My Sister Made Me Ch. 12

Dane snickered. "You said motherfucker?"

Sam shrugged. "It was a gut reaction. He kept calling Pastor Dickhead by his real name."

"Ah," Dane said, nodding.

"So... then he's trying to figure out why I just said motherfucker. And he just wouldn't let it go! He wouldn't shut up about it. He... said his name again, I don't know what else he said because I screamed, "Fuck him," I think.

She turned and looked at her brother, who nodded.

"I immediately apologized but inside I was furious. I was begging him to say that asshole's name again inside my head. I wanted him to. I was... enraged."

"And he did?" Dane asked.

Sam nodded. "I heard it, and everything went silent. I was more furious than I've ever been in my life. I wanted him to feel pain just from me looking at him," she said, shaking her head. Brushing some hair away, she took a deep breath and shrugged at his inquisitive glance. "So, then he sees that he's about to get thrown through a wall or something, and that's when I went to the bathroom to clean up and saw you when I started back."

Dane nodded. "I went back to my room and put on my music."

"When I got back in there, I explained it all, and it was like I was confessing my sins. It was like I was reliving it all over again. But then..." she said, cocking her head and staring into her memories, "he didn't believe me."

Dane looked at her in confusion. "Wait... what?"

She nodded. "He accused me of making it all up so he would break up with me."

Dane was quiet for a moment, staring at her in confusion. Finally, he said, "That's fucking asinine."

She nodded. "I just don't get it," she said. "He didn't believe me, Dane." Feeling the tears coming back, she sighed and shook her head, wiping them away quickly.

Silence engulfed the two then, and she sat quietly, trying to process everything that had transpired. Her head was pounding though, and she stood to get a drink from a bottle of water that was on the dresser. Looking in the mirror, she saw that blood had dripped down her shirt. Sighing, she turned and saw him standing up.

"Are you in a hurry to go somewhere?" she asked. "You keep trying to leave."

"No, I just feel awkward and don't know how to fix this for my little sister," he admitted.

She shook her head, her eyelids feeling heavy. "You can't. Just... just be here with me."

He nodded and smiled, sitting on the edge of the bed.

A thought occurred to her then, and she smiled up at him hopefully, the expression feeling strained. "Do you think we could do snugglebunnies?" she asked.

He smiled, nodding. "Of course," he said.

She went over to her side of the bed and pulled the covers back. Stripping off her clothes without thinking twice, she climbed into bed and covered up, clad only in her pink panties. Dane knew better than to try and get in bed with shoes on, so she waited for him to get those off, noting that they were joined by his shirt and shorts a few seconds later.

"God, take your socks off, dork," she said, smiling as she glanced down.

He smirked. "My feet are cold though."

She sighed. "You can put them on me, just hurry up already. I want damned snugglebunnies."

He chuckled. "This motherfucker is going as fast as he can."

She giggled, admiring his brave attempt at making light of the situation. Soon, her big brother was wearing only his boxers and had slid in bed next to her. Reaching back, she pulled his arm over her, but then decided to face him and leaned in, nuzzling his chest. He started to stroke her hair, and soon, they were laying quietly, enjoying the warmth of each other's bodies.

"Maybe he just needed time to process," she offered finally, ten minutes or so into their relaxing.

"Could be," Dane said. "I know I'd have to take some time to digest something like that if it had happened to Sally"

Sam nodded, gently rubbing the skin of his neck with her fingers, but then said. "I think we both know that you wouldn't have been so fucking blind if it were happening to the woman you loved."

He didn't respond immediately.

"You know, maybe it was more of him not being able to accept it, you know?" Dane asked.

"Like... he just... couldn't?" she asked.

Dane nodded, adding, "Mmmhmm."

"Maybe," she said with a shrug.

He sighed contentedly and fell silent. Soon, the two of them were breathing rhythmically, and she dozed off, facing him, her leg over the top of his.

**

An hour or so later, she awoke slowly, aware of certain pleasurable sensations. Dane's muscular chest was pressed against her nose, and she lifted up a bit, running it through his chest hair. Sighing happily, she couldn't help but kiss the warm, muscular flesh, inhaling the manly scent that clung to him.

Between her legs though, his substantial cock was fiercely erect, pressing against the soft fabric of her panties in exactly the same spot that her brother's erection shouldn't be. Feeling the fat, bulbous head pushing against her lips, she groaned. Unable to stop herself, she pushed forward with her hips, driving the head hard against the fabric and pushing gently backward toward her butt.

