Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 51. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 03 David meets Naomi for the first time. by Woodentop (12/07/23) | 4.77 (114) |
| 52. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 12 Start of yr 2 at Uni & eventful trip to York. by Woodentop (12/28/23) | 4.77 (61) |
| 53. | Gifted Thanks for saving me from girl's night. by Member389 (12/21/23) | 4.77 (418) |
| 54. | Love Among the Stacks Ch. 02 For James and Kellie, college isn’t the only thing coming. by WriterPerson314159 (10/04/23) | 4.77 (112) |
| 55. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 06 First time with Alicia. by Woodentop (12/15/23) | 4.77 (103) |
| 56. | Sophia's Choice Pt. 08 Veronique causes havoc in the Collins household. by Alice_Nicol (07/10/23) | 4.76 (17) |
| 57. | Love Among the Stacks The ways in which books bring us love. by WriterPerson314159 (09/27/23) | 4.76 (144) |
| 58. | First College Party His first college party leads to lots of other firsts. by Leader12 (07/06/23) | 4.76 (472) |
| 59. | Who Would've Guessed Ch. 01 Popular girl finds out her nerdy classmate has a big dick. by Egglime (03/18/24) | 4.76 (793) |
| 60. | Veronique Goes Sailing Ch. 02 Veronique is happy to have gotten rid of Max. by Mingemuncher (06/29/23) | 4.76 (112) |
| 61. | Losing Her Virginity Teenage volleyball captain gives herself to an older man. by Lumiere_Amie (10/06/23) | 4.76 (211) |
| 62. | The Virgin and the Bushwalk A 20-year-old virgin gets stranded with a strange boy. by CinderellaD (10/06/23) | 4.76 (267) |
| 63. | The Art of Lust Pt. 04 One + Two = Sex. by OnePaige (10/01/23) | 4.76 (45) |
| 64. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 07 Is this what it's like to have sex with a supermodel? by JQueen9 (06/11/23) | 4.75 (211) |
| 65. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 10 David - London Olympics. by Woodentop (12/20/23) | 4.75 (77) |
| 66. | The Education of Amelia A young woman is introduced the love, passion, and desire. by Unencumbered (07/24/23) | 4.75 (145) |
| 67. | Nan Ch. 01 Nan loses her virginity in an unusual way in the 1950's. by qwazr (06/19/23) | 4.75 (257) |
| 68. | Couch Time with My Bestie My friend's curiosity leads to some naughty explorations. by Cunning_Linguist_69 (08/07/23) | 4.75 (340) |
| 69. | Work Experience Ch. 02 More training with Mrs Gregory. by Calorific (01/04/24) | 4.75 (320) |
| 70. | Work Experience Ch. 04 Mrs Gregory helps Steve have a date with Vanessa. by Calorific (01/09/24) | 4.75 (228) |
| 71. | Debbie Floats My Boat Florida, sunny sky, warm water, first time sex on a boat. by phynneman (11/27/23) | 4.75 (291) |
| 72. | My Sister's Best Friend A young man finds love with a special young woman. by UltimateSin (03/24/24) | 4.74 (781) |
| 73. | Kimmy's Adventure - Timmy's Virginity Female college track star takes nerd's virginity. by Imnohemingway (12/21/23) | 4.74 (154) |
| 74. | Only the Truth Pt. 03 Mason makes a move. by __Lisa__ (09/18/23) | 4.74 (96) |
| 75. | Laney Fucks a Virgin After six weeks of dalliances, Laney wants something simpler. by Bottom_side_up (02/12/24) | 4.74 (103) |
| 76. | Female Incel Gifts Her Virginity "I don't care if I cum. I just want to offer myself to you." by dasgoodshit (08/06/23) | 4.74 (122) |
| 77. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 02 - Parking Lot Erin encounters Noah in the school parking lot. by emelle78 (06/24/23) | 4.74 (194) |
| 78. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 05 University and meeting the girls again. by Woodentop (12/12/23) | 4.74 (121) |
| 79. | Coach's Cutie Ch. 04 A woman befriends a teen and learns her sexual history. by becca20S (03/28/24) | 4.73 (60) |
| 80. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 04 Ben's reunion with Julie takes a surprising turn. by JQueen9 (06/05/23) | 4.73 (227) |
| 81. | First Bi Fantasy A girl convinces her bff to wank to a bi fantasy she guides. by Votre (07/26/23) | 4.73 (342) |
| 82. | Veronique Goes Sailing Ch. 04 The weather has put an end to the sailing, but not the fun. by Mingemuncher (07/06/23) | 4.73 (78) |
| 83. | Symposium Day Ch. 03 Jen continues my education in various directions. by Slowandeasy47 (01/21/24) | 4.73 (37) |
| 84. | The Education of Donna Pt. 04 Donna takes the lead for the first time. by MissUnderstanding69 (12/23/23) | 4.73 (48) |
| 85. | Tutus and Treachery The Nutcracker and the Mouse King. by SpindleTop (12/01/23) | 4.73 (44) |
| 86. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 05 Sonya reveals her fantasies. by JQueen9 (06/07/23) | 4.73 (234) |
| 87. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 02 Ben meets a new woman. by JQueen9 (05/31/23) | 4.73 (262) |
| 88. | Paying It Back She recalls freeing her lustful hubby from his shell at Prom. by davepepperbury (04/23/24) | 4.73 (211) |
| 89. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 03 Sonya decides she's ready to have sex with Ben. by JQueen9 (06/02/23) | 4.72 (229) |
| 90. | Their First Cuckold Invited to help with a young couple's fantasies. by WolfyLikes (06/15/23) | 4.72 (221) |
| 91. | Summer Storm Unattached girl and boy take shelter from violent storm. by asadama (08/21/23) | 4.72 (891) |
| 92. | Olivia's School Project - Pt. 01 Olivia needs Jake to pose for her painting assignment. by njf539 (09/03/23) | 4.72 (428) |
| 93. | Only the Truth Pt. 04 Sadie sees a light at the end of the tunnel. by __Lisa__ (09/19/23) | 4.72 (79) |
| 94. | Being Taught New Things by Hannah Going to a party, led to more than I had ever expected. by ConfusinglyDelerious (05/04/24) | 4.72 (210) |
| 95. | Sex Shop Slut Innocent Catholic girl finds herself in a sticky situation. by TwistedManc (09/01/23) | 4.72 (803) |
| 96. | 1x: To Fool a Nerd and a Geek Students Prank a Maths Nerd into a Fake Date but are Fooled by AlexFourways (03/18/24) | 4.72 (357) |
| 97. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 02 David meets Alicia. by Woodentop (12/04/23) | 4.72 (116) |
| 98. | Pleasure's Duty Elizabeth learns about pleasure on her wedding night. by IsabellaEmily (08/26/23) | 4.71 (228) |
| 99. | Road Trip 02: Off the Mat Danny reunites with an old flame who helps him move forward. by NomdePlumer (04/11/24) | 4.71 (35) |
| 100. | Love is Being Stupid Together Ch. 05 Kait and Nick visit her parents in south Florida. by RicknCenFl (03/28/24) | 4.71 (34) |
