All Comments on 'Is She, Isn't She? Ch. 04'

Yes this chapter is seriously a marketing gag …. The chapters before have been fine but not in a place to pay for a next and this last doesn’t help with ….. boring one

OK, so the sequel on Amazon is good enough that it makes up for this TERRIBLE bait and switch.

I read the sequel on Amazon. It makes sense that you would want to be officially published and get compensated for your story and work. The sequel was intense in a why can’t they stop hurting each other way. I still liked the characters but their dynamic together was off. I hope you have more books brewing…. The flow of your writing is remarkable.

Sequel can be found on Amazon/kindle: "Will she, won't she" - it's honestly fabulous!!

When

Like most left it unfinished with a promise of another chapter that never came with that I rate this a 1 star cause the blantent lie and story left unfinished

so much for that sequel...............

Can you please write the sequel already?

If your intention by posting this little crap chapter years later was to attract attention to the Amazon Kindle books (2 of them), you should have just said so. Hiding it in you biography isn't the ideal means of conveying information about a single story series (even if it is the only one you've published).

I changed my ratings on all parts of this story to 1 to help prevent others from wasting their time on it.

Well, unfortunately for you, we DO hate you.

You purposely came back years later to add that CRAP chapter onto what WAS a pretty good story.

And then DISAPPEAR. Well, imagine Jeanie's gesture at Tash in their final showdown. Now imagine it aimed at you.

Damn, so hated the way you ended this great/hot story. So disappointed as they seemed so meant for each other, yes Jeanie was a spoiled brag, and maybe cheating on Ashley and so Jeanie deserved to get dumped, but more lead up to the brake up would have been appreciated. Sequels sometimes are hard to locate on Literotica. So, guess we lose what may happen to these two later on. Dropped from a 5 to a 3, so sad but life is full of bumps.

So. Another "Rivals," where the idea is to hook a following and then make them pay, right? Don't hate you, there'll be a sequel? I don't hate you (waste of energy) but I'm not buying your sequel. Pity. I might've bought the whole set, if not for the bait and switch.

7 years later, still waiting for the sequel...

I read a lot of comments, because the story didn`t end with" the cliché" happy ending, well, let`s face it , the relationship is not about good sex only and their was definitely unbalanced; Jeanie's character was unsteady most of the time, she didn`t know what she want, she was hesitated about her sex orientation. For me Ashly deserve a bitter person who is stable and know the true meaning of love not only hot chick like Jeanie. there is a huge difference between lust and love, and their relationship was obviously a pure lust. that is why I liked when they had separated (it is a happy ending to me), but hated it when read they may back together again. it is just will not working life is not about sex only. anyhow, please I want anyone to explain me that sentence (INSERT HOT SPANKING SCENE HERE)!

finally agree or disagree this story build a lot of tension, and that must be recorded for the writer, it`s not ordinally story, it`s a very good written drama story with a hot sex scene by a very talented author.

My mistake I read the chapter 4.

I thought this was an excellent story but I must say that the sequel, "will she-wont she is better. This can be found on Amazon Kindle for a nominal fee. It is a complete follow up from this albeit four years on

Literotica should actually REMOVE stories such as this, notwithstanding the fact that it is a fantastic story (or was).

If the author chooses to write half a story as an advert, then Literotica should remove said story or make it clear that they are charging for their services.

I have no problem with authors making money, BUT it should be made clear from the first part of a story that it is only a teaser and the full tale will be charged for.

For those wondering, the sequel 'will she, won't she' (you can still get it on amazon/kindle) explains a lot of the emotional background and character development for that matter. It's definitely well done and worth your time, completing this story.

I must say I don't understand the character development in this story. Jeanie goes from a down-to-earth, sympathetic, friendly young adult working at a gay bar (even though she is straight but still being friendly and tolerant) to this complete maniac with no common sense or even a trace of empathy.

