The College Girl Next Door Ch. 03: Dinner

Hailey zipped open the bag, rummaged around inside it until she had found what she was looking for. "Hands." she commanded Emily, indicating that she should put her hands on the arm rests. As soon as Emily complied Hailey secured them with a pair of fluffy pink handcuffs. Then she sank to her knees and cuffed Emily's ankles to the chair legs.

"If you can't contain yourself, then you must be forced to watch. Sam I'll need your help for this next bit."

Curious where she was going I stood next to the brunette.

"I want you to slap her."

Even before she was done speaking I interjected, "What? Why? Don't you think that's going a little too far?"

"With your dick, I meant. Just slap her cheeks. Here, I'll help."

The brunette stood behind me, a hand around the base of my dick, softly stroking it to make it as hard as possible. She moved me to stand in front of the blonde. Emily looked up at me with a mix of concern and horniness. It seemed like the horniness was winning out though. Hailey took my dick and slapped Emily in the face with it.

"Like that. She should learn that this dick is mine now." It seemed like Hailey liked giving orders. "Slap her again."

I took my dick in my hand and slapped Emily in the face again. The naughty blonde opened her mouth as my dick passed her. Just a tiny bit too slow.

"Again." I heard behind me. I heard the rustling sound of the bag, Hailey was looking for something else. I slapped Emily again. This time she was fast enough in turning her head, and instead of slapping her she took the tip of my cock in her mouth. Gave it a quick suck.

"Okay, that's enough." Hailey said as she stepped from behind me. In her hand she held a pink shape. A rabbit vibrator. One big cock-like end, and a small protruding tentacle that would caress Emily's clit.

"Because you can't be trusted with the real thing, this is for you. Now open your mouth."

Emily looked at the vibrator with barely concealed horniness. She opened her mouth to cover it in saliva. Hailey pushed it in two, three times, then removed it, strands of saliva connecting the fake dick to the blonde's lips. Looking closely, the vibrator was even more fancy than I expected, with the top rotating a bit together with the vibrating of the whole thing. She traced the device over Emily's body following her curves, stopping to tease the blonde's nipples and then going further down over her belly and navel, down to her lips. She slowed down to tease Emily's clit with the vibrator. Waiting until her roommate started panting to slide the vibrator further downward.

"Open up." She parted Emily's labia. The combined wetness of Emily's saliva and her wet pussy allowed Hailey to easily slide the vibrator into place.

"Just one more thing to go."

"Even more?" Moaned Emily.

Hailey reached inside the bag once more and produced a ball gag. Emily's eyes raised in surprise. "Even more kinky than I thought."

"Open up!" Hailey held the gag in front of Emily's face. Emily obediently opened her mouth wide, sticking out her tongue. With a quick movement Hailey secured the ball in place.

"Now we won't be distracted by any of her complaints." she said as she winked at me. The only thing Emily could do in response was give a piqued moan.

A quick turn on the back of the vibrator brought it back to live in a low setting. I could see the tentacle-like protrusion vibrate against Emily's clit. The blonde jumped up a little and worked against her restraints. Even though they were all fluffy and pink they did their job of securing Emily quite well. She still had some freedom of movement, as was expected, but she wasn't able to close her legs or reach for the vibrator. Hailey took one of Emily's nipples between her fingers and pinched. As Emily moaned into her gag she said: "Now watch me fuck Sam. And you do know that you're not allowed to cum until I say so, don't you?"

Emily shook her head, so Hailey took her other nipple in her other hand. "Is that a 'No, I'm going to do what I want' shake? Or is that a 'No, I won't cum shake?'"

Emily's mumbles into the gag cleared up that she meant the second one. Hailey turned to me and put her hand on my stiff cock. "What do you think Sam, can you make me cum before Emily does?"

"I'll surely do my best." I said with a grin, "Though I don't have any fancy vibrating parts..."

"I'm sure you can make up for it," the brunette replied with a cocky grin, "now let's make this a little harder on Emily." As she reached between the blonde's legs and turned a dial on the back of the vibrator. I heard the vibrator start to make more noise, teasing another moan from behind the gag.

Hailey took my hand and led me to the bed. A quick look back showed that Emily was staring at us intently. Hailey put her hand behind my neck and pulled me in for a kiss. Our lips were touching softly. Where she had been forceful with Emily just a moment ago, now she was putty in my hands. My hands caressed down her sides, stroking her soft skin down to her buttocks. A soft push and we fell entangled on the bed. I broke the kiss and saw Hailey look up at me, a corona of brown hair around her slightly flushed face. Her lips were parted and she was breathing fast. Her hand followed my chest down to my dick. She grabbed it and guided it to her wet opening. Without exchanging any words I looked her deep in her eyes as my cock entered her tight wet pussy. Slowly I pushed farther and farther until I was fully engulfed by her warm wetness. She let out a deep moan.

