The Big Tits Club Pt. 02 Ch. 03-04

"Uh, sorry about all that," Holly offered with an uncharacteristically shaky warble. "I kinda get carried away when I'm with Matty. Perhaps we should've kept it down a bit."

"Fffpt," Naimh blew a raspberry to lighten the mood. "As if you've ever kept it down. Besides, we all knew what'ye two were doin'."

"Y-yeah, yeah, totally," Lily stammered a bit nervously. "Uhhh... I mean like... It's nice to know that... uhhh... even if you and Matty are exes now... uhhh, that your relationship is still... uhhh... cordial."

Belle and Sam immediately burst into laughter.

"'Cordial'? That's an interesting new euphemism," Eva snarked quietly from her seat. "My horizons are certainly being broadened this evening."

"Matty and I are still friends," Holly stated firmly, although I could feel a little tension in her body against my arm. "But I'm really just stopping by. If I'm intruding on your evening, I can leave."

"No, no, of course not," Sam stated firmly as she came over to Holly's other side and draped her arm across the other girl's shoulders. "You're OG BTC, and you are always welcome here."

"See! I told you that you were OG BTC!" I exclaimed to Holly, squeezing her close.

"Thanks, guys," she replied, looking back at me and then over at Sam. "I appreciate it."

"Now come on. It's Friday night," Sam began with the kind of confident presence that always took charge of the room as she surveyed everyone around us. "Let's have a good time."

****

Rather than settle in to watch a movie, we opened the liquor cabinet and circled the coffee table: Holly, me, and Sam on one couch; Naimh, Belle, and Lily on the next couch, and Eva in the armchair. The girls started up a cycle of endlessly shifting conversation, initially just shooting the breeze talking about school and asking Holly questions about San Jose State, although I will note that Lily was uncharacteristically quiet during most of it. But sometime during the second round of drinks, the topic changed when Lily started asking Holly questions about "The OG BTC".

"What did it feel like," Lily began, "to be on the outside looking in at a tight-knit clique of six girls and the one special guy they seemed to trust above all others?"

Holly explained that at first it wasn't really a big deal; she was friends with Sam and Zofi but felt no particular need to try and get closer to the others, and as for me she had no idea yet what kind of guy I really was.

But that said, Holly explained, "After I joined, all six of the girls ultimately welcomed me with open arms. And even though I sometimes felt like I was the seventh wheel or only seventh best, whenever I was with him, Matty always made me feel like I was the most special girl in the world."

Lily beamed at me, although she replied to Holly, "I can see how he might make you feel that way. The only problem is: I'm still trying to figure out how to tell him I'm interested."

Naimh smirked and faced me as well while explaining to Lily, "He's wonderful in so many ways, but he's still just a boy. Boys don't really dig 'subtle'. You gotta make it clear that you want him."

Lily arched an eyebrow and faced me with a serious expression on her face. "Have I NOT made myself clear?"

I gave her an honest look and replied, "You have. But just... not today, Lily."

Holly laughed at me. "You do realize that playing hard to get just makes a girl want you even more."

"Maybe that's the point," Belle drawled. "He wants you to step up your game in chasing him."

"No, no," I interjected while raising both hands. "I'm not trying to play hard to get."

"He really isn't," Sam said reasonably. "Even though he's one man dating three girls at the same time, he's not a player, and he's not trying to 'play' you girls, either. Matty's just very, very devoted to the special girls he has in his life. Prioritizing their wants and needs and doing everything he can to make them happy? It's what he does. It's what he's done for the entire BTC since we first wanted to explore everything a boy and girl could do together. And he's exceptionally loyal to us - Holly should know."

Lily sat up straight and regarded the orange-haired girl. "Well that sounds like there's a story there."

"Oh, there is!" Holly leaned forward, set her drink down, and rubbed her hands rather gleefully. I immediately started blushing as I realized what was about to happen. And then I blushed even deeper when she actually started to tell the story about trying to seduce me that fateful night before the start of our senior year.

"Ohmigawd, that first backrub he gave me was soooo incredibly good," Holly said dreamily, "I felt like I'd seen God!"

Lily moaned and interjected, "I know exactly what you mean!"

Holly laughed and added, "I was so turned on, I couldn't help but launch myself into his arms and start kissing him."

Eva spoke up for the first time in twenty minutes to remark, "Hey Lil... Looks like you missed your golden opportunity."

Lily pursed her lips in thought, shrugged, and then abruptly burst forward from her seat on the other couch and then leaped into my lap, her knees just barely fitting into the gaps to either side of me between my hips and both Holly's and Sam's. Before I knew it, Lily had wrapped her arms around my neck and then pressed her mouth to mine, her tongue parting my lips and feeding me the flavors of Malibu rum. And on pure instinct I found myself wrapping up the petite Hawaiian hottie and kissing her back just as fiercely.

"Hey, hey, pahtty foww!" Sam called while lightly tapping Lily's upper arm.

At the sound of my girlfriend's voice, I blinked and then jerked my head back with a gasp, staring wide-eyed at Sam with a touch of worry that I'd pissed her off.

But Sam just laughed and said, "I was joking! Go back to kissing her!" My girlfriend then promptly grabbed the back of both of our heads and smashed them together so that Lily and I would start snogging again. But unfortunately the moment had been broken, and Lily almost sheepishly pulled back again almost as soon as we'd restarted.

