Sisters Share a Valentine Boyfriend

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

"Hell yes! And I want to taste my big sister while I'm being stuffed! Sit on my face!"

Kim slid up and presented her open, sopping pussy to Nancy. Nancy wasted no time. She was tongue spelunking in Kim's pussy while she fingered her clit.

Nancy slammed the rabbit deep into Kim. It's rotating shaft filled Kim with a hot hunk of motion on her G spot. The rabbit ear tapped out a rhythm on her clit that could only end in orgasm.

Kim wanted to scream, but Nancy's pussy muffled her, covering her mouth and nose. She loved to drive her sister crazy. But it was hard to concentrate when she was being worked by her sister at the same time. She was being pounded by the Rabbit while she ate out her sister. Could it be any better? Kim was so close to fireworks!

"Oh, damn Kim! You've got me so close again! You amazing lover! See why I have to keep you away from Michael? With that pussy...and that mouth...you would kill him! Just like...just like...oh fuck...you are killing me! I'm cumming! I'm cumming! I'm Ahhhhhhhhhhhhh!"

The two sisters went catatonic in a simultaneous bombastic orgasm!

It was time for me to schlep back to the couch before Nancy saw me. And before Kim did anything else to let Nancy know, I was watching. I was quiet padding back to the couch, but if anyone saw me, they would see my engorged cock leading the way!

Maybe it was time to try out that Flesh Lite! I looked for it but realized Nancy had taken it into her bedroom with the other gifts. Damn, this was a frustrating trip!

#

CHAPTER THREE - THE DAY AFTER VALENTINES DAY

Nancy woke me with warm wet kisses to my neck and ears. I rolled from my back to my side on the couch to make room for her. Her slippery sheer robe rubbed against my satin valentine boxers and bare chest. The perfume of sleepy loved up female flesh surrounded me.

"Good morning, Love."

"Mmmm...you are beautiful this morning!"

"I'm sorry we have not had the alone loving weekend we were planning. If my sister was not here, I would have already devoured you for breakfast. And be begging you for a second course."

"Mmmm...I'm hungry for you too!"

"Baby, I have some bad news. Kim got called in to work at the magazine and she needs to get back now. She has an interview appointment at 10. I don't have a car so you need to get her home. Would you do that for me?"

"Of course, Baby. And since I'm halfway home, I should see if I can pick up some hours at work this afternoon."

"I'm sorry! Can we have a do over Valentines next weekend? I promise we won't even leave the apartment. I'll be yours...really yours...in any way you want...full Valentines Fantasy weekend! No little sister! Just you and my undivided attention all over you!"

"Call me tonight and I'll cook up a preview for you!"

"Sure Babe. We better pack up and hit it if she needs to be there by 10."

#

Quick showers and hurried goodbyes. Breakfast bars for the road and a thermos of coffee. Not the luxurious breakfast layout I was expecting. But we had to hit the road!

El Rojo, the TR-6, roared to life. As he was warming up, we dropped the top. We needed hoodies and hats. The cold San Francisco morning jolted us fully awake. We headed down the coast on Highway 1, hugging the coast .

Kim and I were silent, lost in our own thoughts, as El Rojo screamed down the highway.

A static filled Top 40 station was all I could get on the old radio. Cake By The Ocean came on and the energy in the TR-6 cockpit changed.

"I love that Cake By The Ocean song!" Kim said as she started dancing in her seat. "That reminds me of some crazy times!"

"Crazier times than last night, Kim?" I said to change to the subject that was consuming my thoughts.

"Ha ha! You didn't seem to mind. I didn't know you liked to watch, Michael!"

"Actually, I like to take part, but there didn't seem to be an opening for that."

"There were plenty of warm, wet and tight openings. If you just inserted yourself into the situation!"

Was she saying I should have jumped into the middle of their sapphic lovemaking? Just assert myself and insert myself into all that erotically supercharged female flesh?

"Unbelievable" I chortled as the old reliable started stretching the confining pants.

"Unbelievable that your girlfriend and her sister made love? She didn't tell you we were close? Unbelievable that we share everything! Clothes, boyfriends, and even each other?"

"Unbelievable that you're getting hard talking with your girlfriend's little sister?" She reached for the swollen jeans and traced the obvious log.

"Unbelievable that Nancy didn't want you to join in last night?"

"Unbelievable that she wants to keep you only for herself? She surprised me because we always share. Nancy uses me as bait to get the popular guys interested in us. I've always been the pretty and sexy sister. She insisted we were a package deal to get the men she wanted. But with you, she changed her tune. She says he's my boyfriend and keep your hands and other parts off of him!"

