Sister Starts My Harem Ch. 05

"So we're glad you guys hooked-up," Jeannie says with a big grin. "You should fuck Jack as often as the three of you want."

"his pleasure is our pleasure," says Taylor. "That's our motto. So, fill your boots. But try to save some for us too. OK, Jackie."

"You guys are amazing," says Rocky, finally finding her voice. "You don't care what anybody thinks. You know what you want and go for it. I'll never be that confident."

"You'll get there," Sarah says. And then softly adds as if speaking to herself, "I hope that I can get there too."

"Now that your sisters are with you," Shauna adds. "You can go after anything that you want, and we'll all help any way we can. We got you."

"Jeannie and Taylor want Jack to be part of the relationship they've been having for years," She goes on. "It makes them all happy and doesn't hurt anyone, so they get our full support. We're sisters, and that's what we promised."

Rocky grins and says, "OK, I'm starting to understand. But I'll need a little time to get used to the incest stuff. It's just not something that I'm used to. Sorry, Jeannie."

"No worries," Jeannie replies. "Sisters accept and respect each other's feelings. That goes for your feelings too. We didn't promise to think the same and agree on everything. We promised to love each other, share everything, and support each other. I think you'll understand my feelings for Jack once you've seen us together for a while."

"Am I expected to have sex with Jack too?" Rocky asks with some concern in her voice.

"Oh, no, honey," Jeannie says. "That's up to you and Jack. There aren't any conditions on your sisterhood, uh sisterliness, em or whatever. You know what I mean. You're our sister now. One-hundred percent. All you have to do is keep the promises, just like the rest of us."

"Good," Rocky says, "I feel like we five just got married, so I'm not ready for another new relationship right now, even with a hunk like Jack.

"And, aside from a little exhibitionism, I don't have much sexual experience. Heck, I love showing off, but I've never even had sex before. I'm still a virgin. And, seeing him get into the hot tub was a little intimidating. You're scary big, Jack."

"Don't worry," says Taylor, smiling. "If you and Jack ever do have sex, and that is one-hundred percent up to you, you're going to love his giant cock. I promise."

Rocky blushes but doesn't reply.

"You're an exhibitionist?" I say. "Now, I get it."

"She sure is," says Taylor.

Shauna adds, "She's always the first to strip whenever we're swimming or getting some sun."

"And she loves flashing her tits at strangers when we're out partying," Sarah says.

"What's not to love," says Rocky. "It's exciting. I've been like this for a long time."

"That explains your little game this afternoon," I say to her. "I knew you set me up on purpose."

"Guilty as charged," says Rocky with a broad grin.

"What did you do this time, you little minx?" Taylor asks.

Rocky shyly hesitates before answering, "I set it up so Jack would catch me with my hand in my pants when he came out of the house today. It was thrilling."

"You pretended to masturbate so Jack would catch you?" Taylor says. "That's wicked."

"Pretended?" Rocky answers with a sly smile. "Who pretends to masturbate when the real thing feels so good?"

"That's why we love you," says Taylor. "You're just like the rest of us."

"Hold on," says Shauna as if she's just discovered something. "Does this mean that it's OK for us to keep having sex with Jack? How about tonight? Can we have a sleepover, Jack? I want to finish what we started this afternoon?"

"Me too," agrees Sarah.

"Don't look at me," says Taylor. "I've been here for two days, and I'm out of clothes. I'm sleeping at home tonight and grabbing some of my things before I come back tomorrow. Is it alright if I take over one of your empty guest rooms, Jack? I usually share Jeannie's room, but It'll be nice to have a place for more of my stuff."

"Sure thing. Take whichever room you want." I say. "I was going to suggest it myself."

"I can't sleep with him tonight either," Jeannie says with a pout. "We have to sneak around. We can't risk letting the maids know our secret. They'll tell mom, and she would freak out. Incest is not something mom could handle."

"No doubt," I agree.

"So it looks like it's up to you," Sarah says to me. "What do you say? Feel like sleeping with horny redheaded identical twins tonight?"

"You make a strong argument," I say, scratching my chin and pretending that I need convincing.

"But don't expect much in the sex department," I say. "There are physical limits, you know. A guy can only have sex so many times in forty-eight hours, and I hit my limit in the shower with you two."

The twins play innocent, and Shauna says, "Don't worry about us. We'll be on our best behavior."

"Cross our hearts," finishes Sarah with a coy smile while drawing a cross between her lovely breasts as they bob and float in the bubbling water.

