Birthday Pool Party Ch. 31

"Thank you, Steven." Nicole states sincerely. "That was amazing."

"Likewise, Babe." I smile.

"You called me 'Babe'." Nicole smiles happily.

"Of course!" I laugh as I lean forward and peck her lips.

"Shit!" Nicole curses as her hand flies between her legs. "I'm leaking cum!"

"It's fine, this comforter gets cum on it all the time!" Lexi laughs as she playfully reaches over and squeezes one of her sister's tits.

"We'll wash it." I assure Nicole.

"We should clean up, Steven." Nicole says.

"How about a private shower?" I suggest.

"Sounds heavenly." Nicole replies.

"We'll change the sheets while you're cleaning up." Ashley offers.

"Thanks, girls." I say.

I help Lexi and Marcia get Nicole off the bed and onto her feet. Nicole sways slightly as I take her hand and start to lead her toward the bathroom. She glances at me and smiles as we enter the large bathroom attached to the master bedroom.

"Your bathroom is bigger than my bedroom." Nicole giggles.

"I'll take that as a compliment." I chuckle.

"You should!" she says.

Pulling open the shower stall, I start the water. Soon, steam begins pouring out of the shower. I test the water with my hand before helping Nicole into the shower. I can't help but laugh when Nicole turns her butt toward the spray and reaches back to spread her cheeks.

"What?" she blushes. "I have to wash out my bum!"

"It's cute!" I smirk from my place just outside the shower.

"Thanks, I guess." Nicole scrunches her nose cutely.

"You're welcome, Beautiful." I whisper.

"I like when you call me that." Nicole smiles.

"Then I'll keep doing it." I smile.

"Come join me?" Nicole asks, crooking her finger at me.

My smile deepens as I step into the shower with Nicole. I wrap an arm around her waist, resting my hand at her lower back as I pull her close. We share a soft kiss as she runs her hands along my muscular chest.

"Nicole." I whisper.

"Oh, Steven." Nicole moans.

My hand lowers to Nicole's ass as the redhead presses her bare breasts against me. I can feel her hard nipples caressing my chest. She reaches down and grasps my flaccid penis, her soft hand massaging me as our tongues wrestle.

"Fuck, you're so sexy." I groan.

"Steven." Nicole moans again. "Steven, I'm falling for you."

I break our kiss. Looking into Nicole's green eyes, I notice that they are the exact same shade as Lexi's. The exact same eyes. Beautiful, and piercing. Dancing with light and warmth. I can feel the steadiness of her breathing against me as I hold her close.

"I'm falling for you, too." I admit.

"What do we do?" Nicole wonders.

"We have to tell Lexi." I say. "I can't hurt her. I won't."

"I understand." Nicole nods. "What if she doesn't want us to sleep together anymore?"

"Then we have to stop." I state firmly.

"I don't ever want to stop." Nicole states. "You're my first. My only."

"I don't want to stop either." I sigh. "Let's talk to Lexi. We'll see what she says."

"Okay." Nicole mumbles sadly.

We enjoy our shower together. My fingers trail along Nicole's flat stomach, to her bush of fiery red pubic hair. I love soaping up Nicole's titties. Her breasts are lightly-freckled, just like Lexi's. However, Nicole definitely has bigger boobs. I enjoy pressing them together and admiring the way soap gathers at her cleavage.

"Let's talk to her now." I suggest.

"In front of everyone?" Nicole mumbles.

"No, let's call her in here." I say.

"Okay. Let's do it." Nicole nods, gathering her strength.

"Lexi?" I call out loudly after walking over to the bathroom door and opening it.

"Yeah?" my girlfriend shouts back.

"Can you come in here, please?" I ask.

"Sure!" she chirps.

A few seconds later, a naked Lexi walks into the bathroom. Fuck, she's gorgeous. Shapely legs leading up to a shaved pussy and narrow hips. A tone stomach is beneath her small, firm breasts. Auburn hair frames her pretty, lightly-freckled face. Her green eyes glow with affection as she looks at me.

"Lexi." Nicole says nervously.

"Nicole." Lexi inclines her head. "Nice tits."

"You, too!" Nicole giggles.

"So, what's up?" Lexi asks as she closes the door.

"We need to talk." I say calmly.

"Uh-oh." Lexi replies, turning serious. "What's wrong?"

"I'm just gonna say it; Nicole and I have feelings for each other." I state, not wanting to dance around the issue. "It's more than just sex."

"Oh, is that all?" Lexi breathes out a sigh of relief. "You had me worried that something was wrong!"

"You're not upset?" Nicole asks as she stands beside me and crosses her arms beneath her breasts.

"No." Lexi shakes her head. "Why? Should I be?"

