Harem House - Selene Pt. 12

"I'm sorry." Kat said. "I shouldn't have been flippant like that."

There was silence.

"You can spank me for it later?" Kat said with her uncertainty turning the statement into a question by the end.

Arthur laughed. He rinsed his hand, wiped his face for a second, and then returned to the shampoo bottle to massage Kat's scalp. He didn't take her up on her offer or mention it, but he hoped she knew he appreciated it by the way he spent a lot of his time massaging her scalp with his fingers, even after it was long past time to switch back to Selene.

He continued his story then, letting them know about what he'd done after driving away, coming to the parking lot, and dancing.

"You... danced for a bachelorette party?" Selene asked incredulously. "Why didn't you call me?!?"

"Well, they wanted a guy to dance, or I would have!" Arthur laughed.

Selene blushed and slapped his chest with zero force as he started to wash her body with a soaped-up loofa. He caught her wrist and lifted it, scrubbing the side of her torso in a way that made her squirm and dance for him.

"I meant I would have watched!" Selene giggled. "I would have cheered you on!"

"So would half the school." Kat muttered.

"What?" Selene asked, not having heard Kat's comment, even if Arthur did. His soft smile showed gratitude for the compliment, even though he didn't believe it to be true. He knew he was attractive and in shape, but he didn't imagine that every girl at the University wanted to fuck him just for that.

"Maybe a quarter of the school, for humility's sake." Arthur quipped at Kat, and she laughed, slapping his chest with her hand as Selene had done. Arthur repaid her the same way, using the loofa to make her squirm when he spent some extra time washing her tummy.

He continued the story, telling them about his dance routines and how an awkward start had given way to a surprisingly fun time. Then he got to the strangest part of the story.

"Your boss?" Kat asked incredulously as Arthur picked the shower head off its hook again and started rinsing them off.

"The very same." Arthur nodded. "I had no idea she was at the party, and the next thing I know I'm looking down and she's looking up at me with her lips on my belly button trying to suck out some tequila." He laughed.

"Lucky bitch." Selene playfully crossed her arms in mock anger. "I want to lick tequila off you next time."

"You want to lick everything off him." Kat playfully shoved Selene's arm.

"Knock it off, you two." Arthur said, eyeing the slippery shower floor with a bit of concern for their safety. "I'm not even finished with my story yet." He said as he finished rinsing them down and then grabbed the conditioner.

"Yes, Sir." Kat looked sorry but didn't apologize.

He poured the conditioner onto his hand and massaged Kat's scalp again. After that, he explained about Beth's freakout, how she cornered him in his changing room, and how they eventually agreed that it was fine. "Obviously, don't go retelling this part of the story. I'm only telling you two because..." He hesitated.

"You trust us?" Selene asked.

Arthur laughed but nodded. "I guess I do."

"You guess?" Kat asked, opening one eye at the risk of Arthur stopping the best scalp massage she'd ever had. "I had your balls in my mouth earlier. If you don't trust me, you must like to live dangerously."

Selene laughed.

"Can't it be both?" Arthur teased her.

Kat smirked, but the smirk gave way to her contented smile as her eyes reclosed and started to roll in her head at the massage. She couldn't say that it was better than sex, but it was definitely similar. A different kind of orgasm.

"And then I drove home." Arthur said as though that finished the story. "And then-" He started the story again and told them about his call with his dad.

"Wait." Selene said, watching him massaging Kat's scalp and trying to stamp down the feelings of envy going on in her head. She loved watching her sister happy and watching Arthur be happy and making Kat happy, but that scalp massage was good shit, and Kat was getting two when Selene had only gotten one. "After you stormed off earlier, your dad called to offer you a job? Did you take it? Are you moving?"

"I don't know yet." Arthur answered honestly. "I'm thinking about it, but it would depend on the actual offer. The paperwork. My dad's a man for details, and I want to know what details I'm agreeing to before I sign on."

"How big did you say your parent's house was?" Kat asked.

"Six bedrooms. A master suite, four bedrooms on the second floor, and a finished in-law suite apartment in the basement." Arthur answered. "So if I were to live there and be the landlord, that's five bedrooms left."

"But you won't be across the parking lot anymore." Selene pouted.

"That's true..." Arthur hesitated. "But that doesn't really matter, does it?"

"No, but it is nice." Selene admitted. "And your parent's house is... where?"