"Oh Sam, that's what I wanted." And began to kiss me again.

I was happy just to finally feel the brunette's pussy around my cock. Her muscles twitched subconsciously around me as she kept kissing me. Slowly I started moving. Just a centimetre out, and back in again. Two centimetres, and back. Three and slowly back into her tight wet pussy. I didn't really want to leave it. Finally I made it all the way out until the head of my cock was resting lightly between her lips. Then I pushed back in, feeling her open up for me. Hailey stopped kissing me to let out a deep moan.

"Your dick feels so good. Please, fuck me harder."

Happy to oblige I started thrusting a little faster. No more slow-motion, but still a comfortable pace that I could keep up a while. Hailey's moans were coming quicker now. I moved one hand from beside her to fondle the brunette's perky breasts. My hand cupped the soft flesh, massaging her. I went to her nipple and pinched down lightly, eliciting a small moan from the brunette.

I started to increase my speed. The soft flesh of her pussy stimulating me. If I kept up this speed I would no doubt cum soon. The combined teasing of the blowjob and the sneaky fucking by Emily had brought me quite close to the edge already. I focussed on Hailey again. The brunette had stopped kissing me and now had wrapped her hands around me. She used her nails to get a good grip. I whispered in her ear, "You're about to cum, aren't you."

"Hmmm, yesss," she moaned, "please, just a little harder, a little faster."

She said please, who was I to deny her? But maybe I could tease her a little first. I slowed all the way down. My dick planted firmly inside her before I inched it out. Savouring the feeling of her folds on me. When I was almost all the way out I rammed back into her. She couldn't help but moan loudly and her nails bit into my back. Once again I pulled back slowly only to ram my dick into her. Each time I pounded her, her eyes took on a more savage gleam, her nails biting deeper into the flesh of my back. Just as I felt like she was ready to scream with frustration I increased my speed. Faster and faster until I couldn't go any faster I rammed into her. The only sounds to hear were our moans and our flesh slapping against each other.

I couldn't keep this up or I was going to cum. Just as I opened my mouth to warn the beautiful brunette she clamped her legs around me, trapping me inside her. She convulsed, once, twice, thrice. Then she went limp, a smile on her face.

"Fuck that was good. But you didn't cum yet, did you?"

I answered in the negative.

"Just give me a few moments. I want you to cum for me."

We just lay there for a bit. Hailey spent. My dick still throbbing in her pussy, torn away from the edge of an orgasm.

Suddenly a new, muffled moan sounded from behind me. In all excitement in fucking the brunette I had kinda forgotten about Emily's predicament. I looked over my shoulder at the bound blonde. She had used up all the slack the cuffs gave her and was now almost hanging from the chair. The fake cock had vibrated its way out of her pussy and was now lying uselessly oscillating the ground. I saw a frown of frustration on Emily's face. No more pleasure and trapped in an uncomfortable position. I whispered in Hailey's ear: "It looks like your target needs some attention."

She shot back a look of confusion, but slowly recognition dawned on her face. With a soft push she flopped me on my side and went to Emily.

"Couldn't help yourself?" she said as she helped her roommate back in her chair. "Be careful not to fall. I don't want you to get hurt. Just sit right here, enjoy yourself and watch how Sam cums only for me." To be honest, I couldn't promise that I'd only cum for Hailey. The idea of Emily helplessly watching and getting vibed without being allowed to cum did wonders for my libido.

Hailey reached between Emily's legs, hesitated a little and then bowed down to lick the brunette. Immediately I heard another muffled moan coming from behind the gag. I couldn't see what Hailey was doing but looking at Emily's face, I'm sure it was working. The blonde's face was flushed and her chest rose quickly with her breath. Having distracted Emily by expertly licking her pussy, Hailey had picked up the vibrator again. Emily's moans were coming quicker and quicker and increasing in pitch. I was sure she was on the edge of an orgasm. Just when I thought the blonde would cum Hailey moved her head away. "Nuhuh," the brunette said, "I didn't give you permission to cum yet."

Emily led out a sound of frustrated disappointment and pulled on her cuffs. Hailey gave me a wink, "I learned from the best."