"OK. Then it's settled," says Taylor. "I'm going home. Jeannie and Rocky are sleeping in their own beds. And the twins get the whole night to abuse Jack's poor tired, not so little penis."

"I hope you two can wait until the morning," I say to the twins. "It's embarrassing, but I don't think I'll be able to get hard again today."

"Well, you better get up early if you want to fool around in the morning," says Jeannie. "It's yoga class with Andorra poolside at nine o'clock, and she's expecting all of us to be there.

"How about we take the boat out and go snorkeling after yoga?" Taylor suggests. "I know a cool man-made reef I'd love to show you."

Everyone heartily agrees, and Rocky says, "I'll tell the boys to get the boat ready, and in the morning before yoga, I'll load up some coolers."

"I'll help you," says Jeannie.

"So I guess that's it," Jeannie continues. "Unless anyone wants to say something more, our meetings finished."

"I'd like to say something if it's OK," says Rocky.

"Of course," Jeannie says. "You never need permission to talk. We're sisters now."

"I know," Rocky says. "And that's what I want to say. We're sisters now, and I've never had a sister, let alone four. You've made me so happy, and I love you all. And, I will always keep my promises and be the best sister I can be."

"We promise too," says Sarah.

"We'll always be the best sisters we can be for you, too," Shauna says.

The girls have a final group hug, and each makes certain to give Rocky one more teary kiss goodnight.

We have another big day tomorrow, so our party breaks up, and we go our separate ways to get some rest.

The twins and I walk back to the pool house without bothering to dress. They drag me back into the shower to rinse the chlorine from our skin, they're sticklers when it comes to skincare, and I'm pleasantly surprised when they don't try to get me hard in the shower. I guess they accept that I need a little break from all this sex.

Back in my bedroom, it becomes clear that I'm mistaken. The sisters won't wait for morning; they want to fool around now.

First, they make a sexy show of rubbing each other down with moisturizer, and then together, they rub me down too. Each twin tries to get me hard in turns by stroking my cock with the creamy lotion. You can't blame them for trying, but I don't think it's going to work.

They finish with the moisturizer, and I lay on the bed with a twin on either side. They focus their attention on getting me hard. One twin strokes my cock while the other rubs my balls, and both kiss and lick my nipples. Then they switch tasks and work at it some more.

Frustrated that the rubbing alone isn't helping, they change strategies and switch to using their mouths. One sister tongues my balls while the other licks my dick, and every so often, they switch. It's very sexy to watch, but I'm just not getting hard. I've had too much sex over too short a time and need time to replenish my mojo.

Sarah takes her mouth from my still semi-soft dick to watch her sister licking my balls. "It's not working," she says.

Shauna stops licking and looks at her sister from across my flaccid penis.

"I know, but I'm so horny," says Shauna. "I'm dying to feel this monster inside of me. It's been forever since either of us got some. But Jack needs to get some rest. Poor baby."

"I know something that might make him hard," Sarah says in a conspiratorial whisper.

"Cool, I'll try anything," Answers Shauna.

Sarah swallows hard and gives her sister a small smile. Then she leans forward and kisses Shauna fully on the lips.

Surprised by this, Shauna jerks back to stare wide-eyed at her sister. She silently studies Sarah's expression for a moment and whispers back, "Are you sure?"

"I am," says Sarah. "It feels right."

Shauna seems to think about this for another moment before leaning in to return Sarah's kiss.

I watch their passion slowly build until they're locked in an open mouth tongue-duel worthy of the finest lesbian porn. The sisters are kissing and moaning, and I'm starting to think that they've forgotten about me when, without breaking their lip-lock, they move downward to share my cock head between their open kissing mouths.

If Jeannie and Taylor are right, this is the first time the twins have touched each other sexually. It's the first time for them, and that makes the scene even hotter. My tired dick finally starts to thicken.

They kneel upright without breaking their passionate kiss. The sisters caress each other's faces and bodies. They seem hungry for each other, and their energy swiftly grows. Sarah crawls across my body, pushing Shauna backward onto the bed and lying on top of her twin. Their lips never part, and they each start touching and feeling the other's big soft tits and hard pink nipples.

I've watched them smearing each other with suntan lotion and seen their sexy nipple cream regimen, but this isn't the same. The twins are making love to each other. They're both trying to make the other horny, and it's making me horny too.

Sarah breaks their kiss and gazes into Shauna's eyes. "Ready for more?" she asks.

