Top Rated Stories in category:
Page:1
2
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Ashley My childhood babysitter is even more fun as an adult. by Leader12 (04/12/24) | 4.83 (561) |
| 2. | Cold Beer, Boiled Shrimp, New Love A college romance born in 1976 after spring day of revelry. by RoyceFHouton (04/22/24) | 4.82 (256) |
| 3. | Being Taught New Things by Hannah Going to a party, led to more than I had ever expected. by ConfusinglyDelerious (05/04/24) | 4.74 (140) |
| 4. | Paying It Back She recalls freeing her lustful hubby from his shell at Prom. by davepepperbury (04/23/24) | 4.73 (208) |
| 5. | Road Trip 02: Off the Mat Danny reunites with an old flame who helps him move forward. by NomdePlumer (04/11/24) | 4.70 (33) |
| 6. | Summer of '69 Best friends come of age together. by CanadianM (04/18/24) | 4.68 (343) |
| 7. | The Domestic Help Interracial relationship. by BillyB100 (04/30/24) | 4.59 (151) |
| 8. | Doing the Local Guys lust between a young soldier and a local guy overseas by FalconNighthawk2 (05/02/24) | 4.58 (36) |
| 9. | Beltane A girl secures her village's prosperity for the coming year. by MoonlitNightshade (05/04/24) | 4.58 (59) |
| 10. | Oral Advocacy Ch. 11: The Prom Samantha tells the story of her first time with Matt. by kateharris1971 (05/02/24) | 4.57 (21) |
| 11. | My Journey into Becoming Cocksucker Pt. 02 A journey into cocksucking. by sammm123 (04/11/24) | 4.57 (116) |
| 12. | Friday Story - 26 Apr 2024 Kasia and Josie decide to fuck eachother for the first time. by KasiaLaing (04/29/24) | 4.56 (98) |
| 13. | Susan Finds her Place Pt. 04 Susan gladly sheds her virginity. by ACCarruthers (04/16/24) | 4.52 (33) |
| 14. | Alex Fucks Cyn Cyn gets her wish: a man's cock deep inside her. by FreyaGersemi (04/20/24) | 4.51 (118) |
| 15. | Pow, Right in the Kisser! My first blowjob was also my first facial. by skirtnpantyhose (04/13/24) | 4.50 (147) |
| 16. | How I Became a Cocksucker A story about the night I became a cocksucker. by just_sean (04/05/24) | 4.49 (208) |
| 17. | The Duck A college cheerleader has special plans for her first time. by awriterssojourn (04/28/24) | 4.48 (104) |
| 18. | It's Just a Hand Job A straight guy gives his new friend a hand job and likes it. by AmaraSexy (04/14/24) | 4.48 (140) |
| 19. | Weekend Away Begining of a long weekend. by raveen69 (04/23/24) | 4.46 (114) |
| 20. | Lily's Perspective Lily never thought chastity would be this hard. by Teasedtoomuch (05/03/24) | 4.46 (35) |
| 21. | Turning My Teacher I meet my virgin teacher and plan to make him mine. by JimboExplorer (04/21/24) | 4.44 (189) |
| 22. | Ch. 02 - Human Sexuality Curious college freshman's first time masturbating. by tigerandmouse (04/19/24) | 4.44 (68) |
| 23. | Susan Finds her Place Pt. 01 A young woman starts her sexual awakening. by ACCarruthers (04/07/24) | 4.44 (147) |
| 24. | Discovering My Cousin Isabelle A young girl discovers her cousin's true sexual power. by Taylor_Knight (05/02/24) | 4.43 (63) |
| 25. | A Trip to Rome - Tuesday A young girl makes more experiences. by Cougar77 (04/18/24) | 4.43 (7) |
| 26. | Symposium Day Ch. 04 Jen turns us both on as she tells me of her first time. by Slowandeasy47 (04/12/24) | 4.41 (17) |
| 27. | Wife's Unplanned First Wife surprised herself. by handsolow11 (04/11/24) | 4.41 (268) |
| 28. | Bisexual Summer Pt. 02 First time bisexual with older. by Sblue1982 (04/10/24) | 4.41 (123) |
| 29. | Sex Games: The Second Step Continuing toward the Taboo, we create a sex game. by Blurred_Lines (04/05/24) | 4.40 (25) |
| 30. | Boarding School Girls Ch. 02 Frustrated highly sexed school girl is ready to fuck. by generichs (04/30/24) | 4.38 (63) |
| 31. | My Ex Begs for a Facial My ex begs me to give her a facial for the first time. by wildcat19 (04/22/24) | 4.37 (79) |
| 32. | Ross A dream of autofellatio turns into reality...turns into more? by abitfarfetched (05/03/24) | 4.35 (31) |
| 33. | An Unexpected Day at the Beach Kind of Tricked by a Tranny. by sammm123 (04/20/24) | 4.35 (126) |
| 34. | Swinging becomes her Wife enters into swinging. by TommyBoyinNC (04/29/24) | 4.32 (148) |
| 35. | Cut, colour and...cum A passionate fuck between a hairdresser and her client. by WakingUpDreaming (04/07/24) | 4.31 (59) |
| 36. | Tallulah Rocks Angel Tallulah - A Sexy Stripper & Queen of the Pole. by RitaFox (04/09/24) | 4.30 (10) |
| 37. | Bisexual Summer Pt. 01 First time bi with older. by Sblue1982 (04/10/24) | 4.30 (101) |
| 38. | Freshmen Year of College Pt. 02 Giving and receiving oral sex for the first time. by BobMarooga (04/18/24) | 4.29 (75) |
| 39. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 12 The conclusion... by DADDY_LongLegs (04/18/24) | 4.27 (15) |
| 40. | Traveling With Sexy Friends Story of our first time with another couple. by pdxphd (04/28/24) | 4.26 (23) |
| 41. | Learning the office rules New employee disappoints her boss and is taught a lesson. by KasiaLaing (04/22/24) | 4.20 (133) |
| 42. | Can 25yo Widow be That Innocent? Naive widow of minister starts to lose her innocents. by Satsumabook123 (04/07/24) | 4.20 (109) |
| 43. | The Lifeguards It's hard not being horny as a lifeguard. by Ocean_Blue (05/02/24) | 4.20 (101) |
| 44. | Looking Back at Learning As a college student I was pretty much a virgin but then... by PearsonLance (04/05/24) | 4.19 (70) |
| 45. | Fuck Me, I am Your Slut! My brother's friend made me beg to get fucked! by _Saber_ATHENA_ (04/25/24) | 4.18 (141) |
| 46. | My Lovely Blonde First time with lovely blonde. by mseg14 (04/10/24) | 4.17 (86) |
| 47. | Confession - Mentor Fucks Mentee Ch. 02 My sister submits to and fucks my mentor. Ch2 by taryn1994 (04/16/24) | 4.17 (35) |
| 48. | Wife's New Life Night out fun. by ultramanpa59 (04/26/24) | 4.15 (100) |
| 49. | F & N F introduces N to the delights of physical love. by TheCompany (04/19/24) | 4.15 (20) |
| 50. | Influencer How do you become an Influencer? by Sean943 (04/19/24) | 4.14 (7) |
First Time Toplist Page
:
1
2
