Ex Boyfriend's Brother

This story involves consensual sex that leads to a nonconsensual creampie. If that makes you uncomfortable, do not continue to read.

*******************************

Frankie knew that neither of the boys liked her much, but their mother thought she was just darling. She always invited her over for tea, and she kept coming to rub it in the youngest son's face. She broke up with him not too long ago after he started giving another girl more attention. He didn't please her or spend much time with her, then someone else caught his eye.. Of course Frankie had to destroy the relationship and piss off both him and his older brother in the process. Gerard always said he knew she would end up hurting his little brother's feelings, and she supposed he was sort of right.

Frankie leaned forward against the table, her elbows planted on the wood with her arms on either side of her chest as she watched Gerard come into the kitchen. She purposely pressed her arms together slightly, making her breasts slightly swell out of the low neckline of her tanktop. She knew how she affected him. She could tell how much he hated himself for giving into the girl who broke his little brother's heart.

She smirked slightly, shifting her eyes to the woman that had invited her over; the one who was convinced that she was a sweet girl who had done nothing wrong. The mother was preoccupied telling Frankie all about a romance novel she had read recently, showing off the cover and politely offering to lend it to her if she needed some entertainment.

"She doesn't care about romance, ma. Besides, I don't think snakes even have ears," Gerard said with a glare Frankie's way.

With a huff, his mother defended her, fussing that it wasn't her fault that she and his brother had broken up. She had definitely gotten her side of the story.

"I can't believe you're taking her side," he muttered, taking a mug from the cabinet and beginning to fiddle with the coffee maker.

"A girl knows how a girl feels. Women are sensitive, honey. You need to know that or you will never get a girlfriend," his mother said dismissively, standing up from her chair while sliding the book towards Frankie. With a sigh, she announced it was about time for her to pick up her prescription, offering for Frankie to tag along. Of course, she said no thank you.

As the older woman gathered her things, Frankie kept a snails pace when readying herself to leave. At the door, she gently patted the mom's back, saying she was going to speak with Gerard for just one more moment.

Turning on her heels, Frankie made her way back to the kitchen as soon as the front door closed. Gerard gave her a look with a raised eyebrow, but he knew why she stuck around.

"Where's your little brother? Hiding from me?" She said with a teasing tone, swaying her hips as she walked toward him.

"I don't blame him," he scoffed, setting his mug down on the counter.

Frankie reached forward, gently placing one of her hands on his hip as she looked up at him, "Says the one that has been fucking me like a whore at least once a week."

"You're that's begging to be fucked like a whore," Gerard stepped forward, turning their bodies so Frankie's butt was against the cabinets. He reached forward, putting a hand on the counter to keep her in place.

"You love it," she purred softly, turning her hand to slip her fingers down into the waist band of his sweatpants. She trailed her fingers over the v of his hip, letting her hand sink lower and lower. She looked up at him through her eyelashes, "You think you're punishing me somehow. It's kind of sick; fucking your brother's ex." She purposely used venom in her voice, knowing what she said would get under his skin.

Gerard moved forward, slipping his hands down behind her, roughly squeezing her ass through her shorts. "You're the one that's sick," he groaned, removing his hand just to reconnect it with a sharp smack.

"Show me how bad you hate me," Frankie gasped, leaning back against the counter as she lifted one leg up to his hip, letting him pin her there. "I bet you want to ruin me," she slipped her hands up over his clothed chest instead, slowly moving them into his hair.

Gerard pressed his hips forward, rolling them against Frankie's for some kind of friction. He leaned over her, grazing his lips over her neck for a moment before sucking on her spot right below her jaw.

Frankie pulled him as close as possible with her lifted leg, wanting more of him against her. "I hope he finds out and fucking hates you," she said with a soft groan, tilting her head to the side.

"You're a lot hotter when you're quiet," He commented, pulling away to tug her tank top up her stomach, then over her chest. Frankie finished the job for him, then his hands were right over her breasts, lightly squeezing and pressing them up.

She dropped her shirt to the floor with a sigh, hoping he would forget it. "I think it's more fun when I'm loud. I want to get caught."

"I should take you down stairs and shove your face into a pillow," he grumbled, moving one of his hands to the front of her shorts. He slipped his fingers into her underwear, starting to rub slowly as his other hand worked her breast.

"I'll just get louder," She continued, tipping her head back slightly as his finger circled her clit. She closed her eyes, feeling his hand speed up rapidly right where she wanted it.

Gerard groaned, pressing his finger down lower, letting one slip down her slit before returning right to her clit. "Keep your mouth shut," He said with a threatening voice, watching her lips part at the feeling of his hand on her.

"You'll have to make me," she pressed her hips down against his finger as slipped it right over her entrance.

He pulled his hand away, moving them both to her shoulders as he stepped away, pushing her downwards.

Frankie got the message, going to her knees as she tugged down the front of his sweatpants. She looked up at him, slipping her fingers over his shaft as she made a fist, pulling his cock down as she opened her mouth. With a flat tongue, she moved her head forward, licking under the head. When Gerard placed his hand on top of her head, she circled her lips around him, sucking softly before popping right off.

"Stop teasing," Gerard mumbled, gently tugging on her hair. He closed his eyes for a moment, focusing on the feeling of her tongue spreading across him as she licked around his shaft. Once he was slick, her lips glided over him easily.

