First Time Stories Hub
New First Time Sex Stories
Cuck-sitting Best Friend's Hubby
05/02/24First time being present while his wife is fucked by Bull. by
Cold Beer, Boiled Shrimp, New Love
04/22/24A college romance born in 1976 after spring day of revelry. by
Spin!
Random First Time Erotic Stories
Don't Knock It 'Till You've Felt It
03/22/22Virgin gets her pussy eaten the first time, and other tales. by
This is great!!
THoney269 on Going Down (1)Another refreshing story that is a flashback fo many people to their youth. Totally enjoyed every work...
Excoach on Nothing Between Us (936)Less of a train wreck this time, and I still can’t look away. 5 stars, less begrudgingly this time....
BlueBran on Inseparable Pt. 03 (7)Just like our first time!
WEEDME69 on First Taste (3)So...did he pull it out?
KingCuddle on Who Would've Guessed Ch. 01 (24)