Sarah's Naughty Decision

Story Info
The story of Sarah and Marks accidental cuckold.
5.5k words
3.13
47.7k
47

Part 1 of the 2 part series

Updated 06/13/2023
Created 02/09/2023
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

We had never done it before, so the anticipation was at an all time high. Our nerves were through the roof and excitement elevated. Were we really going to do this? I can't believe it's happening. chills ran through my body. We finished up the profile and slammed the laptop shut. I was hard as a rock. With my heart pounding and scared to shit for what we had just started. I looked over into Sarah's eyes. She had a grin of anxiousness across her face. I could tell she was nervous. I loved Sarah. She was the girl of my dreams. A soft personality with a touch of the wild side. Her mischievous side mainly appeared behind closed doors, but she also knew how to have fun out in public. A reserved young women, with a polite and caring personality.

Sarah wasn't exactly a prude but she wasn't one for going out acting like a tramp. She was the right temperature of hot and cold. A healthy medium. A silent slutty side to her. Sarah enjoyed low cut tops and short skirts. Which worked out good. It was a way for me to peer into the darker side of her desires. She never quite said it, but I could tell she had some fantasies buried deep deep within. And wow did she look good in what she wore. She had a knack for finding sexy clothes that, I swear, were almost like they were made for her. What a body.

  God I loved that body. Those tits. Just the perfect size in a low cut crop top. They were always just begging to push out. One strong hug and I swear they would have nursed any shirt at the seems.. They really complimented her tight waist and cute little ass. The perfect fit for a hand to squeeze. Or spank if the mood was right. 

 

 As the night went on, my beautiful wife's smile slowly faded to a blank stare. A dull look of dissatisfaction across her face. With our favorite TV series playing in the background, I couldn't help but notice her enthusiasm from an hour prior had completely faded. "What's wrong sweetheart" I asked. She looked down and showed me her phone. There were no new notifications.

I turned my attention to her.. "I thought this new world only wanted to fuck. "That's what these dating profiles are for. Aren't they?"

I got close to her and put my arm over her shoulder. "Don't worry" I told her. "We will get a message sooner or later, and if not, we can always try another site. I mean it's only been 1 hour right? Give it time." She felt discouraged and I knew it. But to be honest after how much convincing I had to do, I was taken away about how she was the one really wanting it. We got close and turned out attention back to the TV.

Cheering her up wasn't really my strong suit so I remained silent and put her feet in my hand. She loved when I did that. She gave me a little smirk and we continued watching our show. "Don't forget to use the cream. I need my feet soft at all times!" Sarah new when to boss me around.

 

Chapter 2

I headed downstairs for breakfast and to greet my wife in the kitchen. Wearing nothing but panties and a bra, she poured me a fresh cup of coffee and handed me my food. She always knew how to get my attention. My 30 year old wife looked like she had the body of a college student.

Just looking at her made my dick hard. I had never been backed up this much before. At least before I could satisfy myself in the shower. But we agreed to waiting and I did not want to ruin this for us. However, my frustrations began to grow, and my parts felt heavy. I desperately needed some release.

Two weeks had gone by, and apart from the messages from scammers soliciting their favorite crypto currency, and the young bucks trying to score a quickie. We didn't manage to find a suitable match on the dating site we had signed up for. At least I thought. Sarah always tried to change the topic when I tried to dig into the details. It wasn't looking good for us.

The lack of sex was driving me crazy. I was ready to explode in my pants. Sarah had forbid me from pleasuring myself since this was my idea. My erections were starting to hurt and she said I wouldn't get release until she had her "man of choice." I walked up to Sarah and tried to get a little morning action. Something to relieve a little bit of the pressure. She quickly stopped me. "Hey! Slow down mister! It was your idea, you took the time to convince me of this, so you will wait patiently. Just as I have had to." She had a firm tone of rejection in her voice. I knew I had little chance of getting between those legs.

"I can't wait another night." I snarled back. "Either find someone on the site today, or we fuck each others brains out. Just the two of us. I need to be inside you. I want to feel your warmth around my cock."

She smiled at me and let out a giggle. "Careful big guy, you had better watch that potty mouth. Don't make me give you the punishment you deserve."

Punishment? I thought to myself. "What could she possibly mean by punishment." I was never one to partake in whips or anything. I'm not against it, but it's definitely not something I would push. 

