Kayleigh's Revenge

"Now, we will need to deal with you two whores," Todd announced. Kayleigh who was still catching her breath was lifted by Ben and Gary and led from the room her legs too weak to walk. Todd led Jaimie from the room by her hair and closed the door leaving Damien sitting on the bed.

They led them through the vicarage, lecturing the two women the entire time, calling them sluts and whores.

Entering the converted church they all stopped to take in the surroundings. 4 pews stood on each side of the central isle. Pillars surrounded the room and a sturdy marble altar was placed at the front of the room. Hundreds of candles had been lit and spread across the church.

The women were led to the front of the church, both women were pushed to their knees in front of the altar. Kayleigh attempted to adjust her 'Dress' the fishnet material had ridden up her waist during the fucking and the men carrying her had not allowed her to cover herself.

"You stand before god and are expected to show an act of contrition." Todd looked sternly at the two kneeling women. "Sister Kayleigh, you have been violated in by sins of the flesh. We will purge you of your sins." Todd adjusted his erection in front of everyone. "You," he pointed at Jaimie, "You have committed many sins. What do you think your punishments should be?".

Kayleigh spoke up first. She had been planning this moment, had committed it to memory. Todd knew how she wanted the scene to play out. "Forgive me Father for I have sinned. My mouth and pussy have been abused. I must atone."

Todd nodded and looked to Jaimie who stared back, keeping silent. "What say you?" Todd prompted.

"I have nothing to apologise for. She's a whore and we treated her as such." Jaimie held her chin up proudly.

"I see." Todd looked to the other two men. "Shall we teach these sinners the meaning of contrition?".

Todd remained at the altar as Ben and Gary moved in front of the women. "You should not lead us into temptation!" Todd called. He seemed to be enjoying his role. Maybe a bit too much Kayleigh thought nearly smiling before remembering they would be recorded.

Ben pulled his robes open and Kayleigh was met with his erect cock. She wanted to move towards it but she remained where she was, waiting for instructions.

Jaimie gasped to Kayleigh's right. Gary was standing there proudly his huge cock inches from her face. Let's see how she deals with this, Kayleigh thought gleefully.

"Purge the mouth of these sinners!" Todd called and clapped his hands.

Immediately the men's hands shot forwards grabbing the back of the women's heads. Their cocks placed at their mouths quickly. Kayleigh licked her lips before letting Ben push it into her mouth. She heard Jaimie gag and knew Gary was forcing his way into her throat. Gary was used to being in scenes with Sharon who liked to be treated roughly. It's another reason why Kayleigh had chosen him for this scene.

Slurping and gagging sounds filled the church, echoing loudly. "No hands." Ben instructed as Kayleigh moved to play with his balls. She lowered her hands to her thighs and let him work deeper into her mouth. He quickly reached the back of her throat and she gagged but remained still letting him try again....and again.

"Open your eyes sinners, keep them open" Todd announced to the room over the women's gagging. He moved behind Jaimie who's hands were pushing against Gary's legs to stop him pushing deeper. He gathered her wrists together and pulled them behind her, holding her still. Gary pushed the head of his cock deeper it was too wide to go into Jaimie's throat but it didn't stop him from trying.

Todd tapped Gary in his hand and took his place, gathering up Jaimie's hair and pushing his cock into her mouth. He worked slowly, Kayleigh had stressed Jaimie needed to be fucked just right. She needed to know how Kayleigh had been treated. His cock crept to the back of her mouth and she took it easier now, he was smaller then Damien so she seemed more relaxed deep throating him.

Gary joined Kayleigh and Ben, the two men had removed their robes now and stood to either side of Kayleigh. She reached up and slowly jerked Gary's huge cock, still wet from Jaimie's mouth. Ben finally let go of her head and she moved to Gary's waiting cock. She still couldn't get much of him into her mouth but she worshipped his cock for all she was worth. Licking and kissing it all over. She glanced at Todd and Jaimie quickly and Todd's face fucking was forcing her back. She scrabbled backwards choking on his cock until her back hit a pew. Kayleigh renewed her attack on the two cocks in front of her satisfied Jaimie was being treated how she deserved.

Jaimie's gagging and retching was filling the church now and Todd released her head, she fell to the side coughing and wiped her mouth. Gasping for air.

"Bring them to the Altar," Todd said loudly. His voice carrying across the room.

