Little Sister's Big Butt Ch. 08

If she had been more lucid, Gabby would have reasoned that, for all intents and purposes, the 'challenge' she had thrown at Tyler was lost at that point: in the epic duel between her insatiable asshole and his mighty butt-drilling tool, he had clearly won, as proven by the fact that he was still plowing away while she was melting in pleasure and struggling to retain what little control over her dick-milking anal muscles she still had. But Gabby was far from being lucid, and she didn't really care about 'winning' anymore. In truth, the vast majority of her endorphin-addled brain cells would have argued that she was the one who had won, and big time too, and, in that sense, the incessant incapacitating waves of anal and clit-empowered delight washing over her were the sweet prize of her victory.

Eventually, unconcerned and indeed unable to maintain her sassy 'anal queen persona' and caring only about the self-renewing joy brought on by the string of mini climaxes coursing through her, Gabby let herself crumple down, her arms failing to support her any more and thus letting her upper body rest onto Michelle's soft little frame lying underneath her. Finding herself face down and ass up, with her mouth inches away from her friend's nectar-glossy pussy and her dick-impaled booty being held possessively by Tyler's strong hands, Gabby let out a long languid squeal as the many wavelets of delight overwhelming her suddenly coalesced again and exploded outward in another huge assgasm that shook her very core, causing her well-licked slit to gush profusely all over Michelle's mewling, slurping mouth.

"Uuungh! Fuuuuck! Ooohh fuuck yeeeeahhhh!" Gabby screamed, undone by her amazing climax and by the persistent bursts of physical ecstasy that overpowered her and took her breath away again and again and again, reigniting her assgasm every time she felt Tyler's humongous dick slamming balls-deep into her narrow rectum.

Dissolving in the delicious haze of her epic climax, Gabby finally lost the will and ability to control what had been so far the most flawless series of shaft-tugging anal squeezes that Tyler had ever experienced. Still, since Gabby stopped her skillful management of her anal muscles while she was right in the middle of a huge assgasm, Tyler didn't quite experience any major changes at first, since his rectum-plowing schlong seamlessly went from being systematically milked by the velvety grip of the brunette's anal walls to being powerfully massaged and sucked on by the orgasmic spasms that possessed her snug forbidden passage.

Only once the most intense, toe-curling part of Gabby's release was over and the contractions of her steamy chute diminished to milder but still fantastic dong-engulfing pulsations did Tyler realize that, apparently, the brunette had given up on trying to control the situation and had finally surrendered to the pure, unchecked pleasure of their wild anal coupling. Of course a big clue in that sense had already been the sight of Gabby's lithe frame flopping down face first on top of Michelle moments earlier, but still Tyler only realized in full just how overwhelmed the brunette was when he felt his pistoning cock being suckled by the spontaneous ripples of her snug tunnel, rather than by the calculated contractions she herself had so far imposed on her anal walls. In a way, this felt even better, if only because it was a natural and spontaneous response to his sodomizing assault, instead of a stubborn attempt on Gabby's part to 'win' a naughty and super pleasurable albeit unnecessary contest.

Far from being the boisterous or gloating type, Tyler didn't say anything about his obvious 'victory', and he didn't much dwell on the fact that, in a way, he had just kind of tamed an undisputed and very willful anal queen such as Gabby. Sure, those were ego-boosting and nice enough thoughts, but they were far from being the main focus of Tyler's mind at all. Actually, as he steadily kept thrusting himself balls-deep inside Gabby's cozy anus, forcing more and more gushes of girlcum to squirt from her pussy straight into Michelle's slurping mouth while also coaxing louder and throatier yelps of pleasure from Gabby's lips, Tyler began sort of worrying about the brunette's semi-unconscious condition. Though orgasm-induced, Gabby's passivity was somewhat baffling to witness, mostly because it was a state in which Tyler had never seen her before.

And indeed what Gabby felt at that moment was something completely new and undeniably transformative. Limp and surrendered and as totally anally owned as she could ever imagine being, Gabby was so transfixed with sexual bliss that she couldn't even begin to care about showing off her buttqueen status anymore. Tyler's huge ass-splitting cock and Michelle's pussy-pleasing mouth had made the brunette cum like crazy, and she had been hit particularly deep by her epic orgasms because they were empowered by that undefinable, irrepressible spark of love that pervaded the siblings' very cores and radiated outward from them, touching and changing everyone they welcomed into their world and shining out in everything they did.

