The Big Tits Club Ch. 15-16

The next thing I knew I was flat on my back across the mattress while she slowly bobbed her head up and down in my lap. The naked redhead knelt at a right angle to me, tickling my balls with her hand while her hot mouth worked to revive me. I reached out, rubbed the creamy white skin of her perfect ass, and slid a finger into her juicy pussy from behind. She wriggled a little at my touch but tried to focus on her oral technique. After a couple of minutes, though, I grabbed her leg and urged, "Bring that ass over here."

Naimh resisted at first, intent on her blowjob, but when she realized what I was doing, she let me guide her body into a sixty-nine position. She pulled her head off to moan the instant my tongue swiped through her wet labia. And even though she put her mouth back down around me, once I started to really go to work eating her out, her blowjob technique obviously started to suffer.

Whimpering a little, Naimh pulled off and whined, "You're distracting me."

"I'm already hard enough. I wanna get you off first," I muttered before diving back into my task.

The lusty, busty redhead put her forehead down on my thigh and moaned as lightning bolts of pleasure shot up her spine. She twitched and spasmed while my agile tongue wrapped around her clit. And after a minute, she put my dick back into her mouth, sucking on it like a pacifier while I pushed her up toward orgasm.

She was almost there when I impulsively pulled down on her ass and let my tongue swipe along her perineum and across her crinkled sphincter. Naimh screeched and clamped up in surprise. "Matty!" she exclaimed rather loudly, the tone in her voice rather positive.

I chuckled and did it again, only this time I didn't stop. Remembering Mari's reactions, I kept going, licking her anus and even pushing my tongue inside.

"Eep! Matty! Matty! Ohmigawd! You're tonguing my ass!"

"I noticed," I quipped and went back to giving her a rimjob. She was already so close to cumming before that it didn't take long for her to shudder and squeal as her climax rocked her body. And when she finally stopped shaking, I pushed her forward, slid myself out from beneath her body, and stepped off the side of the bed while yanking her butt back to me to put her in a doggy-style position on the bed.

"Matty, Matty, fuuuuuuuuuuccccckkk," Naimh whimpered as I swiftly re-buried my cock to the root. She was more in a frog-position, with her knees out to the sides and her chest pressed down on the mattress, lacking the energy to stay up on all fours. Still, I was able to grab her hips and angle them enough to start pounding her from behind while she closed her eyes, pressed her cheek into the sheets, and moaned while feeling each heavy impact of my pelvis against her ass.

"Fuuuuck meeeee..." the gorgeous girl groaned. "Fuuuuck meeeee..."

On impulse, I reached out and spanked her right asscheek. Naimh squealed and shot up in surprise. "Matty!" Again, her surprised tone was quite positive, even delighted.

So I spanked her left asscheek. And then her right asscheek. And once I even slapped them both at the same time. The Irish redhead just got hotter and hotter every time I did that. She even reached back with both hands to grab her reddened cheeks and pulled them apart, spreading herself even more for my assault.

"Spank me! Spank your naughty girlfriend! Harder! More!"

The thing is, her hands were now covering my prime spanking targets. So I grabbed both of her wrists and yanked them forward over the small of her back. I used my left hand to pin both wrists together, leaving her completely helpless to resist me having my way with her. And I swear Naimh got even HOTTER.

She started screaming in ecstasy while I rutted in and out of her cunt from behind. There were no coherent words, just howls and shrieks mixed with squeals and even a little crying. It was everything I had fantasized about during all those months masturbating to dreams of fucking the hell out of the most gorgeous thing I had ever seen, and she was LOVING IT. She must've cum three times from that round alone.

In the end, I pinned her wrists down with my left hand and rapidly spanked her asscheek with my right hand. She screamed and thrust and bucked and wriggled. And when she howled in orgasmic ecstasy for the third time, her spasming snatch drew the semen out from my pumping prick.

"Neevie! Neevie! FUUUCK!" I grunted as I slammed forward one final time and blasted her cunt with all my cum.

"Ohhhhhhh... Myyyyyyyyy... Gaaaaawwwwwwwddddd..." Naimh groaned as her body finally went still, my pelvis no longer pounding her forward over and over again. She drooled onto the mattress, groaning in mixed agony and ecstasy as I finally let go of her wrists, letting her arms fall limply to her sides. Her eyelids fluttered feeling each shot of sperm shooting into her snatch.