"It's about twenty minutes from campus, in the opposite direction of here, so... about forty minutes from here." Arthur hated to tell her, but someone had to. He'd fantasized, of course, about asking Selene to make the move with him, but... those were just fantasies. He knew he couldn't ask her to do that for real, even if they had decided they were more than friends but not quite girlfriend/boyfriend.

Selene pouted again. "But..."

Kat raised an eyebrow as Arthur finished the scalp massage with conditioner and reached for the shower head again to start rinsing her off.

"What are you acting like it's the end of the world for?" Kat asked. "You say your dad wants to rent these rooms out, right?"

Arthur nodded. "Yeah."

"How much are we talking?" Kat asked.

"I don't know yet." Arthur answered. "I'll find out when I look over the paperwork. I imagine it'd be affordable. I'd have to tell him if he tried to gouge people."

"Well yeah, it'd be pretty cheap if everything's getting split ten to twelve ways." Kat nodded as Arthur rinsed the conditioner out of her hair.

"But you'll be forty minutes away!" Selene reached out to grab his arm, but he moved it too much as he worked.

"Or-" Kat held up her hands. "Or, he'll be down the hall."

It took Selene a second to realize what Kat was suggesting, and then her eyes went wide. She was shocked, almost in disbelief, that she hadn't thought of it first. Instead, Kat was the one to suggest it, and she was the one who wanted to try and keep things casual.

Arthur was silent, thinking it over. On the one hand, moving in with Selene and Kat sounded like a dream. One he wanted to come true. They were, all three of them, currently standing naked as he intimately washed the two of them after a bought of quite possibly the best sex he'd ever had. On the other, he and Selene were moving fast. A week ago, they were just friends. Now they were Master and Slave. A week ago, Kat was just a face and a name. Now she was his submissive pupil, and... bath buddy?

Could it work with them as roommates? Housemates? Or would his life implode? Would the people he trusted suddenly decide he wasn't worth knowing? Or maybe all the talk of Lynn from earlier had put him in a bad mood, and he was letting his trauma of trusting others impact his life more than he consciously wanted it to.

Why did decisions that impacted happiness always seem so much bigger than others? Arthur didn't know. He didn't have all the answers and didn't know what the right decision was or even if there was one to make. Then he realized that if both choices had the potential for misery, he should pick whichever had the most potential for happiness.

He just needed to get out of his head and let himself be happy. He had to go for it.

"What do you think, Master?" Selene purred as she reached for the tub's edge and carefully got to her knees. "Could we live with you? Share your house... maybe even your bedroom?"

Arthur smirked at her. "Not fair." He groaned. "You're not letting me think with my brain."

Selene smiled. "You make it hard for me to think with mine. It's only fair."

"I can't make business decisions like that with my dick." Arthur countered.

"No one's suggesting you think with your dick." Kat admonished him as she took the shower head from him and hung it up. "What we need from you is to think about it." She turned off the water. "And some towels."

Arthur handed her and Selene their towels, and they stepped out of the shower and started to dry off. Arthur helped as he could, rubbing one down and then the other, which they seemed to enjoy. The girls were soft, and the towels were comfortable. Arthur enjoyed the intimacy of the act almost as much as he enjoyed the sexuality of it. The feeling was mutual to all three of them. Even Kat had to admit to feeling oddly connected to the other two.

"We'll take one of those extra rooms. That way, you can still have your own, and it won't be like letting your girlfriend and your girlfriend's BDSM-curious sister move in with you directly." Kat suggested. "And we won't be able to play throughout the whole house, obviously, since we'll be sharing it with a bunch of other people, and neither of us can really be your slaves all the time. But-" She took the towel off her face to look directly at Arthur when she said it. "I wouldn't mind staying close by. It's kind of nice having you around."

Arthur sighed but blushed a little at the compliment. It wasn't that Kat always said the sweetest things. Quite the opposite. She was usually so sour that it was savory when she said something sweet because you knew she meant it.

"Alright." He sighed. "I'll think about it. In the meantime, I need to get my shower."

"Wait!" Selene snapped. "Now, it's our turn to wash you."

Arthur sighed but nodded. He let them wash him, knelt in the tub so they could wash his hair, and then stood to let them wash his body. He only had to slap Selene's hand once when she got too interested in cleaning his cock.

"So then what happened? After the call from your dad, I mean." Kat asked as they washed him.

