The Risk of Sharing Sarah Pt. 03

Chapter 3.

Years later, after we were married, Sarah asked me if I'd be ok sharing her with other guys. When it started, I honestly did it to please her. I shared her with a practical stranger who fucked her safely and sprayed his cum all over her pussy, which I gladly lapped up for her. The next guy was so hung, he stretched her out with his condom-sheathed cock, but when he pulled out to cum, he sprayed his seed into her gaping fertile cunt. The third guy I shared her with had a vasectomy and was shooting blanks. When the first two men heard that we'd let the third man fuck Sarah bareback and cum inside her, they came back for more. And I ate those loads out of her creamy pussy. She'd taken two loads of cum deep inside her when it wasn't exactly her safe time. While creampie eating started to get as much of their seed out as possible, I loved making Sarah feel good. I truly don't mind the taste or the texture.

Just remembering those fun cummy nights makes me hard. Those three strangers were the first I shared Sarah with, but they were not, I now know, the first raw cocks she'd taken.

After sharing her with a few more friends and pals, Sarah told me the whole story of the first time she let a stranger fill her up. She also told me that her first time wasn't with me, it was with two total strangers. As I ate her freshly-fucked pussy, she told me that had happened on that night.

I had been in the room when she lost her virginity to another man, or rather men.

As he flirted with my girlfriend in his wet underwear, Mike, the station wagon driver, saw me passed out on the lounge chair by the pool. He asked if she needed any help getting me to bed. Sarah had gladly accepted his offer. Mike must have slung me over his shoulder, fresh from the pool, in what I remember being nearly sheer underwear barely concealing his impressive package.

Mike had suggested putting me upright in a chair just in case I was drunk and could get sick. Sarah offered him a fresh towel to dry off with, and he'd gladly accepted but didn't use too thoroughly. Sarah told me that she'd seen his dick in his wet underwear and made a joke about it being bigger soft than I was hard. He'd chuckled and asked if she wanted to compare them. He offered to whip it out so she could get a better look.

Sarah told him that she'd already seen more of his dick than any man other than me. He'd joked that she should see a few more cocks before settling down with just one. She'd laughed and said she'd keep that in mind, even saying that she wasn't sure she'd ever be satisfied with just one cock. Mike asked if we'd had any evening plans and she'd confessed that while we were saving going all the way until marriage, she was going to let me tease her pussy with my cock for the first time tonight. She also told him that she'd nearly cum before we headed to dinner and couldn't wait to have an orgasm. Me being out cold, Mike had offered his services, happy to help get her off.

Sarah confessed that seeing his package had turned her on even more than her unfinished orgasm from earlier. She spread her legs to show him that she was wet just thinking about other men's' dicks. Her bikini bottoms were soaked through with her juices and clung to her swollen pussy lips. Mike pulled his wet underwear down and offered her a closer look. He warned her that his cum was super-charged, and he always had to wear a condom when getting anywhere near his wife's pussy. Sarah told him that we didn't bring any since we weren't planning on going that far, and plus, she didn't believe in birth control. He told her he'd be willing to risk it since it was just going to be teasing.

Mike offered to get her off and she ripped her bathing suit off and tossed it to him. He closely examined the soaked crotch of her bikini and inhaled her juices. She told him he was welcome to eat her pussy if he'd like that. Mike went down on my girlfriend, and she was close to cumming when he stopped. Sarah was clearly enjoying what he was doing with his tongue against her clit, and even giggled, telling him that he was almost as good at eating her creamy pussy as I was. Mike suggested they try something she hadn't done with me yet and one day maybe, when the time was right, she could tell me about taking her first cock while I, the love of her life, was in the room. Sarah's whole body quivered with her first mini orgasm just thinking about telling me one day.

Mike asked her if she wanted him to tease her pussy with his bare cock, and she told him it might not be a good idea, since she had her period a week earlier and it might be especially risky. He promised just to tease unless she wanted more, and Sarah laid back again and spread her legs. Mike positioned himself between her legs and slapped his cock against her bare pussy. She loved it and begged for more. His was the first cock to touch her cunt.

Mike went from slapping his hard dick against her pussy lips and ever so gently aligned the tip of his cock where no man had been before. Sarah told me that she remembered her breathing going shallow and rocking her hips, so the very tip eased ever so slightly into her unprotected cunt. Mike was staying perfectly still and letting Sarah take as much or as little of his cock as she wanted. She thanked this man, a total stranger, for letting her use his bare dick to get off.

Sarah took maybe two inches of Mike when she heard a noise. She thought it was me stirring, but when they looked over at me and saw me passed out cold, they realized it was the desk clerk at the door.

The noise had been a knock at the propped-open door, and it was the clerk delivering the spare room key to replace the one I'd lost in the pool. He quickly assessed the situation and saw that Mike was sliding his raw cock into Sarah's pussy while I was passed out cold. She was embarrassed, but he offered a little explanation as Mike kept teasing her cunt. As he undressed, the clerk came clean about something special being added to our honeymoon gift basket chocolates. Mine had been spiked with a sedative and hers had been dosed with an aphrodisiac. As Mike kept pumping her pussy, he himself volunteered that he'd provided the chocolates. He looked down at her as he told her hers wasn't the first pussy they'd shared.

Sarah told me she felt violated, but in the moment, with Mike sliding further and further inside her, and the clerk slowly stripping off the rest of his uniform, she knew she wanted them to use her. It felt good and she knew I'd be fine. She confessed to wanting them both to fuck her. She promised to tell me one day when the time was right, knowing I'd understand. Mike winked at her saying that he'd be glad to fuck her again with me watching one day.

Mike slid all the way in and pounded Sarah while she blew the clerk. Mike's cock brought her to a big orgasm. After Mike came inside her, the men switched places and Sarah took her second raw cock. The clerk slid his meat into her cummy pussy. He was smaller than Mike and she later described the sound of his dick sloshing around inside her. After the clerk filled her up with his load, she had them help me onto the bed. They stripped me naked, and Sarah suckled my soft cock while they each took another turn. By sunrise, she had four loads simmering in her fertile womb. She managed to suck a load out of me as well and spit it into her palm to finger fuck into herself. She even ground her sloppy pussy against my sleeping face as Mike and the clerk dressed and left. Mike gave her a pill that he promised would keep her from becoming pregnant, but she was a little leery of taking any pill they offered her.

Sarah was relieved when she had her next period. It was years later when she told me that I wasn't her first, but I was there, passed out on the bed when she took her first two raw cocks, letting them both cum deep inside her twice. She came clean as well about me eating her creamy pussy the next morning. I'd eaten my load for the first time, mingled with two strangers' fresh seed as it oozed out of her and into my open mouth.

Sarah still tells me I eat her better than anyone ever has.

When she told me the whole story, I was so hard I couldn't help but fuck a load into her before eating it out. l held Sarah and told her that I didn't mind being the third man to fuck her, after we were married, and that she didn't need to keep any secrets. She asked if I meant that, and I eagerly nodded. She then told me I was nowhere near her third cock. She'd let multiple men breed her before I slid all the way inside for the first time. We made plans to see Mike again. All these years later, she'd kept his card. I knew I'd be tasting his load out of her creamy pussy again soon.

To be continued...