I sipped the last bit of my coffee, got up and gave Sarah a big kiss on the cheek. "I love you sweetheart." She smiled, handed me my briefcase and walked me to the door. As I walked out, she opened up the door far enough so any passerby could see. My jaw dropped. This behaviour was not like her. "Don't be late Mark." She yelled. "I have a surprise for you when you get home." My heart sank and my knees felt weak. "You found someone on the site?" I asked with a shocked look on my face. "No, but I think it's time we had a little fun," as she smiled and winked again. 

I walked off to my car with a big grin on my face. "Wow so I get laid tonight. And I fuckin need it too. My dick is in like a permanent boner. I can't wait to fill that tight pussy."

Chapter 3

After working a long day, I grabbed a quick bite in the local drive through, and headed home. "Wow 8pm already? Sarah is going to kill me." I pulled into the driveway, hopped out of the car and put the keys in the front door. Slowly walking in, I called out to Sarah "guess who's home." I received no response. After wondering around the house with no luck in finding her, I decided to check the least likely place she could be. "That's right! The bedroom. I just hope she isn't upset that I'm late." Slowly creeping up to the room in anticipation of finding her. I push open the bedroom door. The lights are off and the room is lit by soft scented candles, with rose petals on the bed. She must be in the en suite bathroom. "Good, I can quickly clean up." I whispered to myself as I ran back downstairs. It was happening. "Fuck ya, finally. Two whole weeks of boners and frustration." I scurried downstairs to quickly rinse off In the basement shower. "Quick shampoo and body wash, and I'll be ready to go."

I quickly dried off with a hand towel, threw my suit back on and ran upstairs. "Honey you in here." 

She slowly walked around the corner. There she was standing at 5'5" wearing some sexy lingerie I had never seen before. My God she looked good. That blonde hair draping down her pushed up breasts. Fuck, I love when she dyes her hair blonde. She's a natural brunette, but look incredibly slutty with that golden hair. She walked slowly and sexually towards me with her fingertips lightly grazing the wall next to her. "Welcome home big man." She lightly whispered to me. She could see the excitement pushing through my pants. 

Her outfit was something straight out of a porn flick. It got me hard as a rock. Those black high heels with the lace stockings to match. Her thin smooth lower legs looked long and toned with thighs thick and juicy. I wanted to put my face between them. "Holy shit, I can't wait to fuck this slut." Holding up those sexy stockings was a tiny black garter belt. With no thong protecting her tight pussy. It was clean shaven and primed for a good fuck. It was amazing how hot she looked. It was nearly impossible to take my eyes off of that cute belly button piercing she decided to put back in. Just the right amount of dangle. The sparkling diamond in it made her look spoiled. Sarah made her way closer, She gently brought two fingers down to her thighs and slid them up to her tight lips. Barely touching it, but still managing to get a bit of her juices on her hand. I nearly fell over. Her fingers running up her body past her skin tight corset. It was nothing short of a miracle that this thing remained on her body. Those big tits just aching to be released. 

"Unbuckle that belt and take a seat Mark" she said with a perverted grin. "I have some fun in mind"

I unbuckled my belt quickly and took a seat like a good boy. "What kind of fun?" I asked. "I notice it's just the two of us. We don't need that stupid app anyway. I'm going to make you scream in pleasure"

Sarah nodded her head in agreement. "Honey, tonight is all we need. But I have special plans for you." 

She had a weird tone to her voice, but I chose to ignore it and began taking my off my clothes. She didn't stop me from rushing, so I kept pace only to end up in my boxers. "Take those off too, you won't be needing them. You are getting your reward tonight." She smiled and began pacing back in forth like a horny model.

"Have you been a good boy or a bad boy today?" she asked. I smiled with a big grin. "A bit of both baby. What's my prize." She pushed me back on the chair and put a blindfold on my face. My dick got harder. Its not a very big dick. I am average size at best, but all the teasing and waiting made me feel huge. I was 6 on a good day, but knew how to use my equipment. Sarah leaned over me. I could smell her light perfume. She was using the expensive stuff tonight. Sarah, Gently grabbing my wrists, pushed them behind me. "Put those back there. I'm in control tonight." I couldn't complain, this caused her big chest to press up against my mouth and I rarely got to see her dominant side. The warmth gave me chills.

*Click* what was that. I could no longer pull my arms back. Was I just handcuffed?

