Conflicted in Paradise Ch. 03

"Go on, do it," he said to her, smiling encouragingly. When he saw her hesitate, he added, "I want to watch you fuck her!"

She gave him a lustful smile, both delighted and at the same time terrified that he'd told her to go play with Kelsey and Carynne. She felt a little jealous twitch in her pussy at the thought of Stacey getting his cum, but she quickly pushed those thoughts aside. Stacey had made her cum so many times the night before that she knew she had absolutely no reason to complain.

She approached the two eagerly fucking girls, smiling broadly when she saw how wet Kelsey's pussy already was.

"What do you want, Kel?" she asked, her knees trembling.

"Whatever you want to do to me," Kelsey moaned. "I just want you to join us."

Carynne took a brief pause from eating Kelsey's pussy to smile Siara. "Kel wants you to take charge, remember? Just do whatever you want. She loves all of it, don't you, baby?" As if to lend truth to her words, Carynne slipped a finger inside Kelsey's ass, causing Kel to let out a long, whimpering groan.

Siara felt her head get woozy at the thought of the incredible brunette being so submissive. She knelt beside Carynne, throwing her a questioning glance.

Carynne nodded, moving aside a little to make space for Siara to join in the assault on Kel's delectable holes. Kelsey helped by moving her left leg off Carynne's shoulder and draping it over Siara's. Siara quickly scooted forward, until she was just inches away from Kelsey's wonderfully soaked cunt.

"Did Stace teach you what to do with a pussy?" Carynne asked bluntly, a wicked grin on her face.

Siara blushed a scarlet crimson, throwing another glance behind her at Stacey and her boyfriend. The two of them had sat down on one of the benches, and Stacey was already hard at work riding Ryan's cock, bouncing herself up and down with wild abandon. Siara returned her attention to Carynne and Kel, and she nodded. "Yes."

"Then do it," Carynne sighed. "Trust me, you've never tasted anything as delicious as Kelsey."

Kelsey moaned at her lover's words, scooting down a little as if she was impatient to feel the touch of Siara's tongue.

Siara closed her eyes, her heart racing a thousand beats per second. She moved her face closer to Kelsey's slit, her nostrils being filled with Kel's wonderful scent. She flinched for a second when her nose touched that drenched little cunt, but she quickly locked her mouth onto Kelsey's pussy.

Her tongue flashed out and drew a slow, teasing line across it, and she couldn't help but grin when she felt Kelsey's delighted shudder. Her mind was flooded with images and feelings of when she'd ground herself off on Kel's face in the dressing room the other day, and suddenly she wanted nothing more than to return the favor to this unbelievable sweetheart.

Siara placed her lips on Kelsey's delightfully hard clit, teasingly sucking it. She felt Carynne's finger still pumping away in Kel's cunt, and she joined a finger to the three that were already in there. Kelsey practically quivered off the couch, and Siara quickly placed a hand on her tummy to keep her in place.

"Do you like that, love?" she asked sweetly. Kelsey didn't respond, so she repeated her question, her grin becoming as wicked as Carynne's.

"Yes!" Kelsey moaned. "You two are driving me nuts! Fuck me, please! Eat my cunt, finger my ass, make me cum!"

"There's plenty of room in her ass for some more fingers," Carynne suggested naughtily. Her black eyes were ablaze with desire as she watched Siara go to work on her lover. She'd seen Stacey and Amanda fuck Kelsey hundreds of times before, of course, but there was something truly delectable about watching the inexperienced British girl doing it.

Siara just nodded, removing her free hand from Kel's tummy and tickling Kel's pussy with it. She rubbed it through Kel's soaked slit for a few moments, getting her fingers wet, then she placed two of them right beside Carynne's at the entrance to Kelsey's ass.

Carynne grinned at her, adding another finger of her own. The two brunettes stared at each other for a moment, both of them smiling, before they pushed their fingers inside.

"Uhm, fuck!" Kelsey hissed at the sudden stuffing of her ass. Unlike Carynne's small fingers, Siara's were long, and the addition of two of them in her butt made it feel like she was being forced open. Her pussy gushed a small trickle of juice, which Siara swiftly sucked into her mouth.

"Oh my, she tastes wonderful!" Siara moaned as the thick, clear nectar oozed across her tongue.

"Uh-huh, I told you so," Carynne said with a knowing smile. "Now let's make her cum. I want to watch her drown you in it!"

Siara gulped and nodded. An image of her own face drenched in a girl's cum floated in front of her, and it nearly shut her brain down. She'd only ever squirted on a few people herself, Kelsey and Ryan being two of them, but she'd never been the recipient of it. Her cunt twitched hungrily at the thought. "What do we do?"