Shauna looks a little afraid, but she replies with a slight silent nod.

Sarah responds with a brief smile and moves down to suck one of Shauna's nipples while pinching and pulling the other with her free hand. Shauna gasps and runs her fingers through Sarah's thick red hair.

"That's it, Sar. Just like that," Shauna breaths. "My pussy tingles when you pinch my nipples."

Sarah gives her nipple another hard pinch causing another moan. Then, she starts trailing her hand down her sister's body.

Shauna shivers as Sarah lightly runs her fingertips over her ribs and down across her sensitive belly. The tickling makes her coo in delight. Sarah strokes Shauna's hip and then grasps her fleshy ass giving it a hard squeeze then a delicate pat. Shauna's eyes are closed, and she's quietly moaning from deep down inside her throat, so Sarah knows she's doing this right.

Shauna's body stiffens in anticipation as Sarah's fingers reach their destination and touch her spread open sex. She gasps and withholds her indrawn breath while, for the first time, Sarah explores the moist folds of her twin sister's pussy.

I wonder if Shauna's pussy feels the same as her own. Do identical twin sisters have identical pussies? Are the twins entirely alike, or do their pussies curve and fold each in their unique way. Is every pussy different? Are they like snowflakes or fingerprints with no two exactly alike? I can't wait to compare them for myself.

Shauna speaks through tightly clenched teeth while slowly releasing her upheld breath, "Sar..." She pauses, "Sar! Don't stop. I keep cumming. Mini-cums. One after another. Oh, my God. Sarah."

Sarah moves to between her sister's widespread thighs until Her face is inches from Shauna's wide-open sex. She looks up and asks, "Are you ready for me? There's no undoing this. We cross this line, and there's no going back."

"I don't want to go back," Shauna answers with bated breath. "Please, this is perfect. I love you, Sar."

Sarah plasters her mouth over Shauna's waiting pussy without hesitation and sinks two outstretched fingers into her sister's eager vagina. She frantically licks and sucks Shauna's pussy like a cunt-starved lesbian nymphomaniac hungry for girl cum. Shauna's eyes squeeze shut, and her face screws into an expression of pure sexual ecstasy.

Shauna guides Sarah with her hands, holding her sister's head as Sarah's tongue darts and slides over her swollen clit and pussy lips. Both girls moan with pleasure.

Suddenly, Shauna seems to remember that I'm here watching and opens her eyes to look my way.

"Oh, my God, Jack," she says between panting breaths. "I can't stop cumming. Move up here and put your cock in my mouth! I want to eat you while She eats me."

I move to Shauna's head and smear her lips with the big dollop of precum that's leaking from my cockhead. Then I sink it into her waiting mouth. I roll my hips in a slowly advancing rhythm and fuck her face with short steady strokes. Her moans build along with my tempo, and I can tell that she likes it. I like it too.

I enjoy Shauna's mouth and watch Sarah licking her first pussy until Shauna spits out my saliva frosted dick to say, "OK, Jack. You're plenty hard now. Move behind Sarah and give it to her doggy. It's her favorite. Fuck her while she licks my pussy."

That's a terrific idea. So, I kneel behind Sarah and lift her fleshy hips to point her ass toward the ceiling. Her piercing flashes a hint of gold, and her little brown rosebud is on full display. I have full access to my new lover's pussy, and I've forgotten any sexual fatigue I was feeling earlier. I can't wait to bury myself in Sarah for the first time.

"Fuck her good with that salami," Shauna says between gasps. "She needs cock, Jack. So, give it to her hard."

Another terrific idea.

Sarah takes a break from her feast and looks back over her shoulder. There's a thick layer of gooey girl-cum coating the lower half of her face, and she pants stuttering, "Yah, Jack. Your cock, n-now, n-n-need it now. Fuck me, baby. Hard!"

I wipe my cockhead along her pussy lips, and It comes away shiny and wet. She's more than ready, so I push myself into her greedy hole. She moans into Shauna's cunt as I sink into her right to the balls.

"Oh my God, Shauna! He's stretching my pussy. It hurts so good. How did you get it down your throat?" She asks and hurriedly returns to her task, not waiting for Shauna's answer.

I grasp Sara's plump hips for leverage and start fucking her with long slow strokes. My fucking grows more urgent, and our bodies begin making meaty slap-slap-slapping sounds with every collision. The heady musk of female arousal flavors the moist air filling my nostrils, and I can taste it in every panting breath.