Shuddering, she moved her hips back as Dane groaned in pleasure. She looked up, and saw that his eyes were closed, and she wondered if he was still sleeping.

Unrelentingly, his cock pushed against her pussy, giving her all sorts of delightfully naughty and inappropriate thoughts. Knowing she shouldn't but not caring in that moment, she reached back and slid her finger under the cusp of her panties, sliding it gently into her butt crack, then slid her finger down. Having to arch her back, she moved her finger back, pulling her underwear further out of the way.

Moving her hand around front, she intended to slide it down and push her panties clear, to let Dane rub on her flesh, but she brushed against the warm, thick shaft instead, whimpering in desperate need. Not caring if he was awake or asleep, she moved her hand down, pushing his cock out of the way as she forced her panties to the side.

Reaching down, she gripped his pulsing, rigid staff and brought it back up, sliding it against the oozing wetness of her pussy. Groaning, she pushed, feeling him slide up the slit, momentarily pushing at her tunnel before moving past.

Whimpering, she desperately moved her hips back, looking up and seeing his eyes still closed. Holding still, she stared up at him, almost afraid to move. Then, gently, she pulled, her hand resting on his hip and gently urging him forward.

Suddenly realizing that she was crossing a serious line, she quickly stopped and shook her head. Dane mumbled in his sleep and she quickly turned over, freezing as he pulled her tight back up to him, sleepily groaning in pleasure as his dick nestled nicely against her panty clad butt crack.

Her moving around had roused him enough to begin to stir, though, and she felt him pull back as he noticed his erection.

"Sorry," he mumbled. "Close proximity and all."

She forced the sexual thoughts racing through her mind to shut the hell up and tried to think about something else other than the hard cock a few inches from her butt.

"Stupid hard cock. Stop fucking tempting me," she thought. "Stop. Just stop it. Stop thinking about sex. This is Dane. He's your brother, not some guy from school. This isn't Marley or Brandon. This is Dane. Stop thinking about his cock. Stop thinking about sliding your panties down and forcing him inside. Stop thinking about him fucking you, nice and slow. Stop thinking about how wonderful it would be to have him inside you. Stop thinking about how tight and snug it would be against his cock. Stop thinking about sliding down and sucking him off. Stop thinking about how warm and yummy his cum would feel in your mouth. Stop thinking about letting him cum in your pussy, harlot. This is Dane. Just stop it."

Obviously, it wasn't working.

After a few minutes of silence, alone with her rampantly horny thoughts, she turned and looked at her brother, half wanting him to make love to her and half wanting to make him leave.

"Thank you for making me feel better," she said, then slid from the sheets and stood, pulling on some clothes.

"Are you okay?" he asked. "Sorry about the... dick... thing."

She smiled. "That's the least of my worries today, Dane. Don't think twice about it." "I SURE AS FUCK WILL, THOUGH!" the little voice inside her screamed. "Just tell him you'll take it in the butt!" she thought, unhelpfully.

He smiled. "I hope Keith's okay. I didn't mean to hurt him."

She nodded. "I didn't either," she said, sighing. "I'll let him come to me, I guess." She turned, looking at him pointedly. "You know... he only got me in the nose with his elbow because you were about to beat him up."

Dane nodded. "Yeah, I know. I'll apologize if I seem him again. If you guys reconcile, that is. Still... he doesn't get to talk to you like that."

She shrugged. "Maybe I deserved it," she said, shrugging.

"Bullshit," he said. "I mean it. You're not to blame, and just because he couldn't handle it, doesn't give him the right to say that shit about you."

She smiled, pulling on a shirt over her bra. "Thank you, Dane. I appreciate it."

He smiled, moving over to give her a hug and immediately making her feel safe all over again. She sighed, stepping back and forcing a smile for his benefit. He winked, kissing her forehead and then turned, leaving the room.

Sam turned, looking in the mirror as she did so. Wondering what was going to happen with her and Keith. Was she a victim? Was Keith right? Was she at fault? She sighed, not having any answers.

Settling in, she turned on some music and drowned out all of the thoughts going through her head, forcing herself to focus on checking her schoolwork to make sure it was done, and getting ready for tomorrow.