And she had the BIGGEST grin on her face the whole time.

After I was done creaming Naimh's cunt, I collapsed onto the mattress beside her. I kissed her nose and rubbed her sweaty body while panting for breath. I'd been fucking her so hard for so long that I was feeling pretty wiped out.

But she opened her eyes, looked at me with an expression of absolute adoration, and said, "You are everything I've ever dreamed of. But we're not done yet."

I blinked and groaned. "Still? I'm TIRED."

Naimh smiled, looking happier than she'd ever been in her life. "I wanna give my boyfriend my last purity. Will you please fuck my virgin arse?"

****

The naked sweaty redhead between my spread legs popped off my prick for a moment, although her right hand still stroked my shaft. "I'm finally gonna get one of Matty's cherries," she said happily. "Holly was your first blowjob. Mari made you spurt with her hands first and was your first deep-throat. And Sam got your virginity, but I'm gonna give you your first arse." And then she went back to blowing me.

I arched an eyebrow. "Are you sure about this?"

She nodded and popped off again. "Never been more sure of anything in my life."

"Not worried at all about The Rule?"

Naimh giggled and replied, "If they wanna keep 'everything in balance', that's up to them. I'm shivering just thinking about all five of us bent over a bed, waiting for you to sodomize us all in a row."

My cock visibly twitched at that thought, but it also gave me pause. Any guy would give his left nut to be in my position, and yet I couldn't help shake the feeling that things were getting a little out of control. What Naimh had just described fit perfectly into the name "Matty's Harem", and while that sounded awesome in theory, I did worry a little if we were changing too much from the original BTC.

While Mari had told me the Monday morning after she'd given me her virginity that she regretted telling me so many secrets about the girls' true feelings for me, I reassured her that she hadn't really told me anything I didn't already know.

Belle had already confessed back during that first blowjob that she was in love with me, and had been in love with me for a few years. I had worried initially that she'd be jealous of Sam getting my cherry first, but the reveal of her voyeuristic desires had taken me by surprise. And in a way, of all the girls I was worried the least about hurting her feelings. The little voyeur might even want Matty's Harem more than I did.

Sam, on the other hand, worried me the most. I'd been watching her this week, actively looking past the misdirection to see if her true face really did reveal itself. She kept a lid on her jealousy, mostly, but it came out in moments. She was quick to say "I love you" immediately after swallowing my cum or fucking me within an inch of my life, and visibly brightened when I replied, "Love you, too." Those responses accurately reflected the way I felt for her in those moments, but I worried that she'd been right all along that she could successfully "buy" my love for her through sexual satisfaction. She was sex personified, the reincarnation of Aphrodite, and she turned me on like crazy. But I knew it needled her how close I was to Belle, and how much I lusted for Naimh, and I wondered what would happen if she ever decided to put her foot down and make me choose a favorite.

Mari wasn't in love with me, which was a relief in a way. She clearly valued the BTC and had integrated her sexuality rather seamlessly with the others. I had tried to spend equal time with her even when Sam, Belle, or Naimh were ready and willing for sex while Mari wasn't. This past week she'd simply been eager to climb aboard instead of finishing a blowjob, but otherwise things had been much the same.

Her secret, on the other hand, was a bit of a ticking time bomb. I had encouraged her to come clean with Belle at least, stating that I was sure her best friend would understand. But Mari's fears had kept that secret locked away for years already, and she wasn't quite ready to open it up again. In the meantime, I knew how important it was to her that I remain the one man in the world she could trust and feel safe with, and I wouldn't violate that trust for anything in the whole world.

Zofi was a mystery. In my humble opinion, she and Naimh were empirically the two most beautiful girls in the entire club. But while she'd always enjoyed being part of the group and even stretching her boundaries with me physically, everything seemed more like a game to her. She sought out unique experiences for the sake of having a unique experience, not because she was horny, and CERTAINLY not because she was emotional. There was no love between us whatsoever, and I felt that she was the only one who still held to the original purpose of the BTC, treating me as the safe guy she could practice on. I didn't worry about her blowing up the club, but if things started to fall apart, we weren't emotionally bonded close enough for me to believe she'd be on my side.