In a way, the fact that Gabby had never reciprocated Michelle's slit-muching attentions all through that wild three-way coupling was the ultimate proof of how genuinely overpowered she was; under normal circumstances, Gabby would never have missed a chance to taste Michelle's exquisite little pussy, but of course the circumstance were currently anything but normal. Although she had expected her first assfuck with Tyler to be a milestone of sorts and most likely a nice big orgasmfest too, Gabby was not prepared for the actual thing, not at all. Even now, as she floated away on wave after wave of mingled anal and clitoral bliss, a tiny semi-rational part of her out-of-order brain still marveled at the fact that, despite having rested her head on Michelle's smooth thigh, she wasn't even attempting to lean closer and press her mouth to her petite friend's dewy pussy. But that simply wasn't possible, not while the thundering aftershocks of Gabby's savage rapture still rumbled through her conquered frame.

A vague semblance of consciousness did return to the brunette once Tyler, getting mildly worried about her incoherent gurgling mewls and her persistent unresponsiveness, relented the beat of his rectum-cramming thrusts and slowed almost to a stop. At the same time, noticing the change of pace in her brother's sodomizing assault, Michelle unglued her lips from Gabby's nectar-dripping pussy, but not before administering a final clit-slurping smooch to it.

"Uuhnghh... N-n-nnoohh... D-d-don't... Don't stop... Mmgh fuck... Oowhh fuck!" Gabby mumbled, her voice dopey and thick with post-orgasmic grogginess and satisfaction.

Grinning and licking her girlcum-glossy lips, Michelle craned her neck and looked around Gabby's shaky legs to see her friend's climax-transfixed face as she asked: "You okay, Gabs? Aren't you dehydrated or something? You squirted like crazy!"

Chuckling weakly as she emerged from her pleasure-trance and tried to catch her breath, Gabby smiled beatifically and said: "That was... Sooo intense! Oh my god, my clit is super sensitive right now... Great job, girl, but, like, that's totally enough. I'm scared that if you eat me out any more I'm gonna die!"

Tittering along with Gabby, Michelle disentangled herself from underneath the brunette's exhausted body, rolled onto her side and then straightened up on her knees beside Tyler, who instantly locked gazes with her and smiled at her while taking in her radiant, girlcum-slick face and her huge jiggly boobs.

With a complicit grin curling up her gorgeous, nectar-glossy lips, Michelle proudly stated: "Looks like we totally won, Ty! Up high!"

Laughing with her, Tyler gladly high-fived Michelle even as Gabby grumbled and groaned.

"Hey, it was two against one, so of course you won, duh... Plus you haven't even cum in me yet, stud, so I call the whole thing, like, null and void or something!"

To the sound of Michelle's ever more entertained giggles, Tyler looked at Gabby, who was in turn looking back at him over her shoulder even as she lay there, face down and ass up, totally wiped out and barely capable to keep her rump tilted up, which she could kinda pull off mostly thanks to Tyler's hands still grabbing onto her buttcheeks and holding her in place. Furrowing his brow yet feeling his fully sheathed cock flex with desire deep inside Gabby's snug anal passage, Tyler asked: "Are you sure? I mean, I'm pretty close, but if you're too tired or..."

"Too tired!?" Gabby scoffed, her usual feistiness and signature smirk returning as she focused her dark eyes on Tyler and somewhat drunkenly went on. "Come on, stud! You should know me better than that! Just fuck my ass and fill it with cum, or I'm gonna have to be mad at you even if you made me squirt like a fucking porn star!"

"Well, you heard her..." Michelle smiled, knee-walking even closer to Tyler and pressing her soft curvy body against his muscular frame, locking her arms around him in a tender hug in the process.

"Okay. Here goes..." Tyler shrugged, nodding at Gabby and instantly resuming his sodomizing assault once again.

Like he had done up to the moment of the brunette's earth-shattering climax, Tyler didn't hold anything back and, on top of it, he also channeled his long-accumulated need to cum in those final booty-plundering thrusts. Reassured by Gabby's wanton mewls and excited by the passionate girlcum-flavored kisses that Michelle began planting on his lips as he humped away like a madman, Tyler reamed the brunette's clingy asshole with the sole purpose of finally emptying his huge cum-laden balls inside the warm, rippling confines of her tight chute.

