Neighbor's New Fucktoy

*Any resemblance to real-life situations is coincidence, this is a work of pure fiction*

It's been two summers since the older and attractive Mr. Johnson moved in next door. Sarah often thinks back to that summer day, when she was freshly 18 and found herself lusting over the mysterious stranger whose muscles strained against his gloriously tight shirt as he lugged in boxes from the moving van. While she didn't know exactly what brought him to the house next door, she was incredibly grateful to have noticed a convenient lack of a wife or child helping him move in or inhabiting the house in the month following, before she left for college. This made it easier for her to imagine herself sneaking over in the dead of night, getting on her knees, and showing him just how much she wanted him. Unfortunately, that fall marked the beginning of her college career and the end of her midnight fantasy escapades with the delicious Mr. Johnson. Oh, how her knees got weak at the thought of her hands in his salt and pepper hair and his mouth exploring every inch of her hungry flesh. He would occasionally smile at her and give a polite greeting when he ran into her in the mornings, his olive complexion soaking up the dawn. These little interactions made her heart flutter and her clit pound as she thought about leaping into his arms, kissing him until her mouth went numb, and letting him ravage her body.

*****

It's been a couple of years and more than a couple of fucks since she first laid eyes on Mr. Johnson. With her newfound independence at college, Sarah sought to show her young, curvy body off and under anybody who'd ask. This was her way of establishing herself as her own woman since back home, her overprotective father had prevented anyone with sexual inclinations for her from coming within a 5 mile radius of their house. It was, in fact, thanks to her fantasies of Mr. Johnson and a little toy she was able to smuggle into her house that she didn't go absolutely feral with lust. When her parents asked her to house-sit for the first couple of weeks of her summer break, all of the emotions she felt for Mr. Johnson flooded back through her body and she was determined to get the real thing this time, without the interference of her parents.

After dropping off her bags in her old bedroom, Sarah examined herself in the mirror before going over to Mr. Johnson's. Since she was traveling, Sarah opted for a simple white crop top that covered only a little bit of skin under her tits and decided to remove the bra just for him. Examining her shorts, they looked fashionably tattered and struggled to hug her ass as a bit peeked out from the bottom. "This should do the trick, any boy back at uni would start drooling if they saw me like this. Hopefully Mr. Johnson is the same way", Sarah mused until she decided to pull one more trick out of her arsenal. She reached for and pulled the strings of her red thong up so they were visible, but not too obvious about what her intentions were.

She quickly put her dark brown hair up with a hair clip, grabbed her phone, and left her house determined and a little nervous. She rang the bell and waited for what felt like the longest 10 seconds of her life. The sight that beheld her when the door opened made her bite her lip in excitement and anticipation. Mr. Johnson seemed to not have aged at all since he first moved in. His tan muscles bulged against his tight shirt and his grey sweatpants hugged all the right places. His hair was damp and messy as if he just got out of the shower. "Hi Mr. Johnson, it's Sarah. I know we didn't really get to be introduced to each other before I left for college, but I just wanted to pop over and say hello and let you know that I am going to be at my parents next door while they're away for a couple of weeks. For, uh,.... safety purposes."

Mr. Johnson, or Rick, was taken aback when this sexy little twenty-something appeared on his doorstep and introduced herself. "Oh, thank you for letting me know. And, feel free to call me Rick. Would you like my number for emergencies since you're going to be by yourself?" Feeling his dick hardening in his boxers, Rick prayed that she didn't notice although something was telling him that that is what she was trying to achieve in the first place.

"Oh yeah! That would be great! Thank you! Maybe we could get to know each other a little more while I'm here, too", Sarah said earnestly, just excited to have access to his number. As Rick typed his number into her phone, Sarah drank him in and saw what she had been dreaming of for the past two years making an appearance in his pants. She smiled to herself and took back her phone, "Thanks Rick!" As she walked back towards her house, she made sure to go slowly and sway her hips side to side for him. It wasn't until she reached her door that she heard his shut.