"Pound her. She loves having her holes plowed," Carynne groaned. As if to illustrate her words, she started pistoning her fingers in both Kel's holes. Siara joined in just a second later, and their combined fingers drove rapidly in and out of Kelsey's pussy and ass.

Without needing to be told, Siara lowered her face back to Kelsey's cunt, locking her mouth on whatever parts of the gorgeous beauty's pussy she could get to. She lapped and licked like she was addicted to it, trying to drive her tongue inside right beside the fingers.

Kelsey's legs began to clench on both girls' shoulders, a clear indication that she was getting close to her climax. Carynne doubled her intensity, her fingers absolutely thrusting into Kel's holes, and again Siara matched her.

"Oh my God!" Kel suddenly screamed at the top of her lungs, a long, drawn-out wail that lasted for what seemed like minutes. Her body trembled and actually jumped at the delicious torture inflicted by the combined fingers and tongue, and her back arched as her orgasm came over her.

Kelsey's first squirt was obstructed by the fingers jammed deep inside her pussy, and the clear liquid burst out along every small crevice it could find, small trickles of it spraying over Carynne and Sia. Carynne yanked her fingers out of Kel's cunt with a wild grin, pulling Siara's along with it, and Kelsey's second gush shot out like it was launched from a fire hose, hitting Siara square in the face.

Siara's expression of stunned lust was adorable, but before Carynne could say anything, Sia pressed her face almost flush against Kel's slit, and she moaned in abandon at every following squirt that hit her.

"Drink it, baby!" Carynne hissed, pushing her face right up against Siara's and nibbling on Sia's earlobe. "Drink all her juice!"

Siara didn't say anything, instead just groaning her agreement as she licked, sucked and slurped every single drop of cum from Kelsey's incredible cunt.

Kelsey was still quivering like she was having a seizure, her eyes closed at the overwhelming power of her orgasm. She felt a pair of lips being pushed against her mouth, and she quickly returned the kiss, knowing instinctively it was Amanda who was kissing her. She tried to wrap her arm around Amanda's neck, but the strength had completely fled her body, and it just flopped limply onto the couch.

A few more small squirts oozed out of her pussy before Kelsey just slumped into oblivion with a deep, satisfied groan.

"Let me see!" Carynne hissed at Siara, turning her friend to face her. "Oh, wow!"

Siara's face was totally drenched in Kelsey's cum. Even Amanda, who had seen Kelsey cum hundreds of times, and had been the recipient of those delicious squirts many times over, was stunned at just how much juice Kelsey had blasted onto Siara's face. Her hair was drenched, and small rivulets of cum were dripping down her neck, over her breasts and down her tummy. Her breasts were glistening, also totally covered in Kelsey's juices, and Sia had her eyes closed, presumably to try to keep the cum from entering them.

Amanda and Carynne both had the same thought, and their tongues flashed out as they leaned closer, hungrily licking Kelsey's syrup off Sia's face. Siara moaned in delight at the feeling, and her own tongue happily wrestled with the girls', trying to nick as much cum from them as she could.

The three made out for awhile, until Sia's face was finally both cleaned from Kel's cum and covered in Carynne's and Amanda's saliva. They grinned at one another with wicked smiles, then they turned their attention back to Kelsey.

"Kel, honey?" Carynne said sweetly. "You awake?"

Kelsey just moaned something unintelligible. She had her eyes closed still, and other than her rapid breathing, she lay absolutely motionless.

"Is she alright?" Siara asked, a worried tone in her voice.

"Yeah, don't worry," Amanda grinned. "When she cums this hard, she's always out of it for a little while. In a few minutes she'll get up and just kiss you to death."

The three of them laughed at the small smile that played over Kelsey's lips, evidence that she was well aware what they were saying, even if she lacked the strength to actually do something.

"So? Did you like it?" Carynne asked Siara.

"Oh bloody hell! That was... it was..." Siara stuttered, trying to find the words. "It was fucking marvelous!"

"Yep," Carynne said, nodding her head knowingly. "Maybe later, you and Kel can spray over Amanda and me?"

Siara blushed softly, though she had an expectant look on her face. "I'd love to!"

Carynne smiled at her before turning her attention to Amanda. "Hey baby!"

"Hi!" Amanda said with a beautiful smile. "I didn't mean to steal all your cum, but when I saw Kel go off like that, I just had to join in."

"Awww, I love sharing with you, you know that!" Carynne said sweetly. The two of them met for a brief kiss, both of them loving being able to have sex with each other again.