Sliding in and out of her well-lubed and thoroughly fucked bootyhole with all the speed and energy that his roaring asslust gave him, Tyler drove his horsecock frenziedly into Gabby's cozy rectum, impaling her over and over again, trading ever steamier kisses with his adored little sister all the while. As he unleashed that savage rump-splitting rampage on Gabby, Michelle couldn't help but sneak her hand back to the brunette's pussy again. Respecting her friend's wishes, Michelle left Gabby's clit alone and limited herself to gently rubbing her nectar-drenched labia, teasing Gabby's virgin slit just enough to enhance the crackling jolts of anal bliss that were raining down on her at Tyler's every rectum-plugging plunge.

Having held back his ejaculation while fucking both of his sister's tight holes first and now Gabby's exquisite butthole too, Tyler didn't take long to reach his limit. His overswollen and achingly stiff boner was buried to the hilt inside Gabby's spasming anal passage when he was finally pushed over the edge, spectacularly so. As his beefy ballsack tingled and a giant load of sperm surged along his throbbing dong, Tyler grunted into Michelle's wet, tongue-sucking mouth and held himself right where he was, jammed balls-deep up Gabby's butt, and finally allowed his pleasure to explode.

"Uuugh fuck! Ooohh yeah, stud, fill my ass!" Gabby mewled in obscene delight as soon as the first geyser-like blast of warm cum erupted into her deepest anal depths, only to be followed by more and more jetting spurts that quickly inundated her cock-crammed rectum with Tyler's creamy, soothing sperm. "Uuunngh yeeaah, cum in my ass... Oohh shiiit, so fucking good!"

Despite having climaxed like crazy already, Gabby had been brought to the edge once again during Tyler's savage rump-wrecking flurry. Unavoidably, now that he was hosing her buttery bowels with his thick seed, the brunette couldn't help but get swept away by another roaring assgasm, one that felt particularly delicious to her both because it was a purely anal climax with no clitoral aftertaste and because it was synced with Tyler's own orgasm and with the massive butt-flooding spray of cum that it entailed.

Less breathtakingly brutal than her previous climaxes, that final assgasm was still way more special than all the others before to Gabby, because only then, while her not-so-fake stud of a boyfriend pumped her ass full of cum, she felt like Tyler had properly claimed her, finally, by painting her anal walls white like he had done with his sister so many times before. Now, much to her inexpressible joy, Gabby knew she was truly inextricably connected to Tyler the way she already felt connected to Michelle, with whom she had been sharing many, many orgasms in the previous days. Indeed, as her pussy gushed with her liquid pleasure once again, the dick-impaled brunette moaned so loud and so blissfully that she more than compensated for the fact that Tyler was too busy making out with Michelle to vocalize his immense pleasure in filling her shaft-squeezing chute with his seed.

Long-delayed as it was, Tyler's ejaculation was even more monumental than usual, so much so that, by the time his fully sheathed pole was done flexing and bucking and swelling against the smooth, snug walls of Gabby's forbidden passage, her ass was so totally flooded with his milky seed that some gooey droplets were starting to seep past the tautly stretched, dick-gripping ring of her butthole, thus crowning the base of Tyler's dong with a frothy sheen of run-off sperm. As Gabby whimpered in orgasmic delight and basked in the slutty joy of having her cock-jammed rectum thoroughly coated in the lewd balm that was Tyler's overabundant jizz, Michelle noticed the pearly globs of her brother's cum trying to escape past the clingy seal of Gabby's dilated sphincter, and that sight instantly spurred her into action.

Ungluing her lips from Tyler's mouth with a final smacking kiss, Michelle leaned down and rested her face sideways on top of Gabby's curvy ass as she stuck her tongue out and began lapping up the trickles of cum seeping past her butt-ring and accumulating at the base of his dong. A puppy-eyed glance was all that Michelle needed to convey to her big brother her desire to feed on more of his heady seed. Chuckling and exhaling in satisfaction as his afterglow set in, Tyler smiled at Michelle and slowly began pulling his horsecock out of Gabby's sperm-flooded rectum. Withdrawing with calculated laziness, Tyler grinned all the way while watching his gorgeous little sister slurp up his cum-lathered shaft as it emerged one fat inch at a time from the brunette's overstretched orifice, his eyes following Michelle's seed-scooping tongue as it fluttered and swiped and swirled all around his retreating truncheon.

