Be Careful What You Ask For Ch. 02

Story Info
Both a wife and husband get involved with the same man.
1.6k words
4.03
32.6k
10

Part 2 of the 5 part series

Updated 10/31/2022
Created 04/17/2014
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here
coollvr1
coollvr1
139 Followers

The first chapter of this story dealt with a woman who was primed for an affair and was taken anonymously. She subsequently discovers that her attacker was someone that she wanted to have sex with anyway. She and her attacker develop a relationship parallel to one which her husband also has with him.

*****

The faceless fucking that Sheilah received from James changed her forever. She now had a spring in her step, a gleam in her eye and a roll in her hips that was not present before. Jack even noticed it but chose not to comment because of the sheer joie de vivre that Sheilah exuded. She was now so alive, so vibrant, so happy that it was infectious. Her girlfriends noticed too and when they tried to question her as to the cause, all she would do was smile.

One day as she and her girlfriends were having their regular morning coffee klatch and engaging in racy conversation, Margie, one of her oldest and most trusted friends and the only one of the group who knew that her husband Jack was the only man that had ever fucked her, declared,

"Shit, I know why Sheilah is so happy!"

All of the other women stopped talking and turned towards her and yelled,

"What is it?...What is it?"

Margie grinned and whispered,

"She's getting fresh cock!"

"Ooh," giggled the other women, "Really? Who, Sheilah, who?

At first Sheilah was dumbstruck by Margie's pronouncement but after they kept playfully badgering her and knowing also that they had all shared intimate assignations and trysts with men other than their husbands with each other, she chuckled and said,

"Marge, you're an old 'ho, but you're right!"

Marge, a five foot eight blonde bombshell but avowed black cock lover responded,

"It takes one to know one but who is it, who is it?

Sheilah turned to them and said, "I'll tell but you guys have to swear not to tell anyone else!"

"Oh please, Sheilah, you know that we only share everything with one another and never tell anybody else. We love our husband's too but a little strange cock every now and then never hurt anybody!" All the women laughed at Joan's outburst.

"Ok, ok," Sheilah replied, " I'll tell you. It's James, that big black guy that works with Jack!"

"Oooo," Margie cooed, " He's gorgeous, I wanted to fuck him myself."

"Tell us how it happened," Joan begged.

Sheilah then recounted the story of the reception and the fireworks display and what happened in the room behind the reception hall. Margie then asked,

"How did you know it was James?"

She then told them about the meeting afterwards in the street and they all clucked and nodded their heads.

Margie asked,"How was he?"

"Oh my God," Sheilah whispered conspiratorially, "He literally fucked my brains out?"

"Did he have a big cock?" Joan whispered.

"The biggest that I ever had," Sheilah replied, knowing that only Marge knew that it was only the second cock that she had been fucked with. Knowing this Marge asked,

"How big was his cock?"

"I didn't see it," said Sheilah, "but it was so big that it sprawled me wide open and reached all the way up into my belly! It left me walking bow legged for a week!" Sheilah exclaimed. All of the women giggled.

"That's what I'm talking about ," Joan commented, "I love big cocks and if you're going to get some strange, you might as well get a good fucking with a nice big cock that stays good and hard.!"

Marge winked at Sheilah and said,

"Welcome to our world."

The other girlfriends thought that Marge was welcoming Sheilah to the group that had affairs while married but Sheilah knew that Marge was welcoming her to the group who had been fucked by big black cocks.

In the early afternoon as Sheilah was completing her work assignment for the afternoon, her telephone rang. Somewhat annoyed by the intrusion, Sheilah picked the phone up and said,

"Laboratory studies, Sheilah speaking."

A very deep smooth baritone voice slipped into her ear with,

"Well, hello, sweet woman, how are you?"

At first her brow furrowed as she paused to get the voice but soon the memory of a deep voice that she recollected coming from behind her as it's owner had gasped,

"You've got some good pussy,"

came back to her. "Is this James?" she inquired.

"Yes, it is," the voice answered.

Her pussy spasmed in ecstatic recollection and soaked her panty crotch as her heart started to pound.

"Hel...he'll...hello," she stuttered, " how are you?"

"I'm fine," he responded. "I was thinking about you today and just thought I'd call to say hi."

Sheilah's chest felt as if it would burst as her heart continued to pound. Taking a deep breath she said,

"Well, this certainly is a surprise!"

A welcome one, I hope,"he answered.

Not wanting to be overly effusive, she said, "Well, I didn't expect anyone to call me at this hour, so it certainly is a surprise and since I haven't see you in a while, it's certainly welcome in that regard." James laughed and said,

"Well at least you aren't mad at me."

"Why should I be mad at you?" Sheilah said.

"Well, our last meeting was certainly not at your instigation and I am not sure how you felt about it."