Once he finally closed his door, Rick could not believe his luck. Sarah, the daughter of his two homely neighbors showed up to his door in barely any clothing and put on a show for him that he would gladly watch any day. She was like a forbidden fruit that he wanted to take a bite out of. "Okay, okay I have to be careful. I don't want to scare her off and I definitely don't want her dad coming after me with a pitchfork" Rick muttered to himself as he went to his kitchen window that directly faced hers and saw her bent over, picking something up. While definitely confident, a part of him doubted if he was even interpreting her signals correctly. Why would a young college girl want him when she clearly didn't need to work to get anyone's attention? Regardless, he knew what he saw and his dick was painfully aware of what he felt.

Rick decided the next morning to message her nonchalantly, "How was your first night alone? Everything go smoothly?"

Sarah almost leapt up when she saw that he had messaged her, but decided that right now, she needed to find a way to get into his house, "yeah, but I wanted to make myself some coffee but found that my parents are all out :("

"Would you want to come over and have a cup? I'm making some right now."

"that would be perfect, I'll be right over!"

Sarah anxiously got up off her bed and fixed herself in her mirror. Her outfit had to be sexy, accessible, and inconspicuous. She had decided on a black top with spaghetti straps and a pink mini-skirt that left little to the imagination when she spun. The top barely contained her tits and she opted out of her bra, hoping it was a little chilly in his house to up the tease-factor. She slipped on some sandals and tussled her hair to make it look like she just woke up before heading out. As she looked in the mirror one last time, she thought to herself, *Yeah, he wants me.*

Rick opted this time to wear a robe, thinking that any boner that would inevitably make an appearance would be less discernable. As the pot started, he heard three knocks and jogged to the door. As he opened the door, he could not believe his eyes, how could she wake up looking so hot?! "Good morning, the kitchen is right this way, I can also make some eggs if you're hungry."

"I think just the coffee will do, Rick, thanks."

"Sorry, it's not done yet, you'll have to wait a bit."

"That's fine, I'm in no rush. It's not like I have anywhere to be right now", Sarah assured him as she sat down and rested her elbows on his table.

*So, she's dressed like that just for me...holy crap I need to find a way into her pants or invest in tissues*, Rick thought. "Really? How's school going, I bet you're really popular with the boys, no?"

"What's that supposed to mean?"

"Oh! Uh...nothing, I mean-"

"It's fine, Rick, I understand and actually, I am. My parents think I am off to school to study science when in reality I am conducting a study of my own, how fast can I get in a boy's bed. But, I've grown tired of all of these boys running around me, trying to get my attention. No, what I want is a man, someone older and with more experience. Kind of like you", Sarah said confidently. She loved saying his name and tried to pepper it in whenever she could. But as soon as the words left her mouth, she saw his jaw drop and started blushing profusely, praying he was going to say something.

When Rick heard her say she wanted someone 'like him', his dick immediately hardened and he didn't know what to say. But, he definitely knew what he wanted to do. After a couple of painfully silent seconds, Rick realized it's been a while since he said anything and replied, "Wow, erm, I'm flattered. But, uh, do you know how old I am? I'm old enough to be your father."

Grateful for the response, Sarah flirtatiously responded, "Does that mean you want me to call you daddy?"

Taking that as approval, Rick immediately told her to "get your sexy ass over here" and kissed her fiercely. As their mouths met and exchanged greetings, Rick picked her up and carried her onto his kitchen table with her straddling him. Sarah's thin excuse for a panty was thoroughly soaked at this point as she fumbled to remove her top. Once her tits sprang free, Rick moaned and groped them like it was the last thing he's ever do. Separating himself from her, Rick said, "Now let me show you how a real man does it." He resumed to kissing her, but started trailing down to her neck and then her pert tits. He took his time to play with each nipple, circling them with his tongue before sucking on her nipples while his tongue continued toying with them. She moaned above him, "Oh god, yes!"

He quickly stood to face her and stated that he took her seriously before and that when she was with him, she would be calling him daddy. She looked at him and realized just how much she loved being bossed around by him, nodding furiously.

He passionately kissed her, making his way down her stomach and to her pussy, temporarily hidden by her skirt. Instead of ripping it off, Rick instead decided to keep it on, knelt on the ground, and faced her pussy under her skirt.

