Too Good To Be True Ch. 09

Suki nodded excitedly.

Courtney took a deep breath and took my dick back in her mouth, too the back of her mouth. She then looked me in the eyes and swallowed my cock, continuing to push until she was bottomed out. Then she started licking my balls, while my dick was lodged in her pulsing throat.

"Holy fuck!" Suki breathed.

"Holy fuck, is right!" I moaned in pleasure.

Suki looked from Courtney, who was trying to stay on my dick as long as possible without choking, to me and back. "I have so much to learn." She breathed. "I'm so excited."

Courtney pulled off, and only had to do one small cough. "It feels great for him, and you feel like a sexy minx doing it." She smiled.

Suki took my dick in her hand and put it in her mouth, after about three inches I felt her body reject her taking it further. She tried to push, but pulled off, gaging. "How?" She gasped.

"You have to work through that." Courtney explained. "I read online that you can start with, like, a toothbrush, and just put it as far back as you can and work through being able to resist gaging that way. That's what I used to practice when I didn't have constant access to this." Courtney explained, stroking my dick. "For now, probably just lick the tip and suck on it. It is the most sensitive part anyway."

Suki took comfort in that and began licking and sucking on my tip.

I groaned in appreciation of her efforts and she wiggled her butt happily.

"Okay, we want his sperm in your mouth, but not that way." Courtney chided.

Suki slightly sadly released my cock from her mouth, but got excited again when Courtney straddled it.

"Guide him into my pussy, Suki." Courtney instructed.

The tiny asian girl took hold of my cock and aimed it at my girlfriend's love hole.

"Now, rub it on me to get it wet, it goes in easier that way." Courtney continued.

Suki was all over it. "Oh, easy girl. We're getting him wet, not stroking him off." Courtney advised.

Suki adjusted her technique appropriately.

"Ready, Suki?" Courtney checked. Suki nodded.

"Ready, Tom?" I nodded as well.

Suki lined me back up with Courtney's opening, and Courtney lowered herself, skewering her pussy.

"Mhm, that looks so good." Suki gasped.

When Courtney had my entire length in her, she started rocking forward and back, trying to maximize the movement without letting my cock slide entirely out of her.

"That looks so sexy," Suki moaned.

"It feels great! But if you want Suki licking my juice out of you, I should probably be on top." I informed my girlfriend.

"Mhm, you're right." Courtney agreed. And she lifted her pussy off my cock.

Courtney flopped on the bed, and Suki, seeing an opportunity, moved up and started sucking on one of her tits, while I got into position, continuing to suck and lick as she watched my dick re-enter Courtney's hungry pussy.

I started sucking Courtney's other breast, thrusting deep with each plunge. Since the other breast I would normally grope was occupied, I reached over and groped Suki's buds instead with my left hand. My right hand groped half of Courtney's ass, Suki noticed what I was doing and groped her side of Courtney's ass.

"Oh, God." Courtney moaned, "Being double teamed feels so good." And shuddered with an orgasm.

I took a breather to tell Courtney, "I'm almost there, if you don't want this to be a short fuck, we're gonna have to change something up."

"Oh, Tom, just dump in me." Courtney begged, "Suki is waiting to eat it out of me."

"Okay, here we go." I told her, and reattached myself to her nipple. I fucked her with vigor, no longer holding back to try to extend the fuck. This drove her wild and she orgasmed again in moments.

As she was coming down, I couldn't last anymore and pushed deep inside her and let loose. Courtney got pushed into another orgasm. Suki saw the unmistakable signs and hurried down to where my cock was buried in Courtney. She watched the pulsing and put a hand on my lower back as she tried to get a good angle.

I pulled out and got out of Suki's way. Suki dived into Courtney's cunt with her tongue. Courtney moaned and started pushing, trying to force my sperm out into Suki's mouth.

Feeling left out, I got behind Suki, grabbed her ass, spread her cheeks and started licking her pussy. Suki jumped then started pressing back into me, and based on the slurping noises, she licked Courtney with renewed motivation.

After a few minutes, Suki pulled away from Courtney shuddering. I gave her a few last licks, and I let Suki lay down. I got on the bed and the girls sandwiched me again.

"No fair." Suki pouted, "That was Courtney's turn and I feel like I got the better end of it."

Courtney laughed, "You didn't feel what his dick did to my insides."

Suki teased back, "You didn't feel what his tongue did to my vagina while I was licking his sperm out of you."