Michael was silent. Where was this conversation going? Should he believe her? Or were these just stories to tease him? It was getting difficult to sit while his parts were being caressed by Kim. It was exciting, but what the hell? She kept challenging me.

"Didn't you hear me ask if you could join us? If you could fill me with the coke can as Nancy called it? Didn't you see me invite you to join us with my eyes, with displaying our bodies, with filling the air with horny love talk? Didn't you want me? Didn't you want her? Both of us together? Fulfilling every fantasy? Didn't you want to make a move?"

I saw the sign for the State Beach 1/2 mile away. I pointed El Rojo onto the road to the beach.

#

The State Beach parking lot was almost empty. Without a word, we parked. If she wanted action, action is what she would get!

I took her hand. We headed down the eucalyptus forest trail to the secluded beach. The last part of the trail descended quickly down the 40 foot high cliffs that enclosed the private beach area. I saw the small wind protected area under the cliff. I guided a wide-eyed, smiling but confused Kim there and sat her in the sun warmed sand.

I took off my hoodie and lay it next to Kim. I signaled to her to do the same. The hoodies were our improvised beach blankets as we sat side by side.

The rhythmic roar of the waves filled our ears. There was no talking. There was no reason to talk.

It was time for action. Her challenges needed an answer!

I wrapped my arms around her petite, sexy body that had been teasing and torturing me for two days. I brushed back her curly blond hair to expose and kiss her neck and ears. There was no resistance. We uttered no words. Our breathing synchronized.

We both knew something was going to happen. There was no escape. I might not have a girlfriend when we finished. But this situation needed to be resolved.

Not waiting for permission, I kissed down her neck and reached to massage her very ample breasts. Her nipples were prominent erasers pushing through her workout top. She was not wearing a bra. God damn was she sexy! What a treat to travel over her tremendous tits with my anxious fingers. She was much more endowed than sister Nancy. It was playtime for me!

Her reactions gave me all the permission I could imagine. Kim's breathing transformed into low moans with occasional quick gasps. She did not have to say anything. She was communicating full speed ahead! Her hands unbuckled and unzipped my pants. My Valentine boxers rose to attention.

I could smell her excitement over the pungent sea shore. Her warmth and vibrating energy unleashed my animal spirits. My hand slid down to cover her womanhood. I felt the heat and the soft squishy feel of soaked lips under the yoga pants. She opened her legs further to encourage my exploration. I could feel her mons and camel toe through the skin tight fabric. She looked naked under the yoga pants. Only one way to find out.

I slid my hand down her taut belly and under her waistband. No panties! And waxed smooth as a baby behind. Nancy had a pale blond bush shaved into a heart shape. Would I have to compare everything about the sisters? You bet I would!

Kim resumed her caressing of my Valentine boxer covered cock. She pushed down the pants farther to get a better angle. This was no time for me to be shy. I grabbed my pants and pulled them off. I rolled them up for a pillow to put it under her blond tresses. I laid her down so she could use the pillow. She laughed when I pulled off my Valentines boxers and wore them as a hat. Whatever it takes!

While I was getting adjusted, I took the chance to pull her yoga pants slowly down her legs and off to make another fragrant pillow for me. No words. But wide open blue eyes opening and closing with each wave of pleasure. And womanly love noises, those sounds that let you know you are really reaching a woman. But no words.

Remember, Michael, she wants action. I laid down directly on top of her, using my knees to encourage her legs to spread further. I looked down and saw her hairless mons. But my exposed throbbing cock was getting the best view for now. We melted into each other's mouths with a kiss that seems to never end. Our bodies were involuntarily grinding on each other. Hands were grasping and caressing. Arms were squeezing. Her legs wrapped around my back and she locked her feet. She was trying to absorb me into her body. I could not pull my body out of her love leg lock.

My tormented belly bouncer erection was finally just an inch from entering heaven. The underside of my steel hard shaft was sliding along her slippery, sopping lips. They call it dry humping, but there was nothing dry about it. We were in a primal rhythm with my every thrust met with her thrust. My engorged cock head roughly rubbed her clit with every stroke. Her entire body was vibrating and her love sounds increased to a scream.

"Oh, God! I'm so close! Make me cum! Oh, rub that coke bottle head all over my soaked lips! And keep rubbing that monster on my clit...Cuz I'm going to explode...all over your big sister boy friend cock!"

