Creep from Down the Street

"Then cum for me!" He shouted, and with one last thrust big up into her, caused Maddy to cum.

Her body shook and stirred as Pete held his cock deep inside her. He held her head and forced her to look him in the eyes as she came. Her pussy tighten up as it sent wave after wave of shivering pleasure through her young body.

"Kiss me." Pete ordered his hungry lips looking for hers.

Maddy obeyed, wrapping her arms around his neck then leaning down and kissing his lips. Maddy hated kissing him though, such a loving sensual act, she didn't want to do with such a beastly man. He wrapped his tongue with hers and forced her to taste his saliva. After only a few hours of copulation, he had already sweated quite a bit and his foul body order started to infest Maddy's nose.

But whether she liked it or not she was stuck here, it was far too late to back out. As she made out with him, she began to move her hips back and forth, allowing Pete's cock to explore her insides. She started slowly but gained speed as she continued to make out with him. She could feel her conscious brain losing the battle to her lust.

Pete sat back and enjoyed the ride. Even though he wasn't the biggest guy, he could still feel his cock stretching Maddy out. She had to be the tightest girl he'd ever fuck, the way her pussy held him made it feel like heaven. The only way to make this better was if she'd let him breed her, then he'd truly be in heaven.

Maddy felt his coarse fat hands reach behind her and grab her ass. He began to massage it, tightly gripping each cheek. She hated to admit it but it felt good having his hands on her ass. She was close to cumming again, this ugly fat man making her feel things she hadn't before.

"Mmmm!!!! Mmmmm!!!" She moaned into his mouth as Pete had taken the opportunity and stuck his fat greedy finger in her ass.

She could feel her asshole stretching, wider than it had ever been before. Madison's tongue had been gentle when it entered her ass, Pete's finger was anything but gentle. He inserted his finger all the way and began to violently thrust it in and out. It was extremely painful and only became worse when he inserted a second finger. She cried out but Pete's tongue kept her from being loud.

Her body betrayed her though and she soon found herself cumming on his cock again. Despite her general disgust, her body very much enjoyed being double penetrated by Pete, as her ass and pussy clamped down around him. Maddy's brain had gone numb, and she couldn't think straight anymore.

Pete couldn't help but smile as he continued to deeply kiss a cumming Maddy. He eventually pulled his fingers out, once she had finished. He stopped kissing her, Maddy resting her head on his shoulder for a moment.

"Mmmmm... I love the feeling of a tight ass." Pete whispered in her ear. "I can't wait to feel it around my cock." While she heard those words, they didn't really register in her mind. "But not now. Now, you need to make me cum."

Pete grabbed Maddy's ass and started to move her up and down on his cock again. Maddy was exhausted, her brain numb but she eventually took over, actively fucking Pete. He rocked his hips in rhythm with her, their bodies colliding creating a loud smacking noise.

"Oohhhh!" Pete suddenly moaned as Madison had snuck in and began to suck on his balls.

Pete was so close to cumming, Maddy could feel his cock pulsing inside her. She looked at Pete's ugly face, a wide smile across it. She wasn't thinking straight as she suddenly leaned in and kissed him again. He had broken her, her mind filled only with lustful thoughts about Pete.

As their tongues embraced, Pete's cock hit its peak and he began to cum inside Maddy. Maddy felt him cumming inside her and instead of being disgusted she was the exact opposite and began cumming with him. Her pussy squeezed down around Pete, trying to get every last drop of cum out.

As they finished up, Maddy broke the kiss to catch her breath. Madison took Pete's cock out of Maddy and began to suck him off, tasting the mix of Pete's and Maddy's cum.

Maddy was almost completely broken, only a sliver of resistance lived in her as Pete would find out later.

------

"Mmm... ya right there!" Madison moaned as Maddy ate her out.

They were back in the master bedroom, both laid out on the bed, Madison was on her back legs open. Maddy was between those legs on her stomach, her left leg bent her right leg straight.

Maddy wasn't sure what time it was, it was sometime in the afternoon as they had finished lunch. Madison had made lunch, grilled cheeses and fries, as Maddy entertained Pete. After lunch, Maddy cleaned as Madison got her time alone with Pete. She seemed to almost revel in getting a chance to be alone with Pete.