He glanced at Selene and then told the story of how she'd wanted a consensual non-consent scene, and being so riled up, he'd given her one. He knew she'd been awake since he saw her in the window before he came up, and as he guessed, she was more or less ready for him, so it was easy to get into the scene and let him vent some of his frustrations.

He didn't know why, but Kat's mouth grew into a smileless line by the time Arthur got to the point of talking about their brief attempt at anal, Selene's use of the safeword, and the immediate end of all sexy times in favor of aftercare, and how Arthur fell asleep.

Selene saw Kat's look and did her best to assure her sister. "It's okay! As soon as I gave the SOS signal, he was like a superhero swooping in and saving me. It was actually pretty hot. Pulling out of my ass like that really showed you cared."

She'd meant it as a joke, and Arthur smiled at her for it, but Kat didn't smile or laugh. She seemed bothered about something.

"What did you mean when you said 'frustrated'?" Kat asked.

"Huh?" Arthur had to ask for clarification since he didn't know what precisely she was trying to quote. He'd been storytelling for a while.

"When you came home last night. You said you were frustrated and took it out on Selene." Kat responded.

"Oh." Arthur realized what she meant now."From all the women teasing me at the bar." He answered. "There was a lot of touching but no direct stimulation. It was... sexually frustrating."

"So you weren't still upset at seeing Lynn?" Kat asked. "It sounds like you got really aggressive with Selene, dragging her across the floor?"

Arthur fell silent as he thought about it, taking time to replay things in his head and examine his motivations.

"You said we couldn't play if we weren't in the right headspace, or however you phrased it." Kat said after a few quiet moments. "It's in the contract we signed."

Arthur nodded. "Yeah..."

"So you weren't in the right headspace when you fucked Selene!" Kat raised her voice a little. "You were so pissed off at Lynn you could have really hurt her!"

Arthur's first instinct was to defend himself, but Selene beat him to it.

"It wasn't like that!" Selene argued. "I told him to be rough with it. To vent through it. I wanted him to be angry when he fucked me. Memory recall is a valid acting technique, so who cares what he had to do to be in character for our scene!"

Kat looked to Arthur for confirmation, doubt evident in her expression but restrained for her sister's sake.

"You've even complained that he's not assertive enough!" Selene complained. "He was plenty assertive last night!"

Arthur looked at Kat, surprised to hear he had disappointed her somehow. She looked away and glared at Selene for commenting on it.

Arthur looked at Kat, then at Selene, and sighed. "No, Selene. She's right."

"What?" Selene asked, turning.

"I was too upset last night. I shouldn't have done that. She's right." Arthur nodded.

"But I want you to take it out on me when you're upset. I didn't sign any contract!" Selene protested. "I don't care who you're mad at. I can make you feel better if you just come home and pound the shit out of me!"

Arthur almost laughed but realized that the timing was wrong. Or maybe he had a premonition of what Kat would do to him if he treated this lightly.

"And I appreciate that and your love for rough fucking. Believe me." Arthur put his hand over hers as she soaped his chest. "But I have to admit it. I screwed up last night. I'm sorry. I did something I told myself I shouldn't and wouldn't do. The only thing I can do now is to admit it, ask you to forgive me, and take steps to make sure it doesn't happen again." Arthur said solemnly.

"Like what?" Kat asked.

"Well...." Arthur had to think about it for a few moments. "I can do a mental checklist before play like that." Arthur finally decided. "And if I answer yes to any of those questions, then I know to turn it off until the situation approves."

Arthur looked at Selene. "I really am sorry." He said. "Do you forgive me?"

"Of course." Selene leaned forward a little, and they kissed. It was a soft, tender kiss, devoid of heat despite their nudity but full of compassion and tenderness.

Kat coughed gently after a minute.

"But I want you to tell me if you ever see this Lynn bitch again." Selene added when they broke the kiss.

"Okay." Arthur couldn't help but crack a smile. "I can do that."

"And I want to know where she lives and, if possible, where she sleeps. And if she has any particular fears that might be useful, like spiders or clowns." Selene's eyes narrowed as she spoke, and her words took on a harsh and protective edge.

Arthur laughed but nodded. "I think it's best if you two never meet. Besides, she's taller than you. I think she might be able to take you, even with spiders and clowns thrown into the mix.

Kat smirked. "But can she take both of us?"

Selene beamed at her sister.