And then there was Naimh: the girl who, if I was being honest with myself, represented the greatest threat to the BTC. She was the one who wanted to be my girlfriend, who wanted me to be her boyfriend, and quite frankly, I wanted those things too. I wished I could go for that drive down the coast in a convertible, hold hands as we walked in the waves, and cuddle together to watch the sunset. I wished I could bring her to a concert, have a quiet dinner at a fancy restaurant, get jealous stares from guys admiring her beauty, and then take her home and make love until the sun came up the next morning.

Nevermind that doing so would destroy my relationships with the other girls. I was tempted. And to have the object of my lust worshiping my dick with her mouth while moaning about how she wanted me to plunder her virgin asshole only magnified that temptation.

Not that either of us would willingly blow up the BTC for a relationship. Naimh would kill herself before betraying the others (hopefully not literally), and I would never intentionally do so either. But I had to admit, I could see myself laying the foundation for a romantic pair-bonded relationship with the gorgeous redhead "just in case". I mean, if things went wrong and the BTC broke up, at least we could be together then, right? And I knew that the very idea of having "girlfriend Naimh" as a backup plan could very well undermine my resolve to keep the BTC together, even if subconsciously.

Presently, "girlfriend Naimh" pushed her face down as far as she could go around my cock, breathing shallowly through her nose while probing her own gag reflex. She pulled back slowly, took a long deep breath, and then sank her face all the way down.

Yes, I mean ALL the way down. The redhead's lips formed a tight ring around the very base of my cock, and I could feel the tense compression of her throat around my cockhead. She only held it for a second or two, whimpering softly before pulling all the way up and off, gasping for breath and coughing twice before flashing me a beaming grin.

"I did it!" she cheered enthusiastically before repeating, "I did it!"

My eyes were huge, and I felt a little bad that my very first thought was, 'Sam is NOT gonna be happy about this.' But I grinned, started clapping slowly, and congratulated her by saying, "You did it! That was amazing!"

Naimh did a little happy dance on her knees, making her big jugs jiggle. Then she bent over and promptly attempted to repeat the feat. She actually couldn't do it, gagging herself about an inch from the bottom over and again until she started to get frustrated. I started to tell her it was alright and that she didn't need to, echoes of that night with Sam after the wedding in my mind. But Naimh sat back for a moment, closed her eyes and became absolutely still. Exhaling slowly, she went into a meditative Zen state, calmed her breathing, and after a minute, she bent over to try again.

She succeeded.

I knew she would. She had that look in her eye right before she pushed her head back down. This girl would succeed at anything she put her mind to.

Even if that thing was... me.

But first, she had another goal in mind. Having completed her second deep-throat, she pulled off my prick and stared straight into my eyes. Her voice was deeper than usual, and deadly serious. "I need you in my arse."

I nodded slowly.

With a cocky little smile, not a single trace of nervousness, the gorgeous redhead crawled up my body and kissed me slowly. But just when I started to really kiss her back, she broke away and moved over to the side. She bent over in that frog-position again, her ass up in the air, and said, "Fuck my pussy first to get nice and lubed up."

I nodded my agreement and sat up to get into position, but the word "lube" ping-ponged around my brain for a few seconds until I suddenly jerked and exclaimed, "Oh yeah!"

Naimh glanced back at me in surprise. "What?"

I was already scrambling off the bed and rummaging through my suitcase. "I have a bottle of lube."

"You do? Why?"

I flashed her a slightly embarrassed smile. "Uh, well, Belle is really small down there, and I'm kinda thick. Sometimes we need a little help to get me in."

"Huh." Naimh blinked a couple of times but nodded her understanding. "Lucky me. I was a bit worried how much this might hurt."

I had climbed back onto the bed, but paused just before opening the cap. "We don't HAVE to do this. I don't want to hurt you."

"Oh no, we're DOING this," she stated emphatically and put her head back down. "Just don't be shy about using a lot of that stuff if you need to."

With that in mind, I went ahead and opened the cap. But the sight of Naimh's beautiful backside thrust up toward me was just too enticing to resist, and I set the bottle down on the nightstand so I could grab her ass with both hands and start rimming her anus again. Naimh squealed and giggled and shook her butt free, complaining, "That tickles! I mean, I like it but just lube me up already, will ya?"

I laughed, retrieved the bottle, and squirted a healthy glob into my hand. I painted her sphincter first, then pushed first one lubricated finger and then a second into her colon while she groaned and gritted her teeth, trying to get used to the sensation. But then I brought my rock-hard dick up with my other hand and guided it into her sopping-wet pussy from behind. And my lusty Irish lover moaned in pleasure as I swiftly buried myself to the root.