"Your tongue wasn't slacking either. What did you think of the taste?" Courtney prodded.

"I love salty foods, and that was delicious." Suki purred.

"Can't wait for my turn." Courtney laughed.

"Should we have invited Sarah to this?" I asked.

"I texted her, she said she was busy." Courtney assured me.

"You know, we should get an extra bed and some dressers in the spare room. That way, there is space for clothes for everyone, and if we have too many people to fit in the bed, they can still spend the night." I suggested.

That was declared to be a great idea. Courtney started making arrangements on her phone.

Suki decided to practice her oral skills and took my spent penis in her mouth. After a moment, she pulled off. "I can still taste Courtney on you." Suki chuckled, and took my head in her mouth again.

Though she couldn't take me deep, she was motivated and seemed to love sucking and licking on me. It wasn't long before her tongue worship of my dick had an effect on me, and she happily continued. Her ass wiggling happily.

"Do you like sucking on me?" I questioned, moving her hair out of the way of her face and massaging one of her breasts.

She shuddered at my touch, then resumed her ass wiggling. "It makes me feel... desirable. Sexy. Like something other than a flat piece of wood."

"You know I like your breasts and ass, right?" I told her.

She looked at me, my cock rolling around in her mouth. She removed her tongue's toy from her mouth. "I'd have to have breasts and an ass for you to like them."

I looked at the mound I was groping, "So is this someone else's or..."

She rolled her eyes and kept sucking.

I caught Courtney's eye and motioned toward the lube and looked at Suki's ass. Courtney's eyes widened and she discreetly brought me the lube, disguising the action as coming to kiss me. "Having fun you two?" She asked.

Suki nodded vigorously on my dick. I nodded as well.

"I'm gonna finish ordering all of this, then I'll join you." Courtney explained.

"You've got time." I said, "With the load I just dumped it'll take me a while to do another, no matter how good Suki here is at what she's doing."

Suki wiggled her butt happily at the praise. Courtney went back to ordering furnishings for the extra bedroom.

I reached over and hooked my hand under her thigh and pulled her booty over. She glanced over at me, but resumed sucking.

I started off by just massaging and kneading the muscular cheerleader ass that was now deposited at my side. I could feel her attention as she obviously wasn't used to such attention to her hindquarters. I jiggled her ass in my hands. From my vantage point I could clearly see the effect my attention on her rear was having on her as her pussy got wetter and wetter.

I decided to go for broke and pulled her cheeks, and admired the pink pucker of her anus, then began rubbing the little star.

"Mmmhhhmmmhhhmmmm!" She moaned onto my cock.

"Oh, I'm sorry, I was under the impression you didn't have an ass." I teased her, continuing to squeeze both of her cheeks as I rubbed her anus with my thumb.

"Maybe...maybe I like this." Suki admitted, pulling off my dick for a second.

"Do you trust me? Can I keep going?" I asked Suki, as Courtney tried not to watch, but even Courtney was clearly getting excited.

"I trust you. You may do what you want with... with my ass." Suki was clearly excited.

Courtney gave up all pretenses of not being invested and got over in prime watching position. Her phone in hand, Courtney almost opened her camera app, then caught herself.

"Suki, I have a video of the first time Tom fucked my ass, it's incredibly hot to watch. Would you like me to video this for you?" Courtney almost begged. Suki nodded enthusiastically and resumed sucking. Courtney opened the phone app and began recording the fine Asian ass on display on the bed.

I opened the lube with one hand and dribbled some in her ass, right on top of her pucker, still playing with her anus. She squeaked as the cool liquid touched her backdoor. I kept rubbing her second hole until I deemed her ready, then pressed my thumb gently into her butt, just a centimeter. Her sphincter welcomed the intrusion and she moaned, still licking my cock.

Courtney put her hand over her mouth as my thumb slowly pushed into her friend's ass. Suki was clearly enjoying everything about this. And her butt wiggled happily, drawing another knuckle of my thumb into her ass.

"Now Suki," I informed the tiny Asian, "I desperately want to fuck this tight ass. But if I just stick my cock in your ass, it's going to hurt. So I'm going to work your ass to loosen it so it won't. Now as It might take some time to get your ass, would you be a sweetheart and keep up your amazing work to keep me hard so you can enjoy it in your ass once it's ready."