Frankie bobbed her head, sucking deeply as she looked up at her ex's older brother. She felt his hips push forward, making her gag slightly, placing her hands on his thighs in an attempt to slow him down. She swallowed thickly, letting him stay deeper inside of her mouth before he pulled back on his own accord.

She wanted to fuss, but Gerard's hips slipped forward again, filling her mouth up with more of his cock. He held the back of her head, rocking his hips slowly before finally pulling away completely.

"I should go off to my room and finish myself up. Leave you here horny," He muttered, pulling his sweatpants back up before starting to walk away.

She quickly pushed herself up, following close behind him. "I hate you so bad."

Gerard led them down to his room in the basement, taking her wrist to tug her towards the bed, turning to push her by the hips to make her fall against it. "Be nice or I'll cum in you," he chuckled, tugging her shorts down her thighs, then off her legs.

"If you do that, I'll actually hate you," she shook her head, tugging on his shirt to get him to strip as well. "I plan on leaving your lame family behind when I'm done with you; not becoming a part of it."

Gerard slipped between her thighs, pulling them around his hips. He reached between her legs, wiping a finger over her wetness, then placing his thumb over her clit. He smirked, adding Mrs. to the front of his last name, testing it out as he slipped a finger into her.

"If you do, I'll tell your mom first thing. She'll buy me the pill and crucify you," Frankie threatened, taking his free hand to place it on her chest. She couldn't help but lift her hips slightly at the feeling of his thumb circling her clit.

"I'm surprised you aren't on birth control since you're a little slut that likes it raw," he took his hand back, smacking her thigh before putting it back on her chest. He worked another finger in, curling them just slightly as he rubbed at the sensitive spot inside of her.

Frankie's breath picked up as Gerard's fingers worked on her, "What, are you scared? Can't pull out in time?" She asked, squeezing his bicep.

Gerard pulled away, tapping her hip and telling her to flip over. He couldn't help but tug her leg as she turned over, making her body drop to the bed. He sat up on his knees, pulling her hips up.

She grunted, keeping her chest and arms against the bed as she rested on her knees with her hips in the air, on full display for Gerard. She pressed her hips backwards, starting to sway her ass from side to side.

"Want me inside of you?" He asked, reaching down to hold her hip steady with one hand, using the other to press himself against her entrance.

"I just want to get fucked. Not specifically by you," She mumbled, pressing her hips back to make his head press into her slightly.

"Maybe I should call your ex down here instead," he pulled his hips back, pushing forward just to make his cock slip under her, over her clit.

Frankie groaned, pressing her cheek against his bed, "Do it. I want him to see how his brother betrayed him."

Gerard's hand lifted from her hip, crashing down with a hard slap to her ass. He grabbed her hip again, pressing into her with disregard for her comfort.

Frankie felt like her breath was knocked out of her chest as Gerard pushed into her, stretching her open suddenly. Her fingers slipped over his bedsheets, balling the fabric up in her fists as he started to move his hips.

As much as Gerard hated her personality, her body felt amazing. She was warm and incredibly tight. He had to snap his hips forward with every thrust to get inside of her.

Her body sank against the bed but her hips stayed in the air, held by Gerard's hands as he used her tight pussy to get off. Frankie's toes curled, loving the feeling of Gerard pounding into her over and over. She finally moved one arm down under her, using her finger to circle her clit.

"Your body loves me," Gerard reached forward, tangling his hand into her hair to pull her head back. Frankie kept her other arm out in front of herself, trying to keep her body steady as Gerard's hips slapped against her ass.

"I hate you so much," She breathed, followed by a loud moan. Her finger worked over her clit, slick from her own wetness.

"Maybe you need the wake up call of getting filled with cum," Gerard pressed deep into her, staying there for a moment as he let go of her hair, moving his hand down to replace her own over her clit.

Frankie gasped softly, feeling his rough finger rub her faster. "Gerard," she said, trying to sound stern but failing. "I'm so ratting you out if you do. We're over if you even try," she insisted.

"You want it so bad," Gerard pulled back before quickly snapping his hips forward again, loving the feeling of being completely enveloped by her. He started thrusting again, drawing out sweet moans from her lips.

"Gerard," she said again, reaching down to try to stop his fingers from moving over her clit. When that didn't work, she resorted to grabbing his wrist, trying to tug it away. "You gotta stop," she said, trying to lift her hips away but only impaling herself onto Gerard further.

"Maybe this will tame you," he groaned, his pace quickening before his hips jolted forward suddenly.

Frankie gasped, hearing Gerard moan before feeling warmth deep inside of her. She could feel every twitch of his cock and the hot spurts that came with each one. She closed her eyes tight, feeling Gerard's rough finger speed up over her clit, tipping her right over the edge. Her body shook as her mouth opened, a sweet moan coming out. Her cervix twitched, taking in the semen that pooled against it.

Gerard moved his hips a few more times before pulling out extra slow, trying to leave as much of his cum inside of her as he could. He patted her ass cheek, grabbing his pillow to slip under her hips.

She slowly sank against the pillow, taking a deep breath. She swallowed thickly before groaning, "Have fun being out $50 for the morning after pill."

Gerard smirked, "Who even said I had $50."