Unlike Maddy, Madison was fully aware of everything going on. It likely was because she turned her brain off and just enjoyed the sex, something Maddy was unable to do. Madison was a little concerned with how easy it was for her to enjoy this, no part of her mind seemed to object at all. She wondered if she was just a freak, that maybe Pete was her taste in men.

As she spent an intimate moment with him on the couch, Madison wondered if it would really be that bad to be with someone like Pete. She looked into his beautiful green eyes as she rocked up and down his cock and felt intimately close to him. She went down and kissed him, her tongue reaching out for his.

'Eww, you'd be ostracized from society.' She imagined Maddy telling her.

She knew it was true, that there was no way society would let her be with Pete. But while she was here, she'd at least enjoy it while she could.

After he finished inside Madison, Pete went off to take another Viagra and ordered Maddy to lick Madison's pussy while he was gone in the master bedroom. Maddy was in such a haze that Pete's orders barely registered but she soon found herself going down on Madison.

She much preferred licking Madison, she tasted better to her and didn't look like a hairy walrus. She quickly became enwrapped in licking Madison, and Madison focused on her orgasm, neither realized Pete had entered the room. Somehow, despite his large appearance, he was able to sneak up on Maddy.

"AAAHHHH!" Maddy suddenly raised her head and screamed.

"What?!?" A confused and shocked Madison asked.

"Oh fuck!" Maddy yelled, now scrunching her face together.

"What is it?" Madison asked again.

"He just stuck it in my ass!" Maddy finally replied.

Madison looked beyond Maddy and saw Pete sinking the last little bit of his cock in her ass. Madison couldn't help but feel a tinge of jealousy as Pete took Maddy's anal virginity.

Pete held his cock deep inside Maddy's ass as she screamed in pain. Her ass was unbelievably tight, her walls hugged him so tightly he was surprised he was able to push in. He had always dreamed of banging Maddy's ass and as she began to calm down, he was able to begin to move. He slowly pulled in and out, Maddy tightening up her glutes making it even tougher to push in.

"AAHHH!!!" She screamed again as Pete tried to push back in.

"Stop tensing up!" Pete barked at her, smacking her fat ass.

It was of no use though, Maddy was in a lot of pain and couldn't relax. Her ass had never been stretched so far before. The resulting pain was unbearable, it woke her from her brain fog as she became aware of her situation. Maddy couldn't relax, she wouldn't, relaxing would let Pete enter her ass again and that was not an option.

But Pete had a trick up his sleeve. He used his overwhelming body size to his advantage, putting more of his weight down onto Maddy. Maddy felt his weight on top of her, she thought he might crush her hips. But he soon completed his goal, his cock being shoved back up her ass.

"AAHHH!!!" Maddy screamed again as Pete's cock stretched her out.

Pete laid down flat on top of Maddy, his thick fat body enveloping her and crushing her into the bed. It took effort just to breathe, and Pete's sweaty body gave off a horrendous odor that Maddy was forced to smell. He held his cock as deep as it would go, hoping Maddy would get used to it.

"I've dreamt of fucking your ass since the day I saw you." He whispered in her ear. "And I have to say, it doesn't disappoint."

Maddy began to cry his disgusting words the final straw. Her body was being crushed and her ass was being painfully stretched, plus she had to endure his dirty talk, it felt like torture.

But slowly but surely, her ass got adjusted, the pain slowly subsided. Maddy didn't want to relax though, and give Pete the satisfaction of fucking her ass. But, as he began to do small pumps inside her, they both knew Maddy's resistance was futile.

Pete finally rose off her, making it easier for her to breathe once again. She could feel her back covered in his sweat, the slimy gross feeling caused her to gag.

"You enjoying my cock in your butt yet?" Pete asked.

"Mmhhmm... no..." Maddy weakly replied, the pain completely gone but she was still unwilling to admit it.

"Whatever, hoe." He said, then grabbed the back of her head. "Back to licking your friend's pussy!"

Pete forced Maddy's face back down onto Madison's pussy. Madison had been frozen watching the scene before. She saw the initial painful reaction of Maddy but recognized that the pain was becoming muted. As Pete forced Maddy's lips back against her folds, Madison leaned back and then joined in holding her friend's face down with 2 hands of her own.

Maddy's head was spinning as Pete began to rail her ass. Her muscles had grown tired of squeezing, loosening up enough for Pete to start fucking her ass. The overwhelming pain was mostly gone, replaced with a growing feeling of pleasure. Her mind resisted but as it grew, her already tired mind found itself giving in to pleasure.

