Lucky Man Ch. 21

"God, that must be awful when Duncan does it," he said.

Kelly giggled, nodding. "When we were newlyweds, he had a habit of doing that and then quickly apologize afterward. Eventually, we worked it out."

Conner smiled. "I just... want to be the type of guy... well... lover... that cares that the other person has fun, too," he said.

He hadn't stopped thrusting gently into her, and she began to feel her pussy getting tingly again, despite the obvious soreness.

"Mmmm," she said closing her eyes, "If it helps, you're making my naughty parts tingle... again..."

He laughed quietly at that, then focused on fucking her for the next few minutes.

"Do you feel... that?" she asked, flexing her Kegels and sending a wave of muscle contraction across his impressive cock.

"Fuck," he groaned. "God... damn... What was that?"

She did it again, eliciting a similar reaction and smiled. "That's me. I'm flexing my Kegels," she said.

Doing it again, he groaned, nodding. "God, I feel like I'm learning so much," he said, laughing.

She laughed quietly along with him, adding, "Well, that's good. At least you're learning."

He had to stop for a second, covering his mouth and recovering from the humorous banter, before they continued.

"What else can you do?" he asked.

She thought for a second, her legs spreading a bit. "Well, I'm super bendy," she told him. "Wanna see?"

He smiled, nodding and moving back a bit, his cock sliding just outside her lips.

Spreading and then lifting her legs, she nodded and slapped the back of her calves.

"Push here while you fuck me," she whispered.

Conner smiled, looking down and sliding his delightful cock back inside her. She groaned, liking the way it went in, realizing that she'd been missing it in the few moments it was gone.

Reaching up, he put his hand in place of hers and pushed, her knees bending and ankles going easily up near her ears. Giggling, she felt him start to fuck harder down into her.

"Ooo," she said, surprised at how good it felt. "That's pretty good."

He nodded. "It feels... like... I'm so deep..." he said.

She decided to take that as a compliment and nodded at him. After a few strokes, she felt her pussy quiver with pleasure, grunting and closing her eyes.

"That's good," she said. "You're fucking my sore little pussy so good," she whispered.

"Fuck, your pussy feels like heaven," he grunted. "I want to fill up that fuckin' pussy."

"You gonna fill up this pussy?" she asked, her dirty talking pushing her own orgasm dangerously close.

"Fuck yes," he grunted.

"Fuck me, baby," she begged. She saw Duncan rouse from his slumber then, smiling weakly at him as he looked at her, amused.

Great spasms of pleasure forced her to lose focus, and she felt Conner cumming deep inside of her quivering pussy as she shuddered from the orgasm. He was crying out loudly, his hips and cock pushing her orgasm higher with every stroke.

Finally, she felt the release and was able to cry out again, going limp and clutching for her husband.

Conner mumbled something after sliding off of her and staggered off to the bathroom.

After she recovered and had a quick, affectionate chat with her husband, she quietly promised herself to actually spend time with him, not just say that she would. She hoped that he didn't feel neglected by her, but knew that he probably didn't, or he would have spoken to her about it.

The shower went much as she'd told her husband. Conner had cleaned up for the most part, when she stepped in, and probably didn't think it was appropriate for him to shower with her, so he stepped out pretty quickly. Plus, she didn't think she could handle anymore sex, so she didn't protest when he did leave.

After a few minutes in the shower, she let the water drain and then drew a warm bath, soaking in it and letting her softer parts take advantage. Eventually, she had to hop out, thinking to let Duncan use it, but he was fast asleep.

Heading into the other room and not bothering to dress, she saw their girlfriend, Kara, talking and laughing with Danielle and Conner in the kitchen. It looked like they were talking about the night before.

"Hey," Kara said, standing and going over to kiss her good morning. "Fun night?"

Kelly smiled, nodding. "You could say that. It's a shame that you've sworn yourself to Duncan and me. That little fucker is fun to play with."

Kara snickered, glancing back as the other two talked.

"You going to be okay for tonight?" she asked.

Kelly nodded. "I'm going to take a nap in a bit, maybe one later too."

"Okay, hun," Kara said. "I'm gonna head up to The Mess Around and meet someone there, make sure everything is setup for tonight."

"Oh, I'm sorry," Kelly said. "I'll go with you if you want me to."

"What? No, you stay and rest," Kara told her. "You've had a long night and you need to be ready for this evening. It's going to be fun."