Ben and Gary stepped back reluctantly knowing Kayleigh's jaw would be hurting by now, they had both been using her for at least ten minutes now.

Kayleigh looked up as Ben offered her a hand as if he hasn't just been trying to choke her. "Sister, may I be of assistance?" she took his hand and he lifted her gently.

Gary was not so kind and he lifted Jaimie under her arms and pulled her to the Altar.

"For your sins we will punish you. Sister Kayleigh you have vowed celibacy but as we all witnessed you have not kept your vows!. Jaimie you were due to be married tomorrow but you have seduced a sister of this church and committed adultery. What do you both say on this matter?".

Kayleigh spoke first. "Forgive me Father for I have sinned. They used me and I gave into temptation. I will suffer any punishment you see fit."

Jaimie stared at Todd not saying anything.

"What say you Whore?" Todd asked her. Sneering as he said the last word.

"We fucked a whore. Nothing more nothing less." Jaimie responded defiantly, lifting her chin proudly.

Todd sighed and walked slowly around the altar grabbing the front of Jaimie's Basque and aggressively tore it open, her breasts exposed suddenly she tried to cover herself but Gary held her wrist. Todd then stepped over to Kayleigh and tore two holes in her fishnet body suit, pulling her breasts through. Kayleigh remained still looking straight forwards.

"Bend them over," he ordered stepping out of the way. Ben and Gary bent the women over the altar. They had to tiptoe to stay on their feet. Todd produced a paddle from inside his robes and rubbed it slowly over Jaimie's arse. "Do you wish to repent?" he asked Jaimie.

She remained silent so Todd's hand raised and fell suddenly. The contact of the paddle echoed loudly in the church. He struck her other cheek. Jaimie remained silent, only gasps leaving her mouth. Todd repeated the manoeuvre two more times before moving behind Kayleigh.

"I see you have already been punished." Todd remarked seeing the red marks on her arse where Damien had been spanking her.

"Yes Father. They have punished me." Kayleigh whispered meekly, acting as innocent as she could.

"Hmmm, well, for you we can move onto repentance. Father Gary please take over paddling the whore until she decides to repent.." Todd handed the paddle to Gary. The glint in his eye told Todd that he would need to keep an eye on him. He might enjoy the spanking a bit to much. Gary was much larger than Todd and his strikes would surely hurt more.

"Father Ben. Please hold our Sisters hands please." Todd instructed standing behind Kayleigh. He ran his finger over her pussy causing her to shiver. "Such a shame that you would react in such a manner Sister. More punishment is obviously required."

"Yes Father," Kayleigh whispered.

Todd pulled his cock from his robe and drove it into her up to his balls. Kayleigh yelped more in surprise then pain. Damien's cum was still inside her leaving her well lubricated and the naked men around her had kept her aroused. Todd drew back and thrust all the way in again her knees banging against the Altar. Realising the position wasn't suitable he turned Kayleigh over so she lay across the altar on her back. Ben grasped her hands above her head again as Todd entered her, pulling Kayleigh's legs across his shoulders.

Jaimie grunted as the paddle came down harder then before, switching between cheeks her arse was soon red. "Please stop. I want forgiveness, I'll do anything."

Gary lowered the paddle and traced his fingers over her dripping pussy. Jaimie grained happily, preferring this treatment to the paddle. Garry worked one finger inside her then two, slowly adding a third. Jaimie began to protest but when he picked up the paddle again she lowered her head to the cold altar watching Kayleigh being fucked and enduring the fingering.

Ben released Kayleigh's hands and placed his cock at her mouth she opened her mouth eagerly her head hanging from the side of the altar. Her husband's thrusts pushed her further onto Ben's cock, she groaned around the cock in her mouth her hands lowering to her clit to stimulate herself. Todd slapped her hand away, "You will not pleasure yourself in front of us. We will not be led to further temptation." Kayleigh whined desperate to cum but she moved her hand away, finding Jaimie's waiting hand their fingers interlocked, holding onto each other as the men had their way. Ben grasped Kayleigh's tits pulling and twisting on her nipples.

Gary turned Jaimie around laying her beside Kayleigh and rubbed his cock over her pussy. He tried to enter her but due to his girth found some resistance. He pulled her legs apart and tried again the head slowly entering her. Jaimie began to pant as if she was giving birth, breathing through the intrusion in her pussy. The girls held hands again as Todd sped up fucking Kayleigh. Gary finally managed to get the head into Jaimie and stayed still allowing her to adjust. Then he began to thrust gently Jaimie moaned loudly not yet having adjusted to his cock. He continued anyway.