"Ahem," she mumbled while blushing pink. And then she slipped off my lap and returned back to the couch.

Sam pointedly looked at Eva and gestured at me. "Wanna go next?"

Eva popped her eyebrows and then sank deeper into her seat. She'd already put her cat-eye sunglasses back on even though it was after sunset and we were indoors, and she pushed them a little higher up the bridge of her nose as if she could somehow hide behind them.

Sam shrugged as if it was no big deal and then turned to grab my head and plant a passionate smooch on me instead, and the rest of the girls (save Eva) all laughed.

"Get on with the story," Naimh insisted, reaching across to the adjacent couch to pat Holly's knee.

Holly gave me a sweet smile and told the story about slipping my hand down the front of her shirt during a movie (which got Lily squirming in her seat). She talked about sliding her hand inside my shorts and how wet she got feeling just how BIG my dick really was and how desperately she wanted to feel every inch of it buried deep inside her (which got Eva squirming in her seat). She explained that she'd returned to my house after everyone else had gone home and then described - in graphic detail - about parking me on the couch, jacking my cock, and then taking as much of me as she could manage into her mouth (which was WAY too much for her to handle, as she tried to deep-throat me but ultimately failed). Now all of the girls were squirming, but nobody interrupted Holly's narrative.

The orange-haired girl recognized a spellbound audience when she had one, so she took her time expounding upon the intricacies of her oral technique and the way my hot and throbbing shaft felt as it pulsed within her mouth in response to her ministrations as if it were an independent creature. She laughed as she told the girls about me losing my load quite quickly - understandable since it was my very first time - and how I blasted two strings of steaming hot semen across her face before she swallowed a few bursts and then finished me off my milking out the rest all over her breasts.

"Holy fuck," Belle grunted as she apparently came just from imagining it.

The rest of the narrative sped up a bit. Holly complimented my natural talent for cunnilingus, saying that I did exceptionally well for a first-timer. "Eventually I had to push him away, pleading, 'No more. No more.' And he's only gotten even better since."

"We know. We could hear you howling for him to keep eating you from down here," Sam drawled with a grin.

The girls all laughed at that.

But then we came to the part where I couldn't go through with losing my cherry. Holly had gotten herself on top of me, straddling me in a cowgirl position, and was about to impale herself on my gorgeous dick when... well...

"'Wait-wait-wait!'" Holly quoted me. "'I'm sorry! I'm sorry!'"

"That definitely sounds like Matty," Eva drawled, and everybody snickered.

"He's like an honorary Canadian or something," Belle quipped.

"What really sold it is what he said afterwards," Holly continued with a somewhat dejected sigh. She frowned, looking a little sorry for herself before explaining, "He said, 'I can't do this to them.'"

"Awww..." Lily... well... 'awwwed'. "That's so sweet. He really loved them."

"He really loved them," Holly agreed. "Even after all the times they'd teased him... Did you know that Sam dry-humped herself on his bulge to orgasm while shoving her boobs into his face twice and he still never reached up and grabbed her tits? He really did love them. He wanted to save himself for them. And in the end... he did save himself for them."

"And for you too," Sam pointed out.

Holly shrugged. "Eventually."

"Worth the wait?" Lily asked, turning to look at me with that doe-eyed look again.

The orange-haired girl turned to smile at me. "Absolutely."

****

The little sidebar about Sam dry-humping herself to orgasm on me (twice) without me ever grabbing her boobs led the girls off on a tangent about all the times they'd teased me back in high school - testing how far they could push their boundaries without me caving in. Bikinis by the pool. Modeling new cute clothes. General ass-grabbing. Belle, Sam, and Naimh all took turns sharing stories while I more or less blushed and shrugged and tried to act like it wasn't a big deal.

Of course, the racier the stories got, the hornier everyone got, including me. I was pitching quite a tent and both Lily and Eva kept sneaking glances at it while the BTC girls paid it no mind. They were too busy having fun telling stories. But just when it seemed like Lily had worked up the nerve to actually go do something about my tent, I headed off that potential complication by standing up and declaring that I needed to pee.

That apparently broke the spell, because when I returned I found Lily and Eva getting up to leave, ready to call it a night.

"We still going to the party tomorrow night together?" Belle asked as she walked her fellow shorty to the door.

"Yeah! Totally! Wouldn't miss it for the world," Lily replied with a buoyant smile, before glancing back into the living room. "Goodnight, girls. Goodnight, Matty."

Meanwhile, Holly wrapped herself around me and made it abundantly clear that she had no intention of driving home tonight. She was still chewing on my ear when I waved to Lily and Eva, replying, "Goodnight, ladies. See you tomorrow."

They waved back and headed out of sight down the short hallway leading to the front door. Sam was suddenly kneeling behind me, yanking my pants down to my ankles. Naimh was suddenly kneeling in front of me, cramming my cock all the way down her throat. And I groaned in erotic ecstasy as her talented mouth went to work.

Only then did I hear Belle close the front door, and she sauntered back into the living room while shaking her head. "You bitches couldn't wait ten seconds?"

Nobody answered her. Holly had already grabbed my head to start making out with me, Naimh's throat was full, and Sam was busy stripping off her clothes.

Let's just say the five of us didn't make it upstairs for another hour.