I can understand behaving differently at work and in private. It's totally believable that she's a party-girl at her age and is afraid of the consequenses a potential outing might have in her homophobic social life. Even having a fling with some male stripper while her friend literally called 10 minutes earlier to pick her up being is understandable I guess considering her confusion and other emotions. Then comes the big 'happy ending' where everyone confesses their love and all that. You don't have to be into that personally and it certainly doesn't work like that in real life but it fits the story. However stating everything was a lie in the epilogue, e.g. lying about the phone call with the parents and all that doesn't make much sense considering the enormous confessions of love in the pervious chapter and their history and effort they made. However the part I don't get at all is Jeanie going compeltey crazy in the end. Every relationship got it's up and downs but they were head over heels in Love just 2 month ago and now Jeanie behaves like a immature child without any empathy or common sense at all. I mean she used to work at a gay bar being straight and handled being hit on with confidence friendliness and self control. Just a few months later she get's a child like and unreasonable tandrum because of her new boss being 'fat', when he's just chubby. It doesn't make any sense at all. This could have been the result of a 20 years long marriage with constant fighting, not 2 month after falling utterly in love with each other. I still enjoyed the story apart from it's ending and partially unreasonable character development though. It was definitely well written and maybe some day there will be a sequel explaining some of what happened.

What a miserable last chapter!! What happened to you? Did you had to run to The Antarctica? Chased by a wolf? On high heels? Did your fairy godmother deserted you? Girl it doesn’t seem to be written by the same person. You acknowledged that in the end but you haven’t done nothing more. Nor a different story. You did so well In the previous chapters...I hope you are fine and take care of yourself but dear your characters had life...and we, the readers of your lost ark, we are expecting you to write as you did in 1,2,3!

Big hug

If you're looking for the sequel....It's Will she , Won't she and itx an ebook..Check it online...

You know after reading the previous chapters witch where realy well written en nice and long this was a sorry excuse of a last chapter

I had better hope for this storry

Hope you will be back with more good stuff like the first 3 chapters

Ummmm... wheres the sequel???

haha first of all...

YEAST infection anyone? beer and coochie should never mix.

second of all...

reading these again in 2019, I can now see the toxicity of their relationship for what it is haha poor ash, should have just stayed away from the straight girls... also I’m not a huge fan of the descriptors used for the non-femme characters - there’s always the implication that the more traditionally ‘butch’ characters are stereotypically masculine or overweight etc they are just generally described using unflattering terms unlike the femmes - show some love for the community man. We are very diverse creatures and we should be allowed to feel accepted regardless of body type.

You can’t buy ebooks on the mobile app. Apple would get a cut of it. You have to buy it using a pc or Mac or Kindle.

I found it on amazon ,, but it said that i cant purchase it anymore .. is their any place i can read it ,, bcz i would love to know the end .

Search for "Will She, Won't She?"

So about this sequel... where’s it at?

How can a love so right go so wrong?

Jeanie seduced Ashie for what ?? The lols??

Stop torturing us and write a sequel as you promised

PLEASE!!!

It’s not fair to ashie and how she was dumped and heartbroken

Thank You for a beautiful story xx

It would be awesome to tell the story from Jeanie’s point of view including the years between their first breakup, the time after Ashley leaves to return home (I am sure Viv coached Jeanie through it all). Would also like to read more about their wedding and family as I am sure the live happily ever after. The first two books were Among the best books I have ever read. Awesome - Thanks!

Hopefully she does do a spinoff, if she would, me personally would choose Chantelle and Vivienne. She could so rock that. We really know nothing about Chantelle. Vivienne is a cook/chef. Chantelle and Vivienne are blunt when they speak it would be really cool to see if she would do a spinoff.

Still re-read Is She, Isn't She? and Will She, Won't She? every now and then. Still among the very best erotica I've read.

Would love almost more than anything for a third chapter in the Ashley and Jeanie story.

Read both books (Kindle) and would like to see more. Understand Ashley & Jeanie may be a closed book, although with their "issues," I somehow doubt that. However, there are some interesting side stories that, IMHO, deserve telling if you put pen to paper again; for instance anything with Chantelle or Meredith & Olivia or spin-off stories from Boltons?

The sequel is on amazon. To me it is a great book. Though I do wish harmony would continue to write. Harmony has a gift of combining erotica and a love story together, that is bold, touching, and comes across realistic also. Hopefully one day she will write more.

When is the sequal coming it's been 3 fucking years

(insert incredibly insightful criticism here)

🤦

Will HarmonyHaze ever write another story? This story was so realistic and in depth. I, purchased both books. Have read many books by many authors to find the kind of depth in this story compaired to others, I have only found one. HarmonyHaze, please continue to write. I'll purchase your books. Thank you for an awesome heartfelt story.

lol it's a pity such a magnificent story can have such a bullshit ending.