*****

Alex

"What would help get you going?" Alex asked.

Eric smiled. "Toni eating you out?" he asked.

She briefly wondered if Kenny had outed her and her sister, but Eric grinned and said, "Just kidding," quickly after giving her his lewd suggestion.

"Mmmhmm," she said.

"I should be good in a few," he said. "Let me just watch you shower."

She smiled, then giggled as he opened the door and stepped out, turning and watching as he grabbed a towel to keep warm. Carefully avoiding getting much of her hair wet, she went about washing herself as sexily as she could figure. Soap dripped down between her tits, and she arched her back and cupped them sexily a few times for him.

It wasn't long before he was sporting a nice hard-on again, and she grinned, turning and playfully wiggling her butt at him.

"Goddamn, I can't believe I'm about to get anal."

She smiled, then turned and looked at him. "I'm the one getting anal," she pointed out.

He laughed, then moved behind her, the stream of water hitting him in the back and protecting her from the spray. She felt the head of his cock, much smaller than her brother's had been, pushing into the tight ring of muscle, and steadied herself on the wall.

"You okay?" he asked, his hands gripping her hips. She smiled back, nodding. He was sweetly taking his time, letting her adjust. Even though he was smaller than Dane had been, it was still uncomfortable. Soon though, she felt him beginning to pull on her hips, and he began to slide in and out of her butt.

"God, that feels... different," he said, smiling. "How does it feel for you?"

"Different," she agreed.

He quickly shook his head and pulled gently out, grabbing the soap and washing himself off.

"Not for you?" she asked, turning and briefly kissing him.

"No, but thank you for letting me give it a shot," he said. "You're an awesome friend."

She smiled. "Well, we can try again sometime if you like."

He nodded. "Maybe it was the water or something."

Nodding, she waited for him to finish washing, then grabbed the soap and washed his cock again.

"If you're going to go out there and fuck my sister, you better be very clean," she said.

He grinned, nodding.

Over the next hour, the three boys and the two sisters went through varying positions together. Alex had each of them in her mouth, and her pussy, as did her twin. Toni seemed greedy with the cumshots though and kept barging in and taking over when one of them got close.

Brie never re-emerged, and she began to wonder what was going on with the two. She wasn't going to pry though and knew that Kenny would talk to her if he needed to. Bear and Eric left about the same time, and Toni was still fooling around with Kenny on the bed, on her knees being fucked from behind for the umpteenth time.

Slipping out of the room, she heard voices from Brie's room. Walking over quietly, she knocked and heard the brunette call out for her to come in.

"Hey," Alex said, poking her head in and hiding behind the door in case she didn't know who was inside.

"Alex," Brie said, smiling. "Have you met my boyfriend?" she asked.

A relatively handsome guy stood and smiled, reaching over for her hand as she let the door open a little wider.

"Sorry, I'm naked. I hope that's okay," she said.

Brie grinned, nodding. "I'm sure he doesn't mind."

Brian grinned, shaking his head. "Nice to meet you. You're Kenny's friend, yeah?"

Alex nodded, smiling. "I just wanted to let you know that I'll be leaving soon," she said, looking over at Brie.

"You and Toni all sexed out?" she asked.

Alex nodded. "Let me know if you need to talk about anything," she said, smiling and hoping she understood what she was saying.

Brie smiled, nodding. "Will do. See you, gorgeous."

Alex closed the door and went back to Kenny's room, smiling and watching as Toni and Kenny kept fucking, getting dressed as she did so. Eventually the two were spent and stopped, Toni kissing him and climbing out of bed. Showering briefly, Toni got dressed and the two said their goodbyes and left, climbing into the car.

"That was a fun time," Toni said.

Alex nodded. "I need to see if Brie and Kenny are okay. It was a little weird there for a minute."

Her twin nodded in agreement. "Yeah, it was fun, but that place is getting weirder and weirder."

Alex smiled. "Hungry?" she asked.

Toni nodded emphatically. "Let's grab a burger," she said.

The twins went through a drive-through and got something quick, then headed home and ate down at the dinner table. Their mother came in, smiling and carrying groceries, then asked the two to help her carry in the rest.

Happy to do so, the twins helped their mother, then finished eating. Heading back up to her room, Toni kissed Alex and then said she was going to crash for a little. Their mother had always said don't sleep after 6, and it was 4:30 then, so she hoped that Toni wasn't out too long.

