Too Good To Be True Ch. 25

Dear Readers,

Here is the Preview for Chapter 25. Thanks a million to Alys21 who helped me with the editing. Glad to get another chapter up. Alys21 has been wonderful to work with. I hope you enjoy this.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Chapter 25

The next morning, as Tina was finishing, licking my sperm from her fingers, she asked me about the photoshoot.

"Is there anything you are hoping for from the photoshoot?" Tina asked.

"Well, I know I am going to love the pictures," I told her. "I mean, I want you to really enjoy it to show Taylor how great it is in the harem. So have fun, and do what is going to make you feel the sexiest. I mean, Taylor got so turned on yesterday that she soaked through her pants."

"Wow, that's pretty horny," Tina murmured, cuddling me. "What's stopping her?"

"The societal expectation of monogamy," I replied.

"Oh pffft," Tina mocked. "The Monogamy thing is a farce. If it was real monogamy people would still be marrying as virgins and only have one lover their entire life. They want to be hooking up with anyone until they get a solo lover for a while, then they just cheat for their multiple lovers."

I thought for a moment, "I might bring that up to her, it's an interesting thought."

"Did you just cuddle Debbie for your shots, or did you do anything sexy with her?" Tina asked.

"Oh, Debbie had pictures sucking my cock, getting groped everywhere, and she took my dick in her vagina and ass, and I even creampied her pussy," I replied.

"Fuck yeah, I'm totally deepthroating you and taking you in my pussy," Tina celebrated then thought for a minute. "I don't mind your dick in my ass, but it doesn't feel as sexy to me. Intimate, sure, but not sexy. Maybe seeing it would help, so I think I'll do that too. What outfits did Debbie wear?"

"Well, she did the traditional schoolgirl outfit, with a lacy thong and bra lingerie set. Then she did a gym outfit with similar lingerie. Then she did a tight red crop top and high slit dress with a g-string and string bra lingerie set."

"Ooooo, that sounds sexy," Tina cooed. "I was thinking of doing my running outfit, then a swimsuit, then something like a clubbing outfit. I could wear lingerie with the running outfit and the clubbing outfit, but the swimsuit would just be that."

"Those sound fucking hot." I grinned, envisioning the fit harem girl flaunting herself in those outfits.

Tina grinned. "I love seeing how much you swoon for me."

I laughed and texted Taylor to warn her what was coming up, and give her time to think on what she wanted Tina to do.

"Sounds good!" Taylor replied.

I worked hard all afternoon getting through my homework. I finished up a project with Courtney for one of our Computer Science classes. Then I spent some time with Suki working on one of my Business classes that was confusing me. After we finished, the discussion turned to the photoshoots.

"How did Debbie's shoot go?" Suki asked.

"I think it went well. Taylor has a ton of pictures to sort through and edit, she says the results of all three photoshoots will probably take her at least a month to get finished," I told her. "But both things I was hoping for seemed to happen pretty well. Debbie got a nice little self confidence boost, and Taylor got horny out of her mind. She seems to be taking this as a challenge to see how far it will go. Like Courtney won't actually let me fuck all three of you in front of her camera."

"Oh, no. Courtney would let you do it and eat the cum out of us," Suki laughed.

"Right, she can't believe that you are all happy to share one dick," I said. "I think the socialized expectation of monogamy is her only barrier. I'm hoping we'll work her through that with Tina's shoot and yours."

Suki looked down, "I don't know why you chose me for this. I'm not sexy enough for a shoot like this."

I reached out and lifted her chin, "I chose you because you don't realize how sexy you are and I am hoping you find a bunch of pictures that show how appealing you are and you will realize that you are one fucking hot girl."

Suki smiled, "If you say so. What are the other girls wearing for their shoots?"

I related what Debbie wore, and Tina had planned, to Suki, and she pondered that for a minute. "I think I am still going to wear what I was planning on. But that is interesting."

"What were you planning on wearing?" I asked.

"Well," Suki admitted, blushing. "I was going to wear a Kimono, and traditionally you do not wear anything under a kimono. I could maybe wear a g-string, but a bra is out. So I would just wear my silk Kimono. Then I wanted to wear my cheer outfit. I can wear lingerie under that. Then finally I wanted to wear a type of Cheongsam, which is a type of asian dress, and I have a few, but one of them... it's just a sex outfit and is open all the way up the side, and I can wear lingerie with that too."