As Emily quieted down again Hailey used her fingers to part the blonde's labia. She took the vibrator and licked it from bottom to top. "Hmmm," she moaned. Then rapidly she inserted the fake pink cock into Emily's pussy. I heard a "Mmph" around the ballgag, but I couldn't decipher if it was a sound of lust or of frustration.

"You've been a bad girl," Hailey said, "removing your vibrator without permission. And bad girls get punished. Now stay still, or your punishment will be worse."

I heard a click, the buzzing started again, then I saw Hailey turn the knob at the back of the vibrator further. The buzzing increased in intensity and I saw a look on Emily's face that was a combination between desperation and excitement. Hailey pushed the vibrator in just a little bit further and I saw Emily squirm. I didn't know if she was able to keep this up without cumming.

"Now since you can't be trusted, I'll need to keep my eye on you." Hailey said as she padded back to the bed. I was still lying where she left me. My dick rock hard from the little show Hailey and Emily had just performed.

Hailey pulled one of the pillows from the headrest and laid it on the bed, then lay down on it with her belly, popping up her ass. She rested her head on her hands as she was studying Emily. Emily in turn couldn't sit still and was writhing in her restraints. I understood Haileys plan and manoeuvred between her legs. As I hovered over her in an outstretched plank position I moved my crotch in line with hers. Slowly I thrusted forwards. The top of my cock grazed her wet lips. Softly I moved forward until it slipped between the warm folds. Hailey adjusted her position a little bit, thrusted back at me and there I was. Back into the brunette's warm pussy. I let out a sigh, she felt so fucking good. I thrusted forward, burying myself to the hilt in her. I already knew I wouldn't be able to hold out much longer.

"How do you like this? Fucking my pussy while watching this slut trying not to cum." Hailey said.

"It's so fucking hot." I answered truthfully. My eyes were drinking in the sight of the blonde trembling against the vibrator. She made little mewling sounds. I saw her trying and failing to find a position where the extra protrusion wouldn't be pleasuring her clit.

I picked up the pace, fucking Hailey. My dick started sliding in and out of her pussy making squelching sounds. Hailey started to moan. "That feels so fucking good."

My eyes travelled over Emily's body, her petite feet, her shapely calves, her soft thighs. Her wet pussy almost dripping on the chair, her abs tensed against the pleasure, her nipples rock hard. Her red lips around the ball gag. Her green eyes filled with lust. I caught her gaze while I kept fucking the brunette. Emily's eyes were full of excitement, and I knew she would be cumming soon. Hailey and I had found a rhythm. Whenever I pushed in her she bucked back at me, burrowing me deeper in her. I really couldn't take this much longer. The brunette squeezing me, the blonde with her piercing green eyes in front of me.

Emily bucked against her vibrator. Her moans were increasing but she had a look of stubborn frustration in her face. She was about to cum, but was trying her best to hold back from the edge. This look of pleasurable frustration almost took me over the edge.

"I'm about to cum." I warned Hailey. She jumped out from under me. Leaving me hanging just on the edge. Quickly she walked towards Emily and shut down the vibrator.

"Sam, get over here," she gestured me towards them. Then she removed the gag from Emily's mouth, letting it hang dripping with drool from her neck. "Fuuuuuck, I was just about to cum."

"I know," Hailey said with a teasing smirk, "now open up."

Hailey grabbed my dick and pumped it two, three times. The short pause had let me relax a little bit, but the deft movements of Haileys hands had me right back on the verge of cumming. She took my dick and put it between Emily's lips. Emily immediately started licking and sucking me towards the inevitable orgasm. Milliseconds before I came I heard a click and the buzzing sound of the vibrator increasing to an even harder buzz. Hailey must have set it to the maximum setting. Emily's lips left my dick to let out a deep moan. She started shaking and took my dick back in my mouth. As Emily was cumming her mouth pushed me over the edge. A long deserved orgasm made its way through my body. I filled the brunette's mouth with cum. One spurt, two, three. She gasped for air and my dick fell out her mouth. More sperm landed on her face and chest.

The blonde was still trembling. "Shut...."

"Huh?" Hailey said?

"Shut it off, I can't take any more."

Hailey playfully bit Emily's nipple. Making her moan even harder. Then she took the vibrator and removed it from Emily's overstimulated pussy. She went to kiss Emily. "Well done," she cooed. Then she frowned. "You swallowed all of it?"

"I had to, I couldn't breathe."

"Guess, I'll have to make do," the brunette said. As she went to the blonde's chest and started licking up the ropes of cum. Taking extra care to lick Emily's sensitive nipples.