Seeing her discomfort Todd released Kayleigh's legs pulling her to her feet. Her mouth came away from Ben's cock with a long line of saliva dribbling down her face. "Sister Kayleigh your mouth and pussy have been violated today. You have one remaining hole. This will be your punishment. Father Ben, will you please take Kayleigh and teach her the error of her ways." Ben nodded silently, Kayleigh remained silent accepting her punishment. "Oh and one more thing. No lube. This is to make you repent for your sins, not for enjoyment."

"Please, no. I need lube Father. It will hurt too much." She grasped at Todd's robes. This hasn't been part of the plan.

Todd shook her lose. "You will repent and name your sins as Ben fulfils your punishment. Do you understand me?" he looked her in the eyes. His face serious.

She nodded slowly, not sure why he was acting this way. It was Jaimie who was supposed to be punished.

Todd stepped back and helped Kayleigh stand. Ben took her hand and led Kayleigh away from the altar to a pew.

Ben tried to bend Kayleigh over a pew desperate to get started but instead she gently spun him around. "Let me punish myself," she whispered huskily. "Take a seat whilst I give confession."

Todd watched them go, curious at why Ben was sitting down. Turning away he moved to the altar nodding to Gary. Jamie was panting heavily as Gary worked more of his cock into her, nearly all the way in now, her hands grasped the sides of the altar trying to find something to grip. Her hands found Todd's robes and her fists clenched in the material. Todd watched, fascinated at how her tiny body could take such a big cock.

Gary turned Jaimie over, positioning her on all fours on top of the aktar. He re-entered her from behind pulling on her hair causing her spine to arch. Todd stroked her face and her eyes fluttered open, they were rolling back in her head, loud groaning noises escaping her lips. Todd knelt down to kiss her gently, she returned the kiss sloppily. She cried out as Gary adjusted his grip on her hips and thrust harder, determined to get his whole cock into her. Todd played with her tits and stroked her hair as she rocked back and forth.

"We are going to fuck your arse. You will repent." Todd explained casually.

"I repent. I repent," she cried, desperate for the harsh fucking to stop.

Tutting Todd smiled, yanking her head back causing her spine to arch again, Gary's cock pushing in deeper due to the angle. He held it inside of her, a whine coming from her throat.

"We offered you repentance. It was declined. I believe you need to be taught a lesson. Don't worry you will be allowed lube. I'm bigger then Ben, it wouldn't be fair for you to take two of us with no lube." Todd explained casually as Gary started his thrusting again. Jaimie was rocking back and forth her head and upper body falling to the altar surface as Todd let her hair go.

Todd moved around to stand behind Jaimie rubbing his hand over her arse. Gary pulled out of her and they watched as her pussy gaped open. Reaching down to the bottom of the altar Todd picked up a bottle of lube. He squirted some onto his fingers and slowly began to circle Jaimie's arse. She made to resist her arms coming backwards behind her but Gary placed a heavy hand on her upper back holding her in place.

"You don't need to do this, I repent. I'll fuck you both. Let me up and I'll ride you." Jaimie pleaded.

"She doesn't understand," Todd explained to Gary as he worked a finger gently into her arse. "We are here to save you, not make you beg." He sounded serious but he was grinning at Gary. His finger slowly making it's way into Jaimie's arse.

Kayleigh was riding Ben, holding onto the pew to bounce, pushing her tits into his face. She was enjoying the sensation of his cock hitting the right spot as he held her arse helping her rise and fall.

He would occasionally slap her arse and kissed his way across her tits, occasionally raising his head so that they could kiss. She could feel him becoming impatient, wanting to fuck harder and faster. Ben lifted her slightly so he could brace his feet and began to thrust upwards hard and fast adjusting his hips so she was at an easier angle to fuck, the same way he had fucked her the first time at the football orgy.

"Huh, huh, huh," she gasped as his balls slapped against her arse. The noise echoing around the church.

"Easy, easy." She chided him trying to slow him down. "I need to repent for my sins. Don't want you cuming too soon. I'm trying to make your cock wet enough to go in my arse". She was worried he would cum too quickly and one of the other two would need fuck her with their bigger cocks.

Ben slowed down but kept his hands on her arse ready to go at speed again.