Kelly smiled. "That's a deal, then."

Kara affectionately talked with her a little more that morning, then left to go do what she needed to do. Seeing Danielle and Conner stand and go running to her bedroom, giggling as they went, Kelly chuckled and went to sit on the couch for a bit. That turned into a nap, and she stayed there for a while until she heard Danielle and Conner in the kitchen.

Yawning, she checked the clock and saw that it was close to noon. Standing, she went into the kitchen, seeing the two turn as soon as they saw her.

"You two still going at it?" she asked.

"Hi Mommy!" Danielle said, dancing over and kissing her.

"Mommy?" Kelly asked, wincing as she looked at her inquisitively.

"You know, like how I call Duncan, "Daddy!"" she said. "It's not the same?"

Kelly laughed, shaking her head. "You can call me that if you like, but I don't think that's how it works."

Danielle frowned for a second, but then shrugged. Conner came up behind her, kissing her on the shoulder and making her giggle in happy pleasure.

"God, babe," she said, "Are you hard again?"

"Well, fuck, I'm 19! Can you blame me?"

Danielle grinned, turning and kissing him.

"Is it okay if I go and fuck my ex-boyfriend in the living room?" she asked.

Kelly smiled. "Of course, duckling," she said.

Danielle grinned widely at hearing her old nickname. "Thanks Mommy!" she said.

Kelly winced, feeling the uncomfortable sting that she now realized Duncan felt each time the lunatic called him Daddy.

"God, that kid is weird," she whispered to no one.

Quietly, she entered her room again and pulled on some clothes, then went and started a load of towels. Kara arrived home soon after, and Duncan awoke a little after that.

After Duncan left for his errands, Kelly finished another load of clothes and started a third, then went and laid down in bed, grabbing her laptop and intending on checking her fan mail real quick.

After logging in, she browsed through the thirty or forty new emails, saving the good looking dicks and replying to the ones that actually wrote something. The last one was interesting. It was new and old at the same time, and it floored her, stopping her in her tracks.

Sitting up in bed, she pulled the laptop up into her lap and scooted back up against the pillows. Clicking the email open full screen, she read it once, and then again.

It read:

"Dear Kelly, Kissed by Fire,

Either I've lost my mind, or you're Kelly O'Sullivan.

I know it's not cool to out people like that, but... I have to know.

Hit me back and let me know"

She wasn't too surprised that someone recognized her from her past, but someone that knew her maiden name had to be someone from before college, or during college.

Quietly, she sat there thinking, wondering if she should email them back or not.

Eventually, she hit reply and settled in to write the mystery person a message.

"Mysterious Creepy Person,

You have me at a disadvantage. Yes, that was my maiden name, but I'm married now.

Who are you? Or are you unwilling to let me know?

- Kelly"

Reading it a couple of times, she nodded emphatically, satisfied with her reply, and sent it off. Smiling, she pushed the laptop aside and scooted down into the bed, sleep finding her quickly.

An hour or so later, she awoke feeling refreshed and much better than she did before. Yawning, she started to get up, but saw that she had five new emails. Two were from random fans, but the last three were from the mystery person.

"I'm not sure I should tell you, we didn't exactly part on the best of terms," was all the first one said.

"I tell you what, I'll send you a picture of my face now, and you can see if you remember me," comprised the entirety of the second.

The third was a picture, and she took a deep breath before clicking the attachment.

He looked a little older, of course, but he was still just as handsome as he'd been back in her college days. Still, her husband had him beat by a country mile. Smiling, she studied his face and confirmed that it was indeed Cooper, her college boyfriend that had purchased her nipple rings for her.

"Cooper! I can't believe that it's you!" she replied, sending the message.

He took a few minutes, but finally replied back.

"Yep. It's me. Do you think we can text over the phone?" he asked. "Would your husband mind?"

She giggled, quickly writing back.

"I assume you've seen my videos on Camille's Creations. My husband and I are deeply devoted to each other and like to share ourselves with a small group of other swingers. He won't mind me talking to you, but anything other than that, and he gets involved. Deal?"

She sent him the email and was surprised to get one back immediately.

"Deal. Is he a big guy?" he asked, adding his number to the email.

She smiled, punching his digits into her phone and adding Cooper to her contacts list.

