All Comments on 'From the Ashes'

Absolutely loved this just like every other story I’ve read of yours thank you so very much for entertaining so very many people.

I loved it, and gave it 5 stars. I think this was my 2nd time reading this one. It had it all, romance, comedy, sorrow, and a well written story. Thank You for sharing it with us.

Great ride. Thanks for a wonderful story.

Death metal? I can't see a death metal band being excited about love ballads or 'gosh I loved my Grandpa so much'. Just about any other music, yeah. But Granny had it right: death metal is just a bunch of noise with "singers" trying to out-shout each other, using their best demon-voice.

a solid 4 Stars on this one . My picture is still at my ex's Dad's house . I hear her new hubby is not fond of that fact .

Read this tale a couple of years ago, and really enjoyed the read. Just found it again and re-read it slowly, enjoying it even more than before. 5 stars for a really nice story

Simply one of the best on here 5 stars

The part with sex article in a major magazine was ridiculous. Writer who randomly musicians are petri dishes. What diseases did magnus pick up?

Weak MC because he doesn't do anything when his wife is cheating with his supposedly good friend and band mate. At least kick his ass and throw her out. But no the typical run away weakling like most of this authors stories. I don't know anyone who is not in a band who didn't kick their band members asses when someone screwed their woman much less wife. Unless they had an open relationship that would be the realistic response. Not run away leaving the cheating ehore in charge of my multi million dollar mansion with all my platinum records and my safe with my valuables. Who the fuck wouldn't make her leave? Shit story at the beginning.

Apparently you didn't read the story because that's not even apart of the damn thing.

Just commenting on Anonymous, two comments below, it is just so obvious this idiot commented without actually reading the story in full, the idiot was too lazy to even skim the story, what an absolute fucking idiot. No wonder he post anonymously. Thanks for the read Soul71. This was my second time reading this story and it’s still a great read⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

The story was good ,moving even,the epilogue was just right.

Magnus was solid.

The MC kicked the cheating whore to the curb and went out and found his best life. Implied in the story was an ass kicking for the the asshole that seduced his wife. Like the way he ghosted his family when they stood with the wife. And the x got what she deserved, a life of shit.

[17.05.24]

Nth re-read, still Excellente all 'round!

11/10!!!!!

Rocking five stars all the way.

A really nice story, and I mean that in the best way. I was afraid for s while that it would change into something else, and was relieved when it developed in that positive way. One side note. The last paragraph would have been more powerful if it had ended with. "I know !" Iona groaned.

Five solid, appreciative stars from me.

/

JPB NOT BOB