As for me, I had fallen down on the bed. My legs were still wobbly from the orgasm. I heard the sound of cuffs getting unlocked and I felt something land on the bed next to me. Heard a kissing sound and I found the two roommates entangled in each other on the bed. I was happy to just watch and catch my breath. As their frantic kisses slowly morphed into slow and sensual caresses the girls fell apart.

"Move over," Emily said while she was crawling to my left side. I obliged her and laid on my back in the middle of the bed. Emily nestled herself to my left, her head on my shoulder, her leg over mine. Seeing this Hailey copied her move, nestling herself to my right side. I wrapped my arms around the girls and inhaled deeply. I could almost fall asleep like this. We lay there, content to just be quiet for a bit.

"Hmmm, that's nice." I heard from my left.

"Yeah, keep going," Hailey purred into my right ear.

Subconsciously I had started to stroke the girls naked backs. It wasn't something I did on purpose, just something I always tend to do when someone snuggles up to me. I kept caressing the girls' supple flesh. After a while I felt Emily's finger started tracing figures over my chest and belly. She was moving equally lazy as I was, just letting her fingers wander. I breathed in deeply. A few weeks ago I hadn't even dared to dream of a threesome with my two twenty-something neighbours. I couldn't have guessed Emily's exhibitionist streak, or Hailey's impulse to dominate her roommate. I felt Emily's fingers trail downward, below my belly button, near my pubes. What had started as some relaxing caresses quickly started to get me excited again. Her fingers were tickling my sensitive flesh. I decided to make my caresses also a little more risque. Where at first I had been satisfied just to caress their backs, now my hands trailed a little more upward, lightly grazing the sides of the two girls' boobs.Hailey moved a little, turning around so my hand could caress her breast.

"Feels like something is awakening again," Emily murmured into my ear. I felt blood slowly start to gather in my dick. Emily's hand travelled further down, now lightly grazing over my cock and balls. Her attention didn't leave me unfazed. Slowly my dick started to get stiffer and stiffer. Her hand encircled my member and she started to lightly stroke me. I couldn't help but let out a moan. I guess that's what got Hailey's attention too, her hand went to my chest while she whispered, "Ready for round two? Do you want to fuck Emily?"

"I'd love to," I answered.

Hailey stood up, only to lay down behind Emily. Her hands started massaging the blonde's boobs before descending to her pussy. I saw her caress the lips before ending up between Emily's legs. Emily's breath increased. I was sure that the brunette had found all of her roommate's sensitive spots.

Emily in turn was still slowly stroking my cock. Making sure to stroke it from the base all the way to the top and back. After an indeterminate period of just slowly stroking, caressing and winding each other up Emily swung her leg over me. She pointed my dick to her opening and in one move her wet pussy encompassed my hard dick. For a while she was happy just to sit down on top of me. Then after a while I started to feel a new sensation, she was using her muscles to start milking my dick. Her wet folds squeezing and relaxing around me.

I let out a moan, "Damn that feels good."

Emily just grinned and kept squeezing me. After a while she started rocking her hips, pushing me even further into her wet pussy. Hailey had used the opportunity to start to kiss me, her soft lips on mine, her hands caressing my chest.

Emily started to move more, letting my dick slip halfway out of her pussy before slamming down again. Hailey whispered in my ear, "Wanna see something funny?"

Before I could answer she had stood up and had sat down behind Emily. First kissing her neck, her hands around her body. Quickly her hands had moved to the blonde's nipples, pinching them and massaging her boobs. I could immediately feel the difference, Emily's pussy clenched around me and Emily let out a deep moan. "Not fair," she moaned.

Encouraged by Emily's moans, Hailey let a hand drop down, expertly finding Emily's little nub. The change was almost instant. Emily dropped down on top of me, her pussy clenching my dick. She moaned from the combined pleasure of a dick in her pussy and fingers circling her clit. She needed a little time to acclimatise to the combined sensations. It seemed like Hailey didn't want to give her that time though. She kissed the blonde's neck while her pace on her nub increased. Emily kept rocking on my dick, her eyes rolled away in pleasure. Slowly the rocking motion turned back into a thrusting motion as she started riding my dick once again. Even though I had already cum once today I felt my orgasm approach again. The feeling of Emily's wet pussy and her enthusiastic riding. The view of these two beautiful college girls pleasuring each other and me was enough to make anybody cum. Emily increased her pace, her boobs swinging with the movement. Her moans filled the air. I was sure I was about to cum, I needed something to distract me. I focussed my eyes on Hailey.