"Why did you do it?" Sheilah asked.

"I don't know what came over me but I had gone to the bathroom and when I returned, I couldn't get on the elevator to go up to see the fireworks, so I went into the back room to see if I could view them from there and I saw you magnificent ass displayed before me with you head and shoulders hanging out the window.

At first I was going to leave the room but it dawned upon me that if I trapped you outside you would never know who it was and I would be able to experience what I have wanted for so long."

"Which was...?" Sheilah asked.

James paused, cleared his throat and said,

"I hope that I don't offend you but I've wanted you from the very first time that I laid eyes on you. Your ass has been in my dreams every night and I wanted to fuck you just like I did. I know that I was wrong but I couldn't help myself...but God knows it was the most wonderful pussy that I have ever had."

Sheilah smiled knowing that James couldn't see her face and said,

"But what if I had told my husband and had you charged with rape?"

James paused and said, "Whatever the consequences, it would have been worth it!

Sheilah closed her eyes as the memory of their clandestine fuck overwhelmed her and she felt a small trickle of her pussy juice wend it's way down her leg.

Her reverie was interrupted by the deep baritone voice asking,

"Sheilah, you still there?"

"hmmm, yes, I'm still here.." She moaned

"Is it possible?" James asked.

"Is what possible?" Sheilah queried.

"I asked you if I could see you again." James responded.

"I don't know," Sheilah replied, "I don't think that I should." Sheilah knew that if James put that big cock up her pussy again she'd be an addict for the rest of her life and she knew that she loved her husband Jack and didn't want to destroy her marriage.

James was silent for a minute and then said, "Sheilah, for what ever it's worth, that was some of the best pussy that I have ever had. I know that you enjoyed me too and I want you to know that I want some more but this time I want you to know its me who is fucking you. I want to look in your face and watch you cum; I want to have you ride my cock; I want to turn your ass to me and fuck it until our juices soak the bed and I even want to fuck your ass."

Sheilah's pussy snapped shut and then popped open ushering out a large glob of juice which soaked her panty crotch. She felt the wetness oozing and made a note to herself to go to the ladies room and dry her pussy before it soaked through to her dress.

"My-y-y ass?" Sheilah stuttered.

"Yes, Sheilah, your ass!" James replied.

"B-b-uttt won't your cock be too big?" She asked in awe.

"Have you ever been fucked in the ass, Sheilah?" James asked.

Sheilah remained quiet but James could hear her breathing rapidly and knew that she was excited.

"If you haven't, I'd love to be the one to take your virginity." James said.

"Oh God-d-d!" Sheilah moaned, remembering the masterful fucking that James had delivered.

"Won't it hurt?" She asked, with a tremulous voice.

"Not when I prepare you properly," he answered.

Sheilah whimpered, "I don't know, James, I don't know..."

Sheilah knew full well that she would submit to

James strong dominant personality. He was handling her right. He just told her what he wanted and she knew that she would allow him to do whatever it was that he wanted. Her anus quivered at the thought of being plundered by James' big cock.

"I'll call you soon,' James told her.

"Ok," responded a submissive Sheilah.

James hung up leaving a pussy soaked Sheilah wondering how she was going to manage James. She knew that she was going to give him what he wanted but didn't know how and she knew that she didn't want to hurt Jack and risk ruining her marriage.

"Oh God," whispered Sheilah as she sat on the commode patting her pussy dry, "Oh God, what am I going to do?"

coollvr1
coollvr1
139 Followers
Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
4 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousalmost 2 years ago

Faithless slut for a disloyal man whore. They deserve each other and James deserves better than the both of them.

BodyartistBodyartistover 8 years ago
Good one..!

Well written, very sexy...!

LeFrog08LeFrog08almost 10 years ago
that marriage is already on the brink...

...of disaster- Someone will get hurt...but who? hopefully the cheating wife and not the husband.

Nitro70652Nitro70652almost 10 years ago
again

Still a well told and captivating story. This chapter a little too short but I guess you should always leave them wanting. As for the Anonymous people who comment, seriously sick people who can't seem to NOT read stories that warn them ahead of time of the content. KentuckySub suggested they are "scary"..... I'd say more demented than scary. Stick to reading the bible and stay away from erotica.

5 stars.

Share this Story

Similar Stories

This Is What Friends Are For My best friend fucks my wife with his big cock.in Loving Wives
She Couldn't Help Herself He wants his boss to make his wife a slut.in Loving Wives
Filling up Amy Devoted wife will do anything for hubby.in Loving Wives
The Seduction of My Wife He sets up his wife for a friend.in NonConsent/Reluctance
My Wife's Only Gangbang It was just supposed to be dinner.in Loving Wives
More Stories