"Yes, cum in me!" Stacey's voice echoed over the boat, and the three girls quickly turned around, seeing Stacey riding Ryan's cock in a reverse cowgirl. His hands were tightly grabbing her hips, and he absolutely slammed his pole inside the tall blonde's cunt. Stacey's tits were bouncing lewdly under the force of his thrusts, and she leaned her head back and squealed as she thundered over the edge into her own climax.

"Fuck!" Ryan growled, his body tensing up and his cock jumping inside Stacey's cunt as he began to blast his seed inside her.

"Oh yum! Excuse me, girls," Siara moaned, quickly moving towards the fucking couple. She patiently waited until Ryan had finished emptying his balls inside Stacey's cunt; then, she pulled his rapidly softening cock out and locked her mouth on Stacey's slit. With a few hungry slurps and groans, she began drinking her boyfriend's cum out of the tall blonde's cunt, to Stacey's obvious joy.

"Boy, she's turning into a real cumslut, isn't she?" Carynne grinned.

"With you and Stacey teaching her, that's not really surprising, is it?" Amanda teased.

Carynne just chuckled, giving Amanda another deep kiss. After that, she looked around, trying to find Damon. She saw him back at the wheel of the boat, though he was repeatedly looking over his shoulder at the action going on. "Is he done for the day?" she asked, unable to keep the disappointment out of her voice.

"No," Amanda grinned. "I got him hard again, and he's more than ready. He just needed to make sure our course was still correct, and I figured one of you two might want to have a go at him."

"I'd love to," Kelsey said softly from behind the two of them, having recovered from her orgasm. She dropped to her knees right between them, giving both girls a big kiss on their cheeks. "But I don't know if I'm ready for Ryan and Siara to know about us yet."

"With the way that we're sharing stuff, and the way I join in with you two, they might have already guessed, you know?" Amanda said seriously.

Kelsey nodded. "Yeah, but I'd like to be cautious, anyways. I love Siara, and I don't want to freak her out; she already seemed quite shocked that I'd call my own brother a hunk. Somehow I don't think that she'd handle the idea that we're fucking each other senseless all that well."

Amanda nodded her agreement. "You're probably right."

"Kel?" Carynne asked, her voice soft and full of longing.

"Yeah baby?"

"If you don't want to fuck Damon, can I?"

"Of course!" Kelsey said with a wide grin. "Make sure he can't walk anymore afterwards, okay?"

Carynne giggled naughtily. "You got it!"

Amanda laughed. "I'll go tell him to report for duty!" She got up and walked back over to Damon, offering to take his spot at the wheel so he could entertain Carynne. His grin was positively joyous as he looked at the petite beauty, nodding eagerly.

"Big surprise there!" Kelsey laughed. "He can't wait to get at that sexy little body of yours!"

Carynne shrugged innocently. "Hey, I can't help being so hot."

"No, that's true, but I love that you are anyways," Kelsey whispered, giving Carynne a quick kiss.

"There was something else... I wanted to... eh..."

"What?" Kelsey asked, putting her hand on Carynne's arm. "C'mon sweetie, you know you can tell me."

"You remember that fantasy I told you about?"

"Which one?" Kelsey grinned. "I must have heard at least a hundred of your fantasies. What was that last one again? You wanted to get your hands on the entire University of Oregon's cheer team, wasn't it?"

Carynne gave her a warm smile. "Well, yeah, but so do you!"

Kelsey just nodded. "I'm not denying that. So which fantasy are we talking about?"

"The one about two boys..." Carynne said, her voice barely above a whisper.

Kelsey looked at her in confusion for a few moments, then she nodded in remembrance. "Oh, that one!"

Carynne actually blushed, and Kelsey's heart beat faster at just how much in love with her slender girlfriend she was. "So you want to fuck Damon and Ryan both, hmmm?" she asked.

"Yes... can I?"

"You'd have to ask Ryan, I think?"

"Well, yeah, but I want to make sure that you'd be okay with him fucking me. If you're not, just let me know, and I'll forget about the whole thing right now. You know I'd never do anything to hurt you."

"I know," Kelsey said, wrapping her arms around Carynne and hugging her girlfriend tightly. "But I'm okay with it."

"Really?"

Kelsey's voice turned husky. "Yes. I can't blame you for wanting to fuck Ryan."

Carynne looked into her eyes. "You want to fuck him too, don't you?" she asked with sudden insight.

Kelsey just nodded, feeling herself blush slightly. "He's so hot. In some ways he's exactly like Damon, but he's just so... I dunno, such a stud. I love how he always simply takes control of a situation. I bet he's exactly the same way in bed, and just thinking about that really turns me on."