Pete was having the time of his life. Maddy's perfect ass was his. He was drooling, Maddy's tight ass making him lose control. Her ass was gripping him hard, making it tough to push back in at first. But as he fucked her, Maddy's ass started to open up, making it easier to fuck. His drool dripped down onto Maddy's ass, which he then rubbed in, giving her ass a shinny effect.

Maddy stuck her tongue in Madison's pussy, only to stop herself from moaning out. She didn't want Pete to know she was enjoying this torture. The room became filled with the sounds of sex. A loud slapping noise from Pete thrusting into Maddy, Madison's moans, and Pete's grunts combined into a symphony of sexual noises.

Pete slowed down for a second if only to catch his breath. He could feel Maddy was close to cumming, her ass was pulsing around his dick and her body had begun to gently shake. He removed Madison's hands from Maddy's head, then grabbed her hair and pulled her up.

"When I make you cum, I want to hear you scream how good it is. Understood?" Pete told Maddy as he held just his cockhead inside her butt.

"Huh..." Maddy didn't know how to respond, her mind a mix of pain, disgust, lust, and pleasure.

Pete looked down and smirked. He was about to make Maddy his whore. He held her hair tight with his right hand and gripped her hip with his left. He started to pummel into her ass with all his force.

"AAAAHHHHHH!!!" Maddy screamed and shut her eyes, the pain and pleasure of Pete's cock overwhelming and forced her into an orgasm.

"Tell me you like it, bitch!" Pete screamed as he felt Maddy's ass tighten up around him.

Maddy was fighting a losing battle. The numbing of her brain was returning and she was powerless to stop it. She didn't want to enjoy this but as Pete continued to pump in and out of her, she couldn't deny it.

"SAY IT!" Pete screamed, thrusting all the way inside her.

"Oh god, it's so good!" Maddy replied, the numbness had won and turned him into Pete's slut. "I love it! I fucking love it!" She screamed over and over again as her body hit its crescendo.

"Damn right." Pete snickered to himself after Maddy's orgasm as he pulled out of her ass.

"I... love... fuck... love it..." Maddy babbled through deep breaths as she was completely lost.

Pete needed a moment, he was exhausted and covered in sweat. But what he saw next changed his mind right away.

"I'm ready babe!" Madison said as she laid on her back next to Maddy.

While Pete was focused on Maddy, Madison had quietly moved beside her and gotten on her back, wanting to watch Pete enter her ass. She swung her legs up in the air and next to her ears, her asshole clearly visible. She took her hands and spread her cheeks opening up her sphincter for Pete.

"I want you in my ass!" She told him, Pete's eyes wider than ever looking at the young woman begging for his cock in her ass.

Pete found a second wind, moving over, lining his cock up with her ass, and sliding in. Madison's ass was much easier to enter as she wasn't tensing up at all. Pete slid his cock in, although he did find her ass tighter than Maddy's even though she was much more willing.

Madison found Pete's cock in her ass painful, especially cause he didn't use lube, but not overwhelming. She had been watching Pete fuck Maddy's ass and becoming increasingly lust-filled as she imagined Pete's cock inside her ass. With the fat man's dick now in her ass, her lust only grew.

Pete wasn't being patient and with no resistance from Madison, he began to fuck her with all he had. His lungs burned as he loudly wheezed, but for him as well the pleasure of Madison's ass wrapped around his cock was too great to stop. Her strong glutes squeezed his cock incredibly tight, as he felt every inch of her insides.

Madison started to rub her pussy as she watched her fat ugly lover bang her ass. Any pain she felt had quickly gone away and all she felt was an overwhelming lustful feeling coming from her ass. She looked up at Pete, his face a bright red, his fat folds jiggling as he pushed into her, and his sweaty brow, which was dripping down onto her stomach. Madison scooped that sweat up and rubbed it on her tits, shining them up.

Pete found his third wind to get to the finish as he saw Madison's perfect glistening chest. The harder he fucked her, the more her chest bounced, hence his new motivation. He put his arms next to Madison's head and leaned forward, looking into the 18-year-old's eyes.

Madison looked into Pete's piercing green eyes and felt more connected with him than she had felt with anyone ever before. She could feel his cock pulsing in her ass and knew he'd be finished soon.