"Now you stay still. I'm going to fuck you until you cum in my arse. You are going in dry so it's going to be very painful. Please don't fuck me like you have been." Kayleigh spoke to him gently like a startled horse. "Next time I will let you fuck me in any position you want but be patient tonight whilst I treat you. Ok?."

He nodded burying his face into her tits again, sucking at her nipples. She raised her hips and he fell from her pussy with a wet sound as his cock slapped against his stomach after leaving her pussy. She took hold of the cock and lined it up with her arse, it was impossible not to be tense. This was going to hurt. Biting her lip, she slowly lowered herself onto the cock. Her hands clenched the pew, her knuckles going white from the pain. She knew if she stopped and took it out then it would all start over again, breathing deeply she continued to push against his cock, pain shooting up her back. Ben moved slightly and she grimaced moaning in pain. Tears filled her eyes as his cock slid into her arse suddenly.

"Don't move Father," she stuck her tongue into his ear. Kayleigh lowered herself further into his cock. "Your cock is so big. It's hurting me Father. I don't know if I can take it," she called out. It hurt but she could handle it, the cameras wanted to see her struggle though. Half way down his cock now she stayed still kissing him deeply before yanking his hair back, she pulled his hair riding him slowly. "Its in my arse. There's no lube, it hurts so badly." She released his hair and grasped the pew again.

Jaimie was still being held in place as Todd worked his finger further into her arse. He was stimulating her clit as well with his other hand, occasionally sticking his finger into her. Her head was facing Kayleigh and she admired the woman's arse as she sank onto Ben's cock. At least she only had a finger in her for now. Her view was blocked by Gary as he shuffled around the alter, still holding her in place. She opened her mouth knowing exactly what he wanted. His cock was so thick she was worried it would catch her teeth.

"Hold your arse open," Todd instructed her, she reached back and opened her arse cheeks, gagging slightly as Gary pushed deeper into her mouth. She could feel saliva pooling under her face. His grip stopped her moving and at this angle she couldn't swallow properly.

Todd added a second finger, watching as Jaimie's hands clenched. He swatted at her arse. "Keep your hands still!". Jaimie whined, the pain spreading through her arse. Her legs were getting tired from resting on her knees for so long. Unable to move she flopped down onto her stomach laying flat, her legs hanging off the altar. Without a word Gary moved to the far end of the altar opposite Todd and pulled her fully onto the surface. Only her feet and head hung off the side.

"She doesn't seem to seek forgiveness. I tried to prep her. Father Gary, you may now take command." Todd removed his fingers from her arse, moving his hands to her upper back to hold her in place. Gary released her and leapt up onto the altar. He laid flat across Jaimie, his heavy weight and extra foot of height holding her in place.

Jaimie panicked she could feel Gary on top of her. She thought he would fuck her against the altar and the depth would be too much. No give in the hard surface would cause her agony. "Relax dear. This won't hurt me in the slightest," he snarled in her ear. She tensed as she felt him raise his hips. It wasn't her pussy he was going for.

"No, oh my god no. Don't do it. You'll tear me. I'm not ready. Please more lube." She started to sob, trying to drag herself free.

"We tried to assist you but you fought us. No you must repent." Todd explained. Placing his hand over her mouth as she began to scream. Gary was as gentle as he could be whilst holding the struggling woman below him. The head of his cock pressed against her arsehole. No woman had ever taken him in their arse. When Kayleigh had recommended the plan he had jumped at the opportunity. His cock slid into her arse surprisingly easy, she screamed. The screams echoed loudly, only stopping for her to take another breath. He stayed still having slipped in quicker then he had anticipated. He knew the pain would be intense, Jaimie's struggles were pushing him deeper and he tried to hold her still.

Jaimie was sobbing into Todd's hand, she had never felt anything like it. She wouldn't give in. Kayleigh never did! If the viewers wanted to see it then she would show them what she was capable of.

Kayleigh's head span around as the screaming started, she could feel Ben letting go of her tits and he shifted under her trying to see. This was something she needed to watch. She raised herself up and took Ben out of her arse, flinching as he left her.

Turning she lowered herself back onto his cock. Lining the cock up with her arse, she slowly lowered herself back into him, the pain was worth it to watch Jaimie get what she deserved. Leaning forwards she placed her hands flat on the floor. "They call this the lazy wheelbarrow, or so I've heard Father." Ben grinned back at her as she slowly ground her hips into him, he thrust gently rocking her back and forth. She groaned biting her lip to stop from calling out.