In one swift motion, Rick grabbed her thin panties, took them off and put them in his robe pocket for later. Now there was nothing that separated him from his prize. He grabbed her ass and pulled her pussy to his mouth, licking in between her delicate folds.

"Oh god, daddy, I love it when you lick my pussy", Sarah moaned.

Rick found her clit, throbbing, and began licking around it, careful not to touch it. He wanted to keep her coming back to him. He circled around it with his tongue while she writhed above him, lost in pleasure that had not been delivered to her before. After a minute of teasing, Rick sucked on her clit, playing with it using his tongue as he did so. Sarah gripped his salt and pepper hair as he did so, feeling her climax approaching. Rick moved his mouth from her clit and instead started slowly licking the length of her young pussy. Sarah grunted in frustration, but not exactly disappointed in what he started doing. Rick found her slit and slipped in his tongue, eager to taste her juices and feel them drip down his chin. Sarah held him tighter and started breathing quickly. After what felt like a couple minutes of doing this, Rick went back to sucking her clit and playing around with the little bean. Sarah started moaning louder and shifting around his face. Taking this as a good sign, Rick started gently flicking her clit with his tongue and then running his whole tongue down it. Sarah couldn't take this and was only able to muster out, "daddy...." before a jolt of electricity shot up her spine and made her eyes roll back in pure pleasure.

She leaned back on the table and looked up at him. He went to kiss her again and as she ran her hands through his salt and pepper hair, a shiver ran down her spine, "I want your cock"

"I want your cock, what?"

"I want your cock daddy"

In a second, he ripped off his robe and his cock sprung out, unrestrained by underwear and already dribbling precum. Sarah got off the table and went down to her knees, "You're so big, daddy. Bigger than any of the boys I've had."

Rick looked down at her and smirked, "Now beg for me"

"Please let me suck your cock daddy. Please, I need it in my mouth, I need to taste your cum. I want my face to be fucked by your cock, daddy"

In response, Rick grabbed his cock and lightly slapped her face with it, leaving behind little trails of precum on her face, "Yeah, you like this, don't you slut. You like it when I hit your face with my cock."

"Yes daddy"

"Show me how much you want my cock"

Sarah reached up and grabbed his cock with her hands, before he swatted them away, "No, show me what your mouth can do".

Sarah leaned into his cock, still on her knees with her hands behind her back, and slowly licked the shaft of his dick before swirling her tongue around the tip of her dick. As he started to breathe harder, she slowly pushed his cock in her mouth, inch by inch until she couldn't anymore without gagging.

"Does my little slut like to gag on daddy's dick?"

In response, she moaned "Mhmm" and continued pushing her mouth up and down Rick's dick while making sure to let her tongue do the exploring. Rick hadn't felt bliss like this in a long time. He looked down and saw her struggle to keep it all in her sweet little mouth. He smiled to himself, just thinking about what he was going to do to her tight little pussy. After three minutes, Rick grabbed Sarah's hair and began taking charge, "Did my little slut say she wanted to get face fucked?"

"MMMhmmmm", Sarah moaned as his dick filled her mouth. Rick began using Sarah's hair to steady himself and started thrusting into her mouth, making her gag every so often. Rick could feel himself getting closer to cumming and started thrusting faster, causing Sarah to moan and gag more.

"My little slut doesn't spit. She swallows, got it?"

Sarah nodded furiously, barely able to think straight, much less say anything.

With the last pump, Rick shoved his dick down her throat, pumping her mouth full of his cum while she knelt there, touching herself.

As his cum pumped into her willing mouth, Sarah couldn't help playing with her clit thinking of all the times she had fantasized about this. Rick had Sarah clean off his dick with her mouth before removing it with a satisfying pop, "It looks like you really enjoyed me fucking your face." Sarah blushed, "yes, daddy. I couldn't help but think about you fucking my pussy next and cumming inside me."

