Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.
You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.
Click here"There's NOTHING wrong with you. You're just small and I'm big, that's all."
"It means we're not as compatible as I want to believe we are."
"Annabelle, please."
"Maybe you're NOT the guy I'm meant to be with the rest of my life. Maybe there IS some other guy with a skinnier dick who'll be able to fuck my ass whenever I want him to without tearing me the fuck in half."
"BELLE."
Grabbing her panties, Belle abruptly dismounted my dick and got off the bed.
"Annabelle, seriously." I climbed off the bed going after her. "Come back here."
"I love you, Matty," she said through tears as she went into the closet and rapidly grabbed some sweatpants and a shirt.
"I love you too, Annabelle. Now will you please come back to bed?"
"I need to go home right now."
"B, please. Don't leave me tonight. It's Valentine's, right? The silver butt plug and everything tomorrow morning?"
It was the wrong thing to bring up. Belle came out of the closet with her pale green eyes on FIRE. "Seriously? I'm having this existential crisis and all you can think of is getting your entire dick into my ass for the first time? How fucking selfish is THAT?"
I blinked. "What? N-n-no! I was just... I mean... It was YOUR idea and your plans. I wasn't... I didn't mean... Belle, seriously, I'll love you for the rest of our lives even if you never fit all of me into your ass."
"Oh, so now you think you'll NEVER fit! I mean, CLEARLY we're not compatible!"
"You're twisting everything I'm saying out of proportion!"
"Oh, so now everything's MY fault!"
"I didn't say that. Belle, please. Just come back to bed and--"
"Good NIGHT, Matthew," she barked, eyes blazing. Without another word, she stomped over to my bedroom door, went through it, and slammed it behind her.
FUCK.
- COMMENTS
Anonymousabout 1 year agoI haven't been commenting all along, but this story is wonderful! I love how much deeper it goes than just the sex, hot as that is.
.
The game-character thing didn't work for me either, but that's not a criticism - it just means I'm not a gamer. Some other things that do work for me (not present in this story, as it happens), some other people can't stand. So what? Dating myself here, but when I was Matt's age, if I'd had three hot, busty girlfriends showing up for a three-on-one orgy dressed as Janet, Magenta and Columbia, I'd have been on Cloud Nine! And then three more in Bill Theiss's uber-sexy costumes from the original Star Trek? Over the top! (TBH, I'd have been on cloud nine if two simultaneous not-busty girlfriends had showed up for a three-way sex date dressed in burlap sacks. But you get the point....) So different strokes and all that.
.
I didn't have too much trouble keeping the game characters straight, mostly because you split them into two groups of three. If it had been six all at once, that would have been a lot more of a challenge.
.
My one *small* criticism: The Morrigan is a goddess from Irish mythology. The wrong girl dressed as her namesake.
Anonymousalmost 2 years agoI for one had no issues with keeping track of who was who in the costumes. Perhaps it was because I Googled their images when you introduced them. You did an excellent job of matching game characters to the girls.
MADDOGINTEXASalmost 2 years agoOkay, saw the "Belle Blowup" coming, just did not think it would be on Valentine's Day...OR, maybe that was exactly the right time for it??!!
Belle just told Matt her long-term plans/dreams for them...babies and all!! He better start paying a lot more attention to details with the girls, the closer end of Senior Year gets to them!
Matt was right not to deflower Alice during the group thing; she DESERVES one-on-one time when it comes around, so she does not have any doubts about Matt wanting to be her first and all that. Alice is as sensitive as the others, regardless of her personality, OR, IN SPITE OF HER PERSONALITY!! She is sweet, and loves Matt ssssoooo much...she will let him know she is ready!
Zofi...and Sam...and Matt...was a mix-up there!! But, all will work out!!
I also was not a fan of the costumes, etc...my poor little brain had to 'try' to keep up with who-was-who (and did not do a very good job of it!) Still, good role-play!
Five**5**Stars, "just because"
