Ryan's Rules

It was a wonderful sight. Two shapely asses, with a glistening pussy between each of them. Every guy's dream! One pussy with slightly protruding labia, and one as smooth as a peach. Natalie's peach was actually dripping. I started putting my cock into it, because she seemed to be in most need. Finally I was fucking Natalie! She showed her appreciation with a magnificent symphony of moans, interspersed with repeated appraisal of the virtues of my cock. I needed that. Her pussy felt warm and welcoming, and of course soaking wet. Meanwhile I stimulated Lillian's clit with my fingers.

After a few minutes I pulled out and entered Lillian's pussy, which did indeed smell like ocean breeze. She had received Ryan's huge tool in an earlier round, but gracefully made no comparisons, even accidentally. She exclaimed: "Oh my god, another great cock". Madelyn watched with a big smile in her face, happy that I had finally probed the pussy of one of her best friends, and that I also got my turn with Natalie, given the obvious affection I had shown for her. And of course she had a big smile because she had been fucked properly, twice.

When I was about to switch pussy again, Owen said: "Wait, I can help you". Madelyn's fondling and my sexual performance had brought his penis back to life. I regretted this a bit, because I wanted to finish inside Natalie, but he was already standing behind her, and there was no stopping him. His cock slid in easily, and soon the room was filled with moans, sighs, the slapping sounds of balls and bellies against buttocks, squeaky bed springs, lewd comments about cocks, pussies and asses, and the sweet smell of sex.

Natalie did not forget to sing the praises of Owen's cock as she did with mine. Perhaps she was used to that, in order to reassure men comparing their tools to Ryan's. Men always believe women who say they have a great cock. "No, it may not be enormous honey, but it fills me so well, and you are making all the right moves with it."

Both ladies started making loud noises indicating their approach to Nirvana. Meanwhile, Madelyn started fondling my balls, and Ryan fingered Natalie's clit while she was being fucked. Now all six of us were involved in the action simultaneously. This could not last long. Indeed, within a short time Lillian, Natalie, Owen and I all reached our climax.

Totally satisfied we all fell down on the bed, our six naked bodies entangled with each other. We were all too tired and too sexually satisfied to think of anything else. After a while we got dressed, but not before each of us had given all the others a warm naked hug. I held on to Natalie a bit longer, pressing my cock against her succulent peach. It started growing again, but I was not going to use it anymore that evening.

Ryan said that he and Natalie were going to return to Chicago the next day. They left without leaving us their address. It left me with a strange, almost surreal spiritual feeling. It was as if they were angels, sent down to us by the god Eros to guide us to the gardens of delight. Their divine bodies and perfect genitals added to the funny feeling that they were not from this world. Only their occasional inability to control their lust suggested that they were human after all.

It is almost as if they had put a spell on us that removed all inhibitions. But I quickly banned these strange thoughts from my mind. Surely it was all just a happy coincidence. Still, it is hard to imagine that we would ever have gone this far without Ryan's gentle nudging. He seemed to have foreseen everything, and left us with the feeling that we were in full control, while he was subtly guiding our desires.

The next morning we did not talk much about what happened, but we all noticed a euphoric glow on each other's faces. We went to the beach, did some shopping, had dinner and went to our apartment. Around the coffee table our memories started coming back.

Lillian said: "This was great material for my upcoming novel. Because, as all of you but Matteo know, I am writing erotic novels. But don't worry, I will change all names and will not write in the first person." "Thanks for that Lillian", I said, "I am now starting to suspect that you organized the whole thing. Did you hire Ryan and Natalie?". Lillian laughed and said: "That could also be a nice theme for a novel. But no, I was taken by surprise like the rest of you."

Lillian then revealed something enlightening: "In fact, before we met I was scheming how I could get us into couple swapping. I knew Madelyn would probably not resist that, and I am sure Owen would do it. But I saw you, Matteo, as a loyal wife-only lover. How wrong I was! One of my plans was to propose going to a nude beach together, and then I hoped the whole thing would start rolling after a few suitably placed lewd remarks." I said: "I would have loved going to a nude beach. I had thought about that already. Your plan might have worked. But Ryan and Natalie made it unnecessary. They enchanted us. One might say that Ryan's seed fell on fertile ground." Lillian quipped "where by fertile ground you mean Madelyn's pussy, I guess."