My orgasm rushes closer, and without warning, I slam myself against Sarah with a roar and spew my load into her shuddering body.

"Fuuuck...," I scream, filling her with all the cum I can still muster. A surprising amount after three days of near-constant sex.

Shauna's eyes fly open, and she yells, "That's it, Jack. Fill her up. Ooh, Sarah, lick me! Lick me, lick me, lick me, I'm cumming too!"

Her mouth never breaks contact with Shauna's pussy as Sarah's body stiffens in orgasm and her cunt gives me one last mighty squeeze.

Her final orgasm slowly recedes, and Sarah collapses, panting between her sister's outspread legs while my deflating cock slips out of her vagina. I drop down to lay beside Shauna, and she turns her head to share a tender, lover's kiss.

Still panting to catch her breath, Sarah crawls up her sister's body. Shauna's cum covers Sarah's face in a shiny glaze, and it mingles with our saliva as we have our first three-way kiss. We linger and enjoy this intimate and tender moment until Sarah pulls away to look into Shauna's eyes.

"Was that OK? Did we go too far?" Sarah asks her sister, sounding concerned. "Are we OK?"

"That's silly. Of course, we're OK. We're wonderful," Shauna reassures her. "I love you, Sar, and I wanted this as much as you, maybe more. Why didn't we do this a long time ago?"

I can hear the relief in Sarah's voice when she answers, "Oh, thank God. I love you too, Sha. I've always wanted this to happen, but I think we waited because It never felt this right before now. Thank you, Jack."

"You're welcome," I say, surprised by her gratitude. "But I didn't do anything; that was all you guys."

"We feel something special when we're with you," Shauna says, smiling. "I don't think we could have done this without you here. You make us brave."

"C'mon," I say. "You two are plenty brave all on your own."

"We're not," Sarah continues. "And, Shauna's right. You're nothing like other guys. You make things seem possible. When we're with you, we feel cared for, even loved, and it makes us bold."

"We feel it even when you're abusing us with that horse-dick of yours," Shauna interjects with a giggle. "Oof!"

"Cut it out," I say. "You're making me blush."

"It's true," Sarah says. "So many guys have pressured us to have sex together, but only so they could watch. They always want the thrill of seeing twins doing it but don't care about what we want. With you, it's different."

"You didn't ask for a show," Shauna adds. "You never even brought it up."

"Also, seeing you with Jeannie today was inspiring," Sarah adds. "We're like you. We love each other just like you and Jeannie do. You both helped us realize that sex with each other is natural, beautiful, and irresistible."

"Tonight was amazing, Jack," adds Shauna. "I can't wait for next time. There're a thousand things I want us to try together."

"There is going to be next time, right Jack?" Sarah asks with a smile.

"Hell yes," I say. "If I have any say, that is. But, for tonight, I'm spent. I'm going to clean up and crash. I can sleep in another room if you two want to be alone together."

"No way," the twins say together.

"We want you right here with us, lover boy," says Sarah.

"Any guy who gets to watch us 'lezzie-out' owes some major cuddling," Shauna says.

With much-exaggerated nodding, Sarah agrees.

"So clean up, get your cute ass back in here, and cuddle," she says.

I carefully extract myself and leave while the girls exchange small kisses and intimate murmured whispers.

I have a quick rinse in the shower and return to find the girls fast asleep and wrapped in each other's arms. One of them is softly snoring, but I can't tell which, and It's adorable. I slip back into bed, being careful not to wake them, and fall asleep immediately.

Sunrise leaking through the curtains teases me awake. I'm feeling rested and refreshed. Judging by my morning wood, my dick has recovered too. The clock says that yoga class starts in less than an hour, and I don't want to disappoint Andorra by being late, so I had better get moving.

I roll over and see the twins awake and wrapped in an early morning sixty-nine session. They're focused on each other and unaware that I'm watching. I briefly consider joining them, but we have a busy day, and I don't want to be late for yoga. I decide to break up their party by playfully slapping Shauna on her exposed ass-cheek.

"C'mon, you two. Sun's up, and we need to get going. Yoga in forty-five," I say.

Shauna lifts her head from between Sarah's thighs and looks my way. "We're almost there. Get in the shower, and we'll meet you in five minutes," she says breathlessly and returns her mouth to Sarah's pussy. I leave them to it.

The twins are all smiles and laughter when they join me in the shower. We playfully scrub each other, and Sarah says it's her turn to suck me, but there's not enough time.