"Well, you got really upset about Stacey being in love with me." I say.

"Of course, I did!" Lexi exclaims. "She wanted to steal you away from me! She's not a Slut-sister! She's not family!"

"I guess that makes sense." I mumble, still not fully understanding how Lexi's brain works.

"You're not gonna try and steal him from me, are you?" Lexi asks Nicole.

"No! Of course not!" Nicole insists. "You're my sister, Lexi. I would never do something like that to you."

"Okay then, we're good." Lexi smiles and nods. "Say, I'm getting hungry. Are we gonna eat dinner soon?"

"Wait, wait, wait!" Nicole says. "What about Steven and I? What do we do now?"

"What do you wanna do now?" Lexi asks.

"I don't know!" Nicole sighs.

"Neither do I." I admit.

"Let's ask the Sluts." Lexi suggests as she turns and marches her naked ass out of the bathroom.

Nicole and I look at each other and start laughing. Lexi really is one of a kind. She has a lot of abandonment issues, but she seems to be accepting that we're all one big family. She knows that the Slut-sisters aren't gonna steal me from her.

I take Nicole's hand and the two of us follow Lexi out of the bathroom. The girls are all lounging about the master bedroom. The television is on, and a popular show is playing in the background. Ashley, Marcia, and Kayla are all on the bed, while Hazel is sitting in my desk chair.

"Nicole and Steven are in love." Lexi announces.

"What?" Ashley asks with a confused expression.

"Uh, okay." Hazel responds.

"Nicole and I have feelings for each other." I explain.

"We all have feelings for each other." Kayla rolls her eyes.

"Is there a problem?" Marcia wonders.

"Yes!" Nicole exclaims as she pulls her hand out of mine and runs both hands through her hair in exasperation. "I'm twenty-six years old! I mean, I know that's not old, but I eventually wanna find a husband. Now, I'm sleeping with my baby sister's boyfriend! My friends see how happy I am and are asking if I'm seeing someone, and I don't know what to do!"

"What do you want to do?" Kayla asks.

"Don't use your brain, use your heart." Ashley suggests.

"I want to date Steven." Nicole admits with a sigh. "But, I can't."

"Sure, you can!" Lexi chirps.

"No, I can't." Nicole shakes her head.

"Says who?" Hazel asks.

"Society!" Nicole insists. "He's dating my sister!"

"Fuck society!" Ashley exclaims.

"C'mon, Nicole," Kayla begins, "we're having a naked meeting here, I'm Steven's daughter, what do you think society would say about that? Who cares!"

"Yeah, we're not hurting anyone." Marcia nods.

"So, you think Lexi and I can both date Steven?" Nicole asks.

"Yes!" Hazel answers. "While I have his baby!"

"Poly relationships are much more common these days, anyway." Ashley reasons.

"Not when two of the people are sisters!" Nicole says.

"True, but still. Just present it as Steven having two girlfriends, not like you're in a three-way relationship." Kayla suggests.

"What do I tell my friends?" Nicole inquires.

"Tell them you're dating a handsome, kind, intelligent, loving man." Hazel says with a smile.

"Go right ahead and tell them it's a poly relationship." Ashley adds. "If they're really your friends, they'll understand."

"What do you think?" Nicole asks, looking toward me.

"It's not just my decision." I answer. "Lexi?"

"You'll never try and steal him from me?" Lexi asks Nicole.

"Never. I respect you too much." Nicole insists.

"Then kiss your boyfriend!" Lexi exclaims.

"C'mere, girlfriend!" I say as I grab Nicole and spin her to face me.

"Kiss me, Steven!" Nicole breathes as she puckers up.

I kiss my new girlfriend. My second girlfriend. Ours is a weird family, but one full of love. I bury one hand in Nicole's hair as my other grabs her butt. Nicole is holding onto my biceps as she shoves her tongue in my mouth.

"I love you." Nicole breaks our kiss to whisper.

"I love you, too!" I breathe back.

"Orgy time?" Ashley asks excitedly.

"No, dinnertime!" Lexi replies. "I'm hungry!"

The seven of us find underwear to put on, then we cover ourselves with robes. Time to fill our stomachs before getting to the fucking. We sit at the massive table in the dining room and serve ourselves a fine meal. There's talk and laughter. Even Hazel is in a good mood.

After dinner, we end up not fucking right away. It is family game night, after all. In the main living room, we pull out the board games. With seven people, we end up having two to three different games being played at once. The entire time, I'm texting Allan. I tell him what Hazel and I agree on; I'm the father.

Steven: I'm gonna be a father again.

Allan: Congratulations! Lexi's pregnant?

Steven: No, her classmate, Hazel.

Allan: Come again?