I had a solid erection imaging her in those.

"Well fuck, you are going to look amazing in those!" I breathed.

Suki smiled, blushing more. "Oh, come one, you've seen me naked so many times! Like wearing something like that will make me any more attractive? I don't think so."

I looked around and saw Ali studying on the other side of the room.

"If Ali wasn't over there, I'd show you just how attractive I think that is," I told her with a laugh.

"You're so sweet," Suki laughed back, and we packed up our stuff.

I had a couple of things to do but I got them done before dinner. At dinner, I sat with Courtney and Tina. Taylor sat next to us directly next to Tina, and started quietly discussing the shoot.

"And you're sure you want to... you know... do this?" Taylor verified.

"Absolutely," Tina assured her. "Why wouldn't I want to?."

Taylor shook her head, then whispered "Because... He's actively fucking a dozen other girls!"

Tina shrugged, "So? We all know about it. We're all cool with it. We all enjoy it. So what's the problem?"

Taylor shivered, "I mean, isn't it weird? Isn't it wrong?"

Courtney laughed quietly. "You don't get it. We're like family, a bunch of sisters and we all care about Tom. You might not start there, but you'll get there. And all it requires is realizing it's okay to share. Monogamy is overrated and most of nature isn't monogamous, so who's to say what's wrong?"

"Besides, the majority of society is only loosely monogamous," I added. "In a truly monogamous world, everyone would remain virgins until after marriage, and divorce wouldn't be such a thing. Instead, there are baby mommas, baby daddies, people on their third and fourth marriages, and almost no one is a virgin when they marry anymore. We're just acknowledging the fact that society is broken and we're doing what is best for us."

Taylor played with her food, deep in thought.

Courtney and I let it drop.

When the food was finished, Taylor looked at me, "Could you help me carry my photo equipment to Tina's room? Tina, go get ready."

Tina and Courtney headed off to Tina's room, and Taylor and I walked to Taylor's room. When we reached Taylor's room, she shut the door.

"Can we talk for a moment?" Taylor asked.

"Sure." I replied and sat down.

Taylor sat cross-legged on her bed.

"Okay, so you've convinced me that Courtney and the other girls are actually all having sex with you, and they all know and are okay with it," Taylor admitted. "I don't get it, and I don't know if I want to participate yet."

I nodded and kept listening.

Taylor took a breath, "So, um... If I did join, I'd get to live here, probably get to keep doing photoshoots, and the girls would probably model for me. Sarah would be a free psychologist for me, and Brittany would give medical advice. I can see why that would appeal. The idea of a bunch of sisters is appealing too."

She shook her head, "But as far as I can tell, the only benefit you get is that you get to have sex with me if I join. Why do you do it?"

I smiled, "Because I care about all of my girls. Yes, we have sex. Yes, I enjoy that. But if it was just me getting variety in bed, Courtney and I wouldn't do it. We do it to help the girls who want a relationship, want the emotional and social support that they aren't able to find in a hookup society full of fuckboys. How many boyfriends have you had?"

"...none," Taylor admitted quietly.

"Do you want a boyfriend?" I continued.

"...yes," Taylor said, even quieter.

"If you had a good boyfriend, would you be having sex with him?" I asked.

Taylor looked to the side. "... maybe. If he was a good boyfriend, probably," she conceded.

"You wish you had someone who valued you and made you feel special. I do my best to value each of my girls and make sure they know they are each special. And some of the girls have said they think being in the harem is better than just having a boyfriend, because if they don't feel like having sex on any given occasion, they don't feel like they have to in order to keep me. Some of the girls are fairly high sex drive girls, and Courtney is always willing to make sure I get what I want. So, you get sex, you get a boyfriend, and you don't have the pressure to put out. And while some of the girls just like spending some time with me, some of the girls, especially Abby, Suki, and Brittany love to go on dates out in public. I don't worry about being seen in public, if anyone questions it, the public thing we say is Courtney's friends are making sure I am a good guy and we're going on 'friend dates'. So I get a bunch of female friends who I happen to be having sex with, and I get to help all of you."

Taylor pulled her knees to her chest.

"I still need to think, but we need to go take all the pictures of Tina. It's still hard to believe it all," Taylor shook her head.

I shrugged, "They all know about it and are excited to see how these pictures make them feel."