This was well beyond our normal play. The anxiousness of what she might do to me was overwhelming. My heart began to beat fast. *Click*. My legs too? She closed them really tight. I couldn't move. Sarah came close and sat down on my lap facing me. I could feel her breath in my mouth. The smell of the lip gloss had a hint of strawberry. We must have been incredibly close to kissing. But she backed off. "Kiss me you dirty sllll" I tried to talk. But felt a large push up against my lips. The push got harder and deeper and something was in my mouth. I couldn't get out any words. I had been gagged. The sound of packing tape began to unwind and instantly wrap around my head. "Wow she has gone full kink tonight. I kind of like it. This is way out of her norm."

The tape line cut, and began starting again. As if the restraints were not enough. Sarah had begun to tape my arms and legs to the chair. My cock began to throb. Her soft gentle hands restraining me aggressively. She seemed determined. Sarah clearly didn't want me to escape. Her breasts still in my face and light silky hair tickling my thighs. I felt her push off and slowly make her mouth down from my neck to my dick.  

The wetness and soft feeling of her tongue gently slid across the shaft of my cock. And suddenly the feeling of nothing. "Where did she go. I couldn't help but wonder what she had planned for the night. I was incredibly aroused.

About a minute went by. With my cock still harder than ever, I slowly began feeling the blindfold drop down my face. "WHAT THE FUCK. She said she didn't meet anyone on the site. Who is this." There he was. In front of me stood a 6'3" man with light brown hair and a well toned torso. His athletic build made me instantly feel intimidated and self conscious. My eyes began creeping up past his well endowed cock. His 8 inches made me look really small. The girth complimented the length and firmness. My eyes continued higher past his well cut abs and up to his firm pecks. "You have got to be fucking kidding me."

I tried to move and get Sarah's attention. "There is no way she is fucking this guy. We agreed to a threesome"

"Honey, I thought long and hard over the past two weeks about our little, agreement." She said with a small pause. "And came to the conclusion, that if you don't mind another man fucking me with you. Than you probably don't mind one fucking me while you watch. I mean, after all. You are still technically here with us. Doesn't that still count?" The rage in me began to boil. "How could she do this to me." My heart began to pound out of my chest. I could feel my heavy sack begin to tingle. One throb, two throb, three throbs! I tilted my head back and felt a slight tingle all over my body. I let out a small muffled grunt as my face began to turn red. I was utterly ashamed. The warm liquid started to run down the shaft of my cock. I could feel the juices flow between my thighs. "Oh my God. Why the fuck am I cumming. I cant help it This is so humiliating." Hoping They didn't see, I shuffled quickly to try and hide any evidence. To no luck at all, I still couldn't move.

Sarah walked her way back to the man. "This is Jake" she said with a twinkle in her eye. "I met him at the mall yesterday. He helped me pick out this lingerie. Do you like it?" I nodded my head in agreement. "Fuck! Why did I just agree with her?" I tried to wiggle free. To at least get a word out. The tape was just too tight.

Sarah leaned into Jake and kissed him with her glossy lips. Her knee pulling up to his big dick, and her arm over his neck. The chemistry between the two was evident. The make out session got more aggressive and passionate. Jake ran his big hands down her smooth body. He aggressively grabbed her ass and began to lift her off the ground. Sarah turned her head upwards and smiled with great pleasure. Her hands and legsnow wrapped around his body while he began passionately kissing her neck. I could see him starting to stiffen up. His big member gently sliding in between my wife's thighs. softly grazing her tight wet lips. The heat of the candle flame could be seen reflecting off of their bodies.

Jake walked her over to the bed and sat down. Sarah with her legs straddling him, slid her way off. She seductively began kissing from his mouth down to his naval. She glanced over at me with that devilish smile. It felt like a bullet to my chest. My idle cock began to swell. Sarah started moving her way to his firm tool. Her soft silky hands placed a firm grip on his thighs as he popped his cock hard up to her cheek. Jake was aroused. The sense of enjoyment and delight could be seen in his eyes. The thoughts of taking someones wife drove his ego and pleasure higher. He loved the thought of me being emasculated.