I stepped up the rhythm, knowing the time for entry was near. I was in a love leg lock with my girlfriend's sister. I was rushing her to orgasm with my naked turgid tool, rubbing her pulsating pussy and clit. It sure had her talking again!

"What do you want Kim? Should I just keep dry humping you until you explode?"

"Oh yeah. Make me cum, you bastard! Let me come all over your cock!"

"Or should I slam my coke can inside so you can feel how a real man fills you up?"

"No. No. Just let me cum all over your cock on the outside. Don't stop now!" She was in anguish.

"Kim...We should slow down. What would Nancy say? Maybe we should take a break and think about this."

I did my best push up and broke Kim's leg lock. I laid on my back next to her. My vertical rocket was obviously not agreeing with this move.

Kim was out of her mind. Finally, she was experiencing what she and Nancy had been doing to me all weekend. Kim slipped her middle finger into her pulsating center. Her other hand did a five finger fast massage of her clit area.

"Damn. I can't just do this to myself. Do it for me! Make me cum!"

I was silent. I slowly stroked my cock in case I needed it for more action.

"Damn you!" Kim screamed.

She sat up and rolled over on her hands and knees. She threw her leg over my prone torso and sat directly on me. My cock bent up to my chest.

"You have to make me cum! Can we do this?" Kim slid her body up so her pussy was on top of my face.

"Do what?"

"Don't you want to taste me? All I need is a few licks and I'll come all over your face!"

"Hmmm...let's see how this works." I wet the tip of my tongue and very lightly licked up her pussy lips from the bottom to the clit. One time. Then I stopped.

Kim jumped and almost convulsed when she felt that tongue. She was so close. And yet so far, unless I finished her.

"Oh, that is sublime. Don't stop! Never stop!"

"I think Nancy would limit me to one lick. But we better never tell her. Because she would kill us. Is there anything else I can help you with?"

Kim groaned and started sliding down my body. Maybe for a kiss? She moved down and raised up over my vertical erection. She grabbed it and rubbed it slowly over her soaked lips. She was watching intently as the purple head split her lips with each shallow movement.

"Fuck you, Michael!" as she descended and took me inside.

"Damn it! I told Nancy I would not fuck you! But I'm such a slut! It feels so hot!"

Kim's cunt was a wet dream come true. I effortlessly slid through her engorged, blossoming lips into the tightest wet spot I had ever entered.

"Don't cum inside! I'm not on any birth control. Do you have a condom?"

"No condom here. Maybe up in El Rojo in the trunk. It is a little inconvenient to get now."

"Damn you, Michael! I can't stand to look at your shit-eating grin while you are boning me! I know how to fix that!"

Kim raised off my throbbing cock and stared down at it. She hesitantly moved down to take me in her mouth. But she reconsidered. And just stared at it while she panted from excitement and exertion.

"Oh no, Kim! You will not leave me in this condition one more time! I need to fuck you!"

Kim moaned and spun her body around. She backed her dripping hairless pussy to hover over my flagpole one more time. Reverse Cowgirl was one of my favorite positions. There is something about seeing her ass dance while watching my cock enter her. But Kim was just hovering and teasing her clit with my rocket in her hand.

"I want to watch the ocean while you make me cum, Michael!"

"How do you want me to make you cum, Kim?"

Kim answered by guiding my rhythmically throbbing dick deep into her cunt!

"Damn it! Oh God! The way you fill me! Do you want me to dance my girly twirl all over your cock?"

Kim's crazed pussy pulled and pulsed and sucked and squeezed my cock until it was ready to explode!

"We should not do this without a condom, Michael! Don't you dare cum inside!"

"It's OK. If I cum in you, I will lick it out. Is that safe enough for you?"

"No, it's not!" Kim pulled off and fell forward with her ass high in the air and the front of her body touching the hoodies in the sand. She could not stop undulating since I still denied her orgasm.

"You are reasoning like an animal! This is out-of-control Michael!"

"Oh, so now I'm an animal because you have teased me into a fucking frenzy! Is that what you want? An animal?"

"I don't want an animal! I want a man! And I want a man inside me! Right now!"

She wanted doggy style. I was happy to fill her from behind. Deeper and deeper with every naked stroke of my cock. Grabbing her hips. Making her tits sway with every loud moaning thrust. She banged right back at me and moaned.

It was hard to concentrate on the fabulous view of the ocean we had. Her love making was getting more intense!