*insert hot spanking scene* wow. just wow.

i really do!

this is much better, at least it is not 9 pages long

When will will she won't she come on the site. Really want to finish reading the series.

You can get the continuation of this story on Amazon. "Will She, Won't She" is the title.

At first I didn't managed to purchase it on Amazon, not in my country. But thank goodness I was able to purchase it on Kindle somehow, it was worth every cents! I'm so glad I could finish the story, the anticipation was killing me. Haha millions of thank you, dear author <3 Looking forward to your next story.

So envy to all the peeps who read wsws ... Wish i can access amazon here iny my country so i can satisfy myself rereading it over & over again... T_T

The conclusion to this story is called- will she won't she? And I purchased it from Amazon!

WTF?

Where is it possible to find the serie outside this site and how? What is it called? I can't find it anywhere and all I see here is how everyone has read it!! Please someone?

Just wanted to say, love your work. I gladly bought your series on amazon.

Will there ever be writing from jeanie's perspective. I'd be interested in purchasing 5yr update lol told from her side.

From the amount of people hounding and pleaded for you to finish WSWS, then straight away complaining because you were smart and understood that you could have success financially from a project YOU worked incredibly hard on, (which by the way 90% of your fans where happy to pay for, and me personally I was like 'shut up and take my money!' lol) shame on the other 10% that ruined it for everybody else! It's called SUPPLY and DEMAND people! You would be crazy not to put it on AMAZON or where ever else! And yes I understand that literotica is a free site, but the author did give you 7 FREE CHAPTERS! And we were all hooked on an incredible story! I am also very disappointed in this site in regards to taking down the WSWS series, were is the loyalty to your writers? Harmony generated some serious buzz over her Ashie and Jeanie love story. I just feel sorry for the people who won't get to stumble over this delightfully loving story! Sucks to be you... but we all know who's to blame. . And it's NOT the author.

-xx chookie

Could you possibly add 'She is, Isn't she?' to kindle unlimited also?

Yes, HH, please let us know once the ebooks are available in other sites other than Amazon. Although we've read d stories in lit,we'd like to show our support n appreciation by purchasing ur ebooks. However, amazon is making it impossible for some of us to do so. It's frustrating. 😒

I'm from Spain and I had no problems buying the book. They also have it in the Spanish Amazon store.

And thanks Harmony this series is a piece of art, perfection in every chapter and complex well written characters. I truly appreciate your work and you sharing it with us.

God this story really made me go crazy! I NEED the sequel...I'm trying to buy it on amazon, but I'm from Spain and i don't know how it will work. I just wanna say Ashley and Jeanie have to end together...! please... :(

I cant thank the author enough for her hard work and for sharing it with us! please never stop doing it!

Really hope you can upload the sequel again...I'm going crazy right now...

Guys, please don't breach my copyright. I've given you most of my stuff for free - 7/8 chapters for free. I worked hard on this project, and I'm asking you to not to do this to me.

I'm working on getting the book onto more sites for you to download and enjoy, so it's got broader reach, and will post availability updates when I can.

I'd like to keep writing, but some of you are making the experience difficult. I published through Amazon because someone exploited ISIS a few years ago and made money from it, so this time, I want to protect my copyright. I'm asking for your cooperation and understanding. I'll continue to give you some of my stuff for free - provided you do the right thing by me also.

HH x

For fuck sake.. That is unacceptable @lucky711. Way to incur the author's wrath.

So ya ain't got a kindle and my phone is incompatible with the kindle app and I don't have no laptop. After all my efforts to try read the whole series I probably will never see how this story plays out :/... Sickened that they took all the other parts to this story down so now I can't even relive the moments. Hope you upload the whole story on to this site sometime. Until then I will keep checking everyonce in awhile. All the best Harmony don't let the take down of the other parts to this story let ya down I'd love to read your future work :). Lots of love and support, Lisa ( your big time Irish fan :D)

This is only the sample

This series is one of my all-time favorites and I've re-read "Is She, Isn't She?" because I care about (and miss--hint, hint, Harmony) these characters.