Taylor rolled her eyes, "You are telling me that you aren't getting a thrill from these shoots and it's all for them?"

I laughed. "No, I enjoy the shoots. But I can be satisfied without them, if it weren't for the best thing for the girls, we wouldn't do it."

Taylor shrugged."I guess that makes sense."

We hauled the lights and setup for the shoot. When we arrived, Tina was already in her jogging gear. Her tight top left her arms and midriff completely exposed. Her jogging shorts were shorter than any of the ones I usually saw her wear. Both the top and bottom were tight enough I could see the outline of her bra and her panties.

Taylor had figured out better how to make her model pose sexily. Tina was sprawled on the bed, had her legs spread, legs pressed together as she rubbed herself, and much more as Taylor got pictures of her in a variety of arousing positions.

"Okay, now for your stripping off of your top and bottom, is there anything you want to do?" Taylor asked.

Tina bit her lip, "I was wondering if we could work a sort of a light bondage scene?"

"Like what are you thinking?" Taylor asked.

"Um, I have some silk rope, we could tie my hands over my head, and there is a ring right there on the ceiling. I could hang from my arms while Tom pulls my top over my head, pulls down my pants, slides my g-string to the side and sticks his dick in my ass and pussy?" Tina explained.

"Okay, let's do it."

Courtney fetched a stool to get the silk rope through the loop on the ring on the ceiling. We were able to get several loops of the rope around her wrists so it wouldn't cut into her wrists. We pulled the rope until she was on her tip-toes. That was great for the stripping scene, but we'd have to shift her for a better fucking position.

Taylor had me move behind her, so Tina was the focus of the pictures. She had me start by groping her through her clothes. My hands slid across her stomach, caressed her breasts, teased her nipples and slid down to massage her already excited vagina through her thin jogging shorts. I slowly raised her shirt, exposing her sports bra and her finely toned upper body. I lifted the light fabric up until it was above her hands and by pulling it against the rope we were using, I made it rest on the knots between her wrists. I resumed my massaging caress of her now exposed body, making goosebumps rise up her arms.

"Okay," Taylor instructed. "Now the bra."

I slipped my hands inside her top, gently squeezing and teasing her breasts before raising the stretch fabric over her sweet tits. I lifted the garment to join her shirt, hanging from the rope between her arms.

Then my attention lowered to her hips and the spandex, skin tight shorts. I remembered not to neglect her fully exposed tits as my hand slid over her crotch, rubbing and teasing her sex through the fabric. I could feel the fabric mold to her pussy, and I was excited to see the sexy cameltoe that I was sure was there. I could feel the moisture soaking the fabric, and slid my hand inside both shorts and the silky g-string to tease her as I kissed the side of her neck.

"Oh, fuck," Tina breathed.

Her pussy was absolutely drenched and my fingers slid inside her opening with ease, rewarding me with a shiver that ran through her body.

"Great, now take them off," Taylor directed from behind her camera, the flaming flush of her face visible around the black block of her tool.

Since Tina's feet weren't bound, I could easily fully remove them. I had an idea, and rested the shorts on her shoulder, emphasizing the fact that I was stripping her for the photos.

"Shit, that's good." Taylor half said, half moaned.

Then Taylor had me lift her to line Tina up, since her legs were shorter than mine, and Taylor had me slowly stick my cock in her pussy about six times while she got different angles, then we repeated the process for her ass.

Taylor then had an idea and and had me pull her g-string off slowly and stuff it in her mouth and (after washing my dick to clean her ass off of it) I repeated the process of fucking her pussy. She had me pull her bra up and fuck her pussy again, then I pulled her bra back down and did the same to her ass.

We did a bunch of groping photos as Tina hung from her wrists, culminating with Tina inverting herself and having me plug her pussy and ass upside down with my cock, though that required us to lower her almost to the floor.

Once we took all the photos, we untied Tina.

"Fuck those felt hot. I am going to have to try getting tied up more," Tina mused. She was becoming more and more of a fetish girl, but I was totally okay with it.

A few moments later, Tina emerged from her closet in a body hugging one-piece swimsuit. Her breasts were pressed into the tight fabric, her nipples standing out against the smooth blue material of the garment. Her legs were completely exposed, and the fabric ended on her sides just below her ribs, arching down to a very thin strip that was wedged in the folds of her vagina, giving her an easily visible and prominent cameltoe. The exposed hips and half of her pelvis that were uncovered made not staring at her crotch impossible, and damn, I was loving it. From behind, her lower back was the only thing covered, except for straps on her shoulders, and the suit was so aggressively tapered that by the time it reached her ass, the thin fabric fit inside the sexy crease of between her cheeks.