For a few minutes, I slow-dicked her snatch while pumping two fingers in and out of her anus, adding more lube every now and again. Then, I pushed a third finger in, causing her to stop and tense up, but after about a minute she went back into that meditative Zen state, relaxed, and allowed me to resume thrusting.

"Soooo... fulllll..." she mumbled into the mattress.

"Still wanna do this?" I asked in concern.

"Mmm-hmm..." Naimh opened her eyes, twisted her face back to me, and reached back with both hands to pull her own buttcheeks apart.

"Fuck my arse, Matty. Be the first one to ever fuck my arse. Be the only man to ever fuck my arse for the rest of my life."

I choked up a little at that last part. The idea of spending the rest of my life with the most gorgeous girl I'd ever seen and having her profess that kind of fidelity to me hit me like Cupid's arrow to the heart. She was inviting me to sodomize her, but I kept my cock in her cunt and bent forward, planting my left hand on the mattress for support so I could get all the way down and kiss her lips.

"I love you, Matty," she told me sincerely.

"I love you, too," I replied with just as much emotion.

"Fuck my arse, lover," she crooned, eyes glittering.

I grinned. "Yes, ma'am."

Coming upright again, I pulled my dick out of her pussy first. She got a fresh grip on her asscheeks, spreading them wide. With the bottle of lube in hand, I pulled my fingers out of her anus and gazed in wonder at the gaping dark hole that remained. I squirted another healthy glob of lube right into that gap, set down the bottle, and aimed my cockhead into her open sphincter. And easier than I would have thought, I pushed the first three inches through.

"Holy shii-aaaaaaaAAAAAHHHH!!!" Naimh's head SHOT up fast at the moment of penetration, and I could only imagine her eyes going saucer-shaped and her mouth gaping open. I suddenly wanted a mirror in front of her for the next time we did this so I could see actual expression on her face.

For my part, Naimh's asshole was unlike anything I'd ever felt before in my life. It was wet from all the lube, but still not nearly as moist as a pussy. She felt tight, almost as tight as Belle's virgin vagina, but less constricting at the same time. And it was HOT. Oh my gawd it was hot in her ass, and I groaned to feel such a uniquely amazing sensation for the very first time.

We were SO doing this again.

Meanwhile, Naimh groaned as she felt her colon being filled with cock for the first time. She kept her head down now, breathing shallowly with her eyes closed, trying hard to maintain that meditative Zen state. I worried a little that I was still hurting her, and even though this felt absolutely amazing to me, I was ready to stop at the first sign of her discomfort.

But she had a wicked smile on her face, all the way up until I hit bottom and had given her every last inch of Matty-cock she could take. "That's everything," I told her. "You've got my entire dick in your ass."

"Yasss..." Naimh hissed, still with that wicked grin. Only then did she open her eyes and look back at me. "Fuck my arse, lover. Fuck my fuckin' arse."

So I fucked her "arse". I started slow, both letting her adjust to my thickness and absorbing the sensations myself. She got up onto all fours, a proper doggy-style position, and started bucking her butt back to meet my thrusts. We started speeding up, really building up a rhythm, although I would pause every now and again to ask her how she felt, getting answers like, "So full", "So good", and finally "I'm fine stop asking just fuckin' FUCK me!"

So I stopped asking and focused on fucking. But I still kept talking. So did she.

"Holy shit, Neevie, I love this. Your ass feels so fucking good."

"Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck," she grunted. "You're so fuckin' big!"

"You're so fuckin' tight! And so hot! I mean your ass is literally HOT! Not that you're not hot, too. I mean you're the hottest thing I've ever seen. It's just... Ohmigawd..."

"Ohmigawd is right. I can't believe you're fucking my arse, Matty! Fuck my arse, fuck my arse, fuck my arse!"

"I'm gonna cum in your ass, Neevie. This is incredible."

"Yes, yes, I want it in my arse! You came in my mouth tonight. Then you came in my pussy. Now you're gonna cum in my arse! I want it all! I want it everywhere!"

"Fuck! Fuck! Fuck! I'm gonna cum!"

"I'm gonna cum too! I'm gonna cum with your cock in my arse! Cum with me! Cum in my arse! I'm gonna--! I'm gonna--! I'm gonna... AAAAAAUUUUUUGGGGHHHH!!!"