I absolutely despised the Epilogue--but it was so necessary. Ashley and Jeanie belong together, but they simply weren't ready to be together at this time in their lives. Harmony has taken a lot of heat for this chapter (forget the [insert spanking scene]--it's in the book, okay?), but this is not the ending. This chapter sets up the next phase (WSWS), that I look forward to with great anticipation.

Thanks, Harmony for all your work on this story. It's wonderful work.

dude that REALLY was a bullshit ending. At the very least you could have written the spanking scene and what happened after.

That was a bullshit ending.

Seriously this chapter is crap u have done a good job for the first 3 chapter. Please give us a good ending not this shit please just a good conclusion

There is a sequel. The first two chapters are up, and it's amazing. We're all eagerly awaiting Chapter 3.

And while the (insert spanking scene) could have been approached differently, she does offer the full epilogue in the ebook version of the story, which has also been polished and tightened up. The full epilogue also sets up the sequel quite well.

The Amazon link is in the author bio

I see a few references in the comments chain to a link on Amazon, but can't find it anywhere. Can someone please post it to here. thanks.

The first three parts were outstanding: well written, sexy and romantic. The epilogue could have had Ashley and Jeanie breaking up and, whilst sad, would have been realistic given their characters. A further sequel reuniting the would have been an option later had you wished to write one.

However, the shambolic *insert hot sex scene* nonsense? Utter crap. Please delete this chapter and give the series back its dignity and charm.

Sue

I didn't see Ashley & Jeanie working out either at this point b/c of Jeanie's immaturity. & if you're possibly reuniting them in the future in their world, then it would only make sense that they'd have to split first. I've not bought the book on Amazon yet, & had I not read the majority of comments - yours in particular Harmony, I wouldn't even bother. But I'm gonna ;-) cuz I trust you. I'm not sure if I'm disappointed with this chapter or not. Not sure I'd want their break up drug out in lenght & sorted details, I think it would make me hate Jeanie, lol. I'm not particularly fond of her right now, but I know it's her age, & hopefully with more age she'll gain wisdom & strength of character. I've myself never tried a relationship with someone significantly younger than me for just this reason. Hoping you bring it round in the end... best wishes... patiently waiting ;-)

Much of this has probably been expressed already, but I want to cleanse my mind on this.

I see nothing wrong with the way you handled Ashie or Jeanie here.

What had really bothered me was the way you delivered the chapter. It looks like you were on a hurry or in a lazy mood when you wrote it. If so, why you did it? It looks like a sloppy draft.

You are such an amazing writer and my hopes were high due to the first 3 chapters. The style, tone, setup, word choice, narration, all of it was pure delight! I honestly cannot say enough about how much I loved it but this one makes me nothing but frustrated. It seems off to me.

But I must say that I trust you.

I trust that your talent will give us the closure the first 3 chapters deserve.

Sure you can do it and I will be here to praise you.

>_> Why didn't you actually enter a second hot sex scene for one and two when are you going to post the next chapter??? i've been waiting forever!

I LOVED this story up until now. The first, second and third were exceptional! But this... this was utter crap. Not only does it not give closure like an epilogue should but it clearly isn't even finished!!

*insert spanking session here* wtf? that's not even funny. Very unhappy with how this ended.

I HATED THE ENDING. Everything else was brilliant (to make it worse Liverpool have just let Chrystal Palace come back from 3:0). You need to finish this. PLEASE.

want more please

The ending felt rather abrupt and slightly confusing, however it was a well written chapter (IMO), and the sex scene was top notch! I am eagerly awaiting the next part, which I hope is just as good (if not better) than this one. I also hope that you consider writing more stories on lit in the future as I have enjoyed this one immensely. I wish you all the best.

- BlueberryWaffles

Very please you have decided to continue with this story and am about to head over to amazon to buy the book. I like and can empathise with both the main characters, although at 22 Jeanie is a little older than I was when I went through the 'am I aren't I' stage, ultimately we cannot help who we fall in love with. If Jeanie has really fallen for Ashley she will at some point realise this and finally make the commitment Ashley needs. Which every direction you take this in I look forward to reading more. Thanks

WTF?

First three parts were wonderful, but this? You named it "epilogue" so I hoped for a real epilogue. And now we have more questions than before. What kind of epilogue has a sequels???