We went into the bathroom and Taylor started taking pictures. Tina was told to pose and grope herself, and walked through dozens of poses, climaxed by having her bend away from the camera and slip her swimsuit to the side to start fingering her own ass.

Next came a series of just sticking my rod in her barely concealed holes. Tina groaned as my cock stretched her pussy and her always tight asshole. Her swimsuit was easily shifted out of the way, to allow me to do as Taylor directed. The stretch fabric of her top was easily slipped into her cleavage to expose her tits, and I groped the orbs and teased her tits as Taylor did her work, whether or not they were in the photo. And for several of the shots, she had Courtney spraying water over Tina as I speared her sexy orifices. She was standing or kneeling in the tub for all of the shots with water.

"Okay... Tina, do you want to do stripping photos and nudes in the shower?" Taylor asked.

"No, I'm happy." Tina assured her.

Courtney licked my dick as she helped clean me up. "I love getting to watch this, I may have to ask for one of these shoots later," she laughed, and I put my clothes on.

"I could do it." Taylor shrugged, toweling off of Tina. "But I want to actually take care of these photos first."

"Mmmmmm, yeah, I'd love that," Courtney laughed.

"Are you as kinky as the other girls?" Taylor asked.

"I am the queen of the kink in the harem." Courtney replied, "I don't think any of the girls would do anything I wouldn't and I still think I've done things they won't."

Taylor's eyes widened. "I'm not sure I want to know."

Taylor and Tina went into the other room to get Tina changed.

"I think Taylor is coming around." Courtney wiggled excitedly.

I shrugged, "We'll see. I think she might be waiting until after Suki's shoot to make her decision. I don't know at this point."

Tina came out a few moments later wearing a tight, sexy black dress. She posed on the bed a few times, then Taylor had me get on and we spent a lot of time with me groping every inch of her body.

"Okay, for the stripping scene Tina wanted something else." Taylor explained.

Instead of taking her dress off, Tina had me pull the top down, exposing her lacy slit-cup bra, and pull the bottom up, exposing her lacy crotchless panties. I was almost immediately naked. We did more photos with her getting groped, sucked and fingered, her dress getting pressed smaller and smaller until it was a small ring of fabric around her tummy. Then instead of getting Tina naked to fuck her, we took advantage of the crotchless panties and the slit exposing her nipples and just started fucking her.

I drilled her pussy hard and long. After her third orgasm, Taylor had me flip Tina on her side and put one of her legs on my shoulder. That was the position I ejaculated into her pussy. With how hot everything had been I must have squirt seven or eight bursts of my semen deep inside her. I knew Tina always wanted me to keep going, she loved having her pussy fucked for hours on end, where her ass could only last for five or ten minutes before becoming so sensitive that she couldn't take it anymore.

Tina had been the one to ask Brittany if ass-to-pussy could be okay. The answer was not really, the risk of infection was always going to be there. No matter how thoroughly the girl was washed out, and even if she didn't eat for hours beforehand (which never happened in the harem, but was a thing for professional porn), there was still a high chance of infection from ass to pussy.

Tina had wanted to know because while she liked anal, she didn't want to wait until she was spent to do it, and didn't want to give up getting her pussy fucked for an hour and a half.

"Fuck, I love feeling you dump your sperm inside me. Keep going!" Tina instructed.

"Wait!" Taylor jumped in, "We want the sperm leaking shot! Pull out!"

I looked at Tina, who looked at me and bit her lip. "Okay, switch to my ass."

I pulled my dick out of her pussy, adjusted and pressed into her asshole. Tina got close for the shots and the shutter accompanied my dick as I buried it in Tina's ass. I enjoyed the tightness of her ass as I began fucking it. The lube from earlier was still good, and my cock plunged deep and hard into her.

"Oooohhhhh, fuuuuuck!!!" Tina gasped, her orgasm pushing gushes of my sperm from her tunnel.

"Oh, that's going to be great," Taylor celebrated.

"Hmmm, Tom, that's the wrong side, your dick is hitting my insides a bit hard, let's go ass up," Tina instructed.