Eventually, once only his large cockhead remained engulfed within the rubbery grip of Gabby's conquered butthole, Tyler locked gazes with Michelle and raised his eyebrows in question, to which she licked her lips and promptly answered with a nod. The next moment, the lewd pop of Tyler's boated glans slipping out of Gabby's distended sphincter mingled with the brunette's sexy moans and with the fleeting giggle that Michelle let out even as she swiftly pressed her lips to Gabby's sperm-oozing gape and stuck her tongue right into her anus. As Michelle's mouth locked Gabby's bootyhole in a lewd, cum-sucking French kiss, the brunette's languid mewls grew in intensity and volume, as did Michelle's muffled moans of appreciation for the huge dribbles of brotherly sperm she was receiving straight from her friend's deeply creampied ass.

A big grin lingered on Tyler's face as he exhaled and slumped back against the pillows: nothing could be more awesome than resting and recuperating from his recent buttfucking efforts while watching his voluptuous sister on all fours behind Gabby's upturned ass, intent on drinking down the monsterload he had just pumped into the brunette's narrow rectum. Unsurprisingly, that epic spectacle prevented Tyler's horsecock from softening much, so that, by the time Michelle finally removed her face from between Gabby's flawlessly round buttcheeks, he was almost as erect as he had been while riding her rump.

To make his own personal live porn show even more awesome, Michelle's first instinct upon unclasping her lips from Gabby's almost completely tightened but still seed-leaking bootyhole was to pull the brunette up, so that they were facing each other on their knees before Tyler, and give her a big cum-sharing kiss. A throaty grunt of approval and arousal escaped Tyler's grinning lips as he watched his sister and Gabby get more and more into their wet, sperm-sloppy make out session, during which they kept passing his load back and forth between their smooching mouths, only gulping down a bit of his cum at each pass, so that they could keep trading his ejaculate again and again through ever more intense sapphic kisses.

Eventually, once his entire load had been shared and swallowed, the girls turned to Tyler and, after a lascivious glance at his stiff rod, they both leaned down to rest on their elbows, placing themselves on either side of his legs so that they could lick up what little cum there still was to find on his meaty schlong. In truth, given Michelle's previous voracity, Tyler's monstercock was glazed mostly with her shiny spittle now, but that detail didn't deter the girls one bit. Mewling and purring, winking at him and giggling at each other, Michelle and Gabby ran their warm wet tongues up and down and all around Tyler's huge pole, licking and slurping for the pleasure of being naughty together.

Taking in that amazing scene and caressing each girl's head with one hand, Tyler lost himself in the lascivious daze of his afterglow, his fingers toying with Michelle's blonde locks and with Gabby's jet black mane with equal gentleness, his mind floating lazily off while his fat boner got sensuously licked by the two girls that mattered the most to him in the whole world.

And then, unexpected and yet very vivid, a thought suddenly intruded upon Tyler's post-orgasmic haze, making his half-closed eyes blink fully open in a jolt of sharp clarity.

"Oh yeah, I almost forgot! Mom called me earlier. She won't be back for a couple more days or so."

Tyler's words didn't phase the girls much at first, the news he delivered failing to distract them from their unhurried oral worship of his massive dick. Still, as that information sank in, some reactions began emerging.

"Mmh, that's cool," Michelle purred, brushing her lips softly against the veiny hardness of her brother's dong. "It means we have more time to have fun! And you can sleep here tonight, Gabs! Yay! Sleepover fuckfest!"

Teasingly flicking her tongue around Tyler's bloated glans, Gabby chuckled along with Michelle and then let out a purring moan before she said: "Yeah, that is seriously great, girl... Now we have all the time for you to lick pussy and get it nice and ready, so I can try to take your brother's big fucking cock in that hole too."

Those words, spoken somewhat nonchalantly yet losing none of their momentousness because of it, made Tyler and Michelle gasp in unison.

"What?!"

"Seriously!?"

Amused by the siblings' matching shocked expression, Gabby cooed as she nodded, her lips curling in a smile that, despite her attempt at sassiness, still seemed uncharacteristically timid, and cuter for it too.

"Yeah, you heard that right," Gabby said, casting a quick glance at Tyler and Michelle before averting her gaze, feeling suddenly very shy and vulnerable all over again. "I mean it. I... I want Tyler to take my virginity."

*****

Silence descended once again, the ringing of the doorbell having dissipated completely in the quiet suburban afternoon, leaving Ellie completely alone with her anxious thoughts and racing heartbeat.

Standing there, facing the closed door of her brother's house, which she had driven straight to without even calling or texting or announcing her random visit in any way, Ellie began regretting the whole crazy notion of reconnecting with her brothers with such intensity that she was suddenly hit by the impulse to just turn around, get back into her rental car, drive away as fast as possible and forget all about that silly mess of an idea.