"INSERT HOT SPANKING SCENE HERE" Yeah, har har... Could you act like a writer and respect your own work?

Can you write like An 8 or 9 page sequel? I really like this story and I want it to continue as much as possible.

I'll wait for the next installment... And as far as Jeanie is concern, yes she's young, immature, selfish, spoiled brat,,,do I need to go on. Sometimes living in an adult environment tend to help the young acquire knowledge to become more mature. IMHO Jeanie will get through this with Ashley's help. I feel Ashely will be Jeanie lifebuoy and anchor. And the grow old together (i wish). On a different note HarmonyHaze I trust, you know what you're doing. Beside who am I...I'm just a simple reader who got hooked on the story. Have a pleasant time and hope to see the sequel when it will be ready.

Yves

Thank you. What 22yo is mature enough not to be a selfish little so-and-so? Especially one who's been as spoilt as Jeanie has been, with looks and brains etc? She thinks she can have whatever she wants, whenever she wants it and her behaviour manifests that.

If Ashley and Jeanie were ever going to work - and I'm not saying that they will, or that they won't - they were not going to work at the end of ch. 3 - precisely because Jeanie was too young.

I know perfectly well what I'm doing. And unless something happens to me, it won't be a 4yr wait, dw. I've set myself a vague 6 month deadline.

I hope you all have a wonderful weekend,

x.x. harmony x.x.

While some of the readers seem put off by the fact that Jeanie still hasn't grown up, I find it quite reasonable. Sure, at the end of chapter 3, she was seemingly devoted to Ashley, but that was the result of a sudden about face, brought on by the fact that Ashley had quit pursuing her. Personally, it sounds as if Jeanie is a girl who is addicted to drama and the "excitement" it brings. I was once engaged to be married to this type of girl. I recognize the type. Ashley should learn, crazy girls are great in the sack, but they aren't really relationship material. Either Jeanie needs to grow up or Ashley needs to move on. Thanks for continuing the story and thanks for keeping Jeanie consistantly immature.

What happen? between ch. 03 & ch. 04, 4 years went by for the readers but surely not for Jeanie & Ashley. 'cause in 4 years Jeanie would have had time to acquire a little bit of maturity but not a 180 on her behavior and attitudes. So please in the next installment give us more substance as opposed to this lousy "epilogue" ( sorry had to speak my mind). I'm 56 years old and my heart still long for story with happy ending and I'm not talking about the physical but rather happy ending. I was so taken by the first chapter that I had to read the others 3 in a row. But still I'll have to give you a 5 stars 'cause it's a moving story.

Thank you, thank you, thank you for the first 3 chapters.

Hi,

I'm so glad to read again from you after so many years. It shows that one should never give up on an author.

"She is, isn't she" was one of the best stories I read on Literotica and I hope that you will keep on writing, at least for a while.

a sequel taking place a couple months later, told from Jeanie's perspective with her trying to get Ashley back.

Time is a natural remedy to all things, I think. Not that my opinion matters a great deal here, but I love how this chapter dealt with the unexpected and expected problems that challenge relationships - it's real. And, before anyone else writes off this sort of writing because it doesn't flow with other porn-infused fantasies that seem to just thrive on this site, it doesn't necessarily implicate the writer "lost her touch". Jesus, hasn't anyone heard of trying something new? Cool off, calm down. If you cannot find it within yourself to respect someone's thoughts for their own, then bite your tongue and try your damnedest to find the cohesive blueprints all writers leave lingering in their work to better understand what, how, and why she included the major events in this chapter in the first place.

Lots of love, Harmony.

I votet 5 stars for this chapter even I've not read it yet. I even dont care about what's going on in this chapter bc I belive in you, in your words. And just let u know, youre doing good. I love your stories and cant wait for next chapter.

I have actually read this stories couple times and the previous one. I can't say likes it all together. I love the feeling that is being displayed in certain part. But as much as I love and enjoy reading lesbian stories in this site, because I considered myself gay. I have read almost all stories in here and have not find many stories I can say that deals with loyalty commitments and love, it's mostly lust and and one night stand, it's always sex before really even knowing someone, can't sex wait after marriage even for lesbians? I don't care what the result is anymore I am done reading from this site altogether. It's just sick porn in written forms.

