by Silasmarner
However improbable the story-line may be, the writing is excellent. Thoroughly enjoyed it, and hope the next part follows soon.
This is one of the most intriguing stories I've read on here in years.
Considering I must've read thousands of tales in that time, that's saying a lot.
I have absolutely no idea where you're taking this story, and I can't even get a good read on Brooke's emotions or motivations. Normally, that would be a criticism of the writing, but in this story she's just a fascinating enigma.
5* can't wait for the next one.
This has a unique plot line and is an extremely well written story. The parts where Brooke is acting as the wife or needy girlfriend can be a bit weird and awkward, but it seems to be intended that way and fits her character as an actress/aunt mentoring her nephew. I’m eager to read more… bravo!
Some editing opportunities, but otherwise a sophisticated plot with some diverging plot lines that keep us readers guessing where we're going. I love the ride so far! 5*
Like the rest of your commentators, you have hooked me, I am engaged with the story of Jonah and his aunt Brooke. I don't know if it's intentional on your part, but you are showing how Brooke, who has known Jonah his whole life and has loved him, is putting him through sexual boot camp.
I'm still rating this at 4 stars, because of the craftsmanship flaws (see my comment to pt. 01), but it's really a 4.5. If you succeed in developing the story as I hope, I will hereafter round up to a 5.