Lillian continues: "Indeed, they enchanted us almost from the start! I have to confess that, just like Madelyn, already in the restaurant I was getting incredibly horny. This guy looked like a deity. And that was before we had even seen his cock. And of course you guys were completely blown away by Natalie. But not just by her. I was amazed at your enthusiastic cock-sucking yesterday, Matteo. And Owen told me he would also have loved to suck Ryan's cock."

Owen said: "Yes indeed! In addition I had hoped to fuck Ryan in the ass. All of you had some same-sex experience yesterday, except for me." I thought he was joking, but I quickly learned he was not. Owen continued: "after Ryan fucked Lillian, and admitted that this broke the rules, I should have said: OK, but now I will also break the rules. I should have taken off my pants, take me cock out, and ask Ryan if I could stick it in his ass. But I did not dare. I thought he would say no, and that my action would ruin the atmosphere."

I looked at him and said: "I did not know you were gay?". He said: "I am not gay, but probably bisexual." Lillian said that they occasionally went to swinger's clubs, and once they went to a bisexual one with a dark room for men. Lillian encouraged Owen to enter there to see what was going on, since she was not allowed. When he came out he had been fucked in his ass, and had fucked another guy in the ass himself. He liked it a lot, but never got a chance to try it again.

Lillian added: "By the way, I am totally OK with Owen being bi-sexual. I don't lose anything because of that. In fact, I have come to love watching men having gay sex. Just as most guys love watching lesbians having sex."

So Ryan was not only an object of desire for Madelyn, Lillian and me, but also for poor Owen, watching all the action with his hard cock enclosed in his swimsuit. Indeed, the dice were not in his favor. On the other hand, I was extremely lucky, getting to suck Natalie's clit as well as Ryan's cock.

I decided this was the moment to come out of the closet as well. So I told Owen: "Look Owen, I am not bi-sexual, but I do have a cock fetish. Before we met Ryan an Natalie, I was fantasizing to suck your dick. But then Ryan's magnificent dick was offered to me on a silver platter, so I sucked his. I never got around to sucking yours". He said: "Cock fetish? Is that just another word for bi-sexual?" I said "No, but it doesn't really matter".

Lillian said: "I think the two of you should do the unfinished business!" I looked at Owen and he nodded in agreement. He asked: "Do you mind, Madelyn?". She said: "No, I feel the same as Lillian. She and I had sex together, so you should too."

Both Owen and I started to undress. Our cocks were already semi-erect, and when he was finished undressing I grabbed his cock and started fondling it. He did the same with mine. Somehow we ended up on the sofa in a 69 position, and we were sucking each other's hard cocks passionately. His cock smelled like musk, sandalwood and a hint of peat-smoked whiskey, combined with a slight odor of urine, because we had not washed before.

I approached ejeculation first, and Owen noticed this from my breathing. He said: Do you want to put it in my ass? Or do you want my cock in your ass? I said "neither. That is the difference between a cock fetish and being gay." Owen's disappointment was noticeable, and his cock softened.

Meanwhile Lillian and Madelyn had also undressed, and they were in a 69 on the other sofa, making loud sopping noises, sensual moans and sighs. When she heard my refusal, Madelyn said: "Come on Matteo. This is a chance in lifetime. Just try it once. Put your dick in his ass, or allow him to do that to you. What do you have to lose? Look at how much fun Lillian and I are having."

Indeed, perhaps this was my only chance in life to have a full anal gay experience. Sometimes I still feel regrets about my decision. It is as if something remained on my bucket list. Shouldn't everyone try gay sex once in their lives? It is a bit like parachute jumping or eating Rocky Mountain oysters. It seems scary, but you don't know what you are missing if you don't try it.

But I just could not bring myself to do it. I am sure my cock would have lost its erection when approaching Owen's asshole. Strangely, I know I have a cock craving, but in the end Owen turned out to be much gayer than I was.

Madelyn and Lillian continued their love making, and had a series of orgasms. Owen and I were watching, and had lost the appetite to suck each other off until the end. But we still needed to release some tension. So Owen huddled up with his lovely wife Lillian, and I embraced my dear wife Madelyn. The evening ended with some hot and steamy straight inter-marital sex, without any regrets about what happened before, and without any doubts that we were going to do it again.