their warm walls. "Lean back on the wall" you tell her, which she does. Now that her body has better support, you lift one of her legs over your shoulder and start licking her clit in earnest.
You alternate between flicking and swirling your tongue around her clit, before sucking on it, while your fingers keep a steady pace penetrating in and out of her pussy. Cassie's leg wraps around the back of your head and her hand grips you by your hair, not giving you a chance to stop until she cums.
You were already out of breath from the workout earlier this morning, but Cassie's leg wrapping around your head and her hand forcing your face deeper into her pussy almost feels like a triangle choke. The lack of oxygen pumps you with more adrenaline, making you furiously use three fingers to fuck her wet slit, as your mouth alternates between sucking and flicking her exposed clit.
"Yes! Yes! I'm almost there!" Cassie exclaims, gripping your hair even tighter. You look up at her momentarily as her boobs jiggle from her grinding motions on your mouth. Her free hand moving from holding on to the back wall to groping her own breast to messing with her own hair, the sheer amount of pleasure making her body unsure how to react. She has her eyes closed, and you can only imagine what she's fantasizing about inside her head.
"Yes! Don't Stop! Yes! It's so good!" she starts shouting even louder in between deep breaths. You can feel she's close, and without any option to stop due to her holding you in place with her leg, you ignore whatever muscle pain you feel in your arms as you pump your fingers even faster in and out of her pussy.
Your fingers feel it, her inner walls just wrapping around them and sucking them in even deeper inside her, before she releases it all on your face in a squirting orgasm.
Time stands still at this moment as you can feel the fluid hit your face in slow motion before you hear a knock on the door of the bathroom.
"Cass, I need to get my toothbrush. Can I come in?" Stella asks from outside.
With your mouth preoccupied and Cassie not really in this dimension right now with her intense orgasm, you couldn't help but fear the disaster about to happen as Cassie shouts...
"~YES!~"
The bathroom door opens.
...
...
"AAAAAAAAAAAAH!!"
CHAPTER 40.1
What happens next?
A few days later
It's been a couple of days since the shower incident happened last Monday. Stella was not pleased with you and Cassie breaking the established 'House Rules' when the two of you decided to have fun in the bathroom outside the agreed upon afternoon hours.
Stella's fury wasn't even the worst part about that incident though. As a result of Stella's scream of bloody murder, combined with yours and Cassie's reactionary screams, Mrs. O'Brien (resident gossipmonger of the building) called the cops on your apartment. The three of you had to explain to two officers what happened and they couldn't help but laugh at the situation.
Stella and Cassie had a lengthy talk about the consequences of breaking that one particular 'House Rule' to prevent further incidents. You were excluded from said talk as Stella didn't even want to look at you after the incident — and you don't blame her. Stella had all the leverage and decided that you and Cassie should keep it in your pants for the rest of the week so that both of your "horny little minds can calm the fuck down", her words. In addition, Cassie has to stay in Stella's room at night to prevent any more funny business.
Come Monday evening, you had a conversation with Tanya after she got back from work, and you asked her to have dinner on Friday. Tanya seemed excited for the dinner date, which gave you some idea as to where she's leaning in terms of seeing you as a romantic partner. So you wonder even more what it is she's confused about.
...
Last Tuesday, you joined the girls for their morning run as part of the 'House Rule' on exercising. You also went shopping with them afterwards so you could buy some new gym clothes, since Stella insisted you stop looking like you're cosplaying Rocky every time you work out with them, and some dresses for them for when they go out on Friday.
Cassie surprised you more and more with how bold she can get, as she really wanted to get naughty with you in the changing room. You reluctantly, but eventually, talked her down from it, and warned her that Stella might just stay with her grandparents if the two of you annoyed her any further with your sexcapades. Stella didn't even want to show you the dress she bought because, as she explains it, you've temporarily lost your dad privileges to comment on what she wears when she saw you eating out her roommate. So, yeah, best not to infuriate her further.
...
As for yesterday, you went back to the gym and the girls had you work out with Brooke instead, so that they can focus on their own workouts that time around. You agreed that you'll do a weekly session with Brooke every Wednesday starting from then on, so that you can be dedicated to your workout regimen even when the girls go back to college by the end of the summer. Chad was still hovering around the girls, trying to get their attention by lifting weights near them and being as loud with his grunts as possible, but the girls paid him no mind.
You learned more about Brooke during your workout yesterday as you guys chatted in-between sets of your workout. Getting to know Brooke was nice, and since the two of you are around the same age, you bonded pretty quickly. She's apparently not just a personal trainer at the gym, but one of the owners of the franchise for this gym's location. So when she said 'management wouldn't let frequent PDA slide', she was apparently referring to her business partner.