Suki mumbled something excitedly as she continued to savor the cock in her mouth. It was quite the distraction, as I applied more lube and withdrew my thumb, replacing it with my index finger. As knuckle after knuckle were swallowed by Suki's ass, Courtney started gently rubbing her clit, stabilizing her elbow on the bed to reduce the shaking of the camera.

The sensation on my finger in her ass was divine. Suki's ass was completely relaxed, and so I could push my finger in easily enough, but once inside the space was hot, wet with lube, and tight. I began working my finger around, forcing the muscles to concede territory. After a good two minutes or so of that, I tested her asshole with a second finger.

I couldn't see her face as my second finger slipped into Suki's ass, but by her reaction, I knew the sensation was powerful for her. Her tongue stopped swirling on my dick, and trembled. Her back muscles rippled and she gripped the sheets tight. The only thing telling me that she was overcome with pleasure, not pain, was the deep, throaty, sexual moan that Suki emitted for the entire descent of my second finger, from the moment my fingertip entered her backdoor to the moment I could push no deeper. My fingers could feel her bowels begin to turn, so deeply embedded in her ass were they pressed.

I gave her a few moments to acclimate to this stretching of her ass, and only when she began her oral administrations on my cock did I resume stretching her ass again. I worked my fingers to spread her insides, preparing them for the coming fucking.

Finally, I deemed her anus as prepared as I could make it.

"You ready to feel what my dick feels like in here?" I asked Suki.

"Uh huh!" Begged Suki, still sucking my dick as directed.

"Then get on your back, and see if you can put your knees behind your shoulders." I'd seen the position in a porn once, it twisted the girls hips she she could see her hole getting fucked.

Suki flipped on her back and without a hint of effort assumed the position I'd instructed, and realizing she could see her asshole, she began breathing deeply, and I could have fucked her ass with just the fluids her vagina was leaking.

Courtney found the perfect angle with her phone camera and stopped playing with herself to make sure she had a good shot.

I lined my spit-lubed dick up with her silicone lubed ass. I put my dome against Suki's pucker and slowly eased myself in. Suki's backdoor allowed me entrance surprisingly easy, considering how tight it was passed the rings of muscle that usually kept any intrusion out.

Suki's eyes were half lidded with overstimulation as she watched my rod slowly split her ass open. "Fuck, don't stop." Suki instructed. "Deeper."

I pushed in another inch.

"Deeper."

I was concerned but pushed more in. I could feel her bowels being forced apart by the head of my penis.

"Tom, don't stop. Deeper!" Suki begged.

I only had a few inches left at this point before my whole 6 inch cock would be buried in Suki's ass. I almost backed out, concerned I'd hurt the poor girl. Suki's eyes were full of hunger and pleading though, so I did as she asked.

I felt the head of my penis hit the bend in her bowels, then twist and go around the bend, and I put the last few inches slowly into Suki's ass.

When my balls touched the crease of her butt and I could fuck her ass no deeper, Suki tossed her head back and grunted, "MMNNMmmnnmmmhhhhhhh!"

"You okay, that was a lot of dick in your ass without letting you get used to it?" I asked Suki.

"It stings a little," Suki admitted. "But it feels too good to stop."

"Shall I start gently then?" I inquired.

Suki nodded quickly.

I withdrew until the head of my penis was just inside her sphincter, then pushed back until I was as deep as I could.

The second thrust made Suki come. It wasn't a gentle orgasm. Her arms shot out and grabbed the bed frame. Her legs snapped down to the bed, temporarily forcing my cock deeper in her bowels. Suki bit down on her lower lip, and I'm surprised there wasn't blood.

I pulled out and thrust again, then started getting a rhythm going. Fuck, her ass was so tight! Add onto it the rippling spasms and, damn, her ass felt amazing around my cock.

"Your ass feels so good!" I moaned.

"I can't believe it all fits..." Suki moaned, watching the rod pumping in and out of her backdoor. "I couldn't fit it all in my vagina."

I felt a climax roll over me, but my balls refused to empty into her. I'd run into this issue once or twice with Courtney when we'd had sex too close together. It usually meant I could pound Courtney's hole until she couldn't take it anymore, but with this being Suki's first time doing anal, I had to be careful not to abuse her enthusiasm.

"Alright, Suki, let me know if your ass starts to get sore, or if it starts to hurt. That's usually the sign your ass is done. Until then, this has felt absolutely heavenly, I love fucking your tight, hot ass. I just don't want to hurt you, so we can do this again soon. " I cautioned my tiny Japanese lover.