"Do you forgive me too?" Arthur asked, looking over to Kat.

She seemed less enthusiastic about it than Selene was, but after watching him for a moment. "Send me that checklist when you think of it. I'll add it to the list of things to do before a session when we have our first one."

"Today still doesn't count?" Arthur asked with a laugh.

"No!" She slapped his arm. "I was serious about that! I want a lesson plan!"

Arthur and Selene laughed. "Okay." He agreed. "I'll get one to you as soon as possible. Does... Tuesday night work for you for your first official lesson?"

"Sure." Kat nodded.

Selene coughed and glared at Kat.

"I mean, yes, Sir." Kat corrected herself.

Arthur laughed. "Good girl." He said to Kat. "Not that you're playing right now, so you can ignore Selene's corrections if you want to."

Selene splashed him a little with the water.

"You're both good girls." Arthur corrected himself. "A little over-eager sometimes, but good."

Selene smiled approval at his amendment and stuck her tongue out at him for calling her over-eager.

Kat laughed, and the two finished soaping and washing Arthur, swapping out their cleaning, scrubbing him down, and rinsing him off with the shower head. The spray flickered in heat when he stood up, but he was grateful for their enthusiasm and effort. He took the shower head from Kat, hung it up, and turned off the water as he wiped some water from his eyes.

Selene pulled his towel from the back of the door and knelt in front of the tub. She lifted it up from kneeling, legs open, with both hands, offering it to him. He took it and patted her head in thanks. She nuzzled into his hand and smiled.

Kat shook her head, drying it with a towel and scrunching her hair to keep the curls. She didn't bring any after-care hair products, but she borrowed spray from his medicine cabinet after holding it up and receiving permission.

After a few minutes of grooming, three people trying and failing to share a single mirror; the three of them walked out of the bathroom after hanging their towels up to dry. All three of them were naked but unashamed. It was comfortable, non-erotic nudity as if nudity were a pair of comfy pajamas.

Arthur headed into his bedroom. Kat hung her collar up by the door. Selene grabbed the duffel and brought it into Arthur's bedroom as Kat moved to her backpack by the couch. Arthur fished through his drawers for a while and pulled out an old t-shirt, a pair of jeans, boxer briefs, and some socks. Selene dumped her bag over the bed and looked up at Arthur as he looked down at the pile of clothes and sighed.

He set his clothes on top of the dresser and started fishing through Selene's pile.

He laid out an outfit for her one piece at a time. A multi-colored, mostly purple calf-length gypsy skirt, a small pair of black panties, a black and white polka-dot bra, and a black thinly strapped cami tank top. He set out her usual flip-flops for shoes and trusted that would be sufficient for her study session with Kat.

He also pulled out a second outfit, which caused Selene to quirk an eyebrow at him. "For Monday." He explained as he pulled out a pair of black leggings with a hole on the left thigh, cut-off jean shorts, a red thong, a white bra, a black t-shirt, socks, and sneakers.

"I don't get to see you until tomorrow?" Selene asked.

"Well, I have to go to my parent's house and fix the door. You have to study with Kat, right? And then I've got my date. If it goes well..." He hesitated. "You might not hear about it until tomorrow. Can we get dinner together?"

"DINNER?!" Selene's shouted question surprised Arthur. She seemed genuinely upset, and his immediate instinct was to try and apologize for upsetting her, but he wasn't sure what he'd said that was so upsetting. Mondays were always busy between work, class, and Theater Club in the evening, which is when they usually hung out on Mondays.

Kat cleared her throat from the doorway where she'd just appeared. "We agreed to leave him alone for his date with Mindy, remember? Slut?" She wore a pair of tight blue jeans that hugged every curve of her hips and showed off her butt as the material brightened there. She rubbed her butt with one hand, feeling sensitive from the spanking earlier, and holding a pink off-the-shoulder sweater over her other shoulder.

Selene nodded.

"So if it goes well..." Kat prompted as she stepped into the bedroom and picked up the bra she'd dropped earlier.

"Then I sleep in our apartment tonight." Selene agreed.

Arthur smiled softly. "It's not the end of the world." He assured her. "If things with Mindy don't go well, I can always call you."

Selene smiled.

"Or you could join me at the gym in the morning." Arthur suggested.

"Pass." Kat said. Then, seeing Selene's glare, she added: "For me, anyway." She said as she put her bra on.