Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | My Freaky Senior Prom Just turned 18 and woke up in someone else's body. Perfect. by somethingfar (03/04/24) | 4.91 (1135) |
| 2. | Love Among the Stacks Ch. 03 A museum, a dinner, and a hotel room for two. by WriterPerson314159 (10/16/23) | 4.88 (86) |
| 3. | Love Among the Stacks Ch. 04 Kellie takes the mic to tell us about the next day. by WriterPerson314159 (11/20/23) | 4.87 (47) |
| 4. | California Dreamin' Pt. 02 Jack and Sloane take things up a notch. by somethingfar (12/31/23) | 4.87 (334) |
| 5. | The Gift Sometimes daydreams do come true. by Member389 (10/20/23) | 4.87 (740) |
| 6. | Mark & Nia: A Tutored First Time Shy, interracial college freshmen 'schooled' in other ways. by MarkLivingston (07/30/23) | 4.86 (58) |
| 7. | Treasures Ch. 03-04 New rules, dessert, and suffering leads to rewards. by TreasureSeeker (01/14/24) | 4.86 (29) |
| 8. | Nothing in Common An unexpected romance. by SilverFoxMullet (11/01/23) | 4.86 (512) |
| 9. | Love is Being Stupid Together Ch. 01 Science nerd and computer geek explore sex. by RicknCenFl (01/22/24) | 4.85 (310) |
| 10. | Suzie's Twenty-Five Acts Shy Suzie breaks free in twenty-five easy steps. by WittyUserName (11/21/23) | 4.85 (188) |
| 11. | California Dreamin' Pt. 01 High school ruined by COVID sends a young man to California. by somethingfar (12/27/23) | 4.85 (421) |
| 12. | Seeing Green When goblin Fetch's heat flares up, Adam has to help! by GoblinBrain (09/03/23) | 4.85 (80) |
| 13. | First and Last A chance meeting at the rec center lets friends reconnect. by NoTalentHack (08/18/23) | 4.85 (958) |
| 14. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 01 Amanda helps Erin break out of her shell. by emelle78 (06/14/23) | 4.84 (334) |
| 15. | Locker Room Dare Ch. 01 A dare takes a crazy turn for a high school geek. by m_storyman_x (12/09/23) | 4.84 (1259) |
| 16. | Pining for Madison A school assignment changes everything. by Secretauthor2021 (02/22/24) | 4.84 (382) |
| 17. | Virgin Freshman from the Farm Kyle's horizons expand when he leaves the farm for college. by badge_25 (05/10/23) | 4.83 (369) |
| 18. | Cold Beer, Boiled Shrimp, New Love A college romance born in 1976 after spring day of revelry. by RoyceFHouton (04/22/24) | 4.83 (210) |
| 19. | Ashley My childhood babysitter is even more fun as an adult. by Leader12 (04/12/24) | 4.83 (541) |
| 20. | Diane's Inamorato Tutee Charlie loses his virginity to a talented masseuse. by GentlemanFlynn (07/27/23) | 4.82 (283) |
| 21. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 10 Our story concludes with a romantic reunion of Ben and Beth. by JQueen9 (06/16/23) | 4.82 (186) |
| 22. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 03 - Biology Class Erin and Amanda are tardy but make it up to their teacher. by emelle78 (06/25/23) | 4.82 (149) |
| 23. | Paige Teaches Perversion Pt. 02 Paige continues to teach Austin about kink. by IsabellaEmily (02/07/24) | 4.82 (131) |
| 24. | Dorm Room Games Group of nerdy college kids play a sexy game. by xxavi (01/22/24) | 4.81 (313) |
| 25. | Veronique Goes Sailing Ch. 03 Veronique weathers a storm. Both emotionally and the weather. by Mingemuncher (07/02/23) | 4.81 (95) |
| 26. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 04 A trip to France and meeting Mai. by Woodentop (12/12/23) | 4.81 (100) |
| 27. | Dormant Desires Pt. 03 Four freshman boys give a mom a perfect night of pleasure. by becca20S (07/01/23) | 4.81 (149) |
| 28. | My Best Friend Alice Pt. 02 A weekend with Alice changes everything. by Secretauthor2021 (09/28/23) | 4.80 (445) |
| 29. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 04 - Teacher's Lounge Erin and Amanda have fun with the Principal. by emelle78 (06/29/23) | 4.80 (97) |
| 30. | My Grey Summer A college students summer coworker expands his horizons. by Warkat747 (09/11/23) | 4.80 (306) |
| 31. | The Lone Ranger and the Ho Our intrepid hero rescues a woman of ill repute. by Trionyx (10/24/23) | 4.80 (254) |
| 32. | Broken Babysitter Injuries open up a young babysitter's world. by Chris6160 (02/06/24) | 4.80 (339) |
| 33. | Water Park Fun Ch. 11 The summer comes to an end. by storyteller19 (12/20/23) | 4.80 (100) |
| 34. | Katie's Corruption Ch. 08 The time has finally come for Kevin to become a man! by Hourglass_Twin_Erotica (09/03/23) | 4.80 (25) |
| 35. | My Best Friend Alice With Alice, practice makes perfect. by Secretauthor2021 (09/14/23) | 4.80 (587) |
| 36. | An Indian Wedding Affair The seduction of a married woman. by GeorgeJames (02/04/24) | 4.80 (84) |
| 37. | Paige Teaches Perversion Pt. 01 Austin visits a pregnant woman to learn about perversion. by IsabellaEmily (01/29/24) | 4.79 (277) |
| 38. | Prof. Johnson's First Frat Party Ch. 02 Alice's adventures continue in the classroom and the office. by emelle78 (03/24/24) | 4.79 (53) |
| 39. | The (un)Lucky Girl Can love bloom in the dead of winter? by Devinter (11/11/23) | 4.79 (514) |
| 40. | Summer Camp Firsts Jake and Mara reconnect at Summer Camp. by Secretauthor2021 (10/20/23) | 4.79 (334) |
| 41. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 05 - College Visit Erin makes Peter’s fantasy a reality. by emelle78 (06/30/23) | 4.79 (84) |
| 42. | Love is Being Stupid Together Ch. 02 Kait and Nick attempt to prove geniuses do stupid things. by RicknCenFl (02/04/24) | 4.79 (135) |
| 43. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 06 - Erin's Performance Erin makes Peter's fantasy come true. Again. by emelle78 (07/19/23) | 4.78 (85) |
| 44. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 09 David and Sabrina. by Woodentop (12/19/23) | 4.78 (76) |
| 45. | Prof. Johnson's First Frat Party Alice breaks out of her shell at a frat party. by emelle78 (02/18/24) | 4.78 (183) |
| 46. | Ashley the First Ash studies hard for a midterm. by wetfanatic (04/28/23) | 4.77 (151) |
| 47. | Pining for Madison: The Favour Madison asks for a special favour. by Secretauthor2021 (03/07/24) | 4.77 (203) |
| 48. | Olympic Dreaming Ch. 11 David takes to the girls to a Greek island. by Woodentop (12/24/23) | 4.77 (75) |
| 49. | Grandpa's Guide to Women Pt. 09 Being so sexy must be a burden. by JQueen9 (06/14/23) | 4.77 (163) |
| 50. | Lost in New York New York City is no place to find yourself alone. by Member389 (06/20/23) | 4.77 (233) |