The rest of the evening, she spent in her room, briefly checking in with Sam and making sure she'd had a good night the night before and day that day.

Sam smiled, assuring her that she had, and Alex went back to her room after talking to her for a few minutes. Her sister mentioned that she'd seen Keith today, and Alex could tell that something was wrong.

"Did something happen?" she asked.

Sam shrugged. "It's not a big deal. I'm still figuring out things. I promise, I'll talk to you about it soon."

Alex smiled, nodding at her. "Okay. If you're sure you're okay."

Sam nodded. "Very sure."

Heading back to her room, she was surprised to see her twin coming through the closet. "Do you think we can talk to mom and dad about the photo shoot thing?" she asked.

"Toni, don't you think we ought to take it a little slower?"

Her twin quickly shook her head, "No. I don't know why, but I really want to do this. I think Mom and Dad will be okay with it, but Camille was right. We need to talk to them first."

Alex nodded. "She was, and we do. It's just... they're going to ask some questions, you know?"

Toni shrugged. "So, we'll answer as honest as we can, and lie about anything we don't want to admit."

Alex sighed again. "Okay. If you really want to do it tonight."

Toni smiled, nodding. "I'll come and get you in a bit."

A little later, Toni did as she'd said and retrieved Alex, then the two went downstairs to find their parents. Toni had her laptop in her hand, and an obvious spring in her step. Alex wasn't as confident as her sister was that this was going to be an easy conversation.

Their mom and dad were both home watching TV and enjoying the evening. Toni and Alex went in together and sat down, their father smiling and pulling Toni in for a hug, while Alex sat down by her mother.

"Can we talk to you guys about something we were thinking about doing?" Toni asked. "We wanted to tell you beforehand so that you aren't shocked or blindsided like the restaurant thing."

"Of course," their father said, turning off the TV.

Surprisingly, Toni didn't turn to Alex to speak, only clearing her throat and moving to sit in another chair so that she could look at both of them. Alex went and sat in another chair as well, hoping to show solidarity.

"First, I'm not making Alex do this," she said. "You guys know about my power over her now, so I just wanted to get that out of the way first."

Alex noticed that both of her parents seemed amused at the statement and smiled herself.

"So, I don't want to beat around the bush, so I'll just come out and say it. "Alex and I are thinking about doing some photo shoots for an internet website."

"Oh?" their mother commented.

"What kind of website?" their father asked, still looking bemused.

"Well... here," Toni said, opening her laptop. "It's an adult website in nature, but it's something that I've been looking into and I really think it might be fun. Camille, the photographer, said that we can make some pretty good money doing stuff like this."

"Nude modeling?" the father asked.

Toni nodded. "Yes, Daddy."

"And Alex is agreeing to this?"

Alex nodded. "She's not forcing me. We're supposed to go and check out a photo shoot coming up later in the week or next weekend."

"Oh," he said, nodding and taking the laptop from Toni. He spent a few minutes looking at it, checking it out and showing their mother, who had scooted closer.

"Well, I can't say that I'm in love with the idea. This is permanent, you realize," he said, setting the laptop down.

"I know," Toni said.

"No, I mean, it's always going to be there. When you're older, married, with kids your age now, they're going to be able to see this."

She nodded. "I know. I'm not saying we're 100% going to do this, but it's something that we're both interested in. I want to be able to look back and say that I did this. I think Alex and I both look really good and it's not going to last forever, so why not do this while we can?"

Alex smirked, laughing quietly.

"What are you laughing at?" her mom asked.

"Toni is just trying to come up with reasons to justify it. It's just something she wants to do. I wasn't really all that on board with it, but... it sounds fun. We're going to check it out more, and if it doesn't look legit, we'll walk away."

Toni nodded.

"You know, friends of mine will see this," their dad said. "Are you ready to be looked at like that?"

Alex chuckled again as Toni answered, "Dad, you might not realize it, but your friends already look at us like that.

He snorted, shaking his head. "Look, all we both want for you is for you to be happy. If this is really what both of you want to do, then we don't have any problem with it. Just make sure that it's safe and they aren't going to try and fly you out to California or to Europe for some questionable stuff."

Toni nodded. "We will."

"This is surprising," their mother said. "Not the photo shoot, but you coming to us first. That's not the Toni we know and love."