When I saw the amazon link I immediately rushed to buy it as this is my all time favorite story on the Lit. I read through the story once more...This story is gripping...It reminds me of Fifty Shades of Grey...You just can't stop reading...You have to get to the very end. That's why when I finished the epilogue I was like "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO" where are the rest of the pages? :-)

http://nooooooooooooooo.com/ (Press when in dire need)

Harmony, we thank you for this marvelous piece of work. As others have said before, please don't make us wait another four years.

Excellent piece of work once more, although it felt heart wrenching to learn of their separation.

I absolutely love this series and have been begging for a continuation.

Guess we're back to the "she isn't" part again , it is a logical turn of events though.

Looking forward to the next chapters , hope it's at the same level as the first 3 .

Thanks Harmony , did buy the book on Amazon. (In South Africa)

I don't know why everyone is upset. True, I was a bit upset about what happened in this chapter but I actually love this chapter because it's real. Things aren't always perfect in relationships you guys. I just hope the next chapters are even better.

Good Job!

You have captured the reality of relationships. Looking forward to more.

Thanks for sharing.

IDB.

love your works...cant wait....please don't make us wait another 4 years...pleaseeeeeeee

The spanking scene is in the book version, and I did what I needed to do to set the stage for the sequel - don't worry, I'm writing you another book. Love your positive, and your negative feedback, equally ;)

x.x. harmony x.x.

I took some time to think through my feedback before posting. I truly loved the first three chapters, beautifully written and a very sweet story... Still, maybe I am the only one that looked at these two girls and thought "this will never work long term"... Because it wouldn't. Jeanie was a brat, yes she came around, and yes she came to Ashley full of love and acceptance... But even till the very end of ch. 3 she was immature, rash and combative. I love Ashley, but i think she was in such a different place in her life that it was bound to be an issue. I actually never figured out why Ashley wanted Jeanie so badly, but attraction and want are hard to figure.

I wish this wasn't chapter 4, I agree that the first three chapters stood on their own.. Too late for that, but I do think the next chapters need to be a new story, with a new title... Reference the original, but when they meet again it should be as who they are now.

Wtf did I just read the other chapters were wonderful. When I came on today I was so happy but when I found it was 2 pages... -_- Just hurry with the sequel and put more effort into it please. The ending could've had more detail.

Seriously,are you punking us right now? I know she needed a spanking,but please as there is christ in heaven,don't let us wait 4yrs for the squeal .

This looks like it was cobbled together in the same amount of time it took to read it.

Your first three chapters were great, but THIS.....Seriously?

This had a complete 180 for the characters. I don't recall Jeanie being that thoughtless and self absorbed......Who are you and what have you done with HarmonyHaze?

Needs to be' uploaded ASAP, else people will start forgetting how beautiful the first 3 chapters were and you'll have ruined this story.

Please be carefull.

P.S. I fucking hate you!

Please get Jeanie and Ashely back together. :((

First off, I'm a big fan of the original three chapters. I have read them numerous times and seem to enjoy them more and more. There are times when I'm feeling down and so I'll read Jeanie's speech in chapter three, it always makes me smile. Now, to learn that she lied about what she told Ashley and herself, I'm flabbergasted.

I'm not surprised that this is where the relationship turned. I get that if you continue a story, you need conflict. But the way they go about it is literally unbelievable. Previously, the characters had so much depth and raw emotion that it was easy to connect with them. Now, there's just two names on a screen, one acting childish the other acting foolish.

I'm so confused on what you wished to accomplish with this post. If anything, this is a good start to an unfinished story. I know that you are more than capable to write something that can greatly surpass this. Please don't ruin the connection your loyal readers have already made with your amazing characters.

This is so dissappointing.. I'm a big fan of your writing skill but this is crap! I hate the ending it seemed to me that it was done in a hurry. Hope you do justice in the next chapter.

When I saw an update for this series, I was stunned - the first three parts rank very high on my list and I remember the story line well. The first page of this had some promise to continue that.... but yeah, this ending. Did you really mean to submit this? It looks like you wrote an outline, and forgot to fill in the last two parts.

I don't want to give a crappy score, so I'll abstain for now in hope that you'll fix this story, which you've clearly demonstrated before that you can.