Rick looked down at her having just swallowed a load and touching herself and felt his dick getting hard again, "Fuck," he thought "at this rate, she's going to be coming back every day." While he offered her a hand up and went to get a glass of water, Rick was also thinking of every different way he can fuck the tight girl standing in his kitchen this summer with only a skirt on without inciting the wrath of his neighbors, who he knew to be overbearing at times.

After she finished drinking the glass of water, Rick picked up Sarah so that she was once again straddling him and he felt his cock was ready for Round 2. He carried her to his bedroom and lightly tossed her onto his bed, ready to truly claim her as his. "Does my little slut want me to fuck her pussy?"

"Yes daddy, please"

He bent down and smacked her ass lightly, "I need you to be a little louder than that"

"Yes daddy, please fuck my little pussy!", Sarah loudly moaned, her body anxious to be filled by Rick's thick cock.

"That's more like it", Rick grabbed her legs and tossed them over his shoulders, positioning his dick at her entrance. First, he circled her slit with his dick, listening to her moans of delight. Then he slowly thrust his dick forward, continuing until he was completely inside of her. He continued this slow movement, allowing her to adjust to his dick while picking up speed with each thrust.

With her back on the bed, Sarah gripped the sheets around her as her hole was completely filled by Rick. She had never felt so full and thanked god that this dick was going to be pounding her pussy each day until she left for university once more. "oh, daddy", she moaned, "faster". Following her cue, Rick picked up the pace, relishing in how her light skirt was bunched at the waist as her legs fell on his shoulders and her titties bounced with each thrust. He was transfixed by them and reached down to grab them and play with her nipples, to the sheer delight of Sarah. After two minutes of Sarah's moaning and pure ecstasy on both ends, Rick abruptly pulled out and pulled her up.

Confused, Sarah stood up and was about to say something until she realized that Rick was laying down so she could ride his delicious dick and have her pussy impaled by him. Sarah climbed on top of him and cautiously lowered herself onto his dick because of just how much it took up every inch of space inside her. When she was completely lowered, she couldn't help but moan, "oh daddy, your dick feels so good inside me, oh god." Rick grabbed her ass cheeks and directed her to show him just how much she learned at college.

Feeling her nipples harden at the mention of the experience she gained on her own, she bounced on Rick's dick, moaning, "oh, daddy, yes!" She moved her hips in circles, seeking desperately to please this man that sent waves of pleasure coursing through her.

Rick was entranced by her bouncing tits as she rode him, wanting to reach out and grab them. To play with them, like they are his own personal play things. "Well, they basically are mine to play with", he thought as Sarah masterfully grinded on him. Just as he was about to have her dismount and get on her knees, Rick felt Sarah's pussy clench around his dick and heard her yell, "Oh daddy!!! Oh god, yes!!" As she sat on him, waves of pleasure coursing through her, Rick wished that he could have this image forever burned into his brain. After a couple of seconds, Rick could feel himself getting more and more lost in pleasure, and decided that he needed her on her knees. Now.

"Alright, my little slut, I need you to get on your knees for daddy", Rick directed as Sarah stared dreamily ahead.

"Oh, anything for you daddy", she listlessly replied as she dismounted and pointed her ass in the air.

Rick could feel his own climax approaching as her flowy skirt attempted to hide her pussy. He lifted it and positioned it at her entrance and suddenly thrust. Sarah moaned, caught a little off guard by the sudden entrance but not at all disappointed. Rick held her hips and fucked her relentlessly, her tits bouncing beneath her and moans wantonly escaping her mouth as she could do nothing but take it all in. "Yeah, you're my little slut, huh. You want every inch of this dick filling you?"

"Yes daddy! Please use me as your little fucktoy daddy!"

With that declaration, Rick could feel Sarah's pussy once more clench around his dick, triggering his own climax once more. He did one final thrust into her ravaged pussy, filling her with his cum. After a couple of seconds, he pulled out his cock and could see a little bead of his cum at her pussy entrance. She collapsed on his bed, knees weak and never wanting to leave.

Rick took a look at his work, proud that this 20 year old wanted to be his own personal fuck toy, then glanced back at the kitchen and declared, "You know, I think our coffee might be ready."