Steven: I got Lexi and Kayla's classmate and friend pregnant.

Allan: You cheated on Lexi?

Steven: No, she gave me permission.

Allan: Wait, wait, wait. You're fucking two eighteen year old girls and they're both okay with it?

Steven: More than two.

Allan: Seriously?

Steven: Seriously.

Allan: I don't know how to respond to this.

Steven: Say you'll come see the baby when he or she is born!

Allan: Of course, I will! Steven, is everything okay?

Steven: Never better, Allan. Never better.

Allan: Well, I'm happy for you.

Steven: Have a good Sunday, my friend.

Allan: You, too.

I chuckle and tell the girls all about texting with Allan. Our group gets a good laugh about it. We're unique, we know that. We also know people won't understand, but that doesn't matter. What matters is that we have each other.

It isn't long before the robes start coming off. We have a great night fucking in every position we can think of. Six girls forming a daisy chain may sound hot, but it isn't very practical. Still, the girls have to try.

One guy with six girls also sounds amazing, but I only have one cock. One cock, and six girls who all want it. I make sure to sample every mouth and every cunt, except Kayla's, of course. She and I still aren't there yet.

Several moments stand out. Five of the girls kneeling in doggystyle as I switch between them, with Kayla at the end to clean me with her mouth. Giving Nicole her first titty-fuck. Laying on the floor in a pile of naked, female flesh. Looking down and watching the girls as they finger and lick each other. Finally, standing over them as I stroke myself while watching them pleasure each other. I explode, covering six Slut-sisters with all the semen my balls can bring forth.

The six girls all take showers before getting fully dressed. I take their picture. They want something they can show everyone. The girls all look so happy as they hold each other and smile at the camera. I send the picture to all of them.

It's getting late, and sadly this day has to come to an end. Ashley and Marcia kiss everyone goodbye before leaving. Nicole and I hold each other in the foyer, gazing into each others eyes as we say goodnight.

"See you soon, boyfriend?" Nicole asks.

"Of course, girlfriend." I reply.

We exchange a soft kiss. I flip off Kayla, Hazel, and Lexi when I hear them laughing at us in the background. Then Nicole and I break apart. She's out the door and gone. I already miss her. With a small smile, I walk back through the house with the three girls who live with me.

The four of us watch a movie in the main living room. I cuddle on the couch with Kayla and Lexi while Hazel sits in one of the armchairs. Hazel has a panic attack during the movie, so we stop it and help the poor girl calm down. Yeah, life is good, not perfect.

It's time for bed. We all offer to spend the night with Hazel, but she says she wants to sleep alone. Hazel goes into her new bedroom while Kayla disappears into her own room. Finally, Lexi and I enter the master bedroom.

"Are you sure you're okay with everything?" I ask Lexi as I start pulling off my clothes.

"It is crazy, isn't it?" Lexi asks as she reaches behind her back and unhooks her bra. "You have two girlfriends, and a baby on the way with a third girl."

"And that's just since Friday." I laugh as I step out of my boxer briefs.

"This has been one crazy fucking weekend." Lexi giggles as she pushes her panties down her smooth legs.

"Yes. Yes, it has." I agree. "And you didn't answer the question; are you okay with everything?"

"I think so." Lexi sighs as she and I get into bed naked. "I know I'm being weird. I'm not okay with Stacey, but I'm okay with this."

"I'm glad you can see that." I nod as I draw her into my arms.

"I guess I just get scared when things come up that remind me of how different we are." she explains as she rests her head on my chest, her arm around my waist. "Stacey is part of your business world, something I know nothing about. She understands you in a way that I don't, she's closer to you in age, too."

"I can talk about work more, if you'd like?" I offer jokingly.

"Yeah, no thanks." Lexi giggles.

"Just thought I'd offer." I smile.

"Anyway, you know I'm terrified of losing you, but I'm okay with you sticking your dick in other willing pussies." she continues. "I like sharing you. Sharing you with people I love and trust. And, I don't trust Stacey. It's hard to explain, but I can just tell she wants you all to herself."

"What about Heather in Bermuda?" I ask.

"Oh, that was for both of us." Lexi giggles before licking her lips. "As soon as I saw her, I knew I had to taste that sweet snatch of hers. And fuck, she was crazy in the sack."

"She was a wild one." I agree.

"The thing is that I had no one." she says. "I had no one, and I ended up getting raped, getting gang-banged, getting passed around like a worthless cum dump."

"I know." I reply while I run my fingers through her hair.

"I-I wasn't even a person to them." Lexi sniffles, and I realize she's crying. "Keith would be hanging out with his friends and I'd have to sit there naked, waiting for one of them to want a turn with me. I remember we were watching TV, one guy just grabbed me by the hair and forced my head into his lap. Didn't even look at me!"