"So deep! You are so deep! Damn you! I am so full. I'm going to cum! I'm going to cum! But you can't cum inside me! Oh, damn!"

"I can't resist your smoking hot pussy a second longer. You are going to make me cum inside you! If you keep fucking me like this, I will have no choice but to fill you with cum!"

"Oh, you bastard! You are going to cum in me anyway, aren't you? You can't resist my churning cunt wrapped around your pulsating cock. You can't...you can't...resist?"

"Oh fuck! I'm so out of control! I'm so close to painting a masterpiece in your magnificent pussy! Do you want me to pull out?"

"Do it!" Kim screamed. "Just fucking do it!"

"Do what? Tell me!"

"Fucking cum in me! Now! Right now! I'm cumming! Cum with me! Cum! Please cum! Cum in me! Fucking cum with me!"

Kim slammed back into me, meeting every amazing pounding thrust. It was a mutual seizure. The world disappeared as we completed a never ending orgasm for both of us!

As we exploded into each other, our screams drowned out the waves and the seagulls. Unfortunately, they also drowned out another couple laughing as they hiked down the trail to the beach.

I saw movement and quickly pulled out of Kim. No time for an afterglow! We gathered our clothes and hastily wrapped our shell-shocked bodies. We were decent before the couple arrived down at beach level and could see us in the windbreak area.

We headed back to El Rojo. We were still shaking from the lovemaking. I embraced Kim and stared into her tired but mischievous blue eyes.

"You know Kim..."

" You know Michael..."

Dramatically pausing, we said in unison: "We can't tell Nancy!"

We couldn't stop laughing! Finally, we fired up El Rojo and headed to Kim's apartment.

#

Kim was more animated on the last leg to her house. She talked constantly while squeezing my leg to accent the important parts. Unbelievably my body was responding again to her closeness and touch. Thank goodness we arrived soon. I walked her to her door and dropped the luggage just inside.

We hugged and kissed goodbye like we were on fire. My body was lobbying for round two, but we both had somewhere to be. She walked me back to El Rojo and sadly watched as I fired him up.

"Thanks for the ride, Michael."

"Kim, I'll give you a ride any time!"

"Mmmm...about that...Hey, now that you know where I live...would you be interested in maybe stopping by...you know.. on the way up or back from seeing Nancy? It could make the drive a little shorter."

"Yeah, Kim. That might work...if you don't tell Nancy."

"Who is Nancy?"

#

Nancy and I FaceTimed that night. She apologized again and again for our Valentine weekend.

"I'm so sorry how our Valentine plans changed. But you better rest up Mister. Valentine's makeup is going to be exhausting for you!"

"Maybe I can show you a little preview!"

She demoed the new rabbit vibrator with the crotchless panties. She told me a sexy story that prominently featured two slutty co-workers sharing a boyfriend. After a couple of days of teasing and torment, we shared a volcanic explosion! The Flesh Lite took it like a champ!

It was good to have a girlfriend at this moment! The orgasmic afterglow was worth all the pain along the way.

After we both regained our breath Nancy murmured, "How was the drive home?"

"Uneventful. We listened to the radio and watched the ocean go by. Kim got back in time for her interview. And I squeezed in a few hours at work."

"You know, I really owe you for letting my sister Kim join us for Valentine's Day. She was so distraught. She always needs sister support when she has man issues. Kim seemed so much happier when she left!"

And so was I!

Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
3 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousalmost 3 years ago

Absolutely loved it. The ending sex with Kim made the story. Nancy being a cock tease I would of got with Kim too in that situation. 5 stars

racfguyracfguyover 3 years ago
Mehhh

Michael needs to RUN as far away as he can get from this pair of psycho sisters.

AustinAvalon20AustinAvalon20over 3 years agoAuthor
Thanks for all the reads! Here is another Valentine Story!

After I wrote a Group Sex story for the 2021 Valentine's Day Contest, "Sisters Share A Valentine Boyfriend," I knew I needed to write another story in the Romance category. Hopefully, this story is more romantic, with plenty of action we love to read on Literotica!

Share this Story

Similar Stories

My Wife's Best Friend A married man is tempted.in Group Sex
Night Out Ch. 01 Dinner with wife's shy friend turns out not to be so shy.in Group Sex
Fuck My Roommates My girlfriend has an unusual request.in Group Sex
Ms. Jackson Ch. 01 Boy is torn between his longtime girlfriend and her sexy mom.in Mature
Roommates or More? Co-ed roommates deal with clothing-optional living.in Exhibitionist & Voyeur
More Stories