Brooke's also been Tanya's trainer since Tanya moved to your apartment building four years ago, and they've been close friends since then, bonding over their singlehood. Unlike Tanya though, she doesn't have kids, and would really like a serious relationship someday. She also goes out with Tanya every other Friday to meet and get free drinks from guys, but apparently Tanya bailed on her last week, and is apparently not available this week either. Oops.
As for the girls for these past couple of days, they've been micromanaging your upcoming date with Tanya. From where you should take her, to what you should wear, and probably the weirdest thing they could advise you on: what the bedroom should look like to make Tanya fall in love with you — they both advise rose petals and scented candles.
Your girlfriend and your daughter giving you advice on how to make another woman fall in love with you in the bedroom. Nothing weird about that at all.
Then there's today. You went on another run with the girls this morning and the three of you decided to just hang out in the apartment for the afternoon and watch a series. Since Cassie found out that your appreciation for volleyball was limited to watching Stella play during high school, they decided to make you watch a volleyball anime that they agree basically encapsulates their love for volleyball and maybe you'll get to appreciate it more too. You got engrossed by the series and only had to stop since you had to cook dinner.
It's now around dinner time and you're preparing dinner for you and the girls, while they watched some videos on YouTube. As you set the table, you get a phone call from someone you haven't heard from in a while.
"Hey Jay! It's your cousin Celeste. I hope you haven't forgotten about me." She greets you over the phone. Forgotten about her? The girl you hate to admit was your first crush? You've been trying to forget her for forever, but it's hard to forget when she's part of the family. The best you could do was just live with the dirty little secret that you had a huge crush on one of your cousins.
"Hey Celeste! How've you been?" you ask her over the phone.
"I've been good! I actually have some business to take care of in your neck of the woods, and my mom and your mom basically forced me to call you to ask if I can stay over at your place so I don't have to book a hotel." She tells you. "You can say no, of course! I can always stay at a hotel." she adds.
"Yeah, of course you can stay over. When are you arriving?" you ask her.
"My flight arrives Saturday afternoon and I'm only staying until Monday morning. Is that okay?" she asks you, and you immediately reply that it wouldn't be a problem. "Alright. If you really don't mind," and you reassure her that you don't, "Okay. I'll see you on Saturday!" she says before saying goodbye.
As the call ends, you can't help but remember your repressed fantasies as a kid. Unlike when you were a kid though, you have a magic app that can tell you how people feel about you. Your juvenile curiosity gets the better of you, and for the first time since Stella told you not to check her scores, you open the Affection Multiplier.
The app hasn't registered a profile for Celeste yet, probably requiring a meeting in person. You notice that your Available Points have been updated though.
Available points: 330 Friendship points / 200 Love points / 200 Lust points (+50)
You're not sure where the additional lust points came from, but you guess it's from Brooke since you did have some physical contact with her during the workout. More interestingly, you notice that there's a new notification bubble over the Trait Catalog. You check the notification. What it shows you makes you wish you didn't.
New Trait suggested for Wishlist!
Normalized Incest (200 Love pts and 200 Lust pts): Everyone accepts the fact that you have a romantic and/or sexual relationship with your relatives, whether by blood or by law. Relatives no longer have inhibitions against a romantic relationship with you, or inhibitions against finding you as an attractive sexual partner, on the sole reason of your familial relation.
You have now acquired enough points to acquire this trait! Would you like to purchase it now?
YES/NO
"YES!" Stella shouts upon seeing that you've made her favorite for dinner. Her excitement is immediately replaced by concern, as she sees your dazed look while holding your phone.
"Hey! You're not looking at my profile are you?"
CHAPTER 41.1
What happens next?
Lost in Thought
"Hey! You're not looking at my profile are you?" Stella asks you inquisitively, making sure you're not breaking another 'House Rule'.
"No. No. I just got a call from Celeste. She's staying over for a couple of days." you tell Stella.
"Oh! Aunt Celeste? It's been a while since we've seen her!" Stella reacts. "When's she coming by? Maybe we could take her to our Girl's Night Out tomorrow." she adds.
"She's arriving Saturday afternoon, and she's here for business so she might not have time to hangout" you tell her.
"Aw. That sucks." Stella says disappointed. "But that's good news right? Why'd you look like you got hit by a truck?
Fuck. You can't tell your own daughter it's because your app is recommending you to buy a trait called 'Normalized Incest'. What kind of misunderstanding would that lead to if she found out you were even considering it?
"I-uh, I just realized I said yes without thinking where she's going to sleep." you fib.