"He's 6'3" and he's got a 10 inch dick," she sent. "Not only will he beat you up, he'll take your girlfriend and make her fall in love."

She began to feel a little bad for having sent that to him, not knowing how he'd take her playful banter. To her surprise, he sent a laughing emoji.

"Goddamn, I can't believe it's really you," he said. "What's more is, I can't believe I saw you on that website!"

She giggled. "Yep! That's me! Did you like what you saw?" she asked.

A new message arrived, and she covered her mouth in surprise when she saw it. Cooper was sitting on what looked like a couch, the phone angled up at his face, an erection visible in frame.

"Does that answer your question?" he asked.

She covered her mouth, quietly wondering if she was crossing any lines. Deciding that she was still okay, she sent a laughing emoji to him.

"That's hilarious!" she sent. "You realize I've never actually seen your dick?"

"Actually, I hadn't thought of that. I guess better late than never!"

Over the next hour or so, the two caught up.

Cooper was divorced but dating someone. It wasn't serious, but they liked to watch porn together, and it had been his girlfriend that had come across the site. He worked in sales for a large company, not too far away from where Kelly lived, a few hours away.

Kelly told him that she was head over heels in love with her husband but didn't feel like explaining the Kara situation. Cooper admitted that he was happy too, and things were going great with his girlfriend.

At the end of the conversation, Cooper admitted that he was sorry for cheating on her, but that he was glad to see that she still had the nipple piercings that he'd purchased.

"Well, you aren't too far away," she said. "Maybe the four of us can go on a double date one weekend?"

Cooper replied. "I think that would be awesome. I'll have to see how my girlfriend feels about getting railed by a big ass dick."

Kelly laughed, shaking her head. "I didn't say we were going to meet up and fuck, you jackass," she replied, adding a laughing emoji so he would know she wasn't serious. "Still, you never know what can happen. We'll probably have to find some way to pass the time while he's railing her."

He replied with the widely grinning one.

"Well, I better get some sleep. I had sex all night with a friend of a friend and we've got our weekly swinger party tonight," she sent, giggling at the expression she was imagining on his face.

"Jesus Christ," he said. "My dick is just gonna explode if we keep talking. Talk to you soon, Kel."

"Bye Cooper," she sent, setting her phone down and quietly musing about the conversation.

That eventually gave way to sleep, and she awoke to her husband smiling down at her from above, kneeling on her side of the bed.

"Hey sleepyhead," he said.

"Hi baby," she said, smiling and kissing him. "How was the visit with Camille?" she asked, yawning.

He smiled. "Casey was there and we looked at the shoot together. She got a little friendly."

Kelly grinned. "Oo, sexy time!"

He shook his head. "Nah, not really."

"Wait, is that the one from before that wouldn't shut up or the one you just worked with?"

He helped her sit up, gently pulling her hand. "The one I just worked with, athletic," he said. "She started kissing me and one thing led to another."

She snickered as he stood and stepped back, letting her turn and put her feet on the ground.

"Did you get some good rest?" he asked.

She smiled, nodding. "I've had two naps today," she said. "I'm feeling pretty rested now."

Standing, she slipped on some flip flops and looked up at him, his hand reaching for hers. "Sorry if that got out of hand last night."

He chuckled, shaking his head. "I knew the kid wouldn't want to stop at just one," he said. "I was like him too once, if you recall."

She smiled. "It was definitely fun," she said. "I might just have to stick to oral tonight, though."

"You sore?" he asked, frowning.

"Yeah," she said. "I took a warm bath and was hoping it would recover for tonight."

"Well, I think most folks might want to take it easy tonight. Maybe you'll be off the hook?"

She shrugged. "I mean, I wouldn't mind playing, I just don't know if I can."

He nodded, then stood and kissed her on the head. "I've got to go update Kara on her car," he said.

She needed to tell him about Cooper but figured she could find him in a minute. Standing, she went to the bathroom and relieved her bladder, then went to see what everyone else had been up to. When she went in the kitchen, she saw that Danielle had finished all of the laundry and was cleaning the kitchen.

"Good afternoon, Mistress," Danielle said coming over to stand in front of her.

Kelly smiled. "Good afternoon, slut," she said, eliciting a grin from her. "You finished all the laundry?"

She smiled and nodded.

"Thank you, sweetheart," she said. Going over to the fridge, she poured herself a glass of cold water and took a sip, then went and sat on a bar stool.