Jake wasted no time and placed his hand on the back of Sarah's head. With a quick push, Sarah had her mouth full of his cock. Jake had began to claim my wife. His large cock thrusting into the back of Sarah's throat. "Oh my God. She is actually sucking this guy off." I thought with pain. "She cant take this back now." The tingling began to grow inside my body as Sarah began to embrace Jake's dominance. Sarah seemed to enjoy the alpha male as she bob her head up and down. She licked up and down the shaft, slurping and savoring the warm spurts of precum. Sarah's hands looked so small while she was gripping the large Cock. Her confidence growing with every stroke. The sounds of wetness and small gags filled the room. Jake's head flipped back in pleasure. Sarah began to speed up. Her mouth getting really aggressive as his cock slid deeper down her throat. From a distance I could see his sack tightening. He was about to explode down her into her warm mouth. "Stop and get that tight ass on the bed" Jake said with a dominant tone. "Spread those legs you little slut."

Jake had a smooth sound to his voice. Really sexy and confident. "Hey Mark! Your wifes mouth is really warm. She swallowed a couple loads over there. Did you notice?" Jake began taunting me." The humiliation made my tongue feel numb. I had no way of responding back.

Sarah took Jakes big cock out of her mouth. As a small drip of cum slowly leaked from the corner of her lips, she quickly took two fingers and pushed it back in. Sarah swallowed it and smiled. With an excited look on her face she climbed onto the bed and spread her legs for Jake. "No please don't." I mumbled into the gag and tape. "Whats that honey." she said. "You want him to fuck me good? Don't worry, I'm sure Jakes big dick will stretch me out good. Oh whats that? you don't want him to use a condom? "Did you here that Jake?" Jake Nodded with a smile. "You no longer have to wrap that thick juicy dick. You get to shoot that big load up my tight pussy." Sarah took a firm grip of Jakes hanging cock. "Its so fucking big. Way bigger than my husbands. I want you to pound me infront of him. I want Mark to watch you claim his innocent wife." Sarah began talking in a way I had never heard before.

The room began to warm up. The heat from the three bodies grew. Mark could see small beads of sweat begin to drip down Jakes muscular back. The moisture gave a shiny reflection glow off of his large biceps.

Sarah, Laying on the bed with her legs wide open, was ready to fuck. Her tight pussy dripping wet from the heat and anticipation. Jake climbed up and positioned himself over top of her. "I want you to eat my pussy." Sarah cried out. "No way baby. That's what husbands do." He replied with confidence. Sarah smiled with her mouth open. She was shocked, but appeared to have loved what he said. Sarah, turned on, let out a soft moan and collapsed her elbows and fell flat on the bed. Perfectly over top of her, Jake began to slide the head of his cut cock up against Sarah's wet primed lips. They both let out a deep breathe as Jake began forcing his way in. Sarah pressed her hand against Jake's chest and let out a loud moan. I could see her pussy begin to stretch further and further as every thick inch dove into her womb. Sarah's hands gripped the soft bed sheets and her toes began to curl. Her eyes shut and her head tilted back. Goosebumps began covering her arms and legs, she let out another load moan. With her knees beginning to shake, I could tell she was receiving an immense amount of pleasure. The excitement of taking another mans cock drove her to a world of lust.

Jake gave one final thrust. He was fully in. He began to fuck back and forth. I could hear the sounds of his massive cock ramming into my innocent wife. The sound of his full sack smacking against her tight ass. I could only imagine the sloppy mess they were making between her thighs as each thrust pushed out more of their cum. Jake was loving every minute of it. He bent down and got closer to Sarah. Wrapping his hand around her waist and pulling her into each pump. "Take this big cock bitch." The alpha male in Jake was beginning to show. He reached around her ass, and using the wet pussy juice from Sarah, he softly pushed a finger in her ass. An enthusiastic moan filled the room. "Oh fuck yes Jake. Harder!" Sarah was screaming his name. She tensed up and her liquid began pouring from her pussy.

Sarah was cumming. Her hips began bucking back and forth. "Oh God yes, Fuck me harder Jake." She yelled with passion. "Fill my pussy with that thick cock." Jake began to thrust violently into my wife. One hand clutched onto my wife's tits and one fingering her ass. I could see he was near finish. His ass flexing with each push. Jake pushed as deep as he could and let out a loud moan. Sarah pleasured from the deep penetration, moaned in sync with Jake. They climaxed together. Jake's seed pumping deep into my wife. Her pussy contracted and pulled up every last drop. They passionately kissed while sharing an orgasm together. Jakes once heavy bag was pulsing and emptying. Cum began seaping out of Sarahs swollen lips.

12