"So why don't we both fuck him then?" Carynne asked eagerly. "I know Siara wouldn't mind, not after what she just did."

Kelsey shook her head. "Damon would freak out like crazy, and I don't want to hurt him."

"I thought he was over that jealousy of his?"

"For you, sure. He loves watching me get destroyed by another girl, but that's just the boy in him that loves watching girls go at it. With another guy, I doubt he'd be anywhere near as cool with it."

"Really?"

"I'm pretty sure, yeah. Have you noticed how both of them have stayed away from the other's girlfriend? Ryan will flirt with Stacey, and you, and sometimes even me, but he's never done anything but smile at Amanda. And the same goes for Damon and Siara."

Carynne frowned. "That's just retarded! We're all having tons of fun together, why does there always have to be this dumb territorial bullshit between guys?"

"I don't know. I guess it's in their genes or something."

"God, they're so irritating! Stupid boys and their stupid genes!"

"They do have something you want, though," Kelsey grinned. "Big, hard cocks."

Carynne bit her lower lip. "Yeah."

"You want them to both fuck you at the same time, don't you?" Kelsey said sensually, her mouth just half an inch away from Carynne's ear.

"Yeah..."

"Up your pussy and your ass," Kelsey breathed. "At the same time. Two cocks inside you."

"Yes!" Carynne hissed. "Fuck, I'm so fucking horny, and just thinking about it drives me nuts!"

"Go do it," Kelsey encouraged.

"You sure?"

"Yes. But after they've fucked you like that, I want you to tell me exactly how it felt. Every single stroke, while you stuff both my holes."

Carynne nodded quickly. She gave Kelsey a deep, lingering kiss; then, she got up, almost running over towards Damon and Amanda, who were making out behind the boat's wheel. She felt a tingle in her tummy when she saw that they were both naked, and she discarded her own bikini bottoms in a flash, teasingly trailing her finger through her cunt while hissing at how utterly soaked she was.

"Hey," she interrupted the kissing couple, practically dying with impatience to be filled with two rock-hard cocks.

"Hi!" Amanda smiled at her.

"Can I borrow your boy toy, please?" Carynne moaned.

Kelsey came up behind her. "She's really eager for cock!"

"Yes!"

"What are you gonna do to him?" Amanda asked, playing it up just to tease Damon.

"I want both him and Ryan to fuck me at once!" Carynne blurted out.

"You mean... in your mouth and pussy?" Damon asked haltingly.

"No, in my pussy and my ass!" Carynne mewled. The heat was rising inside her, and her cunt was so wet that its desire threatened to overwhelm her completely. She was mere inches from mounting Damon right in his chair.

Damon's eyes nearly fell out of their sockets, which made Amanda give him a teasing smirk. "Come on, you know you'd love to!" she grinned. "I've seen your porn."

"He does love that," Kelsey added. "I've watched him jerk off to it!"

"Yeah, but watching it and doing it are two different things," he objected. "I'm not all that thrilled about the idea of rubbing against another guy's junk!"

"Damon, please?" Carynne begged.

"Why don't you do it standing up?" Amanda suggested. "She's slender enough that the two of you can carry her forever. Just put her between you two while you're standing, and you can fuck her to pieces without ever getting really near each other."

Damon gawked at his girlfriend in disbelief, but his badly throbbing cock betrayed how excited he was at the idea. Amanda smirked at him, jerking her hand up and down his shaft a few times and spreading his still slowly oozing cum around with her thumb.

"Please?" Carynne asked again, her gorgeous eyes wide open as she stared at him with a pleading look. She almost looked as if she was about to cry.

He scraped his throat and nodded.

"Yes!" Carynne grinned, her demeanor changing instantly. She turned around and ran over to the other side of the boat where Ryan, Siara and Stacey were talking to each other.

"Shit! That was all just an act, wasn't it?" he asked Amanda.

"Of course it was. I've told you before that you need to be careful of her, especially now that she's dating Kelsey," Amanda said impishly. "Kel knows exactly how to push your buttons, and I'm sure she's explained it to Carynne by now."

"Yup!" Kelsey said with a happy grin.

He grinned as he shook his head. "I've been had."

"Oh whatever! You were going to fuck her anyways, so stop playing so hurt!" his sister smirked, punching him in the shoulder.

"Are you sure you're okay with this, Amanda?" he asked sincerely.

She nodded. "I'm fine. Go fuck her, she deserves it."

He swallowed once more, then got up out of the captain's chair. His cock was like a flagpole in the wind, throbbing like crazy, and he had to admit he felt a secret thrill at the thought of stuffing Carynne with his cock.