"Cum in my ass, babe." She told him. "I wanna feel you fill my ass up!"

"Arrgghh!" Pete groaned as he began to cum, Madison's dirty words pushing him over the top.

His arms gave out and fell forward on top of Madison, his large body completely covering her small slender body.

"Uhh! I'm cumming with you!" Madison moaned as his cock spurting inside her got her off.

Madison wrapped her arms and legs around him, holding him tight. He nuzzled his face against her neck as they rode each other's orgasm out. Madison was having difficulty breathing with Pete on top of her. Yet, she still held him tightly, not wanting him to move away, her sick horned up mind completely lost to lust for Pete, and her ass filled to the brim with his sperm.

------

"Uhh! Uhh! Uhh!" Was the only sound Maddy heard.

It was coming from her best friend who was lying next to her as Pete rammed into her. She hadn't heard Madison actually speak in over an hour, just loud moans whenever Pete was using her. Maddy wasn't sure what time it was, it had to be late as the sun had set awhile ago.

Maddy was exhausted, her body sore and covered in sweat. Pete had been relentless only giving them moments to rest as he got another Viagra. He had taken 6 that day, it was a miracle he didn't have a heart attack. But it was definitely worth the risk, Madison and Maddy were just that good.

After her first anal fucking, Maddy gave up resisting, fully submitting to Pete, and doing whatever he requested. Her brain was mush, she wasn't able to think properly, a defense mechanism to deal with Pete's disgustingness.

"Here... I... cum!!!" He yelled as he exploded into Madison, who lied back and took it.

Maddy looked at her best friend, lying there panting, her tongue out, her eyes rolled back. She had little doubt Pete would be doing the same to her in just a moment. She wasn't panicked or scared, she would accept him, just as she had done dozens of times before.

But before he moved over to Maddy, he reached over and grabbed his phone. He turned the screen on and shoved it in Maddy's face.

"What time is it?" He asked.

Maddy was only half aware but looked at the time. "12... 01." She said.

"That's right, it's Monday." He replied. "Which means our deal is over and you can go home. Or you could stay and let me fuck you one last time. What will it be my little slut?"

If any part of Maddy's brain was still functioning properly, she would have gotten up and left. But lucky for Pete, nothing was.

"Fuck me, baby." She said, not conscious of what she was even saying.

Pete had an evil grin on his face as he slid back into Maddy. She had agreed to fuck him even though she didn't have to. He would enjoy this time the most.

Pete leaned forward, putting his whole body weight on Maddy, who got crushed into the bed. He nuzzled his head against her neck his lips gently kissing her soft skin. He began thrusting in and out of her, her abused pussy having loosen up throughout the day yet still hugged him tightly.

Maddy tried to wrap her arms around him but couldn't quite make it around him. She could feel the fat on his back jiggling around as he pushed into her. His back was a sweaty mess just like the rest of him but in his defense, Maddy was a sweaty mess as well.

"You like this?" Pete asked after a few minutes of pounding into Maddy.

"Ya, I do." She responded.

"And now you know you're a little slut." He whispered into her ear. "You had a chance to leave and never do this again. But you choose to stay, you choose to let me fuck you again. Do you know why? Cause you're a slut, who needs dick and lots of it."

Maddy was hearing Pete's words but not fully understanding them. She wouldn't truly understand them until the next day, when the memories flooded back and caused her to cry.

But right now, all Maddy can think of is her oncoming orgasm. With Pete pounding into her, it was only a matter of time. Pete had become very acquainted with both of the girls' pussies and knew just how they liked it. He loved listening to them moan as he caused them to cum, his gross appearance not stopping them from orgasming.

"Oh god yes!" Maddy moaned out as her body orgasmed on Pete's cock.

"Haha, see I told you, you're a little slut." Pete told her as her orgasm ripped through her young body. "I'm gonna cum soon, too. And I'm gonna dump it inside you. I bought those plan Bs you asked for but I hope you don't take yours and let me knock you up."

It was only a few minutes later that Pete began to cum inside Maddy. He grunted his way through as his sore balls pushed out the last of his cum. Maddy orgasmed as soon as she felt his cum plaster her insides. They began to kiss as they both came down from their orgasms.

It had been quite a day. A day Madison wouldn't soon forget, and Maddy would wish she could forget.