Suki looked up at me overjoyed, "I want your sperm in my ass!" She proclaimed.

"Unfortunately, I'm still recovering from our last round. But if your ass can take it, I'd love to fuck it again later and pump this tight hole full of my cum." I regrettably informed her.

She winced at my next thrust, revealing the state of her ass.

I stopped, "Your ass has reached its limit of what feels good, hasn't it?" I demanded.

I kissed her, "That was amazing, you should be proud of how much I enjoyed your ass. It's a sexy little ass."

Suki shuttered as I extracted myself from her backdoor. Courtney stopped recording.

"You mean it? You like my ass?" She pleaded.

"Of course!" I verified, "A big ass could be fun once in a while, but girls with big asses play into a very specific, but vocal, fetish. Combine that with the body positivity movement, and you've got a loud, and personal overrated, idea that only big bubble butts are what all men want. While I will enjoy anyone's body that joins the harem, personally I like girls more on the petite side, like you and Courtney."

Suki looked over Courtney, seeing that the woman I had chosen for my girlfriend, and main girl in my harem, indeed had smaller tits and a smaller ass. Suki seemed to take comfort in that.

"The other girls in the cheer square call me a two-by-four. They say I'm flat in the front, flat in the back, and too skinny to be attractive." Suki stuttered tearfully, "It's made it very hard to feel... sexy, desirable. I've been afraid I'd never find a good man even willing to touch me. Thank you, for making me feel worth being loved."

I pulled her close and held her. She cried into my chest, overjoyed at the companionship and love she was experiencing. Courtney snuggled up to her too.

"I've found that if people tease you, usually they're jealous. Courtney says you are the top of the pyramid, right?" I comforted her, and she nodded into my chest. "They wish they were lighter, more flexible, and youthful. They know in five years, they'll be spent and you'll still look young and beautiful."

Suki kissed me. "Thank you. I may not... 100% believe you, but I think I love you and will stay so long as you will have me..." she glanced at Courtney, "...as long as you are okay with it. He was yours first...." Suki hurried to add.

"Suki, I wouldn't have it any other way." Courtney assured her, "It's like getting all the sisters I never had growing up, but instead of being family, we all just love the same man."

We cuddled like that until Suki needed to use the restroom.

"I still want to lick your cum out of her vagina." Courtney informed me.

"After what I just did to her ass, she probably won't be able to take my dick in that hole for three days." I estimated, "But if she says no to me fucking her pussy after dinner, I'll me shocked."

Courtney was content with that, and we dressed.

We went into the game room for a while to play video games. When Suki joined us, since Courtney and I were each taking up a Lovesac,she deposited herself in my lap. She wasn't much of a gamer, but picked up fast enough at Super Smash Brothers. Even with her quickly picking up the game, eventually we just were doing a team eight-man brawl, Suki, Courtney and me against an army of Courtney's Amiibos. We'd see how long we could keep Suki alive and Suki just laughed at the hilarity of it all.

When we started getting hungry, Courtney made a teriyaki chicken stir fry. Suki was pleased, because apparently she'd taught Courtney how to cook stir fry some six months past.

"It's a tasty, easy meal." Suki declared.

"What's not to like?" Courtney laughed.

Suki praised the stir fry and told Courtney she could tell Courtney had been practicing.

After dinner, while food was settling, Courtney and Suki debated on who they thought Sarah would bring into the Harem next.

"I'm betting Abby," Courtney decided. "She tries to hide it, but we all know she wants it. The only reason she might not be next is if she is fighting what her body needs too hard."

"You're joking right?" Suki laughed. "If Debbie doesn't find some satisfaction soon, she'll die. She's torn between being so horny she's tempted to walk around campus naked, and being disgusted by the guys that would approach her if she did. She said that the problem with men is that if you broadcast that you're desperate for a good man, the good men run away and the bad men come running." Suki informed me. "Debbie is either next, or right after that."

"I still think Abby should be here soon..." Courtney insisted.

"You just want to watch Tom fuck her because she's you, just with red hair, more tits and more ass." Suki teased.

"Maybe! Is there anything wrong with that?" Courtney countered.

"No." Suki lamented, "Unfortunately, the only other Japanese girls I know are total sluts. Chiyo got chlamydia at a party. Akiko had a condom break and had to get an abortion. And Emiko has gonorrhea right now."

Courtney wrinkled her nose, "Sorry Suki, sounds like until we get a good freshman, you're out of luck on that front."