"I'm here, Lexi." I assure her as I kiss the top of her head.

"Sometimes random memories like that will come back to me. Stuff I had completely forgotten about because I was so high or drunk." she tells me.

"That makes sense." I tell Lexi, just trying to listen to her. I know she needs to get this out.

"So many memories." Lexi whispers. "Laying in bed with my legs spread as they pull a train on me, being surrounded by guys as I shove one cock after another in my mouth, two guys in my pussy at the same time, guys seeing how many cocks they can get in me at once. The record is six."

"Six?!" I wonder, eyes wide.

"Mouth, pussy, ass, one in each hand, one guy fucking my tits." she explains. "That was a rough night."

"How'd they even, you know, fit around you?" I just have to ask.

"Lots of maneuvering." Lexi rolls her eyes. "They were determined."

"Ah." I nod.

"And this is just what I remember. I know there's more that I don't. Then there were other things they did to me, dirty, disgusting things." she whimpers, tears running down her cheeks. "They stuck things in me!"

"You're not alone, Lexi." I whisper.

"I still see that teacher who fucked me. He leers at me in the hall." Lexi sighs.

"Do you want to report him?" I ask.

"No." she answers with a shake of her head. "There's no point. There's no proof he and I ever even had sex. I'd rather just get through the last month or so of high school and get on with my life."

"If that's what you think is best, I support you." I reply.

"Hazel talks about being a whore, and yeah, she was mistaken for a prostitute, but I actually was one." Lexi cries. "Keith got money from guys who wanted to use me. I was his property. I don't even know how many men I've been with. A lot."

"I'm sorry." I say.

"Yeah, me too." Lexi states. "Speaking of Hazel, what did you do with all that money?"

"It's in my desk drawer." I answer with a shrug. "It didn't feel right using it for anything."

"Gotcha." she nods before continuing. "Keith really fucked me up."

"You're free of Keith." I assure her.

"Not yet." Lexi shakes her head. "Not until he's gone away forever. I act like I'm okay, and most of the time, I am. Sometimes though, I just get so overwhelmed and emotional. I remember having my legs forced apart, my tits mauled, being slapped and spit on, being called every name in the fucking book as some piece of shit shoved his cock up my ass!"

"You're okay, you're okay." I coo softly as I hold my girlfriend.

"Then I started hooking up with guys on my own." she continues. "Not even one night stands, I'd just grab guys and drag them into a room to fuck. I'd get on my knees and beg for cum from guys whose names I didn't even know. I remember getting spit-roasted at a frat party, right in the living room. Full view of everyone. Girls jeering at me, calling me a whore. Guys laughing."

"Lexi..." I trail off.

"I just, I just don't ever wanna go back to that place." Lexi mumbles in a small, scared voice.

"You won't. I won't let you." I reply.

"It isn't just you." Lexi says. "My Slut-sisters keep me sane, too. They keep me from having nightmares about Keith, from falling back into old habits. I need all of you."

"So, you see me with Nicole as bringing us all even closer?" I wonder.

"Yes." Lexi confirms.

"Well, you'll never lose any of us." I promise.

"I hope not." she says. "I never want another man besides you. Only you. Forever."

"I love you." I state.

"I love you, too." Lexi replies before looking over at me nervously. "Do we still have the USB drive of the pictures and videos Keith gave my parents?"

"Yeah, it's in my desk drawer." I respond. "Why?"

"Just thinking about how we didn't give it to the police to protect my privacy, but they got all of it anyway." Lexi sighs. "From Keith's phone."

"Are you wishing we gave it to them sooner?" I ask.

"Yes." Lexi admits. "If we had, maybe Keith would have been arrested and Stephanie and Kelsey wouldn't have been raped."

"Maybe." I say slowly. "Or maybe they would have said those videos don't prove anything. Remember, Keith is probably getting arrested for the video he took of Kayla. That's not on the drive we have. The police did say that they probably can't charge Keith or David for anything they did to you."

"I guess." Lexi mumbles. "I just wish Kayla and I could have protected the girls."

"The only ones at fault here are Keith and David." I assure Lexi.

"I hate them so much." Lexi whispers as tears run down her cheeks.

"I know." I respond. "I know. Do you want to start seeing a therapist?"

"No." Lexi answers after a few moments of thought. "You don't have to keep suggesting it. You know that you and my Slut-sisters are my therapists."

"Let me know if you ever change your mind." I say.

"I will." Lexi confirms.

We lay in silence for a couple minutes, holding each other. Lexi looks up at me through tear-filled eyes. I wipe away her tears and hold her face. Then our lips meet. We kiss softly for a few minutes, before she pulls back.