"So, tell me something," she said, looking at the blonde as she went back to cleaning. "Were you really okay that Conner chose me?"

Danielle smiled, looking up from the stove. "You're like the fourth person to ask me that. I totally am! I got to have my choice for my first guy, and even if Conner had been there and been an option, I would have chosen Duncan. I'm totally glad for a him that he got to be with you for his first. It's kinda fitting."

The two discussed some particulars about the night before, then Kelly went to find her husband and hopefully Kara and finish her discussion from earlier. She found them both in the living room, flipping through the channels and talking, her feet in his lap.

"Got a second?" she asked.

They both looked up and smiled, Duncan patting the seat next to him. "What's going on?"

She came in and sat down next to him. "Well, I wanted to let you both know something. I didn't want you to find out later somehow and think I was trying to hide it."

He smiled. "This is about the open marriage thing, isn't it?"

She shrugged, "Kinda, I guess?"

"Did you have sex with the mailman?" he asked.

She snickered and shook her head. "No, of course not."

"Sorry, go ahead," he said, seeing that she was a little hesitant and trepidatious.

"It's not a big deal or anything. I just connected with an old boyfriend," she said.

He looked at her in surprise. She quickly assessed his mood and reaction, sensing that he was just surprised and not really concerned. Kara was slightly bemused but listening.

"Yeah," she confirmed. "Cooper, from college. The one before you."

He smiled. "Ah, the dude that bought the piercings and didn't get to see them."

"Poor guy," Kara said.

She nodded, smiling. "I was checking fan mail and his was the last one. He knew my maiden name and asked if it was really me. I probably shouldn't have, and I won't in the future, but I confirmed that it was me and that was when he sent me his picture."

"Dick?" Duncan asked, smirking.

She giggled. "No, dick-for-brains," she said, using a quote she'd gotten from a movie she'd recently seen. "He sent me a picture of his face, and I confirmed who it was. So, we got to talking and he asked if we could text since it would be easier than email."

Duncan smiled, putting a hand up and interrupting her. "Honey," he said. "It's okay."

"What?" she asked.

"You don't have to tell me every detail, unless you wanted to. I mean, Kara might want you to, but it's okay with me. You're not planning on running off and leaving us for the guy, right?"

She rolled her eyes at the notion. "I didn't date him but a few weeks in college and all we ever did was kiss. I think he saw me topless a few times, but never got to see my piercings. Honestly, the first thing I thought was that you were so much more handsome than he was."

Duncan rolled his eyes. "Honey, come on."

She turned, shaking her head. "No, seriously. I did!"

He nodded, chuckling, but didn't look like he believed her. She figured he thought she was placating his ego instead.

"I really did, I promise. I actually felt a little bad that I was immediately glad that the two of us ended up together because you're more attractive. I mean, the guy isn't ugly or anything."

Duncan nodded. "Okay, I believe you baby."

"You don't look like you do," Kara said, jabbing him with her elbow.

Duncan winced and frowned playfully at her, squeezing her knee.

She let it go at that point, focusing instead on continuing her story.

"So, we texted for awhile. I asked him what he thought about what he'd seen of me online, and if he liked them, and he sent me a picture of his erection."

She looked up at the two and saw only amusement.

"So, I pointed out that he hadn't ever had the chance to show that to me before. After that, we just caught up and talked about how and what we were doing now."

"And?"

"Well, he's semi-recently divorced, but he's been dating a girl. He said that they like to watch porn together and admitted that she was the one that found the site I was on."

"So, are we gonna hang out some time?" Duncan asked.

She smiled. "Well, I might have suggested a double date at some point in the future. It would be nice to see him again."

Kara giggled.

"Oh, damn, I'm sorry," Kelly said. "I wasn't including you in that."

She shook her head, dismissing the notion. "I don't have to be included in everything you guys do. I'm sure you and I will do things and Duncan and I do things. Don't worry about it too much."

Kelly smiled, and Duncan put his arm around Kara.

"I do appreciate you having me in the conversation, though," Kara added. "I feel... included."

"You are," Kelly pointed out. "I realized that I have like... a real girlfriend."

She smiled, as did Kara.

Duncan smiled. "You're ridiculous," he said.

"What?" she asked.

"You were so concerned about telling